Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

Connecting q-mutator theory with experimental tests of the spin-statistics connection

Robert C. Hilborn

Published Jan 1, 2000• 12 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The q-mutator theory is used to connect the value of 1−|q|, the parameter measuring the “difference” between quons and ordinary bosons and fermions, to experiments that test the spin-statistics connection. Such calculations are best carried out using a density matrix formulation because a superselection rule prevents transitions between states associated with different representations of the permutation group. The interpretation of the experimental results, however, in terms of a quantitative limit on 1−|q| can be easily misled by the density matrix formulation. As a concrete example, the theory is applied to a spin-statistics test for photons. The formalism is then applied to spin-statistics tests for electrons in atomic helium and for 16O nuclei in molecules. Finally, the analysis is used to extend experimental limits on composite systems such as 16O nuclei to provide a test of the spin-statistics connection for the constituents of those composite systems (nucleons and quarks in the case of oxygen nuclei).

DOI
10.1063/1.1337722

Related papers

Analysis of an atomic J=0 to J=1 two-photon transition as a test of the spin-statistics connection for photons

Robert C. Hilborn

Using the q-deformed commutator formalism (``q mutators''), we have calculated the two-photon transition amplitude connecting a $J=0$ atomic ground state to a $J=1$ atomic excited state of the same parity. We find, in agreement with a semiclassical calculation, that this transition amplitude vanishes for two equal-frequency photons if the photons are traditional bosons with $q=1.$ If $q<1$ (i.e., if the spin-statistics connection is violated for photons), then the amplitude is nonzero and is proportional to $(1\ensuremath{-}q).$ Thus such an experiment, originally proposed by Budker and DeMille, provides a sensitive test of the spin-statistics connection for photons within the q-mutator formalism.

Physical Review A•Jan 30, 2002•7 citations

Testing the validity of Bose-Einstein statistics in molecules

Pablo Cancio Pastor, Iacopo Galli, Giovanni Giusfredi +2 more

The search for small violations of the validity of the symmetrization postulate and of the spin-statistics connection (SSC) has been addressed in the last four decades by experimental tests performed in different physical systems of identical fermions or bosons. In parallel and consequently, theories extending the quantum mechanics to a more general level have been proposed to explain such possible violations. In this paper, we present the most stringent test to a possible violation of the SSC under permutation of the bosonic $^{16}\mathrm{O}$ nuclei in the $^{12}\mathrm{C}^{16}\mathrm{O}_{2}$ molecule. An upper limit of $3.8\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}12}$ for an SSC-anomalous ${\mathrm{CO}}_{2}$ molecule is obtained using saturated-absorption cavity ring-down spectroscopy in the SSC-forbidden $({00}^{0}1\ensuremath{-}{00}^{0}0) R$(25) rovibrational transition of $^{12}\mathrm{C}^{16}\mathrm{O}_{2}$ at a $4.25\text{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\mu}\mathrm{m}$ wavelength. Quantum mechanics implications of this result are discussed in the frame of the $q$-mutator theory. Finally, the perspective of stringent experimental tests of the symmetrization postulate in molecules that contain three or more identical nuclei is discussed.

Physical Review A•Dec 11, 2015•19 citations

Quon Statistics for Composite Systems and a Limit on the Violation of the Pauli Principle for Nucleons and Quarks

Oscar Wallace Greenberg, Robert C. Hilborn

The quon algebra describes particles, ``quons,'' that are neither fermions nor bosons. The parameter $q$ attached to a quon labels a smooth interpolation between bosons ( $q\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}+1$) and fermions ( $q\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}\ensuremath{-}1$). Wigner and Ehrenfest and Oppenheimer showed that a composite system of identical bosons and fermions is a fermion if it contains an odd number of fermions and is a boson otherwise. We generalize this and show that ${q}_{\mathrm{composite}}{\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}q}_{\mathrm{constituent}}^{{n}^{2}}$ for a system of $n$ identical quons. Using this generalization, we find bounds on possible violations of the Pauli exclusion principle for nucleons and quarks based on such bounds for nuclei.

arXiv:quant-ph/9903020•Physical Review Letters•Nov 29, 1999•39 citations

Small Violations of Statistics

Oscar Wallace Greenberg

There are two motivations to consider statistics that are neither Bose nor Fermi: (1) to extend the framework of quantum theory and of quantum field theory, and (2) to provide a quantitative measure of possible violations of statistics. After reviewing tests of statistics for various particles, and types of statistics that are neither Bose nor Fermi, I discuss quons, particles characterized by the parameter q, which permit a smooth interpolation between Bose and Fermi statistics; q=1 gives bosons, q=−1 gives fermions. The new result of this talk is work by Robert C. Hilborn and myself that gives a heuristic argument for an extension of conservation of statistics to quons with trilinear couplings of the form $$ \bar f$$ fb , where f is fermion-like and b is boson-like. We showed that q f 2=q b. In particular, we related the bound on qg for photons to the bound on q e for electrons, allowing the very precise bound for electrons to be carried over to photons. An extension of our argument suggests that all particles are fermions or bosons to high precision.

arXiv:quant-ph/9903069•Kluwer Academic Publishers eBooks•Dec 19, 2005•5 citations

Testing the symmetrization postulate and the spin-statistics connection for nuclei by molecular spectroscopy

Guglielmo Maria Tino

I present the idea underlying the experiments on molecules to test the validity of the symmetrization postulate of quantum mechanics and the spin-statistics connection for nuclei. I describe in some detail recent experiments on O2 and CO2 molecules and show that these should be considered as tests of the spin-statistics connection for the spin-0 oxygen nuclei. I discuss the possibility of new experiments to test the spin-statistics connection and the symmetrization postulate.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2000•3 citations

Experimental tests of Quantum Mechanics: from Pauli Exclusion Principle Violation to spontaneous collapse models

Catalina Curceanu, Sergio Bartalucci, Angelo Bassi +25 more

The Pauli exclusion principle (PEP) and, more generally, the spin-statistics connection, is at the very basis of our understanding of matter. The PEP spurs, presently, a lively debate on its possible limits, deeply rooted in the very foundations of Quantum Field Theory. Therefore, it is extremely important to test the limits of its validity. Quon theory provides a suitable mathematical framework of possible violation of PEP, where the q violation parameter translates into a probability of violating PEP. Experimentally, setting a bound on PEP violation means confining the q -parameter to a value very close to either 1 (for bosons) or -1 (for fermions). The VIP (Violation of the Pauli exclusion principle) experiment established a limit on the probability that PEP is violated by electrons, using the method of searching for PEP forbidden atomic transitions in copper. We describe the experimental method, the obtained results, both in terms of the q -parameter and as probability of PEP violation, we briefly discuss the results and present future plans to go beyond the actual limit by upgrading the experimental technique using vetoed new spectroscopic fast Silicon Drift Detectors. We mention as well the possibility of using a similar experimental technique to search for eventual X-rays generated as a signature of the spontaneous collapse of the wave function, predicted by continuous spontaneous localization type theories.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 10, 2012•5 citations
The q-mutator theory is used to connect the value of 1−|q|, the parameter measuring the “difference” between quons and ordinary bosons and fermions, to experiments that test the spin-statistics connection. Such calculations are best carried out using a density matrix formulation because a superselection rule prevents transitions between states associated with different representations of the permutation group. The interpretation of the experimental results, however, in terms of a quantitative limit on 1−|q| can be easily misled by the density matrix formulation. As a concrete example, the theory is applied to a spin-statistics test for photons. The formalism is then applied to spin-statistics tests for electrons in atomic helium and for 16O nuclei in molecules. Finally, the analysis is used to extend experimental limits on composite systems such as 16O nuclei to provide a test of the spin-statistics connection for the constituents of those composite systems (nucleons and quarks in the case of oxygen nuclei).
Using the q-deformed commutator formalism (``q mutators''), we have calculated the two-photon transition amplitude connecting a J=0J=0J=0 atomic ground state to a J=1J=1J=1 atomic excited state of the same parity. We find, in agreement with a semiclassical calculation, that this transition amplitude vanishes for two equal-frequency photons if the photons are traditional bosons with q=1.q=1.q=1. If q<1q<1q<1 (i.e., if the spin-statistics connection is violated for photons), then the amplitude is nonzero and is proportional to $(1\ensuremath{-}q).$ Thus such an experiment, originally proposed by Budker and DeMille, provides a sensitive test of the spin-statistics connection for photons within the q-mutator formalism.
The search for small violations of the validity of the symmetrization postulate and of the spin-statistics connection (SSC) has been addressed in the last four decades by experimental tests performed in different physical systems of identical fermions or bosons. In parallel and consequently, theories extending the quantum mechanics to a more general level have been proposed to explain such possible violations. In this paper, we present the most stringent test to a possible violation of the SSC under permutation of the bosonic 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}16O nuclei in the 12C16O2^{12}\mathrm{C}^{16}\mathrm{O}_{2}12C16O2​ molecule. An upper limit of $3.8\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}12}$ for an SSC-anomalous CO2{\mathrm{CO}}_{2}CO2​ molecule is obtained using saturated-absorption cavity ring-down spectroscopy in the SSC-forbidden $({00}^{0}1\ensuremath{-}{00}^{0}0) R$(25) rovibrational transition of 12C16O2^{12}\mathrm{C}^{16}\mathrm{O}_{2}12C16O2​ at a $4.25\text{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\mu}\mathrm{m}$ wavelength. Quantum mechanics implications of this result are discussed in the frame of the qqq-mutator theory. Finally, the perspective of stringent experimental tests of the symmetrization postulate in molecules that contain three or more identical nuclei is discussed.
The quon algebra describes particles, ``quons,'' that are neither fermions nor bosons. The parameter qqq attached to a quon labels a smooth interpolation between bosons ( q=+1q\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}+1q=+1) and fermions ( $q\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}\ensuremath{-}1$). Wigner and Ehrenfest and Oppenheimer showed that a composite system of identical bosons and fermions is a fermion if it contains an odd number of fermions and is a boson otherwise. We generalize this and show that qcomposite=qconstituentn2{q}_{\mathrm{composite}}{\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}q}_{\mathrm{constituent}}^{{n}^{2}}qcomposite​=qconstituentn2​ for a system of nnn identical quons. Using this generalization, we find bounds on possible violations of the Pauli exclusion principle for nucleons and quarks based on such bounds for nuclei.
There are two motivations to consider statistics that are neither Bose nor Fermi: (1) to extend the framework of quantum theory and of quantum field theory, and (2) to provide a quantitative measure of possible violations of statistics. After reviewing tests of statistics for various particles, and types of statistics that are neither Bose nor Fermi, I discuss quons, particles characterized by the parameter q, which permit a smooth interpolation between Bose and Fermi statistics; q=1 gives bosons, q=−1 gives fermions. The new result of this talk is work by Robert C. Hilborn and myself that gives a heuristic argument for an extension of conservation of statistics to quons with trilinear couplings of the form fˉ \bar ffˉ​ fb , where f is fermion-like and b is boson-like. We showed that q f 2=q b. In particular, we related the bound on qg for photons to the bound on q e for electrons, allowing the very precise bound for electrons to be carried over to photons. An extension of our argument suggests that all particles are fermions or bosons to high precision.
The Pauli exclusion principle (PEP) and, more generally, the spin-statistics connection, is at the very basis of our understanding of matter. The PEP spurs, presently, a lively debate on its possible limits, deeply rooted in the very foundations of Quantum Field Theory. Therefore, it is extremely important to test the limits of its validity. Quon theory provides a suitable mathematical framework of possible violation of PEP, where the q violation parameter translates into a probability of violating PEP. Experimentally, setting a bound on PEP violation means confining the q -parameter to a value very close to either 1 (for bosons) or -1 (for fermions). The VIP (Violation of the Pauli exclusion principle) experiment established a limit on the probability that PEP is violated by electrons, using the method of searching for PEP forbidden atomic transitions in copper. We describe the experimental method, the obtained results, both in terms of the q -parameter and as probability of PEP violation, we briefly discuss the results and present future plans to go beyond the actual limit by upgrading the experimental technique using vetoed new spectroscopic fast Silicon Drift Detectors. We mention as well the possibility of using a similar experimental technique to search for eventual X-rays generated as a signature of the spontaneous collapse of the wave function, predicted by continuous spontaneous localization type theories.