Quantum computing is emerging at a meteoric pace from a pure academic field to a fully industrial framework. Rapid advances are happening both in the physical realisations of quantum chips, and in their potential software applications. In contrast, we are not seeing that rapid growth in the design and verification methodologies for scaled-up quantum machines. In this work we describe the field of verification of quantum computers. We discuss the underlying concepts of this field, its theoretical and practical challenges, and state-of-the-art approaches to addressing those challenges. The goal of this paper is to help facilitate early efforts to adapt and create verification methodologies for quantum computers and systems. Without such early efforts, a debilitating gap may form between the state-of-the-art of low level physical technologies for quantum computers, and our ability to build medium, large, and very large scale integrated quantum circuits (M/L/VLSIQ).
Quantum computing is emerging at a meteoric pace from a pure academic field to a fully industrial framework. Rapid advances are happening both in the physical realisations of quantum chips, and in their potential software applications. In contrast, we are not seeing that rapid growth in the design and verification methodologies for scaled-up quantum machines. In this work we describe the field of verification of quantum computers. We discuss the underlying concepts of this field, its theoretical and practical challenges, and state-of-the-art approaches to addressing those challenges. The goal of this paper is to help facilitate early efforts to adapt and create verification methodologies for quantum computers and systems. Without such early efforts, a debilitating gap may form between the state-of-the-art of low level physical technologies for quantum computers, and our ability to build medium, large, and very large scale integrated quantum circuits (M/L/VLSIQ).
Quantum technologies are progressing at an extraordinary pace and are poised to transform numerous sectors both nationally and globally. Among them, quantum computing stands out for its potential to revolutionize areas such as cryptography, optimization, and the simulation of quantum systems, offering dramatic speed-ups for specific classes of problems. As quantum devices evolve and become increasingly pervasive, guaranteeing their correctness is of paramount importance. This necessitates the development of rigorous methods and tools to analyze and verify their behavior. However, the construction of such verification frameworks presents fundamental challenges. Quantum phenomena such as superposition and entanglement give rise to computational behaviors that differ profoundly from those of classical systems, leading to inherently probabilistic models and exponentially large state spaces, even for relatively small programs. Addressing these challenges requires building on the extensive expertise of the formal methods community in classical program verification, while incorporating recent advances and collaborative efforts in quantum systems. An interesting challenge for the verification community is to design and implement novel verification frameworks that transfer the key strengths of classical verification, such as expressive specification, precise error detection, automation, and scalability, to the quantum domain. We expect that the results of this research will play a crucial role in enabling the dependable deployment of quantum technologies across a wide range of future applications.
Design, simulation, analysis and verification methodologies are crucial for developing electronic circuits and systems at large. Whereas long-standing EDA software is used in the semiconductor technology, there is no counterpart for quantum computing systems yet. Although the quantum computing community started utilizing and adapting some of the already existing EDA tools, for instance, to design quantum processors and control electronics for driving the qubits, or even to solve some quantum computing design tasks, they do not fully use the expertise gained over the last decades in the field of design automation. Current intermediate-scale quantum computers have been designed in an ‘adhoc’ manner with heterogeneous methods and tools. As we are entering the large-scale era, it is timely and key to further adopt EDA methodologies and software for quantum computing. In this paper, we provide an overview on how full-stack quantum computing systems are being implemented nowadays and discuss which the main challenges are for transitioning from this current scenario to a comprehensive framework encompassing full automated system-wide architecting, design, simulation, verification, and test.
Quantum computing uses the laws of quantum mechanics to perform computation. Information is stored in qubits and processed using quantum gates arranged as quantum circuits. As quantum hardware grows in size and complexity, verifying these systems becomes increasingly difficult. Traditional verification methods do not scale well and quickly become computationally infeasible. This creates a strong need for more powerful and scalable verification techniques. Formal methods provide a potential solution to this problem. Techniques such as theorem proving, model checking, and symbolic reasoning offer mathematically rigorous ways to verify correctness, equivalence, and implementation. They also help detect design errors early in the development process. This review examines how formal methods are applied to quantum circuit verification. It focuses on barrier certificates, abstract interpretation, model checking, theorem proving, and emerging hybrid approaches. The review discusses both the theoretical foundations and practical applications of these techniques. Their strengths and limitations are analysed through representative case studies. Finally, the review highlights open challenges and identifies promising directions for future research. An extensive set of references is included to support further study and exploration.
Over the past 27 years, quantum computing has seen a huge rise in interest from both academia and industry. At the current rate, quantum computers are growing in size rapidly backed up by the increase of research in the field. Significant efforts are being made to improve the reliability of quantum hardware and to develop suitable software to program quantum computers. In contrast, the verification of quantum programs has received relatively less attention. Verifying programs is especially important in the quantum setting due to how difficult it is to program complex algorithms correctly on resource-constrained and error-prone quantum hardware. Research into creating verification frameworks for quantum programs has seen recent development, with a variety of tools implemented using a collection of theoretical ideas. This survey aims to be a short introduction into the area of formal verification of quantum programs, bringing together theory and tools developed to date. Further, this survey examines some of the challenges that the field may face in the future, namely the development of complex quantum algorithms.
Quantum computing is transitioning from laboratory research to industrial deployment, yet significant challenges persist: system scalability and performance, fabrication yields, and the advancement of algorithms and applications. We emphasize that in building quantum computers -- spanning quantum chips, system integration, instruction sets, algorithms, and middleware such as quantum error correction schemes -- design is everywhere. In this paper, we advocate for a holistic design perspective in quantum computing, a perspective we argue is pivotal to unlocking innovative co-design opportunities and addressing the aforementioned key challenges. To equip readers with sufficient background for exploring co-optimization opportunities, we detail how interconnected computational methods and tools collaborate to enable end-to-end quantum computer design. This coverage encompasses critical stages -- such as chip layout design automation, high-fidelity system-level simulation, Hamiltonian derivation for quantum system modeling, control pulse simulation, decoherence analysis, and physical verification and testing -- followed by quantum instruction set design. We then proceed to quantum system and software development, including quantum circuit synthesis, quantum error correction and fault tolerance, and logic verification and testing. Through these discussions, we illustrate with concrete examples -- including co-optimizing quantum instruction sets with algorithmic considerations, customizing error correction circuits to hardware-specific constraints, and streamlining quantum chip design through tailored code design, among others. We hope that the detailed end-to-end design workflow as well as these examples will foster dialogue between the hardware and software communities, ultimately facilitating the translation of meaningful research findings into future quantum hardware implementations.
Quantum computing is an emerging paradigm that leverages the principles of quantum mechanics to solve computational problems beyond the reach of classical computers. This article provides an overview of the fundamental concepts of qubits, the distinctive features of quantum mechanics such as superposition and entanglement, and the challenges of building scalable, fault-tolerant systems. It surveys key quantum algorithms and their potential applications in fields including cryptography, optimization, finance, chemistry, and machine learning. Additionally, it highlights the importance of verification frameworks for ensuring the reliability of quantum programs. A literature review of significant contributions is presented, drawing insights from recent surveys on quantum algorithms, qubit technologies, and software verification approaches. The article concludes by discussing ongoing challenges, such as error correction overhead, hardware scalability, and verification complexity, and suggests directions for future research.