Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Ninth Marcel Grossmann Meeting

THE QUANTUM CLOCK: A CRITICAL DISCUSSION ON SPACE–TIME

L. Burderi, T. Di Salvo

Published Jan 29, 2015• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We critically discuss the measure of very short time intervals. By means of a gedanken-experiment , we describe an ideal clock based on the occurrence of completely random events. We show that the minimum time interval that this clock can measure scales as the inverse of its size. This implies an uncertainty relation between space and time. We outline and briefly discuss the implications of this uncertainty principle.

DOI
10.1142/9789814623995_0397

Related papers

Fundamental bound for time measurements and minimum uncertainty clocks

Rodolfo Gambini, Jorge A. Pullin

Abstract We present a simple argument leading to a fundamental minimum uncertainty in the determination of times. It only relies in the uncertainty principle and time dilation in a gravitational field. It implies any attempt to measure times will have a fundamental level of uncertainty. Implications are briefly outlined.

arXiv:2006.08730•Journal of Physics Communications•Jun 1, 2020•4 citations

An ideal quantum clock and Principle of maximum force

Yu. L. Bolotin, V. A. Cherkaskiy, Anatoli Tur +1 more

We show that the space-time uncertainty relation for the quantum clock can be derived from the maximum force principle.

arXiv:1604.01945•Apr 7, 2016•8 citations

Quantum Limitations of the Measurement of Space-Time Distances

H. Salecker, Eugene Paul Wigner

This article deals with the limitations which the quantized nature of microscopic systems imposes on the possibility of measuring distances between space-time events. It is proposed to use only clocks for measuring space-time distances and to avoid the use of measuring rods which are essentially macrophysical objects. The accuracy of reading a clock with a given mass is considered and examples for microphysical clocks are given. It is shown that the mass of the clock, and the uncertainty (spread) of this quantity, exceed certain values which depend on the accuracy with which the time interval is to be measured, the magnitude of this time interval (the running time of the clock) and the size of the clock. The minimum mass uncertainty of the clock is given by Heisenberg's relation; the minimum mass itself is higher by the ratio of the running time and the accuracy.If the possibility of constructing states whose wave functions are Gaussian wave packets is admitted, the mass and the mass uncertainty of the clock differs only by logarithmic factors from the uncertainties which follow from general principles of quantum mechanics. The masses are much higher if the possibility of constructing arbitrary wave packets is not admitted.

Physical Review•Jan 15, 1958•391 citations

Time-energy uncertainty relation for quantum events

Matteo Fadel, Lorenzo Maccone

Textbook quantum mechanics treats time as a classical parameter and not as a quantum observable with an associated Hermitian operator. For this reason, to make sense of usual time-energy uncertainty relations such as $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}t\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}E\ensuremath{\gtrsim}\ensuremath{\hbar}$, the term $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}t$ must be interpreted as a time interval and not as a time measurement uncertainty due to quantum noise. However, quantum clocks allow for a measurement of the ``time at which an event happens'' by conditioning the system's evolution on an additional quantum degree of freedom. Within this framework we derive here two uncertainty relations that relate the uncertainty in the quantum measurement of the time at which a quantum event happens on a system to its energy uncertainty.

arXiv:2108.13974•Physical Review A•Nov 24, 2021•11 citations

Time in the Quantum Theory and the Uncertainty Relation for Time and Energy

Yakir Aharonov, David Böhm

Because time does not appear in Schr\"odinger's equation as an operator but only as a parameter, the time-energy uncertainty relation must be formulated in a special way. This problem has in fact been studied by many authors and we give a summary of their treatments. We then criticize the main conclusion of these treatments; viz., that in a measurement of energy carried out in a time interval, $\ensuremath{\Delta}t$, there must be a minimum uncertainty in the transfer of energy to the observed system, given by $\ensuremath{\Delta}({E}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{-}E)>~\frac{h}{\ensuremath{\Delta}t}$. We show that this conclusion is erroneous in two respects. First, it is not consistent with the general principles of the quantum theory, which require that all uncertainty relations be expressible in terms of the mathematical formalism, i.e., by means of operators, wave functions, etc. Secondly, the examples of measurement processes that were used to derive the above uncertainty relation are not general enough. We then develop a systematic presentation of our own point of view, with regard to the role of time in the quantum theory, and give a concrete example of a measurement process not satisfying the above uncertainty relation.

Physical Review•Jun 1, 1961•476 citations

Limitation to Quantum Measurements of Space‐Time Distancesa

Yee Jack Ng, H. van Dam

Inspired by the work of Wheeler among others, we have studied the problem of quantum measurements of space-time distances by applying the general principles of quantum mechanics as well as those of general relativity. Contrary to the folklore, the minimum error in the measurement of a length is shown to be proportional to the one-third power of the length itself. This uncertainty in space-time measurements implies an uncertainty of the space-time metric and yields quantum decoherence for particles heavier than the Planck mass. There is also a corresponding minimum error in energy-momentum measurements.

arXiv:hep-th/9406110•Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences•Apr 1, 1995•60 citations
We critically discuss the measure of very short time intervals. By means of a gedanken-experiment , we describe an ideal clock based on the occurrence of completely random events. We show that the minimum time interval that this clock can measure scales as the inverse of its size. This implies an uncertainty relation between space and time. We outline and briefly discuss the implications of this uncertainty principle.
This article deals with the limitations which the quantized nature of microscopic systems imposes on the possibility of measuring distances between space-time events. It is proposed to use only clocks for measuring space-time distances and to avoid the use of measuring rods which are essentially macrophysical objects. The accuracy of reading a clock with a given mass is considered and examples for microphysical clocks are given. It is shown that the mass of the clock, and the uncertainty (spread) of this quantity, exceed certain values which depend on the accuracy with which the time interval is to be measured, the magnitude of this time interval (the running time of the clock) and the size of the clock. The minimum mass uncertainty of the clock is given by Heisenberg's relation; the minimum mass itself is higher by the ratio of the running time and the accuracy.If the possibility of constructing states whose wave functions are Gaussian wave packets is admitted, the mass and the mass uncertainty of the clock differs only by logarithmic factors from the uncertainties which follow from general principles of quantum mechanics. The masses are much higher if the possibility of constructing arbitrary wave packets is not admitted.
Textbook quantum mechanics treats time as a classical parameter and not as a quantum observable with an associated Hermitian operator. For this reason, to make sense of usual time-energy uncertainty relations such as $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}t\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}E\ensuremath{\gtrsim}\ensuremath{\hbar}$, the term $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}t$ must be interpreted as a time interval and not as a time measurement uncertainty due to quantum noise. However, quantum clocks allow for a measurement of the ``time at which an event happens'' by conditioning the system's evolution on an additional quantum degree of freedom. Within this framework we derive here two uncertainty relations that relate the uncertainty in the quantum measurement of the time at which a quantum event happens on a system to its energy uncertainty.
Because time does not appear in Schr\"odinger's equation as an operator but only as a parameter, the time-energy uncertainty relation must be formulated in a special way. This problem has in fact been studied by many authors and we give a summary of their treatments. We then criticize the main conclusion of these treatments; viz., that in a measurement of energy carried out in a time interval, $\ensuremath{\Delta}t$, there must be a minimum uncertainty in the transfer of energy to the observed system, given by $\ensuremath{\Delta}({E}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{-}E)>~\frac{h}{\ensuremath{\Delta}t}$. We show that this conclusion is erroneous in two respects. First, it is not consistent with the general principles of the quantum theory, which require that all uncertainty relations be expressible in terms of the mathematical formalism, i.e., by means of operators, wave functions, etc. Secondly, the examples of measurement processes that were used to derive the above uncertainty relation are not general enough. We then develop a systematic presentation of our own point of view, with regard to the role of time in the quantum theory, and give a concrete example of a measurement process not satisfying the above uncertainty relation.
Inspired by the work of Wheeler among others, we have studied the problem of quantum measurements of space-time distances by applying the general principles of quantum mechanics as well as those of general relativity. Contrary to the folklore, the minimum error in the measurement of a length is shown to be proportional to the one-third power of the length itself. This uncertainty in space-time measurements implies an uncertainty of the space-time metric and yields quantum decoherence for particles heavier than the Planck mass. There is also a corresponding minimum error in energy-momentum measurements.