Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A Numerical Quantum and Classical Adversary

MICHAEL J. MULLAN

Published Jan 1, 2016• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The Quantum Adversary Method has proven to be a successful technique for deriving lower bounds on a wide variety of problems. However, it assumes perfect quantum computation, which in most modern devices, is unrealistic. Here, we develop a generalization of this technique without this assumption, which can be applied to arbitrary small problems automatically. To do this, we start by reformulating the objective value of the semidefinite program of the spectral adversary method. By relating the final measurement stage of a quantum computation to remote state preparation, we prove that the optimal value of the new objective corresponds to the probability that the quantum computer will output the correct value after a specified number of queries. Once in this framework, the addition of decoherence is natural. In particular, the optimum probability of success can be determined for any probability of phase error. In the limit of complete phase decoherence, we recover the optimal p! robability of success for a classical computation. Our semidefinite programming formulation is suitably general, and so has application outside that of algorithms. In particular, we apply it to the optimization of quantum clocks.

DOI
10.14288/1.0103170

Related papers

Improving Quantum Clocks via Semidefinite Programming

MICHAEL J. MULLAN, Emanuel H. Knill

The accuracies of modern quantum logic clocks have surpassed those of standard atomic fountain clocks. These clocks also provide a greater degree of control, because before and after clock queries, we are able to apply chosen unitary operations and measurements. Here, we take advantage of these choices and present a numerical technique designed to increase the accuracy of these clocks. We use a greedy approach, minimizing the phase variance of a noisy classical oscillator with respect to a perfect frequency standard after an interrogation step; we do not optimize over successive interrogations or the probe times. We consider arbitrary prior frequency knowledge and compare clocks with varying numbers of ions and queries interlaced with unitary control. Our technique is based on the semidefinite programming formulation of quantum query complexity, a method first developed in the context of deriving algorithmic lower bounds. The application of semidefinite programming to an inherently continuous problem like that considered here requires discretization; we derive bounds on the error introduced and show that it can be made suitably small.

arXiv:1107.5347•Jul 26, 2011•0 citations

Semidefinite programming characterization and spectral adversary method for quantum complexity with noncommuting unitary queries

Howard Barnum

Generalizing earlier work characterizing the quantum query complexity of computing a function of an unknown classical ``black box'' function drawn from some set of such black box functions, we investigate a more general quantum query model in which the goal is to compute functions of $N imes N$ ``black box'' unitary matrices drawn from a set of such matrices, a problem with applications to determining properties of quantum physical systems. We characterize the existence of an algorithm for such a query problem, with given query and error, as equivalent to the feasibility of a certain set of semidefinite programming constraints, or equivalently the infeasibility of a dual of these constraints, which we construct. Relaxing the primal constraints to correspond to mere pairwise near-orthogonality of the final states of a quantum computer, conditional on the various black-box inputs, rather than bounded-error distinguishability, we obtain a relaxed primal program the feasibility of whose dual still implies the nonexistence of a quantum algorithm. We use this to obtain a generalization, to our not-necessarily-commutative setting, of the ``spectral adversary method'' for quantum query lower bounds.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703141•Jan 1, 2007•1 citation

Improving quantum clocks via semidefinite programming

MICHAEL J. MULLAN, Emanuel H. Knill

The accuracies of modern quantum logic clocks have surpassed those of standard atomic fountain clocks. These clocks also provide a greater degree of control, because before and after clock queries, we are able to apply chosen unitary operations and measurements. Here, we take advantage of these choices and present a numerical technique designed to increase the accuracy of these clocks. We use a greedy approach, minimizing the phase variance of a noisy classical oscillator with respect to a perfect frequency standard after an interrogation step; we do not optimize over successive interrogations or the probe times. We consider arbitrary prior frequency knowledge and compare clocks with varying numbers of ions and queries interlaced with unitary control. Our technique is based on the semidefinite programming formulation of quantum query complexity, a method first developed in the context of deriving algorithmic lower bounds. The application of semidefinite programming to an inherently continuous problem like that considered here requires discretization; we derive bounds on the error introduced and show that it can be made suitably small.

Quantum Information and Computation•Jul 1, 2012•8 citations

A new quantum lower bound method,

Andris Ambainis, Robert Špalek, Ronald de Wolf

We give a new version of the adversary method for proving lower bounds on quantum query algorithms. The new method is based on analyzing the eigenspace structure of the problem at hand. We use it to prove a new and optimal strong direct product theorem for 2-sided error quantum algorithms computing k independent instances of a symmetric Boolean function: if the algorithm uses significantly less than k times the number of queries needed for one instance of the function, then its success probability is exponentially small in k. We also use the polynomial method to prove a direct product theorem for 1-sided error algorithms for k threshold functions with a stronger bound on the success probability. Finally, we present a quantum algorithm for evaluating solutions to systems of linear inequalities, and use our direct product theorems to show that the time-space tradeoff of this algorithm is close to optimal.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•May 21, 2006•8 citations

Negative weights make adversaries stronger

Peter Høyer, Troy Lee, Robert Špalek

The quantum adversary method is one of the most successful techniques for proving lower bounds on quantum query complexity. It gives optimal lower bounds for many problems, has application to classical complexity in formula size lower bounds, and is versatile with equivalent formulations interms of weight schemes, eigen values, and Kolmogorov complexity. All these formulations rely on the principlethat if an algorithm successfully computes a function then, in particular, itis able to distinguish between inputs which map to different values.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611054•ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jun 11, 2007•215 citations

Techniques For Computing and Approximating Large Optimization Problems in Quantum Information

Mohan, Ankith

Many fundamental problems in quantum information theory can be formulated as optimization tasks over quantum states and measurements. While the convex structure of quantum theory often enables powerful semidefinite programming formulations, a major challenge persists: the exponential growth of Hilbert space dimension with system size. This dissertation discusses techniques to address these and related obstacles across several core problems in quantum information. We first study optimization over separable quantum states. Such problems are typically NP-hard and standard semidefinite programming hierarchies suffer from the curse of dimensionality. We introduce a hybrid algorithm that leverages a quantum co-processor to reduce the effective dimension of the problem. While several existing approaches provide only a numerical bound on the optimal value, our method is guaranteed to return an explicit feasible solution: a valid separable state, even in instances where it is not optimal. We apply this framework to approximate the minimum separable energy of many-body Hamiltonians, define an entanglement measure for their ground spaces, and demonstrate numerical scalability to systems of up to 28 qubits. We next consider the general Bayes framework, as introduced by Helstrom, for state discrimination when, instead of a classical description of the candidate states, one has access to their source code: the quantum circuit that prepares them. We show that the typical semidefinite program for the discrimination problem can be reformulated in terms of the Gram matrix of these states, reducing the variable dimensions from dL to NL, where d is the Hilbert space dimension, N is the number of candidate states, and L is the number of possible guesses. Importantly, we further introduce a quantum pre-processing procedure which efficiently constructs the reduced problem from the source code, enabling our method to operate directly on quantum data. We consider two applications. First, we characterize the optimal identifications for quantum changepoint problems under several reward structures whose associated discrimination problems were previously computationally inaccessible. Second, we consider a quantum error classification problem and show how our reduction makes it tractable for systems of hundreds of qubits. We also analyze structural measurement strategies. As a counterpart to the well-known pretty good measurement for minimum-error state discrimination, we introduce the pretty bad measurement for the exclusion variant, in which the goal is to identify a state that was not sent, rather than to identify the one that was, and prove that both are guaranteed to perform at least as well as blind guessing in their respective objectives. Finally, we consider evaluating Boolean functions under severe memory constraints and prove that a simple local "greedy" measurement strategy is globally optimal precisely for affine Boolean functions, while more generally achieving at least the square of the optimal global success probability. Together, these results demonstrate that high-dimensional quantum optimization problems often admit hidden structure enabling dimension reduction, hybrid computation, and provable approximation guarantees.

•Aug 18, 2026•0 citations
The Quantum Adversary Method has proven to be a successful technique for deriving lower bounds on a wide variety of problems. However, it assumes perfect quantum computation, which in most modern devices, is unrealistic. Here, we develop a generalization of this technique without this assumption, which can be applied to arbitrary small problems automatically. To do this, we start by reformulating the objective value of the semidefinite program of the spectral adversary method. By relating the final measurement stage of a quantum computation to remote state preparation, we prove that the optimal value of the new objective corresponds to the probability that the quantum computer will output the correct value after a specified number of queries. Once in this framework, the addition of decoherence is natural. In particular, the optimum probability of success can be determined for any probability of phase error. In the limit of complete phase decoherence, we recover the optimal p! robability of success for a classical computation. Our semidefinite programming formulation is suitably general, and so has application outside that of algorithms. In particular, we apply it to the optimization of quantum clocks.
The accuracies of modern quantum logic clocks have surpassed those of standard atomic fountain clocks. These clocks also provide a greater degree of control, because before and after clock queries, we are able to apply chosen unitary operations and measurements. Here, we take advantage of these choices and present a numerical technique designed to increase the accuracy of these clocks. We use a greedy approach, minimizing the phase variance of a noisy classical oscillator with respect to a perfect frequency standard after an interrogation step; we do not optimize over successive interrogations or the probe times. We consider arbitrary prior frequency knowledge and compare clocks with varying numbers of ions and queries interlaced with unitary control. Our technique is based on the semidefinite programming formulation of quantum query complexity, a method first developed in the context of deriving algorithmic lower bounds. The application of semidefinite programming to an inherently continuous problem like that considered here requires discretization; we derive bounds on the error introduced and show that it can be made suitably small.
Generalizing earlier work characterizing the quantum query complexity of computing a function of an unknown classical ``black box'' function drawn from some set of such black box functions, we investigate a more general quantum query model in which the goal is to compute functions of NimesNN imes NNimesN ``black box'' unitary matrices drawn from a set of such matrices, a problem with applications to determining properties of quantum physical systems. We characterize the existence of an algorithm for such a query problem, with given query and error, as equivalent to the feasibility of a certain set of semidefinite programming constraints, or equivalently the infeasibility of a dual of these constraints, which we construct. Relaxing the primal constraints to correspond to mere pairwise near-orthogonality of the final states of a quantum computer, conditional on the various black-box inputs, rather than bounded-error distinguishability, we obtain a relaxed primal program the feasibility of whose dual still implies the nonexistence of a quantum algorithm. We use this to obtain a generalization, to our not-necessarily-commutative setting, of the ``spectral adversary method'' for quantum query lower bounds.
The accuracies of modern quantum logic clocks have surpassed those of standard atomic fountain clocks. These clocks also provide a greater degree of control, because before and after clock queries, we are able to apply chosen unitary operations and measurements. Here, we take advantage of these choices and present a numerical technique designed to increase the accuracy of these clocks. We use a greedy approach, minimizing the phase variance of a noisy classical oscillator with respect to a perfect frequency standard after an interrogation step; we do not optimize over successive interrogations or the probe times. We consider arbitrary prior frequency knowledge and compare clocks with varying numbers of ions and queries interlaced with unitary control. Our technique is based on the semidefinite programming formulation of quantum query complexity, a method first developed in the context of deriving algorithmic lower bounds. The application of semidefinite programming to an inherently continuous problem like that considered here requires discretization; we derive bounds on the error introduced and show that it can be made suitably small.
We give a new version of the adversary method for proving lower bounds on quantum query algorithms. The new method is based on analyzing the eigenspace structure of the problem at hand. We use it to prove a new and optimal strong direct product theorem for 2-sided error quantum algorithms computing k independent instances of a symmetric Boolean function: if the algorithm uses significantly less than k times the number of queries needed for one instance of the function, then its success probability is exponentially small in k. We also use the polynomial method to prove a direct product theorem for 1-sided error algorithms for k threshold functions with a stronger bound on the success probability. Finally, we present a quantum algorithm for evaluating solutions to systems of linear inequalities, and use our direct product theorems to show that the time-space tradeoff of this algorithm is close to optimal.
The quantum adversary method is one of the most successful techniques for proving lower bounds on quantum query complexity. It gives optimal lower bounds for many problems, has application to classical complexity in formula size lower bounds, and is versatile with equivalent formulations interms of weight schemes, eigen values, and Kolmogorov complexity. All these formulations rely on the principlethat if an algorithm successfully computes a function then, in particular, itis able to distinguish between inputs which map to different values.
Many fundamental problems in quantum information theory can be formulated as optimization tasks over quantum states and measurements. While the convex structure of quantum theory often enables powerful semidefinite programming formulations, a major challenge persists: the exponential growth of Hilbert space dimension with system size. This dissertation discusses techniques to address these and related obstacles across several core problems in quantum information. We first study optimization over separable quantum states. Such problems are typically NP-hard and standard semidefinite programming hierarchies suffer from the curse of dimensionality. We introduce a hybrid algorithm that leverages a quantum co-processor to reduce the effective dimension of the problem. While several existing approaches provide only a numerical bound on the optimal value, our method is guaranteed to return an explicit feasible solution: a valid separable state, even in instances where it is not optimal. We apply this framework to approximate the minimum separable energy of many-body Hamiltonians, define an entanglement measure for their ground spaces, and demonstrate numerical scalability to systems of up to 28 qubits. We next consider the general Bayes framework, as introduced by Helstrom, for state discrimination when, instead of a classical description of the candidate states, one has access to their source code: the quantum circuit that prepares them. We show that the typical semidefinite program for the discrimination problem can be reformulated in terms of the Gram matrix of these states, reducing the variable dimensions from dL to NL, where d is the Hilbert space dimension, N is the number of candidate states, and L is the number of possible guesses. Importantly, we further introduce a quantum pre-processing procedure which efficiently constructs the reduced problem from the source code, enabling our method to operate directly on quantum data. We consider two applications. First, we characterize the optimal identifications for quantum changepoint problems under several reward structures whose associated discrimination problems were previously computationally inaccessible. Second, we consider a quantum error classification problem and show how our reduction makes it tractable for systems of hundreds of qubits. We also analyze structural measurement strategies. As a counterpart to the well-known pretty good measurement for minimum-error state discrimination, we introduce the pretty bad measurement for the exclusion variant, in which the goal is to identify a state that was not sent, rather than to identify the one that was, and prove that both are guaranteed to perform at least as well as blind guessing in their respective objectives. Finally, we consider evaluating Boolean functions under severe memory constraints and prove that a simple local "greedy" measurement strategy is globally optimal precisely for affine Boolean functions, while more generally achieving at least the square of the optimal global success probability. Together, these results demonstrate that high-dimensional quantum optimization problems often admit hidden structure enabling dimension reduction, hybrid computation, and provable approximation guarantees.