Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Complex Light and Optical Forces

Spatial modes for testing indefinite causal order

Jacquiline Romero, Kaumudibikash Goswami, Christina Giarmatzi, Fabio Costa, Cyril Branciard, Andrew G. White

Published Feb 22, 2018• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The fundamental notion of fixed order between two events is challenged by formulations of quantum mechanics that makes no reference to a global time. The indefinite causal order arising from these formalisms can be realised using the quantum switch, a device where two operations can act in two different orders simultaneously. Similar to entanglement verification which employ entanglement witness, we verify indefinite causal order using a causal witness. In our experiment, we use polarisation as a control for the order of the operations that act on the spatial mode of a photon. We measure a causal witness value of -0.16±0.013, below the threshold of zero, thus demonstrating indefinite causal order in the quantum switch.

DOI
10.1117/12.2292732

Related papers

Indefinite Causal Order in a Quantum Switch

Kaumudibikash Goswami, Christina Giarmatzi, Michael J. Kewming +4 more

Quantum mechanics allows events to happen with no definite causal order: this can be verified by measuring a causal witness, in the same way that an entanglement witness verifies entanglement. Here, we realize a photonic quantum switch, where two operations A[over ^] and B[over ^] act in a quantum superposition of their two possible orders. The operations are on the transverse spatial mode of the photons; polarization coherently controls their order. Our implementation ensures that the operations cannot be distinguished by spatial or temporal position-further it allows qudit encoding in the target. We confirm our quantum switch has no definite causal order by constructing a causal witness and measuring its value to be 18 standard deviations beyond the definite-order bound.

arXiv:1803.04302•Physical Review Letters•Aug 31, 2018•245 citations

Witnessing causal nonseparability

Mateus Araújo, Cyril Branciard, Fabio Costa +3 more

Our common understanding of the physical world deeply relies on the notion that events are ordered with respect to some time parameter, with past events serving as causes for future ones. Nonetheless, it was recently found that it is possible to formulate quantum mechanics without any reference to a global time or causal structure. The resulting framework includes new kinds of quantum resources that allow performing tasks—in particular, the violation of causal inequalities —which are impossible for events ordered according to a global causal order. However, no physical implementation of such resources is known. Here we show that a recently demonstrated resource for quantum computation—the quantum switch —is a genuine example of ‘indefinite causal order’. We do this by introducing a new tool—the causal witness —which can detect the causal nonseparability of any quantum resource that is incompatible with a definite causal order. We show however that the quantum switch does not violate any causal inequality.

arXiv:1506.03776•New Journal of Physics•Oct 19, 2015•196 citations

Experimental violation of a Bell-like causal inequality in a photonic quantum switch

Dengke Qu, Quan Lin, Lei Xiao +2 more

Indefinite causal order can be realized by a quantum switch, yet its experimental certification has so far relied on assumptions about the devices. A device-independent verification of indefinite causal order would show, from the observed correlations alone and without relying on a detailed model of the devices, that they are incompatible with any classical description based on a fixed causal order. Here, we implement a photonic quantum switch in a device-independent scenario and test a Bell-like causal inequality using entangled photons. One photon serves as the control qubit of the quantum switch, while the other is measured by a distant party with rapidly and independently chosen settings. We observe a violation of the causal inequality by 24 standard deviations. These results provide experimental evidence for indefinite causal order, albeit in the presence of remaining loopholes, and mark an important step toward a fully loophole-free device-independent verification of causal indefiniteness in quantum processes.

Science Advances•Aug 7, 2026•0 citations

Indefinite Causal Order and Quantum Coordinates

Anne-Catherine de la Hamette, Viktoria Kabel, Marios Christodoulou +1 more

Classically, the causal order of two timelike separated events A and B is fixed-either A before B or B before A. This is no longer true in quantum theory, where it is possible to encounter superpositions of causal orders. The quantum switch is one of the most prominent processes with indefinite causal order. Optical realizations of the quantum switch have been successfully implemented in experiments, but some argue that this merely simulates a process with indefinite causal order and that a superposition of spacetime metrics is required for a true realization. Here, we provide a relativistic definition of causal order between operationally defined events that defines a meaningful observable in both the general relativistic and quantum mechanical sense. Importantly, this observable does not distinguish between the indefinite causal order implemented on an optical bench and the gravitational quantum switch, a gedanken experiment where the indefinite causal order is achieved by a quantum superposition of gravitational fields. Therefore, our results support the thesis that the optical quantum switch is just as much a realization of indefinite causal order as its gravitational counterpart, which makes use of the quantum mechanical behavior of spacetime.

arXiv:2211.15685•Physical Review Letters•Sep 4, 2025•14 citations

Toward an Experimental Device-Independent Verification of Indefinite Causal Order

Carla M.D. Richter, Michael Antesberger, Huan Cao +2 more

In classical physics, events follow a definite causal order: the past influences the future, but not the reverse. Quantum theory, however, permits superpositions of causal orders—the so-called indefinite causal orders (ICOs)—which can provide operational advantages over classical scenarios. Verifying such phenomena has sparked significant interest, much like earlier efforts devoted to refuting local realism and confirming quantum entanglement. To date, demonstrations of ICO have all been based a process called the quantum switch and have relied on device-dependent or semi-device-independent protocols. Achieving a device-independent verification of ICO would imply that nature allows for correlations that do not respect causality, independent of any experimental assumptions or underlying theoretical description of the experiment. To this end, a recent theoretical development introduced a Bell-like inequality that allows for fully device-independent verification of ICO in a quantum switch. Here we implement this verification by experimentally violating this inequality. In particular, we measure a value of 1.8328 ± 0.0045 , which is 18 standard deviations above the definite causal order bound of 1.75 . Our work presents the first implementation of a device-independent protocol to verify ICO, albeit in the presence of experimental loopholes. This represents an important step toward the device-independent verification of an ICO and provides a context in which to identify loopholes specifically related to the verification of ICO.

arXiv:2506.16949•PRX Quantum•Jan 6, 2026•4 citations

Time-Delocalized Local Measurements in an Indefinite Causal Order

Yann Valibouse, Martí Cladera-Rosselló, Michael Antesberger +3 more

Processes with indefinite causal order (ICO), such as the quantum switch, are an emerging resource for quantum tasks and a fundamental test bed for studies of temporal correlations in quantum mechanics. A limitation of past photonic implementations of the quantum switch, however, is their inability to perform measurements inside the switch without either destroying the superposition of causal orders or delaying readout until the after the quantum switch. Measurements where the results are read out locally are needed for several applications of ICO, but also for a loophole-free verification of ICO. Here, we overcome past limitations by introducing a $\mathit{local}$ measurement scheme and coupling the photon in the switch to a $\mathit{time-delocalized}$ ancilla system. We experimentally realize this protocol using a photonic quantum switch with post-selected linear optical logic gates. Our method ensures that the measurement apparatus interacts with the system at two distinct times and yet yields a single outcome. We use a quantum eraser measurement to preserve the ICO, which we certify by measuring a causal witness and finding a negative value of $\mathcal{C}_W \approx -0.305 (1)$. Furthermore, by explicitly realizing a time-delocalized ancilla system, our protocol not only enables a new class of quantum switch protocols requiring local readout, but also provides a general method for path-coherence-preserving measurements with broad applications beyond ICO.

quant-pharXiv:2604.11878•Apr 15, 2026•0 citations
The fundamental notion of fixed order between two events is challenged by formulations of quantum mechanics that makes no reference to a global time. The indefinite causal order arising from these formalisms can be realised using the quantum switch, a device where two operations can act in two different orders simultaneously. Similar to entanglement verification which employ entanglement witness, we verify indefinite causal order using a causal witness. In our experiment, we use polarisation as a control for the order of the operations that act on the spatial mode of a photon. We measure a causal witness value of -0.16±0.013, below the threshold of zero, thus demonstrating indefinite causal order in the quantum switch.
Quantum mechanics allows events to happen with no definite causal order: this can be verified by measuring a causal witness, in the same way that an entanglement witness verifies entanglement. Here, we realize a photonic quantum switch, where two operations A[over ^] and B[over ^] act in a quantum superposition of their two possible orders. The operations are on the transverse spatial mode of the photons; polarization coherently controls their order. Our implementation ensures that the operations cannot be distinguished by spatial or temporal position-further it allows qudit encoding in the target. We confirm our quantum switch has no definite causal order by constructing a causal witness and measuring its value to be 18 standard deviations beyond the definite-order bound.
Our common understanding of the physical world deeply relies on the notion that events are ordered with respect to some time parameter, with past events serving as causes for future ones. Nonetheless, it was recently found that it is possible to formulate quantum mechanics without any reference to a global time or causal structure. The resulting framework includes new kinds of quantum resources that allow performing tasks—in particular, the violation of causal inequalities —which are impossible for events ordered according to a global causal order. However, no physical implementation of such resources is known. Here we show that a recently demonstrated resource for quantum computation—the quantum switch —is a genuine example of ‘indefinite causal order’. We do this by introducing a new tool—the causal witness —which can detect the causal nonseparability of any quantum resource that is incompatible with a definite causal order. We show however that the quantum switch does not violate any causal inequality.
Indefinite causal order can be realized by a quantum switch, yet its experimental certification has so far relied on assumptions about the devices. A device-independent verification of indefinite causal order would show, from the observed correlations alone and without relying on a detailed model of the devices, that they are incompatible with any classical description based on a fixed causal order. Here, we implement a photonic quantum switch in a device-independent scenario and test a Bell-like causal inequality using entangled photons. One photon serves as the control qubit of the quantum switch, while the other is measured by a distant party with rapidly and independently chosen settings. We observe a violation of the causal inequality by 24 standard deviations. These results provide experimental evidence for indefinite causal order, albeit in the presence of remaining loopholes, and mark an important step toward a fully loophole-free device-independent verification of causal indefiniteness in quantum processes.
Classically, the causal order of two timelike separated events A and B is fixed-either A before B or B before A. This is no longer true in quantum theory, where it is possible to encounter superpositions of causal orders. The quantum switch is one of the most prominent processes with indefinite causal order. Optical realizations of the quantum switch have been successfully implemented in experiments, but some argue that this merely simulates a process with indefinite causal order and that a superposition of spacetime metrics is required for a true realization. Here, we provide a relativistic definition of causal order between operationally defined events that defines a meaningful observable in both the general relativistic and quantum mechanical sense. Importantly, this observable does not distinguish between the indefinite causal order implemented on an optical bench and the gravitational quantum switch, a gedanken experiment where the indefinite causal order is achieved by a quantum superposition of gravitational fields. Therefore, our results support the thesis that the optical quantum switch is just as much a realization of indefinite causal order as its gravitational counterpart, which makes use of the quantum mechanical behavior of spacetime.
In classical physics, events follow a definite causal order: the past influences the future, but not the reverse. Quantum theory, however, permits superpositions of causal orders—the so-called indefinite causal orders (ICOs)—which can provide operational advantages over classical scenarios. Verifying such phenomena has sparked significant interest, much like earlier efforts devoted to refuting local realism and confirming quantum entanglement. To date, demonstrations of ICO have all been based a process called the quantum switch and have relied on device-dependent or semi-device-independent protocols. Achieving a device-independent verification of ICO would imply that nature allows for correlations that do not respect causality, independent of any experimental assumptions or underlying theoretical description of the experiment. To this end, a recent theoretical development introduced a Bell-like inequality that allows for fully device-independent verification of ICO in a quantum switch. Here we implement this verification by experimentally violating this inequality. In particular, we measure a value of 1.8328 ± 0.0045 , which is 18 standard deviations above the definite causal order bound of 1.75 . Our work presents the first implementation of a device-independent protocol to verify ICO, albeit in the presence of experimental loopholes. This represents an important step toward the device-independent verification of an ICO and provides a context in which to identify loopholes specifically related to the verification of ICO.
Processes with indefinite causal order (ICO), such as the quantum switch, are an emerging resource for quantum tasks and a fundamental test bed for studies of temporal correlations in quantum mechanics. A limitation of past photonic implementations of the quantum switch, however, is their inability to perform measurements inside the switch without either destroying the superposition of causal orders or delaying readout until the after the quantum switch. Measurements where the results are read out locally are needed for several applications of ICO, but also for a loophole-free verification of ICO. Here, we overcome past limitations by introducing a local\mathit{local}local measurement scheme and coupling the photon in the switch to a time−delocalized\mathit{time-delocalized}time−delocalized ancilla system. We experimentally realize this protocol using a photonic quantum switch with post-selected linear optical logic gates. Our method ensures that the measurement apparatus interacts with the system at two distinct times and yet yields a single outcome. We use a quantum eraser measurement to preserve the ICO, which we certify by measuring a causal witness and finding a negative value of CW≈−0.305(1)\mathcal{C}_W \approx -0.305 (1)CW​≈−0.305(1). Furthermore, by explicitly realizing a time-delocalized ancilla system, our protocol not only enables a new class of quantum switch protocols requiring local readout, but also provides a general method for path-coherence-preserving measurements with broad applications beyond ICO.