The art of being wise is the art of knowing what to overlook. William James Summary This chapter is devoted to idealized models and theoretical concepts that underlie the topics in the rest of this book. Among the most dramatic effects are the Wigner and Mott transitions, exemplified by electrons in a homogeneous background of positive charge and by the Hubbard model of a crystal. Fermi liquid theory is the paradigm for understanding quasi-particles and collective excitations in metals, building on a continuous link between a non-interacting and an interacting system. The Luttinger theorem and Friedel sum rule are conservation laws for quantities that do not vary at all with the interaction. The Heisenberg and Ising models exemplify the properties of localized electronic states that act as spins. The Anderson impurity model is the paradigm for understanding local moment behavior and is used directly in dynamical mean-field theory. The previous chapters discuss examples of experimental observations where effects of interactions can be appreciated with only basic knowledge of physics and chemistry. The purpose of this chapter is to give a concise discussion of models that illustrate major characteristics of interacting electrons. These are prototypes that bring out features that occur in real problems, such as the examples in the previous chapter. They are also pedagogical examples for the theoretical methods developed later, with references to specific sections. The Wigner transition and the homogeneous electron system The simplest model of interacting electrons in condensed matter is the homogeneous electron system, also called homogeneous electron gas (HEG), an infinite system of electrons with a uniform compensating positive charge background. It was originally introduced as a model for alkali metals. Now the HEG is a standard model system for the development of density functionals and a widely used test system for the many-body perturbation methods in Chs. 10–15. It is also an important model for quantum Monte Carlo calculations, described in Chs. 23–25. To define the model, we take the hamiltonian in Eq. (1.1) and replace the nuclei by a rigid uniform positive charge with density equal to the electron charge density n .
The art of being wise is the art of knowing what to overlook. William James Summary This chapter is devoted to idealized models and theoretical concepts that underlie the topics in the rest of this book. Among the most dramatic effects are the Wigner and Mott transitions, exemplified by electrons in a homogeneous background of positive charge and by the Hubbard model of a crystal. Fermi liquid theory is the paradigm for understanding quasi-particles and collective excitations in metals, building on a continuous link between a non-interacting and an interacting system. The Luttinger theorem and Friedel sum rule are conservation laws for quantities that do not vary at all with the interaction. The Heisenberg and Ising models exemplify the properties of localized electronic states that act as spins. The Anderson impurity model is the paradigm for understanding local moment behavior and is used directly in dynamical mean-field theory. The previous chapters discuss examples of experimental observations where effects of interactions can be appreciated with only basic knowledge of physics and chemistry. The purpose of this chapter is to give a concise discussion of models that illustrate major characteristics of interacting electrons. These are prototypes that bring out features that occur in real problems, such as the examples in the previous chapter. They are also pedagogical examples for the theoretical methods developed later, with references to specific sections. The Wigner transition and the homogeneous electron system The simplest model of interacting electrons in condensed matter is the homogeneous electron system, also called homogeneous electron gas (HEG), an infinite system of electrons with a uniform compensating positive charge background. It was originally introduced as a model for alkali metals. Now the HEG is a standard model system for the development of density functionals and a widely used test system for the many-body perturbation methods in Chs. 10–15. It is also an important model for quantum Monte Carlo calculations, described in Chs. 23–25. To define the model, we take the hamiltonian in Eq. (1.1) and replace the nuclei by a rigid uniform positive charge with density equal to the electron charge density n .
Art is the elimination of the unnecessary. Pablo Picasso Summary Condensed matter is constituted by a huge number of electrons and nuclei interacting with Coulomb potentials. The topic of this chapter is a way to deal with the full, coupled problem by separating it into a part that is tractable and the rest that is approximated. This naturally leads to the appearance of dynamical fields, and to the concept of “quasi-particles” that have the same quantum numbers as non-interacting electrons. The quasi-particles obey equations where the potential and bare interactions in the hamiltonian are replaced by dynamical self-energies and screened interactions that can describe many of the effects of correlation. In this chapter we discuss the intuitive concepts behind this approach in general terms to motivate the more rigorous formulations and approximations used in the Green's function methods of the following chapter and in Part III. The first equations of this book, Eqs. (1.1) and (1.2), express the fundamental theory of matter in terms of electrons and nuclei that interact with Coulomb potentials. For systems with only a few electrons, a solution of the problem can be obtained by exact diagonalization, using configuration interaction methods. For many-electron systems one has to resort to other methods. For example, QMC stochastic simulations (Chs. 22–25) are among the most accurate methods known to calculate certain expectation values, such as equilibrium thermodynamic properties, total energies, the density, and various static correlation functions like those in Ch. 5. Other properties such as excitation spectra are more difficult to access with QMC. Straightforward perturbation theory is, in general, not appropriate since interactions among the electrons are of the same order of magnitude as the independent-particle terms. Hence, we must develop other approaches. One strategy that gives access to equilibrium thermodynamic as well as dynamical excitation properties is to separate the interacting many-body problem into a part that is tractable by some means and the rest of the problem that is dealt with more approximately. The present chapter is devoted to this idea. It is a prelude to many-body Green's function methods; the aim is to provide a unified framework for the developments in Chs. 8–21, along with a qualitative description of the most relevant quantities.
Real knowledge is to know the extent of one's ignorance. Confucius, 500 BCE Summary The topic of this chapter is a small selection of the vast array of experimentally observed phenomena chosen to exemplify crucial roles played by the electron– electron interaction. Examples in the present chapter bring out the effects of correlation in ground and excited states as well as in thermal equilibrium. These raise challenges for theory and quantitative many-body methods in treating interacting electrons, the topics of the following chapters. The title of this book is Interacting Electrons . Of course, there are no non-interacting electrons: in any system with more than one electron, the electron–electron interaction affects the energy and leads to correlation between the electrons. All first-principles theories deal with the electron–electron interaction in some way, but often they treat the electrons as independent fermions in a static mean-field potential that contains interaction effects approximately. As described in Ch. 4, the Hartree–Fock method is a variational approximation with a wavefunction for fermions that are uncorrelated, except for the requirement of antisymmetry. The Kohn–Sham approach to DFT defines an auxiliary system of independent fermions that is chosen to reproduce the ground-state density. It is exact in principle and remarkably successful in practice. However, many properties such as excitation energies are not supposed to be taken directly from the Kohn–Sham equations, even in principle. Various other methods attempt to incorporate some effect of correlation in the choice of the potential. This chapter is designed to highlight a few examples of experimentally observed phenomena that demonstrate qualitative consequences of electron–electron interactions beyond independent-particle approximations. Some examples illustrate effects that cannot be accounted for in any theory where electrons are considered as independent particles. Others are direct experimental measurements of correlation functions that would vanish if the electrons were independent. In yet other cases, a phenomenon can be explained in terms of independent particles in some effective potential, but it is deeply unsatisfying if one has to invent a different potential for every case, even for different properties in the same material. A satisfactory theory ultimately requires us to confront the problem of interacting, correlated electrons.
To avoid confusion, it is necessary to be quite explicit about what is assumed and what is to be proved. A. Klein, Phys. Rev. 121, 950 (1961) Summary The topic of this chapter is functionals that provide a concise formulation for thermodynamic quantities and Green's function methods in interacting many-body systems. Building upon the instructive examples of density functional theory and the Hartree– Fock approximation, functionals of the Green's function are developed to provide a framework for practical methods used extensively in many-body perturbation theory (Chs. 9–15), dynamical mean-field theory (Chs. 16–20), and their combination in Ch. 21. Functional concepts give a firm foundation for those methods, for example, they give the conditions for approximations to obey conservation laws. Additional background and specific aspects are in App. H. Many physical quantities can be expressed as functionals , i.e., they depend on an entire function.1 For example, in the quantum variational method to determine a wavefunction, the total energy of a system of many electrons is a functional of a many-body trial wavefunction ( r 1 , r 2 , …): it is the expectation value of the hamiltonian. At the variational minimum, assuming the trial wavefunction is completely flexible, one finds the many-body Schrödinger equation for the ground state. Many of the properties we are interested in are, formally, simple functionals of the ground- or excited-state wavefunctions. In the search for feasible ways to calculate properties such as excitation spectra, we are led to different types of functional. The idea is to deal only with a physical, measurable quantity Q of interest and a variational functional E [ Q ] of this quantity. The variational character of E allows one to derive equations that determine Q 0 , the value of Q for the system in a desired state, typically the ground state or equilibrium state at T ≠ 0. Other properties should be different functionals F m [ Q ] that can then be evaluated at Q = Q 0 . This strategy is outlined in Fig. 8.1. To appreciate the power of such approaches, one can consider the impact of density functional theory, which is formulated as a functional of the density n ( r ) of electrons; it is defined for a range of densities and the variational minimum for the energy functional E [ n ] leads to equations to determine the actual ground-state density n 0 ( r ) and total energy E 0 .
Abstract The study of the interacting electron gas moving in a charge-compensating background of positively charged ions is central in this book. Not only is this system a model of the solids that surround us, such as metals, semiconductors, and insulators, but historically this system played a major role as testing ground for the development of quantum field theory. In this chapter we shall study the basic properties of this system using the formalism of time-independent second quantization as developed in Chap. 1. The main emphasis will be on the non-interacting electron gas, since it will be clear that we need to develop our theoretical tools further to deal with the electron-electron interactions in full.
The calculation of a wavefunction took about two afternoons, and five wavefunctions were calculated in the whole …. Wigner and Seitz, 1933 Summary In order to explain many important properties of materials and phenomena, it is necessary to go beyond independent-particle approximations and directly account for many-body effects that result from electronic interaction. The many-body problem is a major scientific challenge, but there has been great progress resulting from theoretical developments and advances in computation. This chapter is a short introduction to the interacting-electron problem, with some of the history that has led up to the concepts and methods described in this book. The many-body interacting-electron problem ranks among the most fascinating and fruitful areas of research in physics and chemistry. It has a rich history, starting from the early days of quantum mechanics and continuing with new intellectual challenges and opportunities. The vitality of electronic structure theory arises in large part from the close connection with experiment and applications. It is spurred on by new discoveries and advances in techniques that probe the behavior of electrons in depth. In turn, theoretical concepts and calculations can now make predictions that suggest new experiments, as well as provide quantitative information that is difficult or not yet possible to measure experimentally. This book is concerned with the effects of interactions between electrons beyond independent-particle approximations. Some phenomena cannot be explained by any independent-electron method, such as broadening and lifetime of excited states and two-particle bound states (excitons) that are crucial for optical properties of materials. There are many other examples, such as the van derWaals interaction between neutral molecules that arises from the dipole–induced dipole interaction. This force, which is entirely due to correlation between electrons, is an essential mechanism determining the functions of biological systems. Other properties, such as thermodynamically stable magnetic phases, would not exist if there were no interactions between electrons; even though mean-field approximations can describe average effects, they do not account for fluctuations around the average. Ground-state properties, such as the equilibrium structures of molecules and solids, can be described by density functional theory (DFT) and the Kohn–Sham independent-particle equations. However, present approximations are often not sufficient, and for many properties the equations, when used in a straightforward way, do not give a proper description, even in principle.