Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Topological Trouble: The problem with Braiding Majoranas

David Peter Divincenzo

Published Jan 1, 2017• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

I will begin with a general discussion of anyons, of which Majoranas are an example. I continue with a discussion of why particle statistics in 2D can be neither bosonic nor fermionic, nor even abelian, and what it means for the charge to be fractional. A simple model of Kitaev, of electrons hopping on a branched 1D lattice with strong spin-orbit coupling and superconducting pairing, is sufficient to describe Majoranas and the gates that can be done by moving them around each other (braiding). I discuss a model calculation of the decohence of these Majorana qubits during braiding in a trijunction, due to thermally generated quasiparticles (bosonic environment). The limitations to coherence are significant; topological protection doesn't really work in this scenario. (work with Dr. Fabio Pedrocchi)

Related papers

Topological Protection and Non-Abelian Braiding of Majorana Zero Modes — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

FINDING: Majorana zero modes (MZMs) realize non-Abelian braid statistics via the Ising anyon model, with topological protection scaling exponentially in wire length. | MATH: Braid group \( B_n \) generators \( \sigma_i \) act on a 2D degenerate ground space (for \( 2n \) MZMs) via \( \gamma_i \to \gamma_j = U^\dagger \gamma_i U \), where \( U = \exp(\frac{\pi}{4}\gamma_i\gamma_j) \). The non-Abelian exchange yields \( \sigma_i^2 = -1 \) (fermion parity flip), and the topological gap \( \Delta_{\rm top} \propto e^{-L/\xi} \) (exponential suppression of splitting with wire length \( L \), coherence length \( \xi \)). Kitaev chain Hamiltonian: \( H = -\mu\sum c_i^\dagger c_i - t\sum(c_{i+1}^\dagger c_i + {\rm h.c.}) + \Delta\sum(c_{i+1}^\dagger c_i^\dagger + {\rm h.c.}) \), with MZM operators \( \gamma_1 = c_1 + c_1^\dagger \), \( \gamma_2 = -i(c_N - c_N^\dagger) \) at \( \mu=0, t=\Delta \). | CONNECTION: The braid group \( B_n \) is the fundamental group of configuration space of \( n \) Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Aug 29, 2026•0 citations

Computing with quantum knots: Marjorana modes, non-Abelian anyons, and topological quantum computation

S. Das Sarma

I will discuss the revolutionary new concept of topological quantum computation, which is fault-tolerant at the hardware level with no need, in principle, of any quantum error correction protocols. Errors simply do not occur since the physical qubits and the computation steps are protected against decoherence by non-local topological correlations in the underlying physical system. The key idea is non-Abelian statistics of the quasiparticles (called 'anyons' as opposed to fermions or bosons), where the space-time braiding of the anyons around each other, i.e. quantum 'knots', form topologically protected quantum gate operations. I will describe in detail the theoretical principles guiding the experimental search for the appropriate topological phases of matter where such non-Abelian anyons, which are low-dimensional solid state versions of the elusive and exotic Majorana fermions hypothesized seventy-five years ago, may exist. I will critically discuss the recent experimental claims of observing the Majorana modes in semiconductor nanowire structures following earlier theoretical proposals, outlining the future developments which would be necessary to eventually build a topological quantum computer.

•Oct 3, 2012•0 citations

Anyonic braiding in optical lattices

Chuanwei Zhang, V. W. Scarola, Sumanta Tewari +1 more

Topological quantum states of matter, both Abelian and non-Abelian, are characterized by excitations whose wavefunctions undergo nontrivial statistical transformations as one excitation is moved (braided) around another. Topological quantum computation proposes to use the topological protection and the braiding statistics of a non-Abelian topological state to perform quantum computation. The enormous technological prospect of topological quantum computation provides new motivation for experimentally observing a topological state. Here, we explicitly work out a realistic experimental scheme to create and braid the Abelian topological excitations in the Kitaev model built on a tunable robust system, a cold atom optical lattice. We also demonstrate how to detect the key feature of these excitations: their braiding statistics. Observation of this statistics would directly establish the existence of anyons, quantum particles that are neither fermions nor bosons. In addition to establishing topological matter, the experimental scheme we develop here can also be adapted to a non-Abelian topological state, supported by the same Kitaev model but in a different parameter regime, to eventually build topologically protected quantum gates.

arXiv:quant-ph/0609101•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Nov 13, 2007•67 citations

Topological Quantum Computing: Braid Groups and Majorana 1 Milestone — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

FINDING: Topological quantum computing leverages non-Abelian anyons and braid group representations for inherently fault-tolerant quantum gates, with Microsoft's Majorana 1 chip as a physical milestone. | MATH: Braid group \(B_n\) generators \(\sigma_i\) satisfy \(\sigma_i\sigma_{i+1}\sigma_i = \sigma_{i+1}\sigma_i\sigma_{i+1}\) and \(\sigma_i\sigma_j = \sigma_j\sigma_i\) for \(|i-j|\geq 2\). Non-Abelian anyons carry unitary representations \(U(\sigma_i)\) with \(U(\sigma_i)^2 \neq I\) (unlike fermions/bosons). Majorana zero modes obey \(\gamma_i^\dagger = \gamma_i\), \(\{\gamma_i,\gamma_j\} = 2\delta_{ij}\), and a pair encodes a qubit via parity \(i\gamma_1\gamma_2 = \pm 1\). Topological protection arises from the gap \(\Delta E \sim e^{-L/\xi}\) (exponential suppression with wire length \(L\) vs coherence length \(\xi\)). Fibonacci anyons (from SU(2)\(_3\) Chern-Simons theory) have quantum dimension \(\phi = (1+\sqrt{5})/2 \approx 1.618\), giving dense braiding — universal quantum co Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Aug 27, 2026•0 citations

Non-Abelian Majorana Modes Enable Topologically Protected Quantum Gates — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

FINDING: Majorana zero modes (MZMs) in topological superconductors obey non-Abelian braid statistics, with exponential suppression of coupling between spatially separated modes enabling topologically protected quantum gates. | MATH: The Kitaev chain Hamiltonian \( H = -t\sum c^\dagger_i c_{i+1} + \Delta\sum c_i c_{i+1} + \text{h.c.} - \mu\sum c^\dagger_i c_i \) yields unpaired Majorana operators \( \gamma_1, \gamma_2 \) with \( \gamma_i^\dagger = \gamma_i \), \( \{\gamma_i,\gamma_j\} = 2\delta_{ij} \). Braiding exchanges \( \gamma_i \to \gamma_j \) via unitary \( U_{ij} = \exp(\frac{\pi}{4}\gamma_i\gamma_j) \), giving non-Abelian representation of the braid group \( B_n \) (e.g., \( U_{12}U_{23} \neq U_{23}U_{12} \)). Splitting energy \( \Delta E \propto e^{-L/\xi} \) where \( \xi = \hbar v_F/\Delta \) is the coherence length — exponential suppression with wire length \( L \). | CONNECTION: The braid group \( B_n \) is generated by transpositions \( \sigma_i \) satisfying \( \sigma_i\s Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Aug 28, 2026•0 citations

Majorana Zero Modes Enable Topologically Protected Quantum Gates — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

FINDING: Majorana zero modes (MZMs) realize non-Abelian braid statistics via the Kitaev chain, with topological protection scaling exponentially in wire length, enabling topologically fault-tolerant quantum gates. | MATH: Kitaev chain Hamiltonian \( H = \sum_j [-t(c_j^\dagger c_{j+1} + h.c.) - \mu(c_j^\dagger c_j - 1/2) + \Delta(c_j c_{j+1} + h.c.)] \); Majorana operators \( \gamma_{2j-1} = c_j + c_j^\dagger \), \( \gamma_{2j} = -i(c_j - c_j^\dagger) \), satisfying \( \{\gamma_a, \gamma_b\} = 2\delta_{ab} \); topological gap \( \Delta_{\text{top}} \sim \Delta \) (superconducting gap); exponential suppression of coupling between MZMs: \( \epsilon \propto e^{-L/\xi} \) where \( \xi = \hbar v_F / \Delta \) is the coherence length; braid group \( B_n \) generated by exchanges \( \sigma_i \) with \( \sigma_i^2 = -1 \) (fermionic parity), yielding non-Abelian representation \( \rho(\sigma_i) = e^{\pm \pi \gamma_i \gamma_{i+1}/4} \). | CONNECTION: The braid group \( B_n \) is the fundamental Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Aug 28, 2026•0 citations
I will begin with a general discussion of anyons, of which Majoranas are an example. I continue with a discussion of why particle statistics in 2D can be neither bosonic nor fermionic, nor even abelian, and what it means for the charge to be fractional. A simple model of Kitaev, of electrons hopping on a branched 1D lattice with strong spin-orbit coupling and superconducting pairing, is sufficient to describe Majoranas and the gates that can be done by moving them around each other (braiding). I discuss a model calculation of the decohence of these Majorana qubits during braiding in a trijunction, due to thermally generated quasiparticles (bosonic environment). The limitations to coherence are significant; topological protection doesn't really work in this scenario. (work with Dr. Fabio Pedrocchi)
FINDING: Majorana zero modes (MZMs) realize non-Abelian braid statistics via the Ising anyon model, with topological protection scaling exponentially in wire length. | MATH: Braid group Bn B_n Bn​ generators σi \sigma_i σi​ act on a 2D degenerate ground space (for 2n 2n 2n MZMs) via γi→γj=U†γiU \gamma_i \to \gamma_j = U^\dagger \gamma_i U γi​→γj​=U†γi​U, where U=exp⁡(π4γiγj) U = \exp(\frac{\pi}{4}\gamma_i\gamma_j) U=exp(4π​γi​γj​). The non-Abelian exchange yields σi2=−1 \sigma_i^2 = -1 σi2​=−1 (fermion parity flip), and the topological gap Δtop∝e−L/ξ \Delta_{\rm top} \propto e^{-L/\xi} Δtop​∝e−L/ξ (exponential suppression of splitting with wire length L L L, coherence length ξ \xi ξ). Kitaev chain Hamiltonian: H=−μ∑ci†ci−t∑(ci+1†ci+h.c.)+Δ∑(ci+1†ci†+h.c.) H = -\mu\sum c_i^\dagger c_i - t\sum(c_{i+1}^\dagger c_i + {\rm h.c.}) + \Delta\sum(c_{i+1}^\dagger c_i^\dagger + {\rm h.c.}) H=−μ∑ci†​ci​−t∑(ci+1†​ci​+h.c.)+Δ∑(ci+1†​ci†​+h.c.), with MZM operators γ1=c1+c1† \gamma_1 = c_1 + c_1^\dagger γ1​=c1​+c1†​, γ2=−i(cN−cN†) \gamma_2 = -i(c_N - c_N^\dagger) γ2​=−i(cN​−cN†​) at μ=0,t=Δ \mu=0, t=\Delta μ=0,t=Δ. | CONNECTION: The braid group Bn B_n Bn​ is the fundamental group of configuration space of n n n Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
I will discuss the revolutionary new concept of topological quantum computation, which is fault-tolerant at the hardware level with no need, in principle, of any quantum error correction protocols. Errors simply do not occur since the physical qubits and the computation steps are protected against decoherence by non-local topological correlations in the underlying physical system. The key idea is non-Abelian statistics of the quasiparticles (called 'anyons' as opposed to fermions or bosons), where the space-time braiding of the anyons around each other, i.e. quantum 'knots', form topologically protected quantum gate operations. I will describe in detail the theoretical principles guiding the experimental search for the appropriate topological phases of matter where such non-Abelian anyons, which are low-dimensional solid state versions of the elusive and exotic Majorana fermions hypothesized seventy-five years ago, may exist. I will critically discuss the recent experimental claims of observing the Majorana modes in semiconductor nanowire structures following earlier theoretical proposals, outlining the future developments which would be necessary to eventually build a topological quantum computer.
Topological quantum states of matter, both Abelian and non-Abelian, are characterized by excitations whose wavefunctions undergo nontrivial statistical transformations as one excitation is moved (braided) around another. Topological quantum computation proposes to use the topological protection and the braiding statistics of a non-Abelian topological state to perform quantum computation. The enormous technological prospect of topological quantum computation provides new motivation for experimentally observing a topological state. Here, we explicitly work out a realistic experimental scheme to create and braid the Abelian topological excitations in the Kitaev model built on a tunable robust system, a cold atom optical lattice. We also demonstrate how to detect the key feature of these excitations: their braiding statistics. Observation of this statistics would directly establish the existence of anyons, quantum particles that are neither fermions nor bosons. In addition to establishing topological matter, the experimental scheme we develop here can also be adapted to a non-Abelian topological state, supported by the same Kitaev model but in a different parameter regime, to eventually build topologically protected quantum gates.
FINDING: Topological quantum computing leverages non-Abelian anyons and braid group representations for inherently fault-tolerant quantum gates, with Microsoft's Majorana 1 chip as a physical milestone. | MATH: Braid group BnB_nBn​ generators σi\sigma_iσi​ satisfy σiσi+1σi=σi+1σiσi+1\sigma_i\sigma_{i+1}\sigma_i = \sigma_{i+1}\sigma_i\sigma_{i+1}σi​σi+1​σi​=σi+1​σi​σi+1​ and σiσj=σjσi\sigma_i\sigma_j = \sigma_j\sigma_iσi​σj​=σj​σi​ for ∣i−j∣≥2|i-j|\geq 2∣i−j∣≥2. Non-Abelian anyons carry unitary representations U(σi)U(\sigma_i)U(σi​) with U(σi)2≠IU(\sigma_i)^2 \neq IU(σi​)2=I (unlike fermions/bosons). Majorana zero modes obey γi†=γi\gamma_i^\dagger = \gamma_iγi†​=γi​, {γi,γj}=2δij\{\gamma_i,\gamma_j\} = 2\delta_{ij}{γi​,γj​}=2δij​, and a pair encodes a qubit via parity iγ1γ2=±1i\gamma_1\gamma_2 = \pm 1iγ1​γ2​=±1. Topological protection arises from the gap ΔE∼e−L/ξ\Delta E \sim e^{-L/\xi}ΔE∼e−L/ξ (exponential suppression with wire length LLL vs coherence length ξ\xiξ). Fibonacci anyons (from SU(2)3_33​ Chern-Simons theory) have quantum dimension ϕ=(1+5)/2≈1.618\phi = (1+\sqrt{5})/2 \approx 1.618ϕ=(1+5​)/2≈1.618, giving dense braiding — universal quantum co Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
FINDING: Majorana zero modes (MZMs) in topological superconductors obey non-Abelian braid statistics, with exponential suppression of coupling between spatially separated modes enabling topologically protected quantum gates. | MATH: The Kitaev chain Hamiltonian H=−t∑ci†ci+1+Δ∑cici+1+h.c.−μ∑ci†ci H = -t\sum c^\dagger_i c_{i+1} + \Delta\sum c_i c_{i+1} + \text{h.c.} - \mu\sum c^\dagger_i c_i H=−t∑ci†​ci+1​+Δ∑ci​ci+1​+h.c.−μ∑ci†​ci​ yields unpaired Majorana operators γ1,γ2 \gamma_1, \gamma_2 γ1​,γ2​ with γi†=γi \gamma_i^\dagger = \gamma_i γi†​=γi​, {γi,γj}=2δij \{\gamma_i,\gamma_j\} = 2\delta_{ij} {γi​,γj​}=2δij​. Braiding exchanges γi→γj \gamma_i \to \gamma_j γi​→γj​ via unitary Uij=exp⁡(π4γiγj) U_{ij} = \exp(\frac{\pi}{4}\gamma_i\gamma_j) Uij​=exp(4π​γi​γj​), giving non-Abelian representation of the braid group Bn B_n Bn​ (e.g., U12U23≠U23U12 U_{12}U_{23} \neq U_{23}U_{12} U12​U23​=U23​U12​). Splitting energy ΔE∝e−L/ξ \Delta E \propto e^{-L/\xi} ΔE∝e−L/ξ where ξ=ℏvF/Δ \xi = \hbar v_F/\Delta ξ=ℏvF​/Δ is the coherence length — exponential suppression with wire length L L L. | CONNECTION: The braid group Bn B_n Bn​ is generated by transpositions σi \sigma_i σi​ satisfying \( \sigma_i\s Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
FINDING: Majorana zero modes (MZMs) realize non-Abelian braid statistics via the Kitaev chain, with topological protection scaling exponentially in wire length, enabling topologically fault-tolerant quantum gates. | MATH: Kitaev chain Hamiltonian H=∑j[−t(cj†cj+1+h.c.)−μ(cj†cj−1/2)+Δ(cjcj+1+h.c.)] H = \sum_j [-t(c_j^\dagger c_{j+1} + h.c.) - \mu(c_j^\dagger c_j - 1/2) + \Delta(c_j c_{j+1} + h.c.)] H=∑j​[−t(cj†​cj+1​+h.c.)−μ(cj†​cj​−1/2)+Δ(cj​cj+1​+h.c.)]; Majorana operators γ2j−1=cj+cj† \gamma_{2j-1} = c_j + c_j^\dagger γ2j−1​=cj​+cj†​, γ2j=−i(cj−cj†) \gamma_{2j} = -i(c_j - c_j^\dagger) γ2j​=−i(cj​−cj†​), satisfying {γa,γb}=2δab \{\gamma_a, \gamma_b\} = 2\delta_{ab} {γa​,γb​}=2δab​; topological gap Δtop∼Δ \Delta_{\text{top}} \sim \Delta Δtop​∼Δ (superconducting gap); exponential suppression of coupling between MZMs: ϵ∝e−L/ξ \epsilon \propto e^{-L/\xi} ϵ∝e−L/ξ where ξ=ℏvF/Δ \xi = \hbar v_F / \Delta ξ=ℏvF​/Δ is the coherence length; braid group Bn B_n Bn​ generated by exchanges σi \sigma_i σi​ with σi2=−1 \sigma_i^2 = -1 σi2​=−1 (fermionic parity), yielding non-Abelian representation ρ(σi)=e±πγiγi+1/4 \rho(\sigma_i) = e^{\pm \pi \gamma_i \gamma_{i+1}/4} ρ(σi​)=e±πγi​γi+1​/4. | CONNECTION: The braid group Bn B_n Bn​ is the fundamental Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com