Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

College Physics

On the concept of wave function phase factor——A critique to the book "Quantum mechanics"vol.II chapter 4 by Zeng

Huazhong Li

Published Jan 1, 2006• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

A number of misconceptions in a current text of quantum mechanics by J.Y.Zeng in Chinese are pointed out and analyzed in addition to previously criticized points.

Related papers

Questions of correctness and fidelity——On some concepts in some textbooks on quantum mechanics

Huazhong Li

In present paper,the fraud and misconceptions about the concept of quantum geometric phase in a recent paper by Zeng.are described and proved by a series of references.It is meant that for a textbook written for undergraduates the correctness in physical concepts and interpretations are of primary importance.

College Physics•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

Remarks on “Lewis-Riesenfeld phase” and quantum geometric phase

Huazhong Li, 中山大学高等学术研究中心及物理系,广州 510275

Some misconceptions in an article on the so called “Lewis phase” and quantum geometric phase in Chinese are critically reviewed. We point out the wrong statements given in the paper published in College Physics 21 23,written in Chinese.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 2004•1 citation

The Meaning of the Wave Function

Shan Gao

At the heart of quantum mechanics lies the wave function, a powerful but mysterious mathematical object which has been a hot topic of debate from its earliest stages. Covering much of the recent debate and providing a comprehensive and critical review of competing approaches, this ambitious text provides new, decisive proof of the reality of the wave function. Aiming to make sense of the wave function in quantum mechanics and to find the ontological content of the theory, this book explores new ontological interpretations of the wave function in terms of random discontinuous motion of particles. Finally, the book investigates whether the suggested quantum ontology is complete in solving the measurement problem and if it should be revised in the relativistic domain. A timely addition to the literature on the foundations of quantum mechanics, this book is of value to students and researchers with an interest in the philosophy of physics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 1, 2017•55 citations

Comments on Zeng Jinyan's textbooks of quantum mechanics

Guan Hong

Some basic concepts stated in Zeng Jinyan's textbooks of quantum mechanics are commented.The questions involved are: concept of free particle,meaning of superposition principle,reason of assuming Hermitian operator,interference of photons,identity principle and symmetrical postulate

College Physics•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

A Topological Geometrodynamics of Wave Functions: On the Stationary State Wave Functions, Their Partial Time Derivative and Resultant Theoretical Implications Book VIII: The Topological Geometrodynamics - Use Cases III

Emil Parashkevov

Abstract / Description: This volume explores the application of Topological Geometrodynamics ($\mathcal{M}^5$) to several foundational concepts in quantum mechanics and particle physics. Book VIII: Use Cases III models wave functions as continuous spatial boundaries navigating a multi-sheeted Riemann mapping space. By treating fundamental particles as fractionally orientable Möbius knots within this manifold, the text offers geometric interpretations for phenomena typically described via probabilistic or algebraic methods. Key physical models explored in this volume include: The $22.0~\mu g$ Mass Limit: Calculates a specific mass boundary where the spatial requirements of quantum continuity intersect with geometric saturation constraints, proposing this collision as a geometric mechanism for macroscopic phase-lock and wave function collapse. Interpretations of the Dirac Equation: Offers a topological perspective on Zitterbewegung and negative energy states, modeling them as mathematical consequences of mapping a physically restricted 5D geometry onto a complete $6\pi$ complex topological space. The Geometry of Spin: Investigates the fractional spin quantum number ($s=1/2$) as a geometric consequence of a wave function navigating a phase-canceling Möbius helicoid topology. Quantum Tunneling: Models tunneling as the mathematical generation of a conjugate knot that algebraically resolves the structural impedance of a macroscopic barrier, framing the phenomenon in deterministic terms. New Additions in Version 212.0: This manuscript incorporates two new chapters detailing the $\mathcal{M}^5$ parametric engine and its application to hadronic stability and decay: The Deterministic Spectrum of Stable Prime-Resonant Geometries (Chapter 18): Explores the hypothesis that stable matter configurations are quantized by the topology of a 3D bipartite grid. The chapter outlines a Universal Parametric Sieve to map allowed geometric states—from a 137-knot base model of the electron up to higher-mass isomers—suggesting that the gaps between particle generations correspond to mathematical configurations that fail to resolve into prime-number boundaries. The Geometric Mechanism of Beta Decay (Chapter 17): Proposes a topological model for the instability of the neutron. The text models the neutron's asymmetric ($u, d, d$) configuration as a structure that generates a "Topological Parity Violation". Beta decay is described as a geometric relaxation process, wherein the internal lattice sheds excess knot-volume to resolve into the stable prime-number configuration of the proton.

•Jun 17, 2026•0 citations

A Criticism to the Quantum Mechanics

José Francisco García Juliá

There are two supposed equivalent versions of the quantum mechanics: the matrix mechanics and the wave mechanics. We think that only the first is true.

•Aug 1, 2013•0 citations
At the heart of quantum mechanics lies the wave function, a powerful but mysterious mathematical object which has been a hot topic of debate from its earliest stages. Covering much of the recent debate and providing a comprehensive and critical review of competing approaches, this ambitious text provides new, decisive proof of the reality of the wave function. Aiming to make sense of the wave function in quantum mechanics and to find the ontological content of the theory, this book explores new ontological interpretations of the wave function in terms of random discontinuous motion of particles. Finally, the book investigates whether the suggested quantum ontology is complete in solving the measurement problem and if it should be revised in the relativistic domain. A timely addition to the literature on the foundations of quantum mechanics, this book is of value to students and researchers with an interest in the philosophy of physics.
Abstract / Description: This volume explores the application of Topological Geometrodynamics (M5\mathcal{M}^5M5) to several foundational concepts in quantum mechanics and particle physics. Book VIII: Use Cases III models wave functions as continuous spatial boundaries navigating a multi-sheeted Riemann mapping space. By treating fundamental particles as fractionally orientable Möbius knots within this manifold, the text offers geometric interpretations for phenomena typically described via probabilistic or algebraic methods. Key physical models explored in this volume include: The 22.0 μg22.0~\mu g22.0 μg Mass Limit: Calculates a specific mass boundary where the spatial requirements of quantum continuity intersect with geometric saturation constraints, proposing this collision as a geometric mechanism for macroscopic phase-lock and wave function collapse. Interpretations of the Dirac Equation: Offers a topological perspective on Zitterbewegung and negative energy states, modeling them as mathematical consequences of mapping a physically restricted 5D geometry onto a complete 6π6\pi6π complex topological space. The Geometry of Spin: Investigates the fractional spin quantum number (s=1/2s=1/2s=1/2) as a geometric consequence of a wave function navigating a phase-canceling Möbius helicoid topology. Quantum Tunneling: Models tunneling as the mathematical generation of a conjugate knot that algebraically resolves the structural impedance of a macroscopic barrier, framing the phenomenon in deterministic terms. New Additions in Version 212.0: This manuscript incorporates two new chapters detailing the M5\mathcal{M}^5M5 parametric engine and its application to hadronic stability and decay: The Deterministic Spectrum of Stable Prime-Resonant Geometries (Chapter 18): Explores the hypothesis that stable matter configurations are quantized by the topology of a 3D bipartite grid. The chapter outlines a Universal Parametric Sieve to map allowed geometric states—from a 137-knot base model of the electron up to higher-mass isomers—suggesting that the gaps between particle generations correspond to mathematical configurations that fail to resolve into prime-number boundaries. The Geometric Mechanism of Beta Decay (Chapter 17): Proposes a topological model for the instability of the neutron. The text models the neutron's asymmetric (u,d,du, d, du,d,d) configuration as a structure that generates a "Topological Parity Violation". Beta decay is described as a geometric relaxation process, wherein the internal lattice sheds excess knot-volume to resolve into the stable prime-number configuration of the proton.