Journal of Mathematical Physics

On the Nonorthogonality of Generalized Momentum Eigenfunctions in Quantum Mechanics

Peter D. Robinson

Published Mar 1, 1963• 3 citations

Abstract

The orthogonality requirement usually specified for the eigenfunctions φ of a quantum-mechanical operator P which has a continuous spectrum of eigenvalues λ, is ∫φ*(λ)φ(λ′) dλ=δ(λ−λ′). The derivation of this result is examined; it is seen to be merely a sufficient, but not a necessary condition for the consistent expansion of a bound-state wavefunction ψ in the form ∫ a(λ)φ(λ) dλ. The situation when P is a generalized momentum operator is investigated in detail. Such operators were discussed in the preceding paper. It is shown that any two of the corresponding momentum eigenfunctions are not usually orthogonal. Nevertheless, with the help of Fourier analysis, a consistent expansion ψ=∫ a(λ)φ(λ) dλ is established. The theory is illustrated with the familiar examples of a ``particle in a box'' and a ground-state hydrogen atom. When a space coordinate has a finite range, a quantum condition can be imposed on the generalized momentum eigenvalues so that the momentum eigenfunctions form a complete discrete orthogonal set. We attempt to justify the belief that such quantization is not essential unless it is necessary to ensure single-valued eigenfunctions.

DOI: 10.1063/1.1703960

Related papers

Critical comments on the quantization of the angular momentum: II. Analysis based on the requirement that the eigenfunction of the third component of the operator of the angular momentum must be a single valued periodic function

G. S. Japaridze, Anzor Khelashvili, K. Sh. Turashvili

We discuss the requirement of single valuedness and periodicity of eigenfunction of the third component of the operator of angular momentum. This condition, imposed on a non observable, is often used to derive that the eigenvalues of angular momentum could be only integer. We reexamine the arguments based on this requirement and alternate condition imposed by Pauli and show that they do not follow from the first principles and therefore these constraints can dropped. Consequently, we arrive to the same conclusion as in [1]: there exist regular, normalizable eigenfunctions with the non-integer eigenvalues thus a non-integer angular momentum is perfectly admissible from the theoretical viewpoint. The issue of the nature of eigenvalues forming the spectrum of the angular momentum remains open. What can be derived from the first principles is that to a fixed value of the angular momentum L corresponds a discrete spectrum of eigenvalues of the third component of the angular momentum, m, defined by the relation |m|=L-k, k=0,1,...,[L], where [L] is an integer part of L. As a mathematical byproduct of our analysis of eigenfunctions, we present an alternate definition of a power of a complex number allowing to retain initial translational invariance of a base.

arXiv:2004.10673Apr 17, 20201 citation

GENERALIZED MOMENTUM OPERATORS IN QUANTUM MECHANICS. Series 3

Peter D. Robinson, Joseph O. Hirschfelder

>The usual form for the quantum-mechanical operator P conjugate to a generalized coordinate q is noted to be nonHermitian with respect to physically acceptable bound state wave functions in some cases. A corrected form is shown to be always Hermitian with respect to acceptable bound state wave functions. Eigenfunctions for the new form are not necessartly orthogonal as with the usual form. (D.C.W.)

Apr 16, 19620 citations

- Operators, Eigenvalues and Eigenfunctions

S. Rajasekar, R. Velusamy

A basic quantity in quantum mechanics is the wave function ψ. Given a quantum mechanical system we write the Schrödinger equation for it. Its solution is the wave function. When introducing the wave function we stated that the maximum information about the state of a system can be obtained only from ψ. How do we extract observable properties of the system from the wave function? In quantum mechanics for every classical dynamical variable there exists an operator. For example, the operator of momentum p is −i~∇ while the operator of energy variable H = p2/(2m)+V (X) is −(~2/2m)∇2+V (X). Operation of an operator on ψ gives another function. If the new function is λψ, then λ is the eigenvalue of the operator. For example, the energy of a particle in a particular state represented by ψ can be obtained by operating H on ψ. That is, we have Hψ = Eψ where E is the energy eigenvalue. The expectation value of A(X,p) can be obtained from the formula 〈A〉 = ∫ ∞ −∞ ψ∗Aψ dτ , (3.1) where ψ is the solution of the equation Hψ = Eψ. Operators in quantum mechanics which represent observables are of a spe- cial type: They are linear and Hermitian. Such operators not only form computation tools, but also form the most effective language in terms of which the theory can be formulated. The fascinating point is that using linear operators we can understand the quantum mechanics. Therefore, it is important to study the basic theory of linear operators. In this chapter, we present important properties of linear operators and their eigenfunctions. We discuss the features of various operators which are necessary for studying quantum and ematical structure of quantum mechanics is.

CRC Press eBooksDec 11, 20140 citations

Integral Forms for Quantum-Mechanical Momentum Operators

Peter D. Robinson

The usual differential form P0 for the quantum-mechanical momentum operator P which is conjugate to a generalized coordinate q (α ≤ q ≤ β) is, in atomic units, P0 = − i(g−½) ∂/∂q (g½), where g is the Jacobian of the transformation from Cartesian to generalized coordinates. However, P0 is not always self-adjoint on the domain 𝒟 of physically acceptable bound-state wavefunctions, as a proper quantum-mechanical operator should be. An integral form is proposed for P, defined by Pf(q)=(2π)−12g−12(q) ∫ −∞∞exp (ikq)kF(k) dk, α≤q≤β,where F(k)=(2π)−12 ∫ αβexp (−ikξ)f(ξ)g12(ξ) dξ, f∈D. The effect of this integral operator (which is suggested by the ideas of Fourier transforms) differs from that of P0 only at the end-points of the range of q. In a sense, it is formally equivalent to an operator (suggested by Robinson and Hirschfelder) which is obtained by adding certain delta-function terms to P0, but it suffers from none of the defects, since delta-functions do not appear explicitly. Various properties of the integral operator are derived. Some discussion of the domain 𝒟 is presented as an appendix.

Journal of Mathematical PhysicsNov 1, 19668 citations

Deriving the eigenvector of the operator λ■+μ■ by|x〉

Hongqi Li

By the representation of the coordinate eigenvector |x〉 in the Fock space,the eigenvector |ψ〉 of the operator λ■+μ■ is derived and its orthogonal relation is also proved.These results show that the eigenvector |ψ〉 satisfies the completeness and the orthogonal relations.Therefore,this eigenvector |ψ〉 can be qualified for a representation in quantum mechanics.When λ=1 and μ= 0,the eigenvector |ψ〉 evolves into the coordinate eigenvector |x〉;while λ=0 and μ =1,the |ψ〉 reduces to the momentum eigenvector |p〉.Therefore,the representation consisted by the eigenvectors |ψ〉 is an intermediate representation between the coordinate representation and the momentum representation.

College PhysicsJan 1, 20100 citations

Conditions on wave functions derived from operator domains

Thomas F. Jordan

Conditions on wave functions that are eigenvectors often have a mathematical rather than a physical basis; they are required simply because an eigenvector of an operator must be in the domain of that operator. This is illustrated with derivations of the conditions at the origin on eigenvectors of a nonrelativistic Hamiltonian, for example, for the hydrogen atom or harmonic oscillator, and the condition that eigenfunctions of the angular momentum Lz must be single valued or continuous around a complete circle.

American Journal of PhysicsJun 1, 197616 citations