Quantum cryptography with twisted photons through an outdoor underwater channel
Frédéric Bouchard, Alicia Sit, Felix Hufnagel, Aazad Abbas, Yingwen Zhang, Khabat Heshami, Robert Fickler, Christoph Marquardt, Gerd Leuchs, Robert W. Boyd, Ebrahim Karimi
Quantum communication has been successfully implemented in optical fibres and through free-space. Fibre systems, though capable of fast key and low error rates, are impractical in communicating with destinations without an established fibre link. Free-space quantum channels can overcome such limitations and reach long distances with the advent of satellite-to-ground links. However, turbulence, resulting from local fluctuations in refractive index, becomes a major challenge by adding errors and losses. Recently, an interest in investigating the possibility of underwater quantum channels has arisen. Here, we investigate the effect of turbulence on an underwater quantum channel using twisted photons in outdoor conditions. We study the effect of turbulence on transmitted error rates, and compare different quantum cryptographic protocols in an underwater quantum channel, showing the feasibility of high-dimensional encoding schemes. Our work may open the way for secure high-dimensional quantum communication between submersibles, and provides important input for potential submersibles-to-satellite quantum communication.
Quantum communication has been successfully implemented in optical fibres and through free-space. Fibre systems, though capable of fast key and low error rates, are impractical in communicating with destinations without an established fibre link. Free-space quantum channels can overcome such limitations and reach long distances with the advent of satellite-to-ground links. However, turbulence, resulting from local fluctuations in refractive index, becomes a major challenge by adding errors and losses. Recently, an interest in investigating the possibility of underwater quantum channels has arisen. Here, we investigate the effect of turbulence on an underwater quantum channel using twisted photons in outdoor conditions. We study the effect of turbulence on transmitted error rates, and compare different quantum cryptographic protocols in an underwater quantum channel, showing the feasibility of high-dimensional encoding schemes. Our work may open the way for secure high-dimensional quantum communication between submersibles, and provides important input for potential submersibles-to-satellite quantum communication.
This thesis encompasses a body of experimental work on the use of structured light in quantum cryptographic protocols. In particular, we investigate the ability to perform quantum key distribution through various quantum channels (fibre, free-space, underwater) in laboratory and realistic conditions. We first demonstrate that a special type of optical fibre (vortex fibre) capable of coherently transmitting vector vortex modes is a viable quantum channel. Next, we describe the first demonstration of high-dimensional quantum cryptography using structured photons in an urban setting. In particular, the prevalence of atmospheric turbulence can introduce many errors to a transmitted key; however, we are still able to transmit more information per carrier using a 4-dimensional scheme in comparison to a 2-dimensional one. Lastly, we investigate the possibility of performing secure quantum communication with twisted photons in an uncontrolled underwater channel. We find that though it is possible for low-dimensional schemes, high-dimensional schemes suffer from underwater turbulence without the use of corrective wavefront techniques.
Light with a complex amplitude structure invokes interesting fundamental properties such as phase and polarization singularities, which also enables novel applications in classical and quantum optical experiments [1]. One feature, namely a twisted phase front and its orbital angular momentum, attracted a lot of attention due its broad range of applications. In the quantum domain, structured photons are highly beneficial since they serve as a physical realizations of high-dimensional states, which allow for example an enlarged information content per single carrier and are known to have a better noise resistance in quantum cryptography applications [2]. At first, I will present a set of laboratory experiments, in which we investigate different quantum cryptographic protocols. Our versatile approach relies on a heralded single photon source, a preparation stage at Alice’s sender, a 1 m-long quantum channel, and a detection stage at Bob’s receiver unit. Because the generation and detection is performed using computer generated, re-programmable holograms displayed on spatial light modulators, the same setup can be used to experimentally survey different quantum key distribution techniques and compare their benefits and deficiencies. The investigated protocols are all based on high-dimensional quantum states and include the seminal protocol of Bennett & Brassard, tomographic protocols, and recently introduced differential phase shift protocols [3,4]. We compare the performance of the different approaches in terms of noise resistance and secret key rates. Our study highlights the benefits of using structured photons and high-dimensional quantum states for different implementations and channel conditions. In a second series of experiments, we get a step closer to real world implementations and investigate long distance and underwater quantum cryptography using high-dimensional quantum information encoded on structured light. We establish an approx. 280m long intra-city quantum link and study the influence of turbulence on achievable key rates [5]. We further test the effect of water turbulences on an underwater quantum channel using twisted photons in an outdoor pool of 3 m length [6]. Although we are able establish a secure channel with three dimensional quantum states, we find mode deformations and vortex splitting due to strong turbulent conditions most probably caused by local variations in temperature. We perform a detailed analysis of the observed turbulence and find that underwater channels may give rise to turbulent conditions that are fundamentally different in terms of temporal and spatial disturbance from those present in a free-space channel. [1] H. Rubinsztein-Dunlop et al. Roadmap on structured light, Journal of Optics 19, 013001 (2017) [2] M. Erhard, R. Fickler, M. Krenn, A. Zeilinger, Twisted Photons: New Quantum Perspectives in High Dimensions, Nature Light: Science & Applications, 7 17146 (2018) [3] F. Bouchard et al. Experimental investigation of quantum key distribution protocols with twisted photons, arXiv:1802.05773 [4] F. Bouchard, A. Sit, K. Heshami, R. Fickler, E. Karimi, Round-Robin Differential Phase-Shift Quantum Key Distribution with Twisted Photons, arXiv:1803.00166 [5] A. Sit et al. High-Dimensional Intra-City Quantum Cryptography with Structured Photons, Optica 4, 1006 (2017) [6] F. Bouchard et al. Underwater Quantum Key Distribution in Outdoor Conditions with Twisted Photons, arXiv:1801.10299
Over the last few decades, quantum cryptography has been one of the most important quantum technologies developed. It holds the promise of communicating secure information over untrusted channels. In particular, quantum cryptography is immune to the eventual threats posed by large-scale quantum computers, which is not the case for our current classical cryptography infrastructures. In a world where information, communication and privacy are of paramount importance, the development of secure quantum communication infrastructures becomes imperative. So far, most of the quantum cryptographic systems developed to date are based on two-dimensional encoding schemes, analogous to classical bits, known as qubits. Nevertheless, other than for the polarization of light, photonic degrees of freedom, i.e. position, momentum, time and frequency, naturally occur as high-dimensional quantum systems. Moreover, by considering high-dimensional encoding schemes beyond qubits, advantages in terms of information capacity and noise tolerance are predicted in theory. In this thesis, the basic components of a high-dimensional quantum cryptographic system are investigated. We begin by reviewing important developments in quantum cryptography and high-dimensional quantum information. As a starting point, two different quantum information tasks, i.e. optimal quantum cloning and quantum metrology, are experimentally investigated for high-dimensional quantum systems in order to demonstrate the numerous advantages of performing quantum tasks beyond qubits. The photonic degree of freedom used in these experiments, known as transverse spatial modes, is obtained by combining the position and momentum photonics degrees of freedom. Thus, we develop a novel method to measure high-dimensional quantum states encoded in arbitrary spatial modes. Using a similar characterization technique, several high-dimensional quantum communication channels are characterized to perform high-dimensional quantum cryptography. The tools developed in the laboratory are then brought to realistic conditions in order to test the feasibility of high-dimensional quantum cryptography. Two different types of quantum channels are experimentally investigated, namely an intra-city 300 m long free-space link and a short 3 m outdoor underwater link. Finally, we investigate and compare novel high-dimensional protocols to overcome current limitations.
Abstract Underwater quantum communication has recently been explored using polarization and orbital angular momentum (OAM). Here, we show that spatially structured modes, e.g., a coherent superposition of beams carrying both polarization and OAM, can also be used for underwater quantum cryptography. We also use the polarization degree of freedom to investigate the impact of the channel length on key rates for quantum communication applications. The underwater channel proves to be a difficult environment for establishing quantum communication as underwater optical turbulence results in significant beam wandering and distortions. However, the errors associated to the turbulence do not result in error rates above the threshold for establishing a positive key in a quantum communication link with both the polarization and spatially structured photons. The impact of the underwater channel on the spatially structured modes is also investigated at different distances using polarization tomography.
Photonic entanglement is a fundamental resource in quantum information processing and its distribution between distant parties is a key challenge in quantum communications. Optical satellite links allow transmitting entangled photons over longer distances than currently possible on ground and could provide a path towards global quantum communication networks. The majority of current photonic free-space quantum communication systems, including two recent quantum satellite experiments, use two-dimensional polarization encoding, where each photon can carry at most a single bit of quantum information. Encoding additional qubits in the high-dimensional spatio-temporal degrees of freedom could not only increase channel capacities but also improve robustness with respect to noise and eavesdropping in quantum cryptography. Here, we give an overview of our efforts towards exploiting high-dimensional entanglement in long-distance free-space quantum communications. We report on the results of a first feasibility study, in which we used polarization / energy-time hyperentanglement to increase the dimensionality of the state space and transmit genuine 4-dimensional entanglement via an intra-city free-space link. We discuss how we intend to extend this approach to applications in noise-tolerant large-alphabet quantum key distribution via free-space links, and, ultimately, experiments with satellites.
When light is propagated through a channel that is not a waveguide, such as a fiber, it is known as a free-space optical channel. When used in communication systems, free-space optical channels provide the advantages of high communication rates, lower power, and minimal infrastructure installation. When the free-space optical channel has a random medium in it, such as the atmosphere, the distortions will be applied to the phase. The phase distortions can lead to intensity fluctuations and additional beam spreading. To compensate for the distortions adaptive optics can be used, allowing for the stability of the system to be improved. Additionally, post processing techniques on transmitted data can also be used to improve the stability of the channel. By significantly decreasing the number of photons transmitted, a classical communication channel can be considered as a quantum channel. Encoding information into the quantum states of the transmitted photons, quantum communication can be performed. When transmitting on the order of 1 photon per pulse, classical post processing techniques cannot be used to improve the stability of the channel. To stabilize the free-space optical channel, adaptive optics can be used at the transmitter or receiver. As no measurement of the quantum state is performed by the adaptive optics system, no information in the photon is lost. In this work, quantum key distribution will be implemented over the quantum channel. The focus of this work is on the design and study of how the channel degradations can be overcome, as well as the establishment of a free-space optical channel with adaptive optics in a quantum networking testbed. Quantum key distribution systems were simulated over a 30 km maritime channel as well as over a underwater channel. For the 30 km channel, the use of multiple parallel spatial modes results in the highest increases of the secure key rate at the cost of transmitting a lower average number of photons. When adaptive optics is applied, the secure key rates have a small increase, however as the strength of the turbulence increases from weak to moderate, the relative improvement is higher. For the underwater channel, operation at lower depths is optimal as fewer background photons reach the receiver and the channel attenuation is lower. In the experimental setup, it was found that the single photon detectors that are being used are the limiting the channel loss to be at most 6 dB. The free space optical link established between the Electrical and Computer Engineering building and College of Optical Sciences uses a corner cube retro-reflector to yield a distance of 1.45 km. The channel has been characterized at various times of day to determine the strength of the atmospheric turbulence, which ranges from a scintillation index of 0.07 to 2.21. A classical communication experiment was performed, resulting in error-free transmission while the input power to the EDFA before the photodetector was consistently above -25 dBm.