Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Xinxiang University

Analysis of the Problems of Box Normalization

Yue Xiao-ping

Published Jan 1, 2011• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This paper discussed the physical significance of that the momentum of free particles equals zero or otherwise,thereby,analyzed the reason why the momentum of free particles should not be settled as zero in the problem of Box normalization with the standpoint that when the momentum of free particles are settled as zero,it should also be marked that to which(or what sort of) center of force the momentum opposites,or,the whole activity would be against the basic Physics law.

Related papers

Angular Momentum and the Two-Dimensional Free Particle

Dario Bressanini, Alessandro Ponti

The model system consisting of a free particle is revisited in order to fully exploit it as a teaching resource. Because of this pedagogical aim, we chose the two-dimensional free particle system as the best choice between the opposite requests of algebraic simplicity and physical interest. Indeed, this is the simplest system possessing angular momentum which is thus introduced without undue reference to rotational motion. After briefly reviewing the classical mechanics, the quantum mechanics of a free particle is described in some detail. It is shown how two different sets of eigenfunctions naturally arise from requiring the particle to have a well-defined linear momentum or a well-defined angular momentum. The reasons for the different constant of motions and quantization schemes appearing in the two sets are discussed. The complex eigenfunctions are plotted and the significance of such plots is critically assessed. Finally, it is shown how the two alternative descriptions of the free particle are related to each other.

Journal of Chemical Education•Jul 1, 1998•3 citations

Constrained Particles

Jonathan Allday

One of the classic first problems in quantum theory textbooks is that of the particle trapped in a box. Despite the apparent artificiality of the situation, it has quite a few interesting features that we can quickly apply to some more physically plausible situations. The particle in a box is literally an object, such as an electron, trapped inside a ‘box.’ In a realistic physical example, this ‘box’ would be a volume of space bound by some constraining force acting on the particle. For example, an atom is a ‘box’ as far as the orbiting electrons are concerned, with the electrostatic force between the positive protons in the nucleus and the negative electrons providing the constraint. The first move is to assume that the wave function for any particle in the box will have separate spatial and temporal dependencies. One of the key steps in obtaining our wave function was the quantization of the momentum.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 21, 2022•0 citations

Quantum Free exp(-iEt+ipx) and Why Momentum Alone is Not Sufficient

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In physics (including classical physics), conservation of momentum is always considered, but one must be more careful with conservation of energy as it may include forms like sound etc. As a result, there is a tendency to focus on conservation of momentum all of the time, and conservation of particle energy only in elastic collisions. In addition to this, one may think of a particle striking a target, in which case two equal momentum (but different energies due to different v speed and mo rest mass) cause the same impact. In the case of an interaction with a potential, however, it is strictly energy considerations which are important classically, i.e one uses p dot p /2m + V(x) = E. Knowing momentum without rest mass is not sufficient. One may consider it unusual that one may consider two different scenarios, one which focuses only on momentum (impulse) or conservation of momentum in collisions while only energy is the focus in classical bound states or motion in V(x). Given the classical focus on momentum, imagine that one wishes to describe all free particles with different momenta as a uniform probability distribution such that a product of two probabilities for p1,p2 is the same as for p3,p4 if p1+p2=p3+p4. (We use 1-dimension for simplicity.). One cannot use P= 1/n because p is absent and n->infinite. In one sense, all particles must have the same probability, but at the same time must contain extra information related to p for the conservation of p part of the problem. The notion of a uniform distribution is independent of conservation of momentum, hence of p momentum. Conservation of momentum requires an explicit presence of p. As a result, there seems to be a paradox. One may, however, resolve this paradox by arguing that a probability is a mathematical way of presenting a subset of the information present. If one argues for a uniform probability, then it does not need to contain p, and one would have 1 as an unnormalized probability for any free particle p. A different probability (representing a different subset of information) which respects all free particles as having the same weight, but includes p can also be constructed, namely exp(i C p). C is a constant introduced for unit issues. In this case, the modulus gives all free particle probabilities with p the same weight, but the presence of p allows one to have conservation of momentum. Given that momentum is the key variable that is conserved in classical physics, one should be satisfied with exp(i C p). One might argue that there is no need to consider energy E. We note, however, that if one has p, E1 and -p, E2 in a frame, then in a frame moving with -v, one has gp+gvE1= p1’ and p2’ = -gp + gvE2. Adding yields gv(E1+E2) and so energy automatically appears and cannot be discarded. Furthermore for p, E1 and -p, E2, exp(i C 0) is exp(i C gv(E1+E2)) as seen in the moving frame and so one is forced to consider conservation of energy together with momentum and include both p and E in the more detailed probability. In other words, special relativity automatically links p and E in a 4-vector, leading to the idea that both are important. We argue that one cannot simply consider exp(i C p) due to special relativity. Both E and p must be considered together and this is a key idea, we argue, because if one wishes to have a Lorentz invariant probability, it must be in E and p, i.e. -Et+px. Instead of having a probability for an interaction with p given by exp(i C p) , one has exp(-iEt+ipx) and we argue that this must have the same value in all frames for a particular interaction. One may note that E and p are, on the one hand, separated allowing for impulse hit versus E related interactions, but that overall the probability for interaction includes both and it is the full -Et+ipx which must be invariant. This further suggests that if one does not artificially force an interaction to occur at the center-of-mass, then x,t and x+hbar/p, t+hbar/E are equally good points for the interaction. We argue that there is no need to force x=vt because exp(-iEt+ipx) * exp(iEt+ipx) already shows that one has uniformity, not only for any p,E, but also for any x, t, as there are now four variables. Thus, there is no reason to enforce x=vt in exp(-iEt+ipx), when considering an interaction, we argue. This means that one has two possible interactions at different x,t values, i.e. x,t and x+hbar/p, t+hbar/E. If one is unable to follow the interaction in time, but may follow it in space as in the case of 2-slits about hbar/p apart or for a potential V(x), then one may use the exp(ipx) part of the interaction probability piece by itself. Thus, we argue that special relativity does not allow one to treat p independently of E. For example, for p values that are the same in one frame, but have E1, E2, will be different in another frame. One must consider E and p together and so instead of creating a probability for p alone, one must create one for E,p and then impose Lorentz invariance which leads to different x,t pairs yielding the same probability value for an interaction, i.e. free particle quantum mechanics.

•Feb 28, 2026•0 citations

Laws of Nature Forbid the Existence of p = 0 Condensate in a System of Interacting Bosons

Yatendra Singh Jain

Analyzing the basic dynamics of two bosons, interacting through a central force, we make three unequivocal conclusions: (i). Natural laws, demanding the ground state of a system to have least possible energy, forbid the existence of p = 0 condensate in a system of interacting bosons (SIB). (ii). The ground state of a SIB, with different number of particles having different momenta does not have least possible energy as it should be. (iii). All particles in the true ground state have identically equal energy, εo = h2/8md2, and equivalent momentum, qo = π/d. The real nature of Bose Einstein condensation (BEC) that exists in the superfluid state of a SIB is identified as the condensation of particles in a state of a pair of particles having equal and opposite momenta (q, -q) with center of mass momentum, K = 0 and q = π/d. We also discuss how experimental results pertaining to the existence of electron bubble and free rotation of molecules in helium droplets and clusters support the absence of p=0 condensate and how single particle basis (SPB), having an alliance with p=0 condensate, is inconsistent with certain physical realities of the system at low temperatures. These conclusions render strong support for our theory of superfluidity of a system like liquid 4He (Amer. J. Cond. Mat. Phys. 2, 32-52(2012).

International Journal of Theoretical and Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2012•2 citations

Free Particles/Antiparticles

P. Strange

As in non-relativistic quantum theory, the simplest problem to solve in relativistic quantum theory is that of describing a free particle. Much can be learned from this case which will be of use in interpreting the topics covered in later chapters. Furthermore, some of the most profound features of relativistic quantum theory are well illustrated by the free particle, so it is a very instructive problem to consider in detail. Another advantage of the free-particle problem is that the mathematics involved in solving it is not nearly as involved as that necessary for solving problems involving particles under the influence of potentials.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 17, 1998•0 citations

Self-interacting charged particle

shoichiro otsuka

In this paper, I present the solution of a wave function of a spin-0 charged particle. This solution demonstrates a settlement of the movement of the particle to the one determined by physical characteristic. In my opinion, the meaning of self interaction and the equation of motion should be reconsidered.

•Sep 6, 2026•0 citations
This paper discussed the physical significance of that the momentum of free particles equals zero or otherwise,thereby,analyzed the reason why the momentum of free particles should not be settled as zero in the problem of Box normalization with the standpoint that when the momentum of free particles are settled as zero,it should also be marked that to which(or what sort of) center of force the momentum opposites,or,the whole activity would be against the basic Physics law.
The model system consisting of a free particle is revisited in order to fully exploit it as a teaching resource. Because of this pedagogical aim, we chose the two-dimensional free particle system as the best choice between the opposite requests of algebraic simplicity and physical interest. Indeed, this is the simplest system possessing angular momentum which is thus introduced without undue reference to rotational motion. After briefly reviewing the classical mechanics, the quantum mechanics of a free particle is described in some detail. It is shown how two different sets of eigenfunctions naturally arise from requiring the particle to have a well-defined linear momentum or a well-defined angular momentum. The reasons for the different constant of motions and quantization schemes appearing in the two sets are discussed. The complex eigenfunctions are plotted and the significance of such plots is critically assessed. Finally, it is shown how the two alternative descriptions of the free particle are related to each other.
One of the classic first problems in quantum theory textbooks is that of the particle trapped in a box. Despite the apparent artificiality of the situation, it has quite a few interesting features that we can quickly apply to some more physically plausible situations. The particle in a box is literally an object, such as an electron, trapped inside a ‘box.’ In a realistic physical example, this ‘box’ would be a volume of space bound by some constraining force acting on the particle. For example, an atom is a ‘box’ as far as the orbiting electrons are concerned, with the electrostatic force between the positive protons in the nucleus and the negative electrons providing the constraint. The first move is to assume that the wave function for any particle in the box will have separate spatial and temporal dependencies. One of the key steps in obtaining our wave function was the quantization of the momentum.
In physics (including classical physics), conservation of momentum is always considered, but one must be more careful with conservation of energy as it may include forms like sound etc. As a result, there is a tendency to focus on conservation of momentum all of the time, and conservation of particle energy only in elastic collisions. In addition to this, one may think of a particle striking a target, in which case two equal momentum (but different energies due to different v speed and mo rest mass) cause the same impact. In the case of an interaction with a potential, however, it is strictly energy considerations which are important classically, i.e one uses p dot p /2m + V(x) = E. Knowing momentum without rest mass is not sufficient. One may consider it unusual that one may consider two different scenarios, one which focuses only on momentum (impulse) or conservation of momentum in collisions while only energy is the focus in classical bound states or motion in V(x). Given the classical focus on momentum, imagine that one wishes to describe all free particles with different momenta as a uniform probability distribution such that a product of two probabilities for p1,p2 is the same as for p3,p4 if p1+p2=p3+p4. (We use 1-dimension for simplicity.). One cannot use P= 1/n because p is absent and n->infinite. In one sense, all particles must have the same probability, but at the same time must contain extra information related to p for the conservation of p part of the problem. The notion of a uniform distribution is independent of conservation of momentum, hence of p momentum. Conservation of momentum requires an explicit presence of p. As a result, there seems to be a paradox. One may, however, resolve this paradox by arguing that a probability is a mathematical way of presenting a subset of the information present. If one argues for a uniform probability, then it does not need to contain p, and one would have 1 as an unnormalized probability for any free particle p. A different probability (representing a different subset of information) which respects all free particles as having the same weight, but includes p can also be constructed, namely exp(i C p). C is a constant introduced for unit issues. In this case, the modulus gives all free particle probabilities with p the same weight, but the presence of p allows one to have conservation of momentum. Given that momentum is the key variable that is conserved in classical physics, one should be satisfied with exp(i C p). One might argue that there is no need to consider energy E. We note, however, that if one has p, E1 and -p, E2 in a frame, then in a frame moving with -v, one has gp+gvE1= p1’ and p2’ = -gp + gvE2. Adding yields gv(E1+E2) and so energy automatically appears and cannot be discarded. Furthermore for p, E1 and -p, E2, exp(i C 0) is exp(i C gv(E1+E2)) as seen in the moving frame and so one is forced to consider conservation of energy together with momentum and include both p and E in the more detailed probability. In other words, special relativity automatically links p and E in a 4-vector, leading to the idea that both are important. We argue that one cannot simply consider exp(i C p) due to special relativity. Both E and p must be considered together and this is a key idea, we argue, because if one wishes to have a Lorentz invariant probability, it must be in E and p, i.e. -Et+px. Instead of having a probability for an interaction with p given by exp(i C p) , one has exp(-iEt+ipx) and we argue that this must have the same value in all frames for a particular interaction. One may note that E and p are, on the one hand, separated allowing for impulse hit versus E related interactions, but that overall the probability for interaction includes both and it is the full -Et+ipx which must be invariant. This further suggests that if one does not artificially force an interaction to occur at the center-of-mass, then x,t and x+hbar/p, t+hbar/E are equally good points for the interaction. We argue that there is no need to force x=vt because exp(-iEt+ipx) * exp(iEt+ipx) already shows that one has uniformity, not only for any p,E, but also for any x, t, as there are now four variables. Thus, there is no reason to enforce x=vt in exp(-iEt+ipx), when considering an interaction, we argue. This means that one has two possible interactions at different x,t values, i.e. x,t and x+hbar/p, t+hbar/E. If one is unable to follow the interaction in time, but may follow it in space as in the case of 2-slits about hbar/p apart or for a potential V(x), then one may use the exp(ipx) part of the interaction probability piece by itself. Thus, we argue that special relativity does not allow one to treat p independently of E. For example, for p values that are the same in one frame, but have E1, E2, will be different in another frame. One must consider E and p together and so instead of creating a probability for p alone, one must create one for E,p and then impose Lorentz invariance which leads to different x,t pairs yielding the same probability value for an interaction, i.e. free particle quantum mechanics.
Analyzing the basic dynamics of two bosons, interacting through a central force, we make three unequivocal conclusions: (i). Natural laws, demanding the ground state of a system to have least possible energy, forbid the existence of p = 0 condensate in a system of interacting bosons (SIB). (ii). The ground state of a SIB, with different number of particles having different momenta does not have least possible energy as it should be. (iii). All particles in the true ground state have identically equal energy, εo = h2/8md2, and equivalent momentum, qo = π/d. The real nature of Bose Einstein condensation (BEC) that exists in the superfluid state of a SIB is identified as the condensation of particles in a state of a pair of particles having equal and opposite momenta (q, -q) with center of mass momentum, K = 0 and q = π/d. We also discuss how experimental results pertaining to the existence of electron bubble and free rotation of molecules in helium droplets and clusters support the absence of p=0 condensate and how single particle basis (SPB), having an alliance with p=0 condensate, is inconsistent with certain physical realities of the system at low temperatures. These conclusions render strong support for our theory of superfluidity of a system like liquid 4He (Amer. J. Cond. Mat. Phys. 2, 32-52(2012).
As in non-relativistic quantum theory, the simplest problem to solve in relativistic quantum theory is that of describing a free particle. Much can be learned from this case which will be of use in interpreting the topics covered in later chapters. Furthermore, some of the most profound features of relativistic quantum theory are well illustrated by the free particle, so it is a very instructive problem to consider in detail. Another advantage of the free-particle problem is that the mathematics involved in solving it is not nearly as involved as that necessary for solving problems involving particles under the influence of potentials.