Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Nature Communications

Experimental observation of classical analogy of topological entanglement entropy

Tian Chen, Shihao Zhang, Yi Zhang, Yulong Liu, Su-Peng Kou, Houjun Sun, Xiangdong Zhang

Published Apr 5, 2019• 14 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Long-range entanglement is an important aspect of the topological orders, so efficient methods to characterize the long-range entanglement are often needed. In this regard, topological entanglement entropy (TEE) is often used for such a purpose but the experimental observation of TEE in a topological order remains a challenge. Here, we propose a scheme to observe TEE in the topological order by constructing specific minimum entropy states (MESs). We then experimentally construct the classical microwave analogs of the MESs and simulate the nontrivial topological order with the TEE in Kitaev toric code, which is in agreement with theoretical predictions. We also experimentally simulate the transition from Z2 topologically ordered state to topologically trivial state.

DOI
10.1038/s41467-019-09584-1

Related papers

Entanglement Entropy as a Probe for Topological Order in Quantum Systems

Dr. Rajendra Kumar, Dr. Aram Singh

Topological entanglement entropy (TEE) provides a universal measure of long-range quantum correlations in topologically ordered systems, offering critical insights into exotic phases of matter. While theoretical frameworks, including exactly solvable lattice models, tensor networks, and field-theoretic approaches, enable precise computation of TEE in idealized settings, practical implementation faces multiple challenges. Finite-size and geometry effects, including boundary corners and lattice discretization, introduce significant corrections that can obscure the small topological contribution. Gapless edges in chiral topological phases further complicate the isolation of bulk entanglement, requiring careful separation of edge and bulk contributions. Symmetry-protected and symmetry-enriched phases necessitate additional diagnostics, such as symmetry-resolved entanglement and entanglement negativity, to fully characterize topological properties. Experimental measurement remains challenging, with current approaches limited to small systems using Rényi entropies via swap operations and interferometric methods. This work synthesizes these practical considerations, outlines mitigation strategies, and highlights ongoing directions for bridging theoretical, numerical, and experimental approaches to robustly quantify TEE. Understanding these limitations is essential for accurate characterization of topological order and for guiding the development of quantum technologies leveraging topological protection.

IOSR Journal of Applied Physics•Apr 1, 2025•0 citations

Topological entanglement entropy meets holographic entropy inequalities

Joydeep Naskar, Sai Satyam Samal

Topological entanglement entropy (TEE) is an efficient way to detect topological order in the ground state of gapped Hamiltonians. The seminal work of Kitaev and Preskill~\cite{preskill-kitaev-tee} and simultaneously by Levin and Wen~\cite{levin-wen-tee} proposed information quantities that can probe the TEE. In the present work, we explain why the subtraction schemes in the proposed information quantities~\cite{levin-wen-tee,preskill-kitaev-tee} work for the computation of TEE and generalize them for arbitrary number of subregions by explicitly noting the necessary conditions for an information quantity to capture TEE. Our conditions differentiate the probes defined by Kitaev-Preskill and Levin-Wen into separate classes. While there are infinitely many possible probes of TEE, we focus particularly on the cyclic quantities $Q_{2n+1}$ and multi-information $I_n$. We also show that the holographic entropy inequalities are satisfied by the quantum entanglement entropy of the non-degenerate ground state of a topologically ordered two-dimensional medium with a mass gap.

arXiv:2412.05484•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jun 25, 2026•5 citations

Detecting Topological Order at Finite Temperature Using Entanglement Negativity

Tsung-Cheng Lu, Timothy H. Hsieh, Tarun Grover

We propose a diagnostic for finite temperature topological order using "topological entanglement negativity," the long-range component of a mixed-state entanglement measure. As a demonstration, we study the toric code model in d spatial dimensions for d=2,3,4, and find that when topological order survives thermal fluctuations, it possesses a nonzero topological entanglement negativity, whose value is equal to the topological entanglement entropy at zero temperature. Furthermore, we show that the Gibbs state of 2D and 3D toric code at any nonzero temperature, and that of 4D toric code above a certain critical temperature, can be expressed as a convex combination of short-range entangled pure states, consistent with the absence of topological order.

arXiv:1912.04293•Physical Review Letters•Sep 8, 2020•97 citations

Topological entanglement entropy in the quantum dimer model on the triangular lattice

Shunsuke Furukawa, Grégoire Misguich

A characterization of topological order in terms of bi-partite entanglement was proposed recently [A. Kitaev and J. Preskill, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 110404 (2006); M. Levin and X.-G. Wen, ibid. 96, 110405 (2006)]. It was argued that in a topological phase there is a universal additive constant in the entanglement entropy, called the topological entanglement entropy, which reflects the underlying gauge theory for the topological order. In the present paper, we evaluate numerically the topological entanglement entropy in the ground states of a quantum dimer model on the triangular lattice, which is known to have a dimer liquid phase with ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ topological order. We examine the two original constructions to measure the topological entropy by combining entropies on plural areas, and we observe that in the large-area limit they both approach the value expected for ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ topological order. We also consider the entanglement entropy on a topologically nontrivial ``zigzag'' area and propose to use it as another way to measure the topological entropy.

arXiv:cond-mat/0612227•Physical Review B•Jun 5, 2007•148 citations

Topological entanglement entropy in Gutzwiller projected spin liquids

Jiquan Pei, Steve Han, Haijun Liao +1 more

The topological entanglement entropy (TEE) of Gutzwiller projected RVB state is studied with Monte Carlo simulation. With tricks to speed up the convergence of TEE, we are able to show that the spin liquid state studied in Zhang et al. [Phys. Rev. B 84, 075128 (2011)] actually does not support ${Z}_{2}$ topological order. We find that both an approximate Marshall sign structure and a long-ranged RVB amplitude are responsible for the suppression of the vison gap in this spin liquid state. On the other hand, a TEE of $\mathrm{ln}2$ is clearly demonstrated for a short range RVB state on triangular lattice proposed in Yunoki et al. [Phys. Rev. B 74, 014408 (2006)]. We find the TEE of the RVB wave function is mainly determined by its phase rather than its amplitude. Our results indicate that the effective field theory misses some key information for the topological property of a RVB state.

arXiv:1212.2703•Physical Review B•Sep 25, 2013•6 citations

Efficient computation of topological order

Louis Fraatz, Amit Jamadagni, Hendrik Weimer

Abstract We analyze the computational aspects of detecting topological order in a quantum many-body system. We contrast the widely used topological entanglement entropy with a recently introduced operational definition for topological order based on error correction properties, finding exponential scaling with the system size for the former and polynomial scaling for the latter. We exemplify our approach for a variant of the paradigmatic toric code model with mobile particles, finding that the error correction method allows to treat substantially larger system sizes. In particular, the phase diagram of the model can be successfully computed using error correction, while the topological entanglement entropy is too severely limited by finite size effects to obtain conclusive results. While we mainly focus on one-dimensional systems whose ground states can be expressed in terms of matrix product states, our strategy can be readily generalized to higher dimensions and systems out of equilibrium, even allowing for an efficient detection of topological order in current quantum simulation experiments.

arXiv:2409.12704•New Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
Abstract Long-range entanglement is an important aspect of the topological orders, so efficient methods to characterize the long-range entanglement are often needed. In this regard, topological entanglement entropy (TEE) is often used for such a purpose but the experimental observation of TEE in a topological order remains a challenge. Here, we propose a scheme to observe TEE in the topological order by constructing specific minimum entropy states (MESs). We then experimentally construct the classical microwave analogs of the MESs and simulate the nontrivial topological order with the TEE in Kitaev toric code, which is in agreement with theoretical predictions. We also experimentally simulate the transition from Z2 topologically ordered state to topologically trivial state.
Topological entanglement entropy (TEE) provides a universal measure of long-range quantum correlations in topologically ordered systems, offering critical insights into exotic phases of matter. While theoretical frameworks, including exactly solvable lattice models, tensor networks, and field-theoretic approaches, enable precise computation of TEE in idealized settings, practical implementation faces multiple challenges. Finite-size and geometry effects, including boundary corners and lattice discretization, introduce significant corrections that can obscure the small topological contribution. Gapless edges in chiral topological phases further complicate the isolation of bulk entanglement, requiring careful separation of edge and bulk contributions. Symmetry-protected and symmetry-enriched phases necessitate additional diagnostics, such as symmetry-resolved entanglement and entanglement negativity, to fully characterize topological properties. Experimental measurement remains challenging, with current approaches limited to small systems using Rényi entropies via swap operations and interferometric methods. This work synthesizes these practical considerations, outlines mitigation strategies, and highlights ongoing directions for bridging theoretical, numerical, and experimental approaches to robustly quantify TEE. Understanding these limitations is essential for accurate characterization of topological order and for guiding the development of quantum technologies leveraging topological protection.
Topological entanglement entropy (TEE) is an efficient way to detect topological order in the ground state of gapped Hamiltonians. The seminal work of Kitaev and Preskill~\cite{preskill-kitaev-tee} and simultaneously by Levin and Wen~\cite{levin-wen-tee} proposed information quantities that can probe the TEE. In the present work, we explain why the subtraction schemes in the proposed information quantities~\cite{levin-wen-tee,preskill-kitaev-tee} work for the computation of TEE and generalize them for arbitrary number of subregions by explicitly noting the necessary conditions for an information quantity to capture TEE. Our conditions differentiate the probes defined by Kitaev-Preskill and Levin-Wen into separate classes. While there are infinitely many possible probes of TEE, we focus particularly on the cyclic quantities Q2n+1Q_{2n+1}Q2n+1​ and multi-information InI_nIn​. We also show that the holographic entropy inequalities are satisfied by the quantum entanglement entropy of the non-degenerate ground state of a topologically ordered two-dimensional medium with a mass gap.
We propose a diagnostic for finite temperature topological order using "topological entanglement negativity," the long-range component of a mixed-state entanglement measure. As a demonstration, we study the toric code model in d spatial dimensions for d=2,3,4, and find that when topological order survives thermal fluctuations, it possesses a nonzero topological entanglement negativity, whose value is equal to the topological entanglement entropy at zero temperature. Furthermore, we show that the Gibbs state of 2D and 3D toric code at any nonzero temperature, and that of 4D toric code above a certain critical temperature, can be expressed as a convex combination of short-range entangled pure states, consistent with the absence of topological order.
A characterization of topological order in terms of bi-partite entanglement was proposed recently [A. Kitaev and J. Preskill, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 110404 (2006); M. Levin and X.-G. Wen, ibid. 96, 110405 (2006)]. It was argued that in a topological phase there is a universal additive constant in the entanglement entropy, called the topological entanglement entropy, which reflects the underlying gauge theory for the topological order. In the present paper, we evaluate numerically the topological entanglement entropy in the ground states of a quantum dimer model on the triangular lattice, which is known to have a dimer liquid phase with Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ topological order. We examine the two original constructions to measure the topological entropy by combining entropies on plural areas, and we observe that in the large-area limit they both approach the value expected for Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ topological order. We also consider the entanglement entropy on a topologically nontrivial ``zigzag'' area and propose to use it as another way to measure the topological entropy.
The topological entanglement entropy (TEE) of Gutzwiller projected RVB state is studied with Monte Carlo simulation. With tricks to speed up the convergence of TEE, we are able to show that the spin liquid state studied in Zhang et al. [Phys. Rev. B 84, 075128 (2011)] actually does not support Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ topological order. We find that both an approximate Marshall sign structure and a long-ranged RVB amplitude are responsible for the suppression of the vison gap in this spin liquid state. On the other hand, a TEE of ln2\mathrm{ln}2ln2 is clearly demonstrated for a short range RVB state on triangular lattice proposed in Yunoki et al. [Phys. Rev. B 74, 014408 (2006)]. We find the TEE of the RVB wave function is mainly determined by its phase rather than its amplitude. Our results indicate that the effective field theory misses some key information for the topological property of a RVB state.
Abstract We analyze the computational aspects of detecting topological order in a quantum many-body system. We contrast the widely used topological entanglement entropy with a recently introduced operational definition for topological order based on error correction properties, finding exponential scaling with the system size for the former and polynomial scaling for the latter. We exemplify our approach for a variant of the paradigmatic toric code model with mobile particles, finding that the error correction method allows to treat substantially larger system sizes. In particular, the phase diagram of the model can be successfully computed using error correction, while the topological entanglement entropy is too severely limited by finite size effects to obtain conclusive results. While we mainly focus on one-dimensional systems whose ground states can be expressed in terms of matrix product states, our strategy can be readily generalized to higher dimensions and systems out of equilibrium, even allowing for an efficient detection of topological order in current quantum simulation experiments.