Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics

On the Crucial Role of the Variational Principle in Quantum Theories

Eliahu Comay

Published Jan 1, 2017• 0 citations

Abstract

The paper shows that the variational principle serves as an element of the mathematical structure of a quantum theory. The experimentally confirmed properties of the corpuscular-wave duality of a quantum particle are elements of the analysis. A Lagrangian density that yields the equations of motion of a given quantum theory of a massive particle is analyzed. It is proved that if this Lagrangian density is a Lorentz scalar whose dimension is then the associated action consistently defines the required phase of the quantum particle. The dimension of this Lagrangian density proves that also the quantum function has dimension. This result provides new criteria for the acceptability of quantum theories. An examination of the first order Dirac equation demonstrates that it satisfies the new criteria whereas the second order Klein-Gordon equation fails to do that.

DOI: 10.4236/jamp.2017.511171

Related papers

Remarks on the Order of Quantum Equations of Motion

Eliahu Comay

The paper examines the Dirac-Pauli differences concerning the order of the primary differential equation of an elementary massive quantum particle.The analysis relies on several self-evident constraints that an acceptable quantum theory must satisfy, like conservation laws, compatibility with Maxwellian electrodynamics and the correspondence principle.The dimension of the quantum function that is used in the Lagrangian density of a given quantum theory together with the corresponding differential equations play an important role in the reasoning procedure.The paper proves that Dirac was right and that second-order quantum theories like the Klein-Gordon equation and the electroweak theory of the W ± bosons do not satisfy fundamental constraints.This outcome is inconsistent with the Standard Model of Particle Physics.

OALibJan 1, 20201 citation

Hamiltonian, Lagrangian and Physical Laws

E. Comay

The significance of the correspondence between the classical limit of quantum theories and the laws of classical physics is explained.It is proved that this correspondence yields constraints on acceptable quantum theories.The variational principle is taken as the basis of the analysis.The discussion shows that the first order Dirac equation abides by these constraints, whereas second order quantum equations fail to do that.

OALibJan 1, 20191 citation

Fundamental Concepts of Quantum Theories

Eliahu Comay

The foundations of the mathematical structure of quantum theories of a massive particle are the basis of this analysis.It proves the coherence of the particle-wave duality of quantum theories and the principle of complementarity as well.Furthermore, the noncommutativity of Hermitian operators proves that quantum theories are inherently indeterministic.This feature does not deny the fact that the classical limit of quantum theories agrees with classical physics.It is also shown that the foundations of the mathematical structure of quantum theories impose constraints on any specific quantum theory.It is proved that the first-order Dirac theory is consistent with all constraints.In contrast, second-order theories, such as the Klein-Gordon, the electroweak theory of the W ± and the Z particles, and the Higgs boson theory fail to do that.An analogous analysis proves that also the Majorana neutrino theory is inconsistent with fundamental requirements.Similarly, inconsistencies of Proca's idea about a massive photon are shown.

OALibJan 1, 20203 citations

The Significance of Density in the Structure of Quantum Theories

E. Comay

It is proved that density plays a crucial role in the structure of quantum field theory. The Dirac and the Klein-Gordon equations are examined. The results prove that the Dirac equation is consistent with density related requirements whereas the Klein-Gordon equation fails to do that. Experimental data support these conclusions.

arXiv:quant-ph/0605187May 22, 20061 citation

To Principles of Quantum Mechanics Development

Dmitri Yerchuck, Alla Dovlatova, F. N. Borovik +2 more

New insight on the principles of the quantum physics development is given. The quite different behavior of quantum microworld mechanical systems in comparison with classical mechanical macroworld systems is attributed to the drastical change of the role of the gravitation field on the dynamics of microworld mechanical systems, for which it seems to be vanishing in com- parison with the role of the gravitation field on the dynamics of macroworld mechanical systems, for which it is decisive. The conclusion on the status of the second main postulate of quantum mechanics is given. Its formulation in all textbooks has to be represented in the form of the proved statement, since the hypothesis of Schrödinger on the existence of the field scalar function, being to be observable quantity, just charge density, is strictly mathematically proved. It is shown, that the field scalar function, being to be the solution of the corresponding nonstationary in general case Schrödinger equation and being to be the function the only of coordinates and time, actually describes the state of the atomic system, more strictly its corpuscular aspect. The atomic system is considered from the positions of the field theory, that is, it is the association of elementary particles with corresponding fields. The given fields being to be the media for the particles’ propagation are responsible for the wave aspect in the characteristic of atomic systems. The wave aspect is described by the independent scalar wave-function which was also introduced in quantum physics by Schrödinger, althogh the given fact seems to be unknown to the wide circle of the readers. The second main postulate being to be mathematically strictly grounded in Schrödinger formulation of quantum nechanics, in the popular probabilistic form of quantum nechanics cannot be proved for the general case, although the probabilistic theatise, proposed by Born is true in a number of special cases, quite correctly indicated by Dirac. The possible ways of the development of quantum theory, based on clear understanding of the origin of corpuscular-wave dualism and based on the fundamental both now mathemtically grounded main postulates are analysed.

arXiv:1407.2603International Journal of PhysicsSep 5, 20141 citation

On the Fundamental Meaning of the Principle of Least Action and Consequences for a “Dynamic” Quantum Physics

H. Tributsch

The principle of least action, which has so successfully been applied to diverse fields of physics looks back at three centuries of philosophical and mathematical discussions and controversies. They could not explain why nature is applying the principle and why scalar energy quantities succeed in describing dynamic motion. When the least action integral is subdivided into infinitesimal small sections each one has to maintain the ability to minimize. This however has the mathematical consequence that the Lagrange function at a given point of the trajectory, the dynamic, available energy generating motion, must itself have a fundamental property to minimize. Since a scalar quantity, a pure number, cannot do that, energy must fundamentally be dynamic and time oriented for a consistent understanding. It must have vectorial properties in aiming at a decrease of free energy per state (which would also allow derivation of the second law of thermodynamics). Present physics is ignoring that and applying variation calculus as a formal mathematical tool to impose a minimization of scalar assumed energy quantities for obtaining dynamic motion. When, however, the dynamic property of energy is taken seriously it is fundamental and has also to be applied to quantum processes. A consequence is that particle and wave are not equivalent, but the wave (distributed energy) follows from the first (concentrated energy). Information, provided from the beginning, an information self-image of matter, is additionally needed to recreate the particle from the wave, shaping a “dynamic” particle-wave duality. It is shown that this new concept of a “dynamic” quantum state rationally explains quantization, the double slit experiment and quantum correlation, which has not been possible before. Some more general considerations on the link between quantum processes, gravitation and cosmological phenomena are also advanced.

Journal of Modern PhysicsJan 1, 20169 citations