Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

OALib

Problems with Mathematically Real Quantum Wave Functions

E. Comay

Published Jan 1, 2016• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Theories of a mathematically real quantum function are discussed.The analysis relies on fundamental elements of quantum theories and proves the existence of a new type of problems in these theories.Particle density plays a key role in the discussion.The results show new contradictions in the Majorana neutrino theory and in the Yukawa theory of the nuclear interaction.Experimental data support these conclusions.New problems exist with the theories of the Z and the Higgs bosons.

DOI
10.4236/oalib.1102921

Related papers

Fundamental Concepts of Quantum Theories

Eliahu Comay

The foundations of the mathematical structure of quantum theories of a massive particle are the basis of this analysis.It proves the coherence of the particle-wave duality of quantum theories and the principle of complementarity as well.Furthermore, the noncommutativity of Hermitian operators proves that quantum theories are inherently indeterministic.This feature does not deny the fact that the classical limit of quantum theories agrees with classical physics.It is also shown that the foundations of the mathematical structure of quantum theories impose constraints on any specific quantum theory.It is proved that the first-order Dirac theory is consistent with all constraints.In contrast, second-order theories, such as the Klein-Gordon, the electroweak theory of the W ± and the Z particles, and the Higgs boson theory fail to do that.An analogous analysis proves that also the Majorana neutrino theory is inconsistent with fundamental requirements.Similarly, inconsistencies of Proca's idea about a massive photon are shown.

OALib•Jan 1, 2020•2 citations

The Wave Function Cannot Be a Real Wave—Then, Can We Speak of an Ontology of Particles?

Sofia Wechsler

Is the wave-function a physical reality traveling through our apparatus? Is it a real wave, or it is only a mathematical tool for calculating probabilities of results of measurements? Different interpretations of the quantum mechanics (QM) assume different answers to this question. It is shown in this article that the assumption that the wave-function is a real wave entails a contradiction with the predictions of the QM, when the special relativity is invoked. Therefore, this text concentrates on interpretations that conjecture that the reality that moves in our apparatuses is particles, and they move under the constraints of the wave-function. The de Broglie-Bohm interpretation, which matches this picture, assumes that the particle travels along a continuous trajectory. However, the idea of continuous trajectories was proved to lead to a contradiction with the quantum predictions. Therefore this interpretation is not considered here. S. Gao conjectured that the particle is in a permanent random and discontinuous motion (RDM). As it jumps all the time from place to place, the total set of occupied positions at a certain time is given by the absolute square of the wave-function. As motivation for his idea, Gao argued that if a charged particle were simultaneously in two or more locations at the same time, the copies of the particle would repel one another, destroying the wave-function. It is proved here that the quantum formalism renders this motivation wrong. Although refuting this motivation, the RDM interpretation is examined here. A couple of problems of this interpretation are examined and it is proved that they don’t lead to any observable contradictions with the QM predictions, except one problem which seems to have no solution. In all, it appears that none of the wide-spread interpretations of the QM is free of contradictions.

arXiv:2210.03530•Journal of Quantum Information Science•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Does the quantum mechanical wave function exist?

Claus Kiefer

I address the question whether the wave function in quantum theory exists as a real (ontic) quantity or not. For this purpose, I discuss the essentials of the quantum formalism and emphasize the central role of the superposition principle. I then explain the measurement problem and discuss the process of decoherence. Finally, I address the special features that the quantization of gravity brings into the game. From all of this I conclude that the wave function really exists, that is, it is a real (ontic) feature of Nature.

arXiv:1908.04607•Philosophical Problems in Science (Zagadnienia Filozoficzne w Nauce)•Jul 30, 2019•0 citations

The Significance of Density in the Structure of Quantum Theories

E. Comay

It is proved that density plays a crucial role in the structure of quantum field theory. The Dirac and the Klein-Gordon equations are examined. The results prove that the Dirac equation is consistent with density related requirements whereas the Klein-Gordon equation fails to do that. Experimental data support these conclusions.

arXiv:quant-ph/0605187•May 22, 2006•1 citation

The Wave Function and Quantum Reality

Shan Gao, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Gregg S. Jaeger +2 more

We investigate the meaning of the wave function by analyzing the mass and charge density distributions of a quantum system. According to protective measurement, a charged quantum system has effective mass and charge density distributing in space, proportional to the square of the absolute value of its wave function. In a realistic interpretation, the wave function of a quantum system can be taken as a description of either a physical field or the ergodic motion of a particle. The essential difference between a field and the ergodic motion of a particle lies in the property of simultaneity; a field exists throughout space simultaneously, whereas the ergodic motion of a particle exists throughout space in a time‐divided way. If the wave function is a physical field, then the mass and charge density will be distributed in space simultaneously for a charged quantum system, and thus there will exist gravitational and electrostatic self‐interactions of its wave function. This not only violates the superposition principle of quantum mechanics but also contradicts experimental observations. Thus the wave function cannot be a description of a physical field but be a description of the ergodic motion of a particle. For the later there is only a localized particle with mass and charge at every instant, and thus there will not exist any self‐interaction for the wave function. It is further argued that the classical ergodic models, which assume continuous motion of particles, cannot be consistent with quantum mechanics. Based on the negative result, we suggest that the wave function is a description of the quantum motion of particles, which is random and discontinuous in nature. On this interpretation, the square of the absolute value of the wave function not only gives the probability of the particle being found in certain locations, but also gives the probability of the particle being there. The suggested new interpretation of the wave function provides a natural realistic alternative to the orthodox interpretation, and it also implies that the de Broglie‐Bohm theory and many‐worlds interpretation are wrong and the dynamical collapse theories are in the right direction by admitting wavefunction collapse.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•2 citations

On the Crucial Role of the Variational Principle in Quantum Theories

Eliahu Comay

The paper shows that the variational principle serves as an element of the mathematical structure of a quantum theory. The experimentally confirmed properties of the corpuscular-wave duality of a quantum particle are elements of the analysis. A Lagrangian density that yields the equations of motion of a given quantum theory of a massive particle is analyzed. It is proved that if this Lagrangian density is a Lorentz scalar whose dimension is then the associated action consistently defines the required phase of the quantum particle. The dimension of this Lagrangian density proves that also the quantum function has dimension. This result provides new criteria for the acceptability of quantum theories. An examination of the first order Dirac equation demonstrates that it satisfies the new criteria whereas the second order Klein-Gordon equation fails to do that.

Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations
Theories of a mathematically real quantum function are discussed.The analysis relies on fundamental elements of quantum theories and proves the existence of a new type of problems in these theories.Particle density plays a key role in the discussion.The results show new contradictions in the Majorana neutrino theory and in the Yukawa theory of the nuclear interaction.Experimental data support these conclusions.New problems exist with the theories of the Z and the Higgs bosons.
The foundations of the mathematical structure of quantum theories of a massive particle are the basis of this analysis.It proves the coherence of the particle-wave duality of quantum theories and the principle of complementarity as well.Furthermore, the noncommutativity of Hermitian operators proves that quantum theories are inherently indeterministic.This feature does not deny the fact that the classical limit of quantum theories agrees with classical physics.It is also shown that the foundations of the mathematical structure of quantum theories impose constraints on any specific quantum theory.It is proved that the first-order Dirac theory is consistent with all constraints.In contrast, second-order theories, such as the Klein-Gordon, the electroweak theory of the W ± and the Z particles, and the Higgs boson theory fail to do that.An analogous analysis proves that also the Majorana neutrino theory is inconsistent with fundamental requirements.Similarly, inconsistencies of Proca's idea about a massive photon are shown.
Is the wave-function a physical reality traveling through our apparatus? Is it a real wave, or it is only a mathematical tool for calculating probabilities of results of measurements? Different interpretations of the quantum mechanics (QM) assume different answers to this question. It is shown in this article that the assumption that the wave-function is a real wave entails a contradiction with the predictions of the QM, when the special relativity is invoked. Therefore, this text concentrates on interpretations that conjecture that the reality that moves in our apparatuses is particles, and they move under the constraints of the wave-function. The de Broglie-Bohm interpretation, which matches this picture, assumes that the particle travels along a continuous trajectory. However, the idea of continuous trajectories was proved to lead to a contradiction with the quantum predictions. Therefore this interpretation is not considered here. S. Gao conjectured that the particle is in a permanent random and discontinuous motion (RDM). As it jumps all the time from place to place, the total set of occupied positions at a certain time is given by the absolute square of the wave-function. As motivation for his idea, Gao argued that if a charged particle were simultaneously in two or more locations at the same time, the copies of the particle would repel one another, destroying the wave-function. It is proved here that the quantum formalism renders this motivation wrong. Although refuting this motivation, the RDM interpretation is examined here. A couple of problems of this interpretation are examined and it is proved that they don’t lead to any observable contradictions with the QM predictions, except one problem which seems to have no solution. In all, it appears that none of the wide-spread interpretations of the QM is free of contradictions.
I address the question whether the wave function in quantum theory exists as a real (ontic) quantity or not. For this purpose, I discuss the essentials of the quantum formalism and emphasize the central role of the superposition principle. I then explain the measurement problem and discuss the process of decoherence. Finally, I address the special features that the quantization of gravity brings into the game. From all of this I conclude that the wave function really exists, that is, it is a real (ontic) feature of Nature.
We investigate the meaning of the wave function by analyzing the mass and charge density distributions of a quantum system. According to protective measurement, a charged quantum system has effective mass and charge density distributing in space, proportional to the square of the absolute value of its wave function. In a realistic interpretation, the wave function of a quantum system can be taken as a description of either a physical field or the ergodic motion of a particle. The essential difference between a field and the ergodic motion of a particle lies in the property of simultaneity; a field exists throughout space simultaneously, whereas the ergodic motion of a particle exists throughout space in a time‐divided way. If the wave function is a physical field, then the mass and charge density will be distributed in space simultaneously for a charged quantum system, and thus there will exist gravitational and electrostatic self‐interactions of its wave function. This not only violates the superposition principle of quantum mechanics but also contradicts experimental observations. Thus the wave function cannot be a description of a physical field but be a description of the ergodic motion of a particle. For the later there is only a localized particle with mass and charge at every instant, and thus there will not exist any self‐interaction for the wave function. It is further argued that the classical ergodic models, which assume continuous motion of particles, cannot be consistent with quantum mechanics. Based on the negative result, we suggest that the wave function is a description of the quantum motion of particles, which is random and discontinuous in nature. On this interpretation, the square of the absolute value of the wave function not only gives the probability of the particle being found in certain locations, but also gives the probability of the particle being there. The suggested new interpretation of the wave function provides a natural realistic alternative to the orthodox interpretation, and it also implies that the de Broglie‐Bohm theory and many‐worlds interpretation are wrong and the dynamical collapse theories are in the right direction by admitting wavefunction collapse.
The paper shows that the variational principle serves as an element of the mathematical structure of a quantum theory. The experimentally confirmed properties of the corpuscular-wave duality of a quantum particle are elements of the analysis. A Lagrangian density that yields the equations of motion of a given quantum theory of a massive particle is analyzed. It is proved that if this Lagrangian density is a Lorentz scalar whose dimension is then the associated action consistently defines the required phase of the quantum particle. The dimension of this Lagrangian density proves that also the quantum function has dimension. This result provides new criteria for the acceptability of quantum theories. An examination of the first order Dirac equation demonstrates that it satisfies the new criteria whereas the second order Klein-Gordon equation fails to do that.