Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

PARTICLE AND WAVE DESCRIPTIONS ARE NOT EQUIVALENT

H. Ezawa

Published Apr 1, 1994• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is demonstrated with a simple model of non-interacting Bose system in one-dimensional space that, contrary to prevailing expectations, the transformation mediating the wave- and the particle-pictures does not exist in the Fock space in the continuum limit.
DOI
10.1142/9789814327060_0007

Related papers

Simple illustration of the equivalence of a wave and of a particle description for light

T. Ferbel

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1980•2 citations

Many-body excitations in trapped Bose gas: A non-Hermitian approach

Manoussos G. Grillakis, Dionisios Margetis, Stephen Sorokanich

We study a physically motivated model for a trapped dilute gas of Bosons with repulsive pairwise atomic interactions at zero temperature. Our goal is to describe aspects of the excited many-body quantum states of this system by accounting for the scattering of atoms in pairs from the macroscopic state. We start with an approximate many-body Hamiltonian, H a p p \mathcal {H}_{\mathrm {app}} , in the Bosonic Fock space. This H a p p \mathcal {H}_{\mathrm {app}} conserves the total number of atoms. Inspired by Wu [J. Math. Phys. 2 (1961), 105–123], we apply a non-unitary transformation to H a p p \mathcal {H}_{\mathrm {app}} . Key in this procedure is the pair-excitation kernel, which obeys a nonlinear integro-partial differential equation. In the stationary case, we develop an existence theory for solutions to this equation by a variational principle. We connect this theory to a system of partial differential equations for one-particle excitation (“quasiparticle”-) wave functions derived by Fetter [Ann. Phys. 70 (1972), 67–101], and prove existence of solutions for this system. These wave functions solve an eigenvalue problem for a J J -self-adjoint operator. From the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian, we derive a one-particle nonlocal equation for low-lying excitations, describe its solutions, and recover Fetter’s energy spectrum. We also analytically provide an explicit construction of the excited eigenstates of the reduced Hamiltonian in the N N -particle sector of Fock space.

arXiv:2106.02152•Quarterly of Applied Mathematics•Sep 26, 2022•2 citations

What makes a particle detector click

Erickson Tjoa, Irene López-Gutiérrez, Allison Sachs +1 more

We highlight fundamental differences in the models of light-matter interaction between the behavior of Fock state detection in free space versus optical cavities. To do so, we study the phenomenon of the resonance of detectors with Fock wave packets as a function of their degree of monochromaticity, the number of spatial dimensions, the linear or quadratic nature of the light-matter coupling, and the presence (or absence) of cavity walls in space. In doing so we show that intuition coming from quantum optics in cavities does not straightforwardly carry to the free-space case. For example, in ($3+1$) dimensions the detector response to a Fock wave packet will go to zero as the wave packet is made more and more monochromatic and in coincidence with the detector's resonant frequency. This is so even though the energy of the free-space wave packet goes to the expected finite value of $\ensuremath{\hbar}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}$ in the monochromatic limit. This is in contrast to the behavior of the light-matter interaction in a cavity (even a large one) where the probability of absorbing a Fock quantum is maximized when the quantum is more monochromatic at the detector's resonance frequency. We trace this crucial difference to the fact that monochromatic Fock states are not normalizable in the continuum; thus physical Fock states need to be constructed out of normalizable wave packets whose energy density goes to zero in the monochromatic limit as they get spatially delocalized.

arXiv:2102.05734•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jun 22, 2021•19 citations

Can waves be treated as particles? There is still disagreement in the interpretation of the quantum theory.

Max Born, W. Biem

•Jan 1, 1968•0 citations

Discrete spacetime, quantum walks, and relativistic wave equations

Leonard D. Mlodinow, Todd A. Brun

It has been observed that quantum walks on regular lattices can give rise to wave equations for relativistic particles in the continuum limit. In this paper, we define the three-dimensional discrete-time walk as a product of three coined one-dimensional walks. The factor corresponding to each one-dimensional walk involves two projection operators that act on an internal coin space; each projector is associated with either the ``forward'' or ``backward'' direction in that physical dimension. We show that the simple requirement that there is no preferred axis or direction along an axis---that is, that the walk be symmetric under parity transformations and steps along different axes of the cubic lattice be uncorrelated---leads, in the case of the simplest solution, to the requirement that the continuum limit of the walk is fully Lorentz-invariant. We show further that, in the case of a massive particle, this symmetry requirement necessitates the use of a four-dimensional internal space (as in the Dirac equation). The ``coin flip'' operation is generated by the parity transformation on the internal coin space, while the differences of the projection operators associated with each dimension must all anticommute. Finally, we discuss the leading correction to the continuum limit, and the possibility of distinguishing through experiment between the discrete random walk and the continuum-based Dirac equation as a description of fermion dynamics.

arXiv:1802.03910•Physical Review A•Apr 30, 2018•21 citations

Are therespontaneous objectifications of the wave-particle properties of a single photon?

Juergen Baldzuhn, W. Martienssen

The European Physical Journal B•Jun 1, 1991•6 citations
We study a physically motivated model for a trapped dilute gas of Bosons with repulsive pairwise atomic interactions at zero temperature. Our goal is to describe aspects of the excited many-body quantum states of this system by accounting for the scattering of atoms in pairs from the macroscopic state. We start with an approximate many-body Hamiltonian, H a p p \mathcal {H}_{\mathrm {app}} , in the Bosonic Fock space. This H a p p \mathcal {H}_{\mathrm {app}} conserves the total number of atoms. Inspired by Wu [J. Math. Phys. 2 (1961), 105–123], we apply a non-unitary transformation to H a p p \mathcal {H}_{\mathrm {app}} . Key in this procedure is the pair-excitation kernel, which obeys a nonlinear integro-partial differential equation. In the stationary case, we develop an existence theory for solutions to this equation by a variational principle. We connect this theory to a system of partial differential equations for one-particle excitation (“quasiparticle”-) wave functions derived by Fetter [Ann. Phys. 70 (1972), 67–101], and prove existence of solutions for this system. These wave functions solve an eigenvalue problem for a J J -self-adjoint operator. From the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian, we derive a one-particle nonlocal equation for low-lying excitations, describe its solutions, and recover Fetter’s energy spectrum. We also analytically provide an explicit construction of the excited eigenstates of the reduced Hamiltonian in the N N -particle sector of Fock space.
We highlight fundamental differences in the models of light-matter interaction between the behavior of Fock state detection in free space versus optical cavities. To do so, we study the phenomenon of the resonance of detectors with Fock wave packets as a function of their degree of monochromaticity, the number of spatial dimensions, the linear or quadratic nature of the light-matter coupling, and the presence (or absence) of cavity walls in space. In doing so we show that intuition coming from quantum optics in cavities does not straightforwardly carry to the free-space case. For example, in (3+13+13+1) dimensions the detector response to a Fock wave packet will go to zero as the wave packet is made more and more monochromatic and in coincidence with the detector's resonant frequency. This is so even though the energy of the free-space wave packet goes to the expected finite value of $\ensuremath{\hbar}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}$ in the monochromatic limit. This is in contrast to the behavior of the light-matter interaction in a cavity (even a large one) where the probability of absorbing a Fock quantum is maximized when the quantum is more monochromatic at the detector's resonance frequency. We trace this crucial difference to the fact that monochromatic Fock states are not normalizable in the continuum; thus physical Fock states need to be constructed out of normalizable wave packets whose energy density goes to zero in the monochromatic limit as they get spatially delocalized.
It has been observed that quantum walks on regular lattices can give rise to wave equations for relativistic particles in the continuum limit. In this paper, we define the three-dimensional discrete-time walk as a product of three coined one-dimensional walks. The factor corresponding to each one-dimensional walk involves two projection operators that act on an internal coin space; each projector is associated with either the ``forward'' or ``backward'' direction in that physical dimension. We show that the simple requirement that there is no preferred axis or direction along an axis---that is, that the walk be symmetric under parity transformations and steps along different axes of the cubic lattice be uncorrelated---leads, in the case of the simplest solution, to the requirement that the continuum limit of the walk is fully Lorentz-invariant. We show further that, in the case of a massive particle, this symmetry requirement necessitates the use of a four-dimensional internal space (as in the Dirac equation). The ``coin flip'' operation is generated by the parity transformation on the internal coin space, while the differences of the projection operators associated with each dimension must all anticommute. Finally, we discuss the leading correction to the continuum limit, and the possibility of distinguishing through experiment between the discrete random walk and the continuum-based Dirac equation as a description of fermion dynamics.