Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Analysis of an atomic J=0 to J=1 two-photon transition as a test of the spin-statistics connection for photons

Robert C. Hilborn

Published Jan 30, 2002• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Using the q-deformed commutator formalism (``q mutators''), we have calculated the two-photon transition amplitude connecting a $J=0$ atomic ground state to a $J=1$ atomic excited state of the same parity. We find, in agreement with a semiclassical calculation, that this transition amplitude vanishes for two equal-frequency photons if the photons are traditional bosons with $q=1.$ If $q<1$ (i.e., if the spin-statistics connection is violated for photons), then the amplitude is nonzero and is proportional to $(1\ensuremath{-}q).$ Thus such an experiment, originally proposed by Budker and DeMille, provides a sensitive test of the spin-statistics connection for photons within the q-mutator formalism.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.65.032104

Related papers

How we know that photons are bosons: Experimental tests of spin-statistics for photons

David P. DeMille

We discuss theoretical models and experimental data that shed light on possible small violations of the spin-statistics relation for photons. Particular emphasis is given to our recent experimental search for non-symmetric photon states, using atomic two-photon transitions.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2000•2 citations

Towards an improved test of Bose-Einstein statistics for photons

D. N. Brown

In this contribution we describe our current efforts at Berkeley to improve upon a limit on Bose-Einstein statistics violation for photons obtained earlier (D. P. DeMille, D. Budker, N. Derr, and E. Deveney, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83(20), 1378 (1999)). The principle differences between the new and the previous experiments are the use of a narrow-band cw laser, an atomic beam, a different transition in atomic Ba, and possibly a different detection technique. We also discuss the ultimate limits that one can hope to obtain with this degenerate two-photon transition technique. Some potential conceptual difficulties with the interpretation of this experiment and the ways to avoid them are discussed as well.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2000•2 citations

Atomic parity violation in two-photon J=0-to-1 transitions

Dimitri R. Dounas-Frazer, K.V. Tsigutkin, D. English +1 more

We present a method for measuring nuclear-spin-dependent atomic parity violation without nuclear-spin-independent background. Such measurements can be achieved by observing interference of parity-conserving and parity-violating two-photon J=0-to-1 transitions driven by collinear photons of the same frequency in the presence of an external static magnetic field.

arXiv:1111.0102•Nov 1, 2011•1 citation

Exclusion principle for photons: Spin-statistic selection rules for multiphoton transitions in atomic systems

Timur A. Zalialiutdinov, Dmitry A. Solovyev, Leonti N Labzowsky +1 more

We establish the existence of spin-statistic selection rules (SSSRs) for multiphoton transitions with equal photons in atomic systems. These selection rules are similar to those for systems of many equivalent electrons in atomic theory. The latter are a direct consequence of the Pauli exclusion principle. In this sense, the SSSRs play the role of the exclusion principle for photons: they forbid some particular states for the photon systems. We established several SSSRs for few-photon systems. (i) First rule: two equivalent photons involved in any atomic transition can have only even values of the total angular momentum, $J$. This selection rule is an extension of the Landau-Yang theorem to the photons involved in atomic transitions. (ii) Second rule: three equivalent dipole photons involved in any atomic transition can have only odd values of the total angular momentum, $J=1,3$. (iii) Third rule: four equivalent dipole photons involved in any atomic transition can have only even values of the total angular momentum, $J=0,2,4$. We also suggest a method for a possible experimental test of these SSSRs by means of laser experiments.

arXiv:1411.1591•Physical Review A•Mar 30, 2015•11 citations

Symmetry-suppressed two-photon transitions induced by hyperfine interactions and magnetic fields

M. G. Kozlov, D. English, Dmitry Budker

Two-photon transitions between atomic states of total electronic angular-momentum ${J}_{a}=0$ and ${J}_{b}=1$ are forbidden when the photons are of the same energy. This selection rule is analogous to the Landau-Yang theorem in particle physics that forbids decays of vector particle into two photons. It arises because it is impossible to construct a total angular-momentum ${J}_{2\ensuremath{\gamma}}=1$ quantum-mechanical state of two photons that is permutation symmetric, as required by Bose-Einstein statistics. In atoms with nonzero nuclear spin, the selection rule can be violated due to hyperfine interactions. Two distinct mechanisms responsible for the hyperfine-induced two-photon transitions are identified, and the hyperfine structure of the induced transitions is evaluated. The selection rule is also relaxed, even for zero-nuclear-spin atoms, by application of an external magnetic field. Once again, there are two similar mechanisms at play: Zeeman splitting of the intermediate-state sublevels, and off-diagonal mixing of states with different total electronic angular momentum in the final state. The present theoretical treatment is relevant to the ongoing experimental search for a possible Bose-Einstein-statistics violation using two-photon transitions in barium, where the hyperfine-induced transitions have been recently observed, and the magnetic-field-induced transitions are being considered both as a possible systematic effect, and as a way to calibrate the measurement.

arXiv:0907.3727•Physical Review A•Oct 9, 2009•10 citations

Connecting q-mutator theory with experimental tests of the spin-statistics connection

Robert C. Hilborn

The q-mutator theory is used to connect the value of 1−|q|, the parameter measuring the “difference” between quons and ordinary bosons and fermions, to experiments that test the spin-statistics connection. Such calculations are best carried out using a density matrix formulation because a superselection rule prevents transitions between states associated with different representations of the permutation group. The interpretation of the experimental results, however, in terms of a quantitative limit on 1−|q| can be easily misled by the density matrix formulation. As a concrete example, the theory is applied to a spin-statistics test for photons. The formalism is then applied to spin-statistics tests for electrons in atomic helium and for 16O nuclei in molecules. Finally, the analysis is used to extend experimental limits on composite systems such as 16O nuclei to provide a test of the spin-statistics connection for the constituents of those composite systems (nucleons and quarks in the case of oxygen nuclei).

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2000•12 citations
Using the q-deformed commutator formalism (``q mutators''), we have calculated the two-photon transition amplitude connecting a J=0J=0J=0 atomic ground state to a J=1J=1J=1 atomic excited state of the same parity. We find, in agreement with a semiclassical calculation, that this transition amplitude vanishes for two equal-frequency photons if the photons are traditional bosons with q=1.q=1.q=1. If q<1q<1q<1 (i.e., if the spin-statistics connection is violated for photons), then the amplitude is nonzero and is proportional to (1\ensuremath−q).(1\ensuremath{-}q).(1\ensuremath−q). Thus such an experiment, originally proposed by Budker and DeMille, provides a sensitive test of the spin-statistics connection for photons within the q-mutator formalism.
In this contribution we describe our current efforts at Berkeley to improve upon a limit on Bose-Einstein statistics violation for photons obtained earlier (D. P. DeMille, D. Budker, N. Derr, and E. Deveney, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83(20), 1378 (1999)). The principle differences between the new and the previous experiments are the use of a narrow-band cw laser, an atomic beam, a different transition in atomic Ba, and possibly a different detection technique. We also discuss the ultimate limits that one can hope to obtain with this degenerate two-photon transition technique. Some potential conceptual difficulties with the interpretation of this experiment and the ways to avoid them are discussed as well.
We establish the existence of spin-statistic selection rules (SSSRs) for multiphoton transitions with equal photons in atomic systems. These selection rules are similar to those for systems of many equivalent electrons in atomic theory. The latter are a direct consequence of the Pauli exclusion principle. In this sense, the SSSRs play the role of the exclusion principle for photons: they forbid some particular states for the photon systems. We established several SSSRs for few-photon systems. (i) First rule: two equivalent photons involved in any atomic transition can have only even values of the total angular momentum, JJJ. This selection rule is an extension of the Landau-Yang theorem to the photons involved in atomic transitions. (ii) Second rule: three equivalent dipole photons involved in any atomic transition can have only odd values of the total angular momentum, J=1,3J=1,3J=1,3. (iii) Third rule: four equivalent dipole photons involved in any atomic transition can have only even values of the total angular momentum, J=0,2,4J=0,2,4J=0,2,4. We also suggest a method for a possible experimental test of these SSSRs by means of laser experiments.
Two-photon transitions between atomic states of total electronic angular-momentum Ja=0{J}_{a}=0Ja​=0 and Jb=1{J}_{b}=1Jb​=1 are forbidden when the photons are of the same energy. This selection rule is analogous to the Landau-Yang theorem in particle physics that forbids decays of vector particle into two photons. It arises because it is impossible to construct a total angular-momentum ${J}_{2\ensuremath{\gamma}}=1$ quantum-mechanical state of two photons that is permutation symmetric, as required by Bose-Einstein statistics. In atoms with nonzero nuclear spin, the selection rule can be violated due to hyperfine interactions. Two distinct mechanisms responsible for the hyperfine-induced two-photon transitions are identified, and the hyperfine structure of the induced transitions is evaluated. The selection rule is also relaxed, even for zero-nuclear-spin atoms, by application of an external magnetic field. Once again, there are two similar mechanisms at play: Zeeman splitting of the intermediate-state sublevels, and off-diagonal mixing of states with different total electronic angular momentum in the final state. The present theoretical treatment is relevant to the ongoing experimental search for a possible Bose-Einstein-statistics violation using two-photon transitions in barium, where the hyperfine-induced transitions have been recently observed, and the magnetic-field-induced transitions are being considered both as a possible systematic effect, and as a way to calibrate the measurement.
The q-mutator theory is used to connect the value of 1−|q|, the parameter measuring the “difference” between quons and ordinary bosons and fermions, to experiments that test the spin-statistics connection. Such calculations are best carried out using a density matrix formulation because a superselection rule prevents transitions between states associated with different representations of the permutation group. The interpretation of the experimental results, however, in terms of a quantitative limit on 1−|q| can be easily misled by the density matrix formulation. As a concrete example, the theory is applied to a spin-statistics test for photons. The formalism is then applied to spin-statistics tests for electrons in atomic helium and for 16O nuclei in molecules. Finally, the analysis is used to extend experimental limits on composite systems such as 16O nuclei to provide a test of the spin-statistics connection for the constituents of those composite systems (nucleons and quarks in the case of oxygen nuclei).