Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Structure of Quantum Resources for Bell-diagonal states

Jin-Xing Hou, Yunlong Su, Siyuan Liu, Xiaohui Wang

Published Apr 7, 2017• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Two-qubit Bell-diagonal states can be depicted as a tetrahedron in three dimensions. We investigate the structure of quantum resources, including coherence and quantum discord, in the tetrahedron. The ordering of different resources measures is a common problem in resource theories, and which measure should be chosen to investigate the structure of resources is still an open question. We consider the structure of quantum resources which is not affected by the choice of measure. Our work provides a complete structure of coherence and quantum discord for Bell-diagonal states. The pictorial approach also indicates how to explore the structure of resources even when we don't have consistent measure of a concrete quantum resource.

Related papers

Quantum Discord and the Geometry of Bell-Diagonal States

Matthias D. Lang, Carlton M. Caves

The set of Bell-diagonal states for two qubits can be depicted as a tetrahedron in three dimensions. We consider the level surfaces of entanglement and quantum discord for Bell-diagonal states. This provides a complete picture of the structure of entanglement and discord for this simple case and, in particular, of their nonanalytic behavior under decoherence. The pictorial approach also indicates how to show that discord is neither convex nor concave.

arXiv:1006.2775•Physical Review Letters•Oct 4, 2010•220 citations

Surfaces of Constant Discord for Bell-Diagonal States

Matthias Lang, Carlton M. Caves

The set of Bell-diagonal states for two qubits can be depicted as a tetrahedron in three dimensions. We consider the level surfaces of entanglement and quantum discord for Bell-diagonal states. This provides a complete picture of the structure of entanglement and discord for this simple case and, in particular, of their nonanalytic behavior under decoherence. The pictorial approach also indicates how to show that discord is neither convex nor concave.

•Jun 14, 2010•0 citations

Experimental determination of tripartite quantum discord

Vaishali Gulati, Shaileyee Bhowmick, Tim Byrnes +2 more

Quantum discord is a measure of nonclassical correlations in quantum systems. While the bipartite version of quantum discord is experimentally well-studied, the multipartite version has never been convincingly measured. In this study, we experimentally investigate tripartite quantum discord using an NMR quantum information processor. Building on a theoretical framework for conditional projective measurements and quantum conditional mutual information, we quantify the tripartite quantum discord and its contributions in different three-qubit states such as the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) and Werner (W) states as well as classical mixtures of biseparable Bell states, and classical mixtures of product states. The experiments employed full quantum state tomography and temporal averaging to prepare mixed states, achieving fidelities exceeding 95%. Our results confirm that quantum discord persists even in the absence of entanglement, highlighting its utility as a broader indicator of quantum correlations. Furthermore, we validate the nonconvexity of discord, confirming that classical mixtures of zero-discord states can exhibit nonzero discord. This experimentally confirms that quantum discord does not fit into the framework of resource theory. This work establishes a robust methodology for measuring quantum discord, illuminating the structure and distribution of quantum correlations in multipartite systems.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Jul 2, 2025•3 citations

On two-qubit states ordering with quantum discords

M. Okrasa, Zbigniew Walczak

The counterintuitive effect of non-unique ordering of two-qubit states with quantum entanglement measures was discovered over ten years ago. More precisely, it was shown by Monte Carlo simulations that there exist states for which the entanglement of formation and the negativity do not impose the same ordering of states, i.e. E F (ρ AB )⩽(⩾)E F (ρ' AB ) is not equivalent to N (ρ AB )⩽(⩾) N (ρ' AB ). Recently, it was discovered that quantum discord and the geometric quantum discord do not necessarily imply the same ordering of two-qubit X -states, which means that the lack of the unique ordering of states with quantum entanglement measures goes beyond entanglement. Inspired by this observation, we study the problem of the states ordering with quantum discords, considering two-qubit Bell-diagonal states for analytical simplicity. In particular, we identify some classes of states for which the states ordering with quantum discords is preserved as long as the states belong to the same class and give a few illustrative examples.

arXiv:1109.4132•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•May 1, 2012•27 citations

Quantifying necessary quantum resources for nonlocality

Lucas Tendick, Hermann Kampermann, Dagmar Bruß

Nonlocality is one of the most important resources for quantum information protocols.The observation of nonlocal correlations in a Bell experiment is the result of appropriately chosen measurements and quantum states.We quantify the minimal purity to achieve a certain Bell value for any Bell operator.Since purity is the most fundamental resource of a quantum state, this enables us also to quantify the necessary coherence, discord, and entanglement for a given violation of two-qubit correlation inequalities.Our results shine a light on the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality by showing that for a fixed Bell violation an increase in the measurement resources does not always lead to a decrease of the minimal state resources.

arXiv:2102.08722•Physical Review Research•Jan 14, 2022•9 citations

Unification of quantum resources in distributed scenarios

Hongyi Zhou, Xiao Yuan, Xiongfeng Ma

Quantum resources, such as coherence, discord, and entanglement, play a key role for demonstrating an advantage in many computation and communication tasks. In order to find the nature behind these resources, tremendous efforts have been made to explore the connections between them. In this work, we extend the single party coherence resource framework to the distributed scenario and relate it to basis-dependent discord. We show the operational meaning of basis-dependent discord in quantum key distribution and propose its resource measures. With any basis-dependent discord measure, we show how to extend it to measure coherence, discord, and entanglement by considering the relation of the resource free states. Our results lead to a unification of measures of quantum resources.

arXiv:1808.03757•Physical Review A•Feb 22, 2019•10 citations
Two-qubit Bell-diagonal states can be depicted as a tetrahedron in three dimensions. We investigate the structure of quantum resources, including coherence and quantum discord, in the tetrahedron. The ordering of different resources measures is a common problem in resource theories, and which measure should be chosen to investigate the structure of resources is still an open question. We consider the structure of quantum resources which is not affected by the choice of measure. Our work provides a complete structure of coherence and quantum discord for Bell-diagonal states. The pictorial approach also indicates how to explore the structure of resources even when we don't have consistent measure of a concrete quantum resource.
Quantum discord is a measure of nonclassical correlations in quantum systems. While the bipartite version of quantum discord is experimentally well-studied, the multipartite version has never been convincingly measured. In this study, we experimentally investigate tripartite quantum discord using an NMR quantum information processor. Building on a theoretical framework for conditional projective measurements and quantum conditional mutual information, we quantify the tripartite quantum discord and its contributions in different three-qubit states such as the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) and Werner (W) states as well as classical mixtures of biseparable Bell states, and classical mixtures of product states. The experiments employed full quantum state tomography and temporal averaging to prepare mixed states, achieving fidelities exceeding 95%. Our results confirm that quantum discord persists even in the absence of entanglement, highlighting its utility as a broader indicator of quantum correlations. Furthermore, we validate the nonconvexity of discord, confirming that classical mixtures of zero-discord states can exhibit nonzero discord. This experimentally confirms that quantum discord does not fit into the framework of resource theory. This work establishes a robust methodology for measuring quantum discord, illuminating the structure and distribution of quantum correlations in multipartite systems.
The counterintuitive effect of non-unique ordering of two-qubit states with quantum entanglement measures was discovered over ten years ago. More precisely, it was shown by Monte Carlo simulations that there exist states for which the entanglement of formation and the negativity do not impose the same ordering of states, i.e. E F (ρ AB )⩽(⩾)E F (ρ' AB ) is not equivalent to N (ρ AB )⩽(⩾) N (ρ' AB ). Recently, it was discovered that quantum discord and the geometric quantum discord do not necessarily imply the same ordering of two-qubit X -states, which means that the lack of the unique ordering of states with quantum entanglement measures goes beyond entanglement. Inspired by this observation, we study the problem of the states ordering with quantum discords, considering two-qubit Bell-diagonal states for analytical simplicity. In particular, we identify some classes of states for which the states ordering with quantum discords is preserved as long as the states belong to the same class and give a few illustrative examples.
Nonlocality is one of the most important resources for quantum information protocols.The observation of nonlocal correlations in a Bell experiment is the result of appropriately chosen measurements and quantum states.We quantify the minimal purity to achieve a certain Bell value for any Bell operator.Since purity is the most fundamental resource of a quantum state, this enables us also to quantify the necessary coherence, discord, and entanglement for a given violation of two-qubit correlation inequalities.Our results shine a light on the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality by showing that for a fixed Bell violation an increase in the measurement resources does not always lead to a decrease of the minimal state resources.
Quantum resources, such as coherence, discord, and entanglement, play a key role for demonstrating an advantage in many computation and communication tasks. In order to find the nature behind these resources, tremendous efforts have been made to explore the connections between them. In this work, we extend the single party coherence resource framework to the distributed scenario and relate it to basis-dependent discord. We show the operational meaning of basis-dependent discord in quantum key distribution and propose its resource measures. With any basis-dependent discord measure, we show how to extend it to measure coherence, discord, and entanglement by considering the relation of the resource free states. Our results lead to a unification of measures of quantum resources.