Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on “Test of the Stark-effect theory using photoionization microscopy”

Panagiotis Giannakeas, F. Robicheaux, Chris H. Greene

Published Jun 3, 2015• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

An article by Zhao et al. [Phys. Rev. A 86, 053413 (2012)] tests the local frame transformation (LFT) theory by comparing it with benchmark coupled-channel calculations. The system under consideration is an alkali-metal atom that is two-photon ionized in the presence of a static external electric field. Zhao et al. state that the differential cross sections computed in the LFT theory disagree with their supposedly more accurate coupled-channel calculations. They went on to diagnose the discrepancy and claimed that it originates in an inaccurate correspondence between the irregular functions in spherical and parabolic-cylindrical coordinates, a correspondence that lies at the heart of LFT theory. We have repeated the same tests and find that our calculations rule out the discrepancies that were claimed in Zhao et al. [Phys. Rev. A 86, 053413 (2012)] to exist between the LFT approximation and the exact calculations. This Comment thus helps to clarify the accuracy of the Harmin-Fano theory and demonstrates that it is in fact remarkably accurate not only for the total photoionization cross section in the Stark effect, but also for the differential cross section in photoionization microscopy.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.91.067401

Related papers

Photoionization microscopy in terms of local-frame-transformation theory

Panagiotis Giannakeas, F. Robicheaux, Chris H. Greene

Two-photon ionization of an alkali-metal atom in the presence of a uniform electric field is investigated using a standardized form of the local-frame-transformation and generalized quantum defect theory. The relevant long-range quantum defect parameters in the combined Coulombic plus Stark potential are calculated with eigenchannel $R$-matrix theory applied in the downstream parabolic coordinate $\ensuremath{\eta}$. The present formulation permits us to express the corresponding microscopy observables through the local frame transformation, and it gives a critical test of the accuracy of the Harmin-Fano theory.

arXiv:1410.5360•Physical Review A•Apr 30, 2015•18 citations

Photoionization microscopy of the lithium atom: Wave-function imaging of quasibound and continuum Stark states

S. Cohen, M. M. Harb, A. Ollagnier +5 more

Photoionization of an atom in the presence of a uniform static electric field provides the unique opportunity to expand and visualize the atomic wave function at a macroscopic scale. In a number of seminal publications dating back to the 1980s, Fabrikant, Demkov, Kondratovich, and Ostrovsky showed that this goal could be achieved by projecting slow (meV) photoionized electrons onto a position-sensitive detector and underlined the distinction between continuum and resonant contributions. The uncovering of resonant signatures was achieved fairly recently in experiments on the nonhydrogenic lithium atoms [Cohen et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 183001 (2013)]. The purpose of the present article is the general description of these findings, with emphasis on the various manifestations of resonant character. From this point of view, lithium has been chosen as an illustrative example between the two limiting cases of hydrogen, where resonance effects are more easily identified, and heavy atoms like xenon, where resonant effects were not observed.

Physical Review A•Jul 19, 2016•21 citations

Photoionization of the hydrogen atom near the ionization limit in strong electric fields

H. Rottke, K. H. Welge

The Stark spectroscopy of the hydrogen atom has been investigated near the ionization threshold in static homogeneous external electric fields from \ensuremath{\sim}1000 to \ensuremath{\sim}8000 V/cm with use of a two-step excitation H(n=1)+\ensuremath{\Elzxh}${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{\mathrm{vuv}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}$H(n=2)+\ensuremath{\Elzxh}\ensuremath{\omega} $_{\mathrm{uv}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}$${\mathrm{H}}^{\mathrm{*}}$ with vuv and uv laser radiation, independently tunable and linearly polarized either parallel (\ensuremath{\pi}) or perpendicular (\ensuremath{\sigma}) with respect to the external field. Different from other, nonhydrogenic atoms, the hydrogen atom is a peculiar case insofar as the initial states of H(n=2), from which excitation takes place, are essentially of parabolic character at the field strengths employed in this study.Individual sublevels (${n}_{1}$,${n}_{2}$,\ensuremath{\Vert}${m}_{l}$\ensuremath{\Vert}) have been prepared in the n=2 state with sub-Doppler resolution. Photoionization spectra have been obtained with \ensuremath{\pi}- and \ensuremath{\sigma}-polarized uv radiation from the four possible sublevels of the n=2 Stark manifold: \ensuremath{\Vert}1,0,0〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉, \ensuremath{\Vert}0,1,0〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉, \ensuremath{\Vert}0,0,\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉, and \ensuremath{\Vert}0,0,\ensuremath{\mp}1〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉. All spectra show sharp line structures of quasistable field-ionizing states superimposed on continua in the energy region between the classical saddle point, ${E}_{\mathrm{SP}=\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}2\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\surd}}\mathrm{F}}$ a.u., and the zero-field ionization threshold E=0 a.u. Employing existing theoretical treatments, the quasistable spectral structures are quantitatively completely analyzed and accounted for, as long as their field ionization rate is less than \ensuremath{\sim}5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{11}$ ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}1}$. Field-ionization rates of quasistable states have been measured and are compared with theory. Oscillatory resonance structures of the ionization cross section near the zero-field threshold are observed with pronounced modulation degree only in the spectrum from the \ensuremath{\Vert}1,0,0〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉 sublevel excited with the uv \ensuremath{\pi}-polarized. The energy spacing of the oscillations has been measured as a function of the electric field strength F and found to be nearly proportional to ${F}^{3/4}$, with slight but definite deviations. Theoretical analysis of the oscillations yields quantitative agreement with the experiment.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1986•103 citations

Comment on “Laser-assisted formation of antihydrogen”

James S. Cohen

In a recent paper, Whitehead, McCann, and Shimamura [Phys. Rev. A 64, 023401 (2001)] presented classical-trajectory Monte Carlo (CTMC) calculations of the effects of laser fields on the cross section for antihydrogen formation in collisions of antiprotons with positronium. They also use the same method to calculate the photoionization rate of isolated positronium in a strong field. The purpose of this Comment is to point out (i) the criteria for validity of the quasiclassical approximation are not satisfied for all the conditions used; (ii) some of their numerical results do not agree with the values obtained with a corroborated code; (iii) the ambiguity of a cross section when the target can ionize even before the projectile arrives; and (iv) the essential effect of quantum-mechanical tunneling on the strong-field ionization rate. A recently published method allowing tunneling in a CTMC calculation [J. S. Cohen, Phys. Rev. A 64, 043412 (2001)] is used for (iv). It is concluded that the laser effect on formation of antihydrogen may be much greater than that found by Whitehead et al., but the pulse must be better characterized for quantitative predictions.

Physical Review A•Jan 31, 2003•6 citations

Electric-Field Level-Crossing Spectroscopy

Abbas Khadjavi, W. Happer, Allen Lurio

Differential Stark effect in second excited state of alkali metal atoms described, using electric field level crossing spectroscopy

Physical Review Letters•Aug 29, 1966•19 citations

Spectroscopy between parabolic states in hydrogen: Enhancement of the Stark-induced resonances in its photoionization

Wallace L. Glab, Kwan Ng, Decheng Yao +1 more

We present calculations of the photoionization spectrum of excited hydrogen using \ensuremath{\pi} polarization in the presence of a strong electric field as a function of the spherical (applicable to complex atoms) and parabolic quantum numbers of the excited state. We also present corresponding measurements of the photoionization yield from the individual parabolic states of n=2. Both the calculations and the measurements show an enhancement of the depth of the so-called ``Stark-induced modulation'' in the region E\ensuremath{\ge}0 when the initial excited state is a pure ${m}_{l}$=0 blue state, and disappear almost completely when the initial state is a pure ${m}_{l}$=0 red state. These results are understood using arguments based on the fact that the charge distribution of the Stark-induced states is tremendously extended up field. Because of the excellent signal to noise ratio of the enhanced modulations, we were able to measure the field dependence of the spacings with sufficient accuracy to confirm the (3/4) power law and rule out the recently suggested (2/3) power law.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1985•55 citations
An article by Zhao et al. [Phys. Rev. A 86, 053413 (2012)] tests the local frame transformation (LFT) theory by comparing it with benchmark coupled-channel calculations. The system under consideration is an alkali-metal atom that is two-photon ionized in the presence of a static external electric field. Zhao et al. state that the differential cross sections computed in the LFT theory disagree with their supposedly more accurate coupled-channel calculations. They went on to diagnose the discrepancy and claimed that it originates in an inaccurate correspondence between the irregular functions in spherical and parabolic-cylindrical coordinates, a correspondence that lies at the heart of LFT theory. We have repeated the same tests and find that our calculations rule out the discrepancies that were claimed in Zhao et al. [Phys. Rev. A 86, 053413 (2012)] to exist between the LFT approximation and the exact calculations. This Comment thus helps to clarify the accuracy of the Harmin-Fano theory and demonstrates that it is in fact remarkably accurate not only for the total photoionization cross section in the Stark effect, but also for the differential cross section in photoionization microscopy.
Two-photon ionization of an alkali-metal atom in the presence of a uniform electric field is investigated using a standardized form of the local-frame-transformation and generalized quantum defect theory. The relevant long-range quantum defect parameters in the combined Coulombic plus Stark potential are calculated with eigenchannel RRR-matrix theory applied in the downstream parabolic coordinate $\ensuremath{\eta}$. The present formulation permits us to express the corresponding microscopy observables through the local frame transformation, and it gives a critical test of the accuracy of the Harmin-Fano theory.
Photoionization of an atom in the presence of a uniform static electric field provides the unique opportunity to expand and visualize the atomic wave function at a macroscopic scale. In a number of seminal publications dating back to the 1980s, Fabrikant, Demkov, Kondratovich, and Ostrovsky showed that this goal could be achieved by projecting slow (meV) photoionized electrons onto a position-sensitive detector and underlined the distinction between continuum and resonant contributions. The uncovering of resonant signatures was achieved fairly recently in experiments on the nonhydrogenic lithium atoms [Cohen et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 183001 (2013)]. The purpose of the present article is the general description of these findings, with emphasis on the various manifestations of resonant character. From this point of view, lithium has been chosen as an illustrative example between the two limiting cases of hydrogen, where resonance effects are more easily identified, and heavy atoms like xenon, where resonant effects were not observed.
The Stark spectroscopy of the hydrogen atom has been investigated near the ionization threshold in static homogeneous external electric fields from \ensuremath{\sim}1000 to \ensuremath{\sim}8000 V/cm with use of a two-step excitation H(n=1)+\ensuremath{\Elzxh}${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{\mathrm{vuv}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}$H(n=2)+\ensuremath{\Elzxh}\ensuremath{\omega} $_{\mathrm{uv}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}$H∗{\mathrm{H}}^{\mathrm{*}}H∗ with vuv and uv laser radiation, independently tunable and linearly polarized either parallel (\ensuremath{\pi}) or perpendicular (\ensuremath{\sigma}) with respect to the external field. Different from other, nonhydrogenic atoms, the hydrogen atom is a peculiar case insofar as the initial states of H(n=2), from which excitation takes place, are essentially of parabolic character at the field strengths employed in this study.Individual sublevels (n1{n}_{1}n1​,n2{n}_{2}n2​,\ensuremath{\Vert}ml{m}_{l}ml​\ensuremath{\Vert}) have been prepared in the n=2 state with sub-Doppler resolution. Photoionization spectra have been obtained with \ensuremath{\pi}- and \ensuremath{\sigma}-polarized uv radiation from the four possible sublevels of the n=2 Stark manifold: \ensuremath{\Vert}1,0,0〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉, \ensuremath{\Vert}0,1,0〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉, \ensuremath{\Vert}0,0,\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉, and \ensuremath{\Vert}0,0,\ensuremath{\mp}1〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉. All spectra show sharp line structures of quasistable field-ionizing states superimposed on continua in the energy region between the classical saddle point, ${E}_{\mathrm{SP}=\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}2\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\surd}}\mathrm{F}}$ a.u., and the zero-field ionization threshold E=0 a.u. Employing existing theoretical treatments, the quasistable spectral structures are quantitatively completely analyzed and accounted for, as long as their field ionization rate is less than \ensuremath{\sim}5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}1011{10}^{11}1011 ${\mathrm{sec}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}1}$. Field-ionization rates of quasistable states have been measured and are compared with theory. Oscillatory resonance structures of the ionization cross section near the zero-field threshold are observed with pronounced modulation degree only in the spectrum from the \ensuremath{\Vert}1,0,0〉 \ensuremath{\Vert}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1/2〉 sublevel excited with the uv \ensuremath{\pi}-polarized. The energy spacing of the oscillations has been measured as a function of the electric field strength F and found to be nearly proportional to F3/4{F}^{3/4}F3/4, with slight but definite deviations. Theoretical analysis of the oscillations yields quantitative agreement with the experiment.
In a recent paper, Whitehead, McCann, and Shimamura [Phys. Rev. A 64, 023401 (2001)] presented classical-trajectory Monte Carlo (CTMC) calculations of the effects of laser fields on the cross section for antihydrogen formation in collisions of antiprotons with positronium. They also use the same method to calculate the photoionization rate of isolated positronium in a strong field. The purpose of this Comment is to point out (i) the criteria for validity of the quasiclassical approximation are not satisfied for all the conditions used; (ii) some of their numerical results do not agree with the values obtained with a corroborated code; (iii) the ambiguity of a cross section when the target can ionize even before the projectile arrives; and (iv) the essential effect of quantum-mechanical tunneling on the strong-field ionization rate. A recently published method allowing tunneling in a CTMC calculation [J. S. Cohen, Phys. Rev. A 64, 043412 (2001)] is used for (iv). It is concluded that the laser effect on formation of antihydrogen may be much greater than that found by Whitehead et al., but the pulse must be better characterized for quantitative predictions.
We present calculations of the photoionization spectrum of excited hydrogen using \ensuremath{\pi} polarization in the presence of a strong electric field as a function of the spherical (applicable to complex atoms) and parabolic quantum numbers of the excited state. We also present corresponding measurements of the photoionization yield from the individual parabolic states of n=2. Both the calculations and the measurements show an enhancement of the depth of the so-called ``Stark-induced modulation'' in the region E\ensuremath{\ge}0 when the initial excited state is a pure ml{m}_{l}ml​=0 blue state, and disappear almost completely when the initial state is a pure ml{m}_{l}ml​=0 red state. These results are understood using arguments based on the fact that the charge distribution of the Stark-induced states is tremendously extended up field. Because of the excellent signal to noise ratio of the enhanced modulations, we were able to measure the field dependence of the spacings with sufficient accuracy to confirm the (3/4) power law and rule out the recently suggested (2/3) power law.