Exploration of Higher-Order Quantum Interference Landscapes

Sascha Agne

Published Aug 31, 2017• 1 citation

Abstract

Earth, Moon and Sun unite when they star together in the three-body problem, whose intricate plot still baffles us today. For some reason, the factorization of the two-body problem into two one-body problems does not, in general, cross the N=2 border. Is computational irreducibility responsible for this emergence of complexity, as Stephen Wolfram likes to think? We don't know. The introduction to this thesis in Chapter 1, however, makes it clear that the history of science is marked by intermittent encounters of sudden complexities when the number 2 is left behind. In Chapter 2, I present an experiment that is quite similar in spirit, for my colleagues and I observe three-photon interference without two-photon and single-photon interference. We had to overcome significant experimental challenges that are typical for most quantum interference experiments involving more than two photons. Next in line is the three-slit interference experiment. Again a deceptively simple extension of the famous double-slit experiment, we are faced with questions that are difficult to access experimentally: the existence of genuine three-slit interference was first denied and then affirmed, though no experiment has decided yet. My contribution to the study of this problem is outlined in Chapter 3, where I use symmetry of measurement settings in such interference experiments to theoretically derive higher-order interference terms. In Chapter 4, I take a step back in one sense, for we study a two-photon phenomenon, but we also leap forward and discover entirely new interference landscapes. Theoretically and experimentally, I demonstrate how to use a polarization-modulated lasers to go beyond the standard Hong-Ou-Mandel (HOM) dip, and generate both triangular and square wave HOM interference patterns. Two-photon interference is also subject of Chapter 5, but with an interesting twist. While laser HOM interference relies on two independent photons, here we endow the pair with the strongest known correlations, namely entanglement. More specifically, we entangle a polarization and a time-bin qubit and use this hybrid to assess the viability of a rather special interferometer for quantum communication purposes.

Related papers

Multi-photon interference phenomena

Adrian J. Menssen

In this work I demonstrate the interference of three photons, a generalisation of the famous Hong Ou Mandel (HOM) interference. I show that three-photon interference is governed by four parameters and measure three-photon interference independent of two-photon interference. I demonstrate that even when the states of the photons are highly distinguishable they can still exhibit strong quantum interference, challenging our intuition formed by the double slit and HOM interference. This is followed by a demonstration of four-photon interference, where surprisingly we can still observe a "fringe" when the involved particles are pairwise orthogonal. To explain these effects, I present a new framework to describe multi-photon interference in terms of a graph-theoretical approach, which illustrates the origin of different orders of multi-photon interference. My work leads to a more general definition of what we regard as an interference fringe in multi-photon scattering. This study of multi-photon interference is followed by an interdisciplinary work between photonics and solid state physics in the newly developing field of topological photonics. I realise a simulation of the Jackiw-Rossi model as a localised topological mode in a photonic-crystal analogue of the 2D graphene lattice. I succeed in the experimental demonstration of a single such excitation and I am able to study the detailed mode structure for the first time. The mode is a result of a topological defect and is, as such, protected against errors that do not change the topology of the system.

arXiv:2209.02893Sep 7, 20220 citations

Manipulating Two-Photon Interference Using Metasurfaces

Wai Hin Fan

Interference experiments like the light and electron double-slit are crucially important to quantum mechanics since they illustrate the core principle of wave-particle duality, by demonstrating the wave-like aspect of particle phenomena. In such experiments, a device is typically required to manipulate the particle-wave dual phenomenon, producing controllable interference. Metasurfaces, with their highly flexible configurability, can serve as more versatile versions of such devices. They are powerful tools capable of modulating a broader category of effects beyond classical interference, such as the quantum Hong-Ou-Mandel (HOM) effect. The HOM effect is caused by interference taking place not between coherent waves from distinct sources which intersect in real space, but rather between parallel processes indistinguishable to the measurement apparatus. Existing research has highlighted the outsized importance of measurement in HOM interferometry, by showing that the occurrence of process interference depends only on indistinguishability at the detectors and nowhere else. We are therefore interested in how quantum measurement occurs in HOM, and how metasurfaces can be used to enhance the HOM effect. In this thesis, we extend a formulation of quantum trajectory theory in two-eigenstate systems to 𝑁-state systems, producing a three-state formalism which serves as a possible description of coincidence pair detection in HOM experiments. We then develop an analytic model of polarisation HOM interferometry capturing both the width and the 𝑔2 ratio of the HOM dip; finally, we design and fabricate a metasurface that exhibits polarisation filtering with respect to two-photon coincidence, whereupon HOM photon bunching occurs only at select metasurface orientations relative to photon polarisation. Our three-state quantum state collapse model offers a promising explanation for how state measurement takes place in an HOM interferometer, where the interferometer output is a superimposition of three two-photon eigenstates. Meanwhile, our interferometer model and experiments provide evidence of successful polarisation filtering in HOM interferometry.

Jan 1, 20250 citations

Higher-Order Interference in Extensions of Quantum Theory

Ciarán M. Lee, John H. Selby

Quantum interference, manifest in the two slit experiment, lies at the heart of several quantum computational speed-ups and provides a striking example of a quantum phenomenon with no classical counterpart. An intriguing feature of quantum interference arises in a variant of the standard two slit experiment, in which there are three, rather than two, slits. The interference pattern in this set-up can be written in terms of the two and one slit patterns obtained by blocking one, or more, of the slits. This is in stark contrast with the standard two slit experiment, where the interference pattern cannot be written as a sum of the one slit patterns. This was first noted by Rafael Sorkin, who raised the question of why quantum theory only exhibits irreducible interference in the two slit experiment. One approach to this problem is to compare the predictions of quantum theory to those of operationally-defined ‘foil’ theories, in the hope of determining whether theories that do exhibit higher-order interference suffer from pathological—or at least undesirable—features. In this paper two proposed extensions of quantum theory are considered: the theory of Density Cubes proposed by Dakić, Paterek and Brukner, which has been shown to exhibit irreducible interference in the three slit set-up, and the Quartic Quantum Theory of Życzkowski. The theory of Density Cubes will be shown to provide an advantage over quantum theory in a certain computational task and to posses a well-defined mechanism which leads to the emergence of quantum theory—analogous to the emergence of classical physics from quantum theory via decoherence. Despite this, the axioms used to define Density Cubes will be shown to be insufficient to uniquely characterise the theory. In comparison, Quartic Quantum Theory is a well-defined theory and we demonstrate that it exhibits irreducible interference to all orders. This feature of Życzkowski’s theory is argued not to be a genuine phenomenon, but to arise from an ambiguity in the current definition of higher-order interference in operationally-defined theories. Thus, to begin to understand why quantum theory is limited to a certain kind of interference, a new definition of higher-order interference is needed that is applicable to, and makes good operational sense in, arbitrary operationally-defined theories.

arXiv:1510.03860Foundations of PhysicsOct 22, 201650 citations

Distinguishability in quantum interference

Alexander Edward Jones

Quantum interference constitutes one of the sharpest divides between our classical intuition and the weirdness of the quantum world. Whenever there are multiple paths leading to the same outcome, it is the interplay of associated probability amplitudes that determines measurement results. In the double slit experiment, wave-like interference governs the distribution of particles on a detection screen. Extending to multiple particles allows behaviour that cannot be described by a classical wave, such as the bunching of photon pairs in Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. In both these examples, the ability to distinguish the interfering paths leads to degradation of interference and a return to behaviour described by probabilities. Understanding how this transition evolves for larger multiparticle quantum systems is of fundamental interest and also vital for developing photonic quantum technologies that rely on many-photon interference. In this thesis we investigate the role of distinguishability in the interference of three and four independent photons by using polarisation and time delays. For three photons, a new type of collective distinguishing phase appears that goes beyond a pairwise description of the similarity of quantum states. We use nonlinear photon sources and a fibre interferometer to experimentally demonstrate the ability to tune and isolate this phase in interference statistics. Extending to four photons we show that, contrary to intuition from two-photon experiments, the interference of photons prepared in distinguishable states is possible due to a four-particle phase. This is confirmed experimentally using a bulk four-mode interferometer. We then extend our study to include the effects of state impurity in the interference of three photons. New properties of this interference enable diagnosis of realistic experimental imperfections and characterisation tasks impossible using only two photons. Finally, we link discussions of state distinguishability to the group representations underpinning the exchange symmetry of multiparticle wavefunctions.

Jul 1, 20190 citations

Quantum Entanglement and its Applications

Mohd Asad Siddiqui

This thesis is a dissemination of the work I have done in the last four years, under supervision of Prof. Tabish Qureshi. The central theme is towards the understanding of entanglement as a physical resource and looking for its possible applications. This thesis contains six chapters.The Chapter 1 provides the background knowledge for the thesis work, which includes the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics and the conceptual understanding of entanglement.The Chapter 2 unfolds the idea of fundamental concepts such as Bohr’s complementarity principle, quantum interference, which-path information, their trade-off relation, quantum eraser and also discuss how these issues play their role in building the foundations of quantum theory.The Chapter 3 is devoted to three slit interference experiments. The interference experiment is one of the most prominent concept of quantum theory. The two slit interference set-up is broadly studied and clearly understood, the synopsis for more than two slits are still not clear, recently a focussed research has been shifted towards three slit set-ups. We study the trade-off relation for three slit experiment in terms of visibility and the path distinguishability based on unambiguous quantum state discrimination (UQSD) method.The Chapter 4 discusses the wave-particle duality for multi-slit interference. Several attempts have been made in the past two decades to procure the trade-off relation for multi-slit experiments, yet a satisfactory answer was lacking. We obtain an analogous wave particle duality relation in terms of coherence and path-distinguishability based on UQSD. The role of coherence in building the interference pattern is largely admitted and their amount is readily stated by fringe visibility. Recently coherence has been understood as an information theoretical resource. We explore the measure of coherence as a wave quantifier rather than well known fringe visibility. We also analyze a recently proposed multi-path relation of Bagan et al. which claims to be in Englert’s form. We show that the proposed relation does not hold the essence of complementarity. We also derive a relation similar to Englert’s one to fill the exigency and to explicate its equivalence with our earlier proposed relation.The Chapter 5 discuss the scenario when the source is considered to be entangled. The entangled photon exhibits an interesting phenomenon known as ghost interference. The trade-off relation for two and three slit ghost experiment has been formulated, and also a doable quantum eraser has been proposed.The Chapter 6 aims to use the entanglement as a resource and develop the quantum information technologies, with Quantum Key Distribution (QKD). We propose a QKD protocol using entangled qubits which is shown to add an additional security over the well known BB84 protocol.

Oct 13, 20170 citations

Multi-Photon Interferences of Independent Light Sources

Steffen Oppel

In this thesis we discuss an extension of the historical Hanbury Brown and Twiss experiment and investigate spatial intensity correlations of higher-orders in the radiation field of statistically independent light sources. The light sources can be non-classical like single-photon emitters or classical, obeying thermal or coherent statistics. Although the light sources are assumed to emit the photons in an incoherent manner, we find spatial photon correlations in the far field which can be explained by the quantum mechanical concept of multi-photon interferences. We demonstrate that spatial correlation measurements between indistinguishable photons based on linear optical detection techniques can be used to overcome the resolution limit of classical optics (Abbe/Rayleigh limit) and also to manipulate the spatial radiation characteristic of the light sources. Both remarkable properties of higher-order intensity correlations have been experimentally verified using statistically independent pseudothermal light sources. Due to the fact that the reported correlation measurements require neither special quantum tailoring of light nor N-photon absorbing media, they are of particular interest for the field of quantum imaging and quantum information processing. The thesis is divided into three main parts: In the first part (Chapter 2 and 3) we introduce a quantum path formalism which allows to describe multi-photon interferences arising in both classical and nonclassical light fields. This quantum path approach explains the origin of the underlying interference mechanism of the higher-order spatial intensity correlation functions in a transparent and simple manner. Moreover, it enables us to compare the multi-photon interferences obtained by nonclassical single-photon emitters with those generated by classical light sources. In the course of this discussion it appears that Dirac's famous statement “Each photon interferes only with itself. Interference between two different photons never occurs.” should better read “A multi-photon state of independent photons only interferes with itself. Interference between different multi-photon states never occurs.” This general statement summarizes the physics behind all multi-photon interference phenomena investigated in this thesis. In the second part of the thesis (Chapter 4) we investigate particular multi-photon interference measurements of independent light sources in the context of quantum imaging. We demonstrate that the Nth-order spatial intensity correlation functions display at specific ‘magic’ detector positions the ability to filter sub-wavelength information out of the light fields arising from N incoherently radiating light sources. These multi-photon interference patterns achieve a higher resolution for N>2 than the classical Abbe/Rayleigh limit for imaging the light source. In case of N single-photon emitters we theoretically show that the super-resolving interference patterns obtained for the ‘magic’ detector positions are identical to the ones generated by NOON states with N-1 photons. Quite unexpected, the same is true for N thermal light sources, except for a reduced visibility. Experimental results with up to eight independent thermal light sources confirm this approach to improve the spatial resolution in imaging. In the last part of this thesis (Chapter 5) we finally demonstrate that multi-photon detections can lead to a strong angular focussing of incoherent photons emitted again by either uncorrelated single-photon sources or statistically independent classical light sources. For this effect the sources can be far away from each other and do not interact. The mth-order intensity correlation measurement causes source correlations which produce a heralded peaked emission pattern for the initially uncorrelated light sources. In particular, we show that if m-1 photons have been detected in a particular direction, the conditional probability to detect the mth photon in the same direction can be as high as 100 %. Owing to the great flexibility of detector positions for the correlation measurement, a wide variety of additional detection schemes exists which produces similar directional photon emission patterns. This theoretically predicted measurement-induced focussing was experimentally confirmed with up to eight pseudothermal light sources for three particular detection schemes.

Jan 1, 20120 citations