Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1912.04293 · Physical Review Letters

Detecting Topological Order at Finite Temperature Using Entanglement Negativity

Tsung-Cheng Lu, Timothy H. Hsieh, Tarun Grover

Published Sep 8, 2020• 83 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose a diagnostic for finite temperature topological order using "topological entanglement negativity," the long-range component of a mixed-state entanglement measure. As a demonstration, we study the toric code model in d spatial dimensions for d=2,3,4, and find that when topological order survives thermal fluctuations, it possesses a nonzero topological entanglement negativity, whose value is equal to the topological entanglement entropy at zero temperature. Furthermore, we show that the Gibbs state of 2D and 3D toric code at any nonzero temperature, and that of 4D toric code above a certain critical temperature, can be expressed as a convex combination of short-range entangled pure states, consistent with the absence of topological order.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.125.116801

Related papers

Finite-Temperature Quantum Topological Order in Three Dimensions

Shu-Tong Zhou, Meng Cheng, Tibor Rakovszky +2 more

We identify a three-dimensional system that exhibits long-range entanglement at sufficiently small but nonzero temperature-it therefore constitutes a quantum topological order at finite temperature. The model of interest is known as the fermionic toric code, a variant of the usual 3D toric code, which admits emergent fermionic pointlike excitations. The fermionic toric code, importantly, possesses an anomalous two-form symmetry, associated with the spacelike Wilson loops of the fermionic excitations. We argue that it is this symmetry that imbues low-temperature thermal states with a novel topological order and long-range entanglement. Based on the current classification of three-dimensional topological orders, we expect that the low-temperature thermal states of the fermionic toric code belong to a phase of matter that, in the context of equilibrium phases of matter, only exists at nonzero temperatures. We conjecture that further examples of topological orders at nonzero temperatures are given by discrete gauge theories with anomalous two-form symmetries. Our Letter therefore opens the door to studying quantum topological order at nonzero temperature in physically realistic dimensions.

arXiv:2503.02928•Physical Review Letters•Jul 1, 2025•8 citations

Entanglement cost in topological stabilizer models at finite temperature

Tsung-Cheng Lu, En-Jui Kuo, Hung-Hwa Lin

The notion of entanglement has been useful for characterizing universal properties of quantum phases of matter. From the perspective of quantum information theory, it is tempting to ask whether their entanglement structures possess any operational meanings, e.g., quantifying the cost of preparing an entangled system via free operations such as the local operations and classical communication (LOCC). While the answer is affirmative for pure states in that entanglement entropy coincides with entanglement cost, the case for mixed states is less understood. To this end, we study the entanglement cost required to prepare the thermal Gibbs states of certain many-body systems under positive-partial-transpose (PPT) preserving operations, a set of free operations that include LOCC. Specifically, we show that for the Gibbs states of $d$-dimensional toric code models for $d = 2, 3, 4$, the PPT entanglement cost exactly equals entanglement negativity, a measure of mixed-state entanglement that has been known to diagnose topological order at finite temperature.

arXiv:2201.08382•Jan 20, 2022•0 citations

Long-Range Toric Code: Finite-Temperature Topological Order in Two Dimensions

Jacopo Gliozzi, Taylor L. Hughes, Kyung-Su Kim

We introduce two-dimensional toric code models with additional long-range loop interactions. Our models preserve the topologically ordered ground states of the ordinary toric code, while confining anyons at zero temperature. For sufficiently long-ranged interactions, we argue that this confinement persists at finite temperatures, strongly constraining anyon mobility and giving rise to finite-temperature topological order. This topological phase acts as a self-correcting quantum memory and exhibits long-range entanglement. For shorter-ranged interactions, signatures of topological order survive only up to an exponentially large length scale at finite temperature, yielding a partially self-correcting quantum memory.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2610.37765•Oct 29, 2026•0 citations

Characterizing long-range entanglement in a mixed state through an emergent order on the entangling surface

Tsung-Cheng Lu, Sagar Vijay

Topologically-ordered phases of matter at nonzero temperature are conjectured to exhibit universal patterns of long-range entanglement, which can be detected using the entanglement negativity, a mixed-state entanglement measure. In this paper, we show that the entanglement negativity in certain topological orders can be understood through the properties of an emergent symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order that is localized on the entanglement bipartition. This connection leads to an understanding of (i) universal contributions to the entanglement negativity, which diagnose finite-temperature topological order and (ii) the behavior of the entanglement negativity across certain phase transitions in which thermal fluctuations eventually destroy long-range entanglement across the bipartition surface. Within this correspondence, the universal patterns of entanglement in the finite-temperature topological order are related to the stability of an emergent SPT order against a symmetry-breaking field. SPT orders protected by higher-form symmetries---which arise, for example, in the description of the entanglement negativity for ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ topological order in $d=4$ spatial dimensions---remain robust even in the presence of a weak symmetry-breaking perturbation, leading to long-range entanglement at nonzero temperature for certain topological orders.

arXiv:2201.07792•Physical Review Research•Jul 17, 2023•19 citations

Finite-temperature topological entanglement entropy for CSS codes

Zhi Li, Roger S. K. Mong

We consider topological entanglement entropy (TEE) at finite temperature for CSS codes, which include some ordinary topological-ordered systems such as the toric code and some fracton models such as the Haah's code and the X-cube model. We find, under the assumption that there is no extended critical phase, the finite-temperature TEE is a piecewise constant function of the temperature, with possible discontinuities only at phase transitions. We then consider phase transitions of CSS codes. We claim that there must exist a phase transition at zero temperature for any CSS codes in 2D and 3D with topological order. This statement can be rigorous proved for some familiar examples, while for general models it can be argued based on the low-temperature expansion. This indicates the break down of topological orders at finite temperature. We also discuss possible connections with self-correcting quantum memory.

arXiv:1910.07545•Oct 16, 2019•4 citations

Disentangling transitions in topological order induced by boundary decoherence

Tsung-Cheng Lu

We study the entanglement structure of topological orders subject to decoherence on the bipartition boundary. Focusing on the toric codes in $d$ space dimensions for $d=2,3,4$, we explore whether the boundary decoherence may be able to induce a disentangling transition, characterized by the destruction of mixed-state long-range entanglement across the bipartition, measured by topological entanglement negativity. A key insight of our approach is the connection between the negativity spectrum of the decohered mixed states and emergent symmetry-protected topological orders under certain symmetry-preserving perturbation localized on the bipartition boundary. This insight allows us to analytically derive the exact results of entanglement negativity and characterize the universality class of the disentangling transition without using a replica trick.

arXiv:2404.06514•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 23, 2024•12 citations
We propose a diagnostic for finite temperature topological order using "topological entanglement negativity," the long-range component of a mixed-state entanglement measure. As a demonstration, we study the toric code model in d spatial dimensions for d=2,3,4, and find that when topological order survives thermal fluctuations, it possesses a nonzero topological entanglement negativity, whose value is equal to the topological entanglement entropy at zero temperature. Furthermore, we show that the Gibbs state of 2D and 3D toric code at any nonzero temperature, and that of 4D toric code above a certain critical temperature, can be expressed as a convex combination of short-range entangled pure states, consistent with the absence of topological order.
We identify a three-dimensional system that exhibits long-range entanglement at sufficiently small but nonzero temperature-it therefore constitutes a quantum topological order at finite temperature. The model of interest is known as the fermionic toric code, a variant of the usual 3D toric code, which admits emergent fermionic pointlike excitations. The fermionic toric code, importantly, possesses an anomalous two-form symmetry, associated with the spacelike Wilson loops of the fermionic excitations. We argue that it is this symmetry that imbues low-temperature thermal states with a novel topological order and long-range entanglement. Based on the current classification of three-dimensional topological orders, we expect that the low-temperature thermal states of the fermionic toric code belong to a phase of matter that, in the context of equilibrium phases of matter, only exists at nonzero temperatures. We conjecture that further examples of topological orders at nonzero temperatures are given by discrete gauge theories with anomalous two-form symmetries. Our Letter therefore opens the door to studying quantum topological order at nonzero temperature in physically realistic dimensions.
The notion of entanglement has been useful for characterizing universal properties of quantum phases of matter. From the perspective of quantum information theory, it is tempting to ask whether their entanglement structures possess any operational meanings, e.g., quantifying the cost of preparing an entangled system via free operations such as the local operations and classical communication (LOCC). While the answer is affirmative for pure states in that entanglement entropy coincides with entanglement cost, the case for mixed states is less understood. To this end, we study the entanglement cost required to prepare the thermal Gibbs states of certain many-body systems under positive-partial-transpose (PPT) preserving operations, a set of free operations that include LOCC. Specifically, we show that for the Gibbs states of ddd-dimensional toric code models for d=2,3,4d = 2, 3, 4d=2,3,4, the PPT entanglement cost exactly equals entanglement negativity, a measure of mixed-state entanglement that has been known to diagnose topological order at finite temperature.
We introduce two-dimensional toric code models with additional long-range loop interactions. Our models preserve the topologically ordered ground states of the ordinary toric code, while confining anyons at zero temperature. For sufficiently long-ranged interactions, we argue that this confinement persists at finite temperatures, strongly constraining anyon mobility and giving rise to finite-temperature topological order. This topological phase acts as a self-correcting quantum memory and exhibits long-range entanglement. For shorter-ranged interactions, signatures of topological order survive only up to an exponentially large length scale at finite temperature, yielding a partially self-correcting quantum memory.
Topologically-ordered phases of matter at nonzero temperature are conjectured to exhibit universal patterns of long-range entanglement, which can be detected using the entanglement negativity, a mixed-state entanglement measure. In this paper, we show that the entanglement negativity in certain topological orders can be understood through the properties of an emergent symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order that is localized on the entanglement bipartition. This connection leads to an understanding of (i) universal contributions to the entanglement negativity, which diagnose finite-temperature topological order and (ii) the behavior of the entanglement negativity across certain phase transitions in which thermal fluctuations eventually destroy long-range entanglement across the bipartition surface. Within this correspondence, the universal patterns of entanglement in the finite-temperature topological order are related to the stability of an emergent SPT order against a symmetry-breaking field. SPT orders protected by higher-form symmetries---which arise, for example, in the description of the entanglement negativity for Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ topological order in d=4d=4d=4 spatial dimensions---remain robust even in the presence of a weak symmetry-breaking perturbation, leading to long-range entanglement at nonzero temperature for certain topological orders.
We consider topological entanglement entropy (TEE) at finite temperature for CSS codes, which include some ordinary topological-ordered systems such as the toric code and some fracton models such as the Haah's code and the X-cube model. We find, under the assumption that there is no extended critical phase, the finite-temperature TEE is a piecewise constant function of the temperature, with possible discontinuities only at phase transitions. We then consider phase transitions of CSS codes. We claim that there must exist a phase transition at zero temperature for any CSS codes in 2D and 3D with topological order. This statement can be rigorous proved for some familiar examples, while for general models it can be argued based on the low-temperature expansion. This indicates the break down of topological orders at finite temperature. We also discuss possible connections with self-correcting quantum memory.
We study the entanglement structure of topological orders subject to decoherence on the bipartition boundary. Focusing on the toric codes in ddd space dimensions for d=2,3,4d=2,3,4d=2,3,4, we explore whether the boundary decoherence may be able to induce a disentangling transition, characterized by the destruction of mixed-state long-range entanglement across the bipartition, measured by topological entanglement negativity. A key insight of our approach is the connection between the negativity spectrum of the decohered mixed states and emergent symmetry-protected topological orders under certain symmetry-preserving perturbation localized on the bipartition boundary. This insight allows us to analytically derive the exact results of entanglement negativity and characterize the universality class of the disentangling transition without using a replica trick.