Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

How to couple trapped ions to superconducting resonators: towards hybrid quantum devices

Sönke Möller

Published Jan 1, 2016• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

In this dissertation, we present work on a quantum hybrid device comprising of a trapped calcium atom and a superconducting LC resonator. This hybrid device is a first step towards building a hybrid quantum computer that can take advantage of the different properties of atomic and superconducting quantum systems and combine the best characteristics of both. We model a trapped ion as an LC circuit and calculate its coupling to a mode of an LC resonator. Further, we optimize the trap geometry and placement of coupling electrodes to increase the coupling. We also outline the manufacturing process and simulation of the trapping potentials for the surface traps used in this work. Finally, we report on initial experiments coupling a trapped ion to a resonant mode of the LC resonator, increasing the heating rate to 220 phonons/ms on resonance versus 0.5 phonons/ms without additional heating from the resonator. The ratio of the heating rates for the two secular frequencies of the ion confrm our simulated coupling rates.

Related papers

Cryogenic ion trapping for next generation quantum technologies

De Motte, C E Darren

Quantum technology has made great strides in the last two decades with trapped ions demonstrating all the necessary building blocks for a quantum computer. While these proof of principle experiments have been demonstrated, it still remains a challenging task to scale these experiments down to smaller systems. In this thesis I describe the development of technology towards scalable cryogenic ion trapping and quantum hybrid systems. I first discuss the fundamentals of ion trapping along with the demonstration of ion trapping on a novel surface electrode ion trap with a ring shaped architecture. I then present the development of a cryogenic vacuum system for ion trapping at ~4 K, which utilizes a closed cycle Gifford McMahon cryocooler with a helium gas buffered ultra-low vibration interface to mechanically decouple a ultra-high vacuum system. Ancillary technologies are also presented, including a novel in-vacuum superconducting rf resonator, low power dissipation ceramic based atomic source oven and an adaptable in-vacuum permanent magnet system for long-wavelength based quantum logic. The design and fabrication of microfabricated surface ion traps toward quantum hybrid technologies are then presented. A superconducting ion trap with an integrated high quality factor microwave cavity and vertical ion shuttling capabilities is described. The experimental demonstration of the cavity is also presented with quality factors of Q6~6000 and Q~15000 for superconducting niobium nitride and gold based cavities respectively, which are the highest demonstrated for microwave cavities integrated within ion trapping electrode architectures. An ion trap with a multipole electrode geometry is then presented, which is capable of trapping a large number of ions simultaneously. The homogeneity of five individual linear trapping regions are optimized and the design for the principle axis rotation of each linear region is presented. An overview of microfabrication techniques used for fabricating surface electrode ion traps is then presented. This includes the detailed microfabrication procedure for ion traps designed within this thesis. A scheme for the integration of ion trapping and superconducting qubit systems as a step towards the realization of a quantum hybrid system is then presented. This scheme addresses two key diffculties in realizing such a system; a combined microfabricated ion trap and superconducting qubit architecture, and the experimental infrastructure to facilitate both technologies. Solutions that can be immediately implemented using current technology are presented. Finally, as a step towards scalability and hybrid quantum systems, the interaction between a single ion and a microwaves field produced from an on chip microwave cavity is explored. The interaction is described for the high-Q microwave cavity designed in this thesis and a 171Yb+ion. A description of the observable transmission from the cavity is described and it is shown that the presence of a single ion can indeed be observed in the emission spectrum of high-Q microwave cavity even in the weak coupling regime.

•Dec 14, 2016•0 citations

OPTICAL AND ELECTRICAL RESPONSE OF SUPERCONDUCTING RESONATORS FOR A HYBRID QUANTUM SYSTEM

Kristen Voigt

I describe my contributions towards a hybrid quantum system that would have coupled 87Rb atoms to a superconducting device. I first discuss my work coupling an optical fiber to a translatable thin-film LC lumped-element superconducting Al microwave resonator operating at 100 mK in a dilution refrigerator. The LC resonators had resonance frequencies f0 of 6.15 GHz, quality factors Q of 1.5 x 105 to 6.5 x 105 at high powers, and were mounted inside a superconducting aluminum 3D cavity with a resonance frequency of 7.5 GHz and Q of 8 x 103. An optical microfiber (60 µm diameter) passed through a hole in the 3D cavity near the LC resonator. The 3D cavity was mounted on an x-z attocube-translation stage that allowed the LC resonator to be moved relative to the fiber. The resonator’s f0 and Q were affected both by the fiber dielectric perturbing the resonator’s electric field and from scattered light from the fiber. I measured both effects as a function of fiber-resonator position. I modeled the resonator’s optical response by accounting for optical production, recombination, and diffusion of quasiparticles and the non-uniform position-dependent illumination of the resonator. Using the model, I extracted key parameters describing quasiparticles in the resonator. The hybrid quantum system requires the 87Rb and LC resonator resonance to be tuned to the same frequency. I describe our LC resonator tuning method which moves a superconducting Al pin into the resonator’s electric field, decreasing the resonator capacitance and increasing its resonance frequency up to 137 MHz. This was done at 15 mK using an attocube translation stage. I also investigated two-level system (TLS) defects in an LC resonator by applying a dc voltage. I describe a model in which the TLS causes a capacitive perturbation to the resonator rather than the ‘standard’ electric-dipole coupling model. I use this model of a capacitive TLS or cTLS, to describe intermittent telegraph noise measured in the transmission S21 through the resonator. I measured shifts in f0 of more than 6 kHz corresponding to a cTLS fluctuating its capacitance contribution by 430 zF.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Superconducting Microwave Resonators for Hybrid Quantum Systems in Extreme Conditions

Benedikt Wilde

Hybrid quantum systems play an essential role in efforts towards the advancements of quantum information technology and quantum sensing by bridging distinct technological platforms. In particular, hybrid systems comprising superconducting microwave circuits are being pursued intensely in light of existing achievements in superconducting qubits and precise quantum control in microwave circuits. Their realization relies on the design of superconducting resonators capable of coupling to an oscillatory mode of a second quantum system, facilitating the probing and manipulation of one via the other. In order to accommodate the coupled system, its particular constraints and requirements must be respected, which may be quite extreme from the perspective of established superconducting circuit design and operation. Overcoming this challenge has proved to be a substantial obstacle for the attainment of strongly coupled hybrid systems, despite spectacular advances in superconducting microwave circuits individually. In this work, we examine two approaches tackling this issue for different hybrid quantum systems, focusing on the optimization and characterization of the superconducting circuits. The first device aims at a superconductor-atom hybrid system through the coupling to Rydberg-Rydberg transitions in ultra-cold Rb-87 atoms trapped near the superconducting chip. Using simulations in conjunction with theoretical considerations, we demonstrate a comprehensive geometry parameter optimization procedure for maximum coupling rate. Presenting an experimental implementation of the resulting circuit, we validate its suitability for use under the intended operation conditions, including the option of tuning the electronic transition frequencies using a dc voltage. Secondly, we investigate a device designed for applications in large magnetic in-plane fields used to mediate coupling to integrated micromechanical oscillators; more specifically it is a flux-tunable SQUID resonator comprising Josephson nano-constrictions as nonlinear inductive components. Performing a thorough characterization of its frequency and Kerr anharmonicity tuning behavior at fields up to several hundred mT, we discover a pronounced asymmetry in its flux response at large fields. We show this asymmetry to be caused by the nano-constrictions turning into Josephson diodes, develop an intuitive macroscopic model for its field-induced emergence and reconstruct the diode current-phase relation from the flux tuning data. Several figures of merit informing the suitability of the SQUID resonators for optomechanical systems as well as other applications are improved by the diode effect, highlighting the potential of Josephson diodes in superconducting microwave circuits. Our results provide a promising stepping stone for the advancement of hybrid systems involving superconducting microwave circuits, putting new and exciting operation and coupling regimes within reach.

•Mar 6, 2026•0 citations

Experimental system design for the integration of trapped-ion and superconducting qubit systems

De Motte, Anton Grounds, Marian Rehak +8 more

We present a design for the experimental integration of ion trapping and superconducting qubit systems as a step towards the realization of a quantum hybrid system. The scheme addresses two key difficulties in realizing such a system; a combined microfabricated ion trap and superconducting qubit architecture, and the experimental infrastructure to facilitate both technologies. Developing upon work by Kielpinski et al. [1] we describe the design, simulation and fabrication process for a microfabricated ion trap capable of coupling an ion to a superconducting microwave LC circuit with a coupling strength in the tens of kHz. We also describe existing difficulties in combining the experimental infrastructure of an ion trapping setup into a dilution fridge with superconducting qubits and present solutions that can be immediately implemented using current technology.

arXiv:1510.07298•Oct 25, 2015•1 citation

Experimental system design for the integration of trapped-ion and superconducting qubit systems

De Motte, Anton Grounds, Marian Rehak +8 more

We present a design for the experimental integration of ion trapping and superconducting qubit systems as a step towards the realization of a quantum hybrid system. The scheme addresses two key difficulties in realizing such a system: a combined microfabricated ion trap and superconducting qubit architecture, and the experimental infrastructure to facilitate both technologies. Developing upon work by Kielpinski et al. (Phys Rev Lett 108(13):130504, 2012. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.108.130504 ), we describe the design, simulation and fabrication process for a microfabricated ion trap capable of coupling an ion to a superconducting microwave LC circuit with a coupling strength in the tens of kHz. We also describe existing difficulties in combining the experimental infrastructure of an ion trapping set-up into a dilution refrigerator with superconducting qubits and present solutions that can be immediately implemented using current technology.

Quantum Information Processing•Jul 12, 2016•18 citations

Hybrid quantum systems with trapped charged particles

Shlomi Kotler, Raymond W. Simmonds, Dietrich G. Leibfried +1 more

Trapped charged particles have been at the forefront of quantum information processing (QIP) for a few decades now, with deterministic two-qubit logic gates reaching record fidelities of $99.9%$ and single-qubit operations of much higher fidelity. In a hybrid system involving trapped charges, quantum degrees of freedom of macroscopic objects such as bulk acoustic resonators, superconducting circuits, or nanomechanical membranes, couple to the trapped charges and ideally inherit the coherent properties of the charges. The hybrid system therefore implements a ``quantum transducer,'' where the quantum reality (i.e., superpositions and entanglement) of small objects is extended to include the larger object. Although a hybrid quantum system with trapped charges could be valuable both for fundamental research and for QIP applications, no such system exists today. Here we study theoretically the possibilities of coupling the quantum-mechanical motion of a trapped charged particle (e.g., an ion or electron) to the quantum degrees of freedom of superconducting devices, nanomechanical resonators, and quartz bulk acoustic wave resonators. For each case, we estimate the coupling rate between the charged particle and its macroscopic counterpart and compare it to the decoherence rate, i.e., the rate at which quantum superposition decays. A hybrid system can only be considered quantum if the coupling rate significantly exceeds all decoherence rates. Our approach is to examine specific examples by using parameters that are experimentally attainable in the foreseeable future. We conclude that hybrid quantum systems involving a single atomic ion are unfavorable compared with the use of a single electron because the coupling rates between the ion and its counterpart are slower than the expected decoherence rates. A system based on trapped electrons, on the other hand, might have coupling rates that significantly exceed decoherence rates. Moreover, it might have appealing properties such as fast entangling gates, long coherence, and flexible topology that is fully electronic in nature. Realizing such a system, however, is technologically challenging because it requires accommodating both a trapping technology and superconducting circuitry in a compatible manner. We review some of the challenges involved, such as the required trap parameters, electron sources, electrical circuitry, and cooling schemes in order to promote further investigations towards the realization of such a hybrid system.

arXiv:1608.02677•Physical Review A•Feb 21, 2017•43 citations
In this dissertation, we present work on a quantum hybrid device comprising of a trapped calcium atom and a superconducting LC resonator. This hybrid device is a first step towards building a hybrid quantum computer that can take advantage of the different properties of atomic and superconducting quantum systems and combine the best characteristics of both. We model a trapped ion as an LC circuit and calculate its coupling to a mode of an LC resonator. Further, we optimize the trap geometry and placement of coupling electrodes to increase the coupling. We also outline the manufacturing process and simulation of the trapping potentials for the surface traps used in this work. Finally, we report on initial experiments coupling a trapped ion to a resonant mode of the LC resonator, increasing the heating rate to 220 phonons/ms on resonance versus 0.5 phonons/ms without additional heating from the resonator. The ratio of the heating rates for the two secular frequencies of the ion confrm our simulated coupling rates.
Quantum technology has made great strides in the last two decades with trapped ions demonstrating all the necessary building blocks for a quantum computer. While these proof of principle experiments have been demonstrated, it still remains a challenging task to scale these experiments down to smaller systems. In this thesis I describe the development of technology towards scalable cryogenic ion trapping and quantum hybrid systems. I first discuss the fundamentals of ion trapping along with the demonstration of ion trapping on a novel surface electrode ion trap with a ring shaped architecture. I then present the development of a cryogenic vacuum system for ion trapping at ~4 K, which utilizes a closed cycle Gifford McMahon cryocooler with a helium gas buffered ultra-low vibration interface to mechanically decouple a ultra-high vacuum system. Ancillary technologies are also presented, including a novel in-vacuum superconducting rf resonator, low power dissipation ceramic based atomic source oven and an adaptable in-vacuum permanent magnet system for long-wavelength based quantum logic. The design and fabrication of microfabricated surface ion traps toward quantum hybrid technologies are then presented. A superconducting ion trap with an integrated high quality factor microwave cavity and vertical ion shuttling capabilities is described. The experimental demonstration of the cavity is also presented with quality factors of Q6~6000 and Q~15000 for superconducting niobium nitride and gold based cavities respectively, which are the highest demonstrated for microwave cavities integrated within ion trapping electrode architectures. An ion trap with a multipole electrode geometry is then presented, which is capable of trapping a large number of ions simultaneously. The homogeneity of five individual linear trapping regions are optimized and the design for the principle axis rotation of each linear region is presented. An overview of microfabrication techniques used for fabricating surface electrode ion traps is then presented. This includes the detailed microfabrication procedure for ion traps designed within this thesis. A scheme for the integration of ion trapping and superconducting qubit systems as a step towards the realization of a quantum hybrid system is then presented. This scheme addresses two key diffculties in realizing such a system; a combined microfabricated ion trap and superconducting qubit architecture, and the experimental infrastructure to facilitate both technologies. Solutions that can be immediately implemented using current technology are presented. Finally, as a step towards scalability and hybrid quantum systems, the interaction between a single ion and a microwaves field produced from an on chip microwave cavity is explored. The interaction is described for the high-Q microwave cavity designed in this thesis and a 171Yb+ion. A description of the observable transmission from the cavity is described and it is shown that the presence of a single ion can indeed be observed in the emission spectrum of high-Q microwave cavity even in the weak coupling regime.
I describe my contributions towards a hybrid quantum system that would have coupled 87Rb atoms to a superconducting device. I first discuss my work coupling an optical fiber to a translatable thin-film LC lumped-element superconducting Al microwave resonator operating at 100 mK in a dilution refrigerator. The LC resonators had resonance frequencies f0 of 6.15 GHz, quality factors Q of 1.5 x 105 to 6.5 x 105 at high powers, and were mounted inside a superconducting aluminum 3D cavity with a resonance frequency of 7.5 GHz and Q of 8 x 103. An optical microfiber (60 µm diameter) passed through a hole in the 3D cavity near the LC resonator. The 3D cavity was mounted on an x-z attocube-translation stage that allowed the LC resonator to be moved relative to the fiber. The resonator’s f0 and Q were affected both by the fiber dielectric perturbing the resonator’s electric field and from scattered light from the fiber. I measured both effects as a function of fiber-resonator position. I modeled the resonator’s optical response by accounting for optical production, recombination, and diffusion of quasiparticles and the non-uniform position-dependent illumination of the resonator. Using the model, I extracted key parameters describing quasiparticles in the resonator. The hybrid quantum system requires the 87Rb and LC resonator resonance to be tuned to the same frequency. I describe our LC resonator tuning method which moves a superconducting Al pin into the resonator’s electric field, decreasing the resonator capacitance and increasing its resonance frequency up to 137 MHz. This was done at 15 mK using an attocube translation stage. I also investigated two-level system (TLS) defects in an LC resonator by applying a dc voltage. I describe a model in which the TLS causes a capacitive perturbation to the resonator rather than the ‘standard’ electric-dipole coupling model. I use this model of a capacitive TLS or cTLS, to describe intermittent telegraph noise measured in the transmission S21 through the resonator. I measured shifts in f0 of more than 6 kHz corresponding to a cTLS fluctuating its capacitance contribution by 430 zF.
Hybrid quantum systems play an essential role in efforts towards the advancements of quantum information technology and quantum sensing by bridging distinct technological platforms. In particular, hybrid systems comprising superconducting microwave circuits are being pursued intensely in light of existing achievements in superconducting qubits and precise quantum control in microwave circuits. Their realization relies on the design of superconducting resonators capable of coupling to an oscillatory mode of a second quantum system, facilitating the probing and manipulation of one via the other. In order to accommodate the coupled system, its particular constraints and requirements must be respected, which may be quite extreme from the perspective of established superconducting circuit design and operation. Overcoming this challenge has proved to be a substantial obstacle for the attainment of strongly coupled hybrid systems, despite spectacular advances in superconducting microwave circuits individually. In this work, we examine two approaches tackling this issue for different hybrid quantum systems, focusing on the optimization and characterization of the superconducting circuits. The first device aims at a superconductor-atom hybrid system through the coupling to Rydberg-Rydberg transitions in ultra-cold Rb-87 atoms trapped near the superconducting chip. Using simulations in conjunction with theoretical considerations, we demonstrate a comprehensive geometry parameter optimization procedure for maximum coupling rate. Presenting an experimental implementation of the resulting circuit, we validate its suitability for use under the intended operation conditions, including the option of tuning the electronic transition frequencies using a dc voltage. Secondly, we investigate a device designed for applications in large magnetic in-plane fields used to mediate coupling to integrated micromechanical oscillators; more specifically it is a flux-tunable SQUID resonator comprising Josephson nano-constrictions as nonlinear inductive components. Performing a thorough characterization of its frequency and Kerr anharmonicity tuning behavior at fields up to several hundred mT, we discover a pronounced asymmetry in its flux response at large fields. We show this asymmetry to be caused by the nano-constrictions turning into Josephson diodes, develop an intuitive macroscopic model for its field-induced emergence and reconstruct the diode current-phase relation from the flux tuning data. Several figures of merit informing the suitability of the SQUID resonators for optomechanical systems as well as other applications are improved by the diode effect, highlighting the potential of Josephson diodes in superconducting microwave circuits. Our results provide a promising stepping stone for the advancement of hybrid systems involving superconducting microwave circuits, putting new and exciting operation and coupling regimes within reach.
We present a design for the experimental integration of ion trapping and superconducting qubit systems as a step towards the realization of a quantum hybrid system. The scheme addresses two key difficulties in realizing such a system; a combined microfabricated ion trap and superconducting qubit architecture, and the experimental infrastructure to facilitate both technologies. Developing upon work by Kielpinski et al. [1] we describe the design, simulation and fabrication process for a microfabricated ion trap capable of coupling an ion to a superconducting microwave LC circuit with a coupling strength in the tens of kHz. We also describe existing difficulties in combining the experimental infrastructure of an ion trapping setup into a dilution fridge with superconducting qubits and present solutions that can be immediately implemented using current technology.
We present a design for the experimental integration of ion trapping and superconducting qubit systems as a step towards the realization of a quantum hybrid system. The scheme addresses two key difficulties in realizing such a system: a combined microfabricated ion trap and superconducting qubit architecture, and the experimental infrastructure to facilitate both technologies. Developing upon work by Kielpinski et al. (Phys Rev Lett 108(13):130504, 2012. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.108.130504 ), we describe the design, simulation and fabrication process for a microfabricated ion trap capable of coupling an ion to a superconducting microwave LC circuit with a coupling strength in the tens of kHz. We also describe existing difficulties in combining the experimental infrastructure of an ion trapping set-up into a dilution refrigerator with superconducting qubits and present solutions that can be immediately implemented using current technology.
Trapped charged particles have been at the forefront of quantum information processing (QIP) for a few decades now, with deterministic two-qubit logic gates reaching record fidelities of 99.999.9%99.9 and single-qubit operations of much higher fidelity. In a hybrid system involving trapped charges, quantum degrees of freedom of macroscopic objects such as bulk acoustic resonators, superconducting circuits, or nanomechanical membranes, couple to the trapped charges and ideally inherit the coherent properties of the charges. The hybrid system therefore implements a ``quantum transducer,'' where the quantum reality (i.e., superpositions and entanglement) of small objects is extended to include the larger object. Although a hybrid quantum system with trapped charges could be valuable both for fundamental research and for QIP applications, no such system exists today. Here we study theoretically the possibilities of coupling the quantum-mechanical motion of a trapped charged particle (e.g., an ion or electron) to the quantum degrees of freedom of superconducting devices, nanomechanical resonators, and quartz bulk acoustic wave resonators. For each case, we estimate the coupling rate between the charged particle and its macroscopic counterpart and compare it to the decoherence rate, i.e., the rate at which quantum superposition decays. A hybrid system can only be considered quantum if the coupling rate significantly exceeds all decoherence rates. Our approach is to examine specific examples by using parameters that are experimentally attainable in the foreseeable future. We conclude that hybrid quantum systems involving a single atomic ion are unfavorable compared with the use of a single electron because the coupling rates between the ion and its counterpart are slower than the expected decoherence rates. A system based on trapped electrons, on the other hand, might have coupling rates that significantly exceed decoherence rates. Moreover, it might have appealing properties such as fast entangling gates, long coherence, and flexible topology that is fully electronic in nature. Realizing such a system, however, is technologically challenging because it requires accommodating both a trapping technology and superconducting circuitry in a compatible manner. We review some of the challenges involved, such as the required trap parameters, electron sources, electrical circuitry, and cooling schemes in order to promote further investigations towards the realization of such a hybrid system.