Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2004.10673

Critical comments on the quantization of the angular momentum: II. Analysis based on the requirement that the eigenfunction of the third component of the operator of the angular momentum must be a single valued periodic function

G. S. Japaridze, Anzor Khelashvili, K. Sh. Turashvili

Published Apr 17, 2020• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We discuss the requirement of single valuedness and periodicity of eigenfunction of the third component of the operator of angular momentum. This condition, imposed on a non observable, is often used to derive that the eigenvalues of angular momentum could be only integer. We reexamine the arguments based on this requirement and alternate condition imposed by Pauli and show that they do not follow from the first principles and therefore these constraints can dropped. Consequently, we arrive to the same conclusion as in [1]: there exist regular, normalizable eigenfunctions with the non-integer eigenvalues thus a non-integer angular momentum is perfectly admissible from the theoretical viewpoint. The issue of the nature of eigenvalues forming the spectrum of the angular momentum remains open. What can be derived from the first principles is that to a fixed value of the angular momentum L corresponds a discrete spectrum of eigenvalues of the third component of the angular momentum, m, defined by the relation |m|=L-k, k=0,1,...,[L], where [L] is an integer part of L. As a mathematical byproduct of our analysis of eigenfunctions, we present an alternate definition of a power of a complex number allowing to retain initial translational invariance of a base.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2004.10673

Related papers

Critical comments on quantization of the angular momentum: I. Analysis based on the physical requirement on eigenfunctions and on the commutation relations

G. S. Japaridze, Anzor Khelashvili, K. Sh. Turashvili

Eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the operator of the square of the angular momentum are studied. It is shown that neither from the requirement for the eigenfunctions be normalizable nor from the commutation relations it is possible to prove that the eigenvalues spectrum is a set of only integer numbers (in units $\hbar=1$). We present regular, normalizable eigenfunctions with the non-integer eigenvalues thus demonstrating that a non-integer angular momentum is admissible from the theoretical viewpoint.

arXiv:1912.08042•Dec 4, 2019•1 citation

Novel Outlook on the Eigenvalue Problem for the Orbital Angular Momentum Operator

G. S. Japaridze, Anzor Khelashvili, K. Sh. Turashvili

Based on the novel prescription for the power function, (x+iy)m, the new expression for Ψ(x,y|m), the eigenfunction of the operator of the third component of the angular momentum, M^z, is presented. These functions are normalizable, single valued and, distinct to the traditional presentation, (x+iy)m=ρmeimϕ, are invariant under the rotations at 2π for any, not necessarily integer, m—the eigenvalue of M^z. For any real m the functions Ψ(x,y|m) form an orthonormal set, therefore they may serve as a quantum mechanical eigenfunction of M^z. The eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the angular momentum operator squared, M^2, derived for the two different prescriptions for the square root, (m2)1/2, (m2)1/2=|m| and (m2)1/2=±m, are reported. The normalizable eigenfunctions of M^2 are presented in terms of hypergeometric functions, admitting integer as well as non-integer eigenvalues. It is shown that the purely integer spectrum is not the most general solution but is just the artifact of a particular choice of the Legendre functions as the pair of linearly independent solutions of the eigenvalue problem for the M^2.

arXiv:2206.03282•Physics•Jun 1, 2022•0 citations

- Angular Momentum I

Alastair I. M. Rae, Jim Napolitano

Angular momentum is a very important and revealing property of many physical systems. In classical mechanics the principle of conservation of angular momentum is a powerful aid to the solution of such problems as the orbits of planets and satellites and the behaviour of gyroscopes and tops. The role of angular momentum in quantum mechanics is probably even more important and this will be the subject of the present chapter and the next. We shall find that the operators representing the components of angular momentum do not commute with each other, although they all commute with the operator representing the total angular momentum. It follows that no pair of these components can be measured compatibly and we shall therefore look for a set of eigenfunctions that are common to the operators representing the total angular momentum and one of its components. We shall find that the angular momentum eigenvalues always form a discrete set and that, in the case of a central field, the operators commute with the Hamiltonian, implying that the total angular momentum and one component can be measured compatibly with the energy in this case, so that their values, once measured, remain constant in time. Consideration of angular momentum will also enable us to make predictions about the behaviour of atoms in magnetic fields, and we shall find that these are in agreement with experiment only if we assume that the electron (in common with many other fundamental particles) has an intrinsic “spin” angular momentum in addition to the “orbital” angular momentum associated with its motion. The interaction between spin and orbital angular momenta leads to detailed features of the atomic spectra which are known as “fine structure.” We shall also use the measurement of angular momentum to illustrate the quantum theory of measurement discussed in the previous chapter.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2015•0 citations

Angular Momentum Theory

Ana Marı́a Cetto, Luis de la Peña

Chapter 11 is devoted to the quantum theory of angular momentum. As in classical mechanics, working with angular momentum requires leaving the one-dimensional space, with all the complications that this entails. The importance of angular momentum resides in at least three facts: i) central problems are of particular interest; (ii) many particles have an intrinsic angular momentum (the spin); and iii) the physics of angular momentum involves features such as the so-called space quantization. The first part of the chapter deals with the orbital angular momentum and its eigenfunctions, the spherical harmonics. Its algebraic properties, embodied in the matrix representation, allow for an extension of the theory to half-integer angular momentum in terms of Pauli matrices, as well as the addition of angular momenta.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

A classical, elementary approach to the foundations of Quantum Mechanics

David Rodríguez

Elementary particles are found in two different situations: (i) bound to metastable states of matter, for which angular momentum is quantized, and (ii) free, for which, due to their high energy-momentum and leaving aside inner a.m. or spin, the $h$-quantization step is completely harmless. Perhaps Quantum Mechanics can be seen just as the simplest mathematical formalism where angular momentum (the magnitude of each of its three orthogonal projections) is by construction quantized: all possible values are taken from a discrete set. Indeed: (i) This idea finds support in very reasonable, completely classical physical arguments, if we place ourselves in the framework of Stochastic Electrodynamics (SED): there, all sustained periodic movement of a charge must satisfy a power balance that restricts the value of the average angular momentum, on each of its projections. (ii) It gives a natural explanation of the concept of "photon", as a constraint on the observable spectrum of energy-momentum exchanges between metastable physical states, in particular also for its discreteness. QM would be, in this picture, a semi-static theory, transparent to all the (micro)-dynamics taking place between apparently "discrete" events (transitions in the state of the system). For instance, (the magnitude of the projections of) quantum angular momentum would only reflect average values over a (classical) cyclic trajectory, a fact that we regard as almost obvious given the particularity of the corresponding addition rules in QM.

arXiv:1112.3369•Dec 13, 2011•0 citations

Angular Momentum

A. C. Sharma

This chapter covers various aspects of orbital, total, and spin angular momenta and the Clebsch-Gordon coefficients. An approach that is not found in many books, is used to derive eigenvalues of orbital angular momentum. The Pauli theory of spin half systems, addition of angular momenta, eigenfunctions of orbital angular momentum, computation of Clebsch-Gordon coefficients, solved examples, and unsolved exercises are included in the chapter. The basic purpose of the chapter has been to bring out the quantum mechanical importance of the theory of angular momenta with the use of essential mathematical derivations, which are self-consistent, and to adopt an elegant modern approach. Special mention on why orbital angular momentum cannot have non-integer values is made. The concept of spin angular momentum, which is purely a quantum mechanical quantity, is introduced in a simple and most convincing manner.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 18, 2021•0 citations
We discuss the requirement of single valuedness and periodicity of eigenfunction of the third component of the operator of angular momentum. This condition, imposed on a non observable, is often used to derive that the eigenvalues of angular momentum could be only integer. We reexamine the arguments based on this requirement and alternate condition imposed by Pauli and show that they do not follow from the first principles and therefore these constraints can dropped. Consequently, we arrive to the same conclusion as in [1]: there exist regular, normalizable eigenfunctions with the non-integer eigenvalues thus a non-integer angular momentum is perfectly admissible from the theoretical viewpoint. The issue of the nature of eigenvalues forming the spectrum of the angular momentum remains open. What can be derived from the first principles is that to a fixed value of the angular momentum L corresponds a discrete spectrum of eigenvalues of the third component of the angular momentum, m, defined by the relation |m|=L-k, k=0,1,...,[L], where [L] is an integer part of L. As a mathematical byproduct of our analysis of eigenfunctions, we present an alternate definition of a power of a complex number allowing to retain initial translational invariance of a base.
Eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the operator of the square of the angular momentum are studied. It is shown that neither from the requirement for the eigenfunctions be normalizable nor from the commutation relations it is possible to prove that the eigenvalues spectrum is a set of only integer numbers (in units ℏ=1\hbar=1ℏ=1). We present regular, normalizable eigenfunctions with the non-integer eigenvalues thus demonstrating that a non-integer angular momentum is admissible from the theoretical viewpoint.
Based on the novel prescription for the power function, (x+iy)m, the new expression for Ψ(x,y|m), the eigenfunction of the operator of the third component of the angular momentum, M^z, is presented. These functions are normalizable, single valued and, distinct to the traditional presentation, (x+iy)m=ρmeimϕ, are invariant under the rotations at 2π for any, not necessarily integer, m—the eigenvalue of M^z. For any real m the functions Ψ(x,y|m) form an orthonormal set, therefore they may serve as a quantum mechanical eigenfunction of M^z. The eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the angular momentum operator squared, M^2, derived for the two different prescriptions for the square root, (m2)1/2, (m2)1/2=|m| and (m2)1/2=±m, are reported. The normalizable eigenfunctions of M^2 are presented in terms of hypergeometric functions, admitting integer as well as non-integer eigenvalues. It is shown that the purely integer spectrum is not the most general solution but is just the artifact of a particular choice of the Legendre functions as the pair of linearly independent solutions of the eigenvalue problem for the M^2.
Angular momentum is a very important and revealing property of many physical systems. In classical mechanics the principle of conservation of angular momentum is a powerful aid to the solution of such problems as the orbits of planets and satellites and the behaviour of gyroscopes and tops. The role of angular momentum in quantum mechanics is probably even more important and this will be the subject of the present chapter and the next. We shall find that the operators representing the components of angular momentum do not commute with each other, although they all commute with the operator representing the total angular momentum. It follows that no pair of these components can be measured compatibly and we shall therefore look for a set of eigenfunctions that are common to the operators representing the total angular momentum and one of its components. We shall find that the angular momentum eigenvalues always form a discrete set and that, in the case of a central field, the operators commute with the Hamiltonian, implying that the total angular momentum and one component can be measured compatibly with the energy in this case, so that their values, once measured, remain constant in time. Consideration of angular momentum will also enable us to make predictions about the behaviour of atoms in magnetic fields, and we shall find that these are in agreement with experiment only if we assume that the electron (in common with many other fundamental particles) has an intrinsic “spin” angular momentum in addition to the “orbital” angular momentum associated with its motion. The interaction between spin and orbital angular momenta leads to detailed features of the atomic spectra which are known as “fine structure.” We shall also use the measurement of angular momentum to illustrate the quantum theory of measurement discussed in the previous chapter.
Chapter 11 is devoted to the quantum theory of angular momentum. As in classical mechanics, working with angular momentum requires leaving the one-dimensional space, with all the complications that this entails. The importance of angular momentum resides in at least three facts: i) central problems are of particular interest; (ii) many particles have an intrinsic angular momentum (the spin); and iii) the physics of angular momentum involves features such as the so-called space quantization. The first part of the chapter deals with the orbital angular momentum and its eigenfunctions, the spherical harmonics. Its algebraic properties, embodied in the matrix representation, allow for an extension of the theory to half-integer angular momentum in terms of Pauli matrices, as well as the addition of angular momenta.
Elementary particles are found in two different situations: (i) bound to metastable states of matter, for which angular momentum is quantized, and (ii) free, for which, due to their high energy-momentum and leaving aside inner a.m. or spin, the hhh-quantization step is completely harmless. Perhaps Quantum Mechanics can be seen just as the simplest mathematical formalism where angular momentum (the magnitude of each of its three orthogonal projections) is by construction quantized: all possible values are taken from a discrete set. Indeed: (i) This idea finds support in very reasonable, completely classical physical arguments, if we place ourselves in the framework of Stochastic Electrodynamics (SED): there, all sustained periodic movement of a charge must satisfy a power balance that restricts the value of the average angular momentum, on each of its projections. (ii) It gives a natural explanation of the concept of "photon", as a constraint on the observable spectrum of energy-momentum exchanges between metastable physical states, in particular also for its discreteness. QM would be, in this picture, a semi-static theory, transparent to all the (micro)-dynamics taking place between apparently "discrete" events (transitions in the state of the system). For instance, (the magnitude of the projections of) quantum angular momentum would only reflect average values over a (classical) cyclic trajectory, a fact that we regard as almost obvious given the particularity of the corresponding addition rules in QM.
This chapter covers various aspects of orbital, total, and spin angular momenta and the Clebsch-Gordon coefficients. An approach that is not found in many books, is used to derive eigenvalues of orbital angular momentum. The Pauli theory of spin half systems, addition of angular momenta, eigenfunctions of orbital angular momentum, computation of Clebsch-Gordon coefficients, solved examples, and unsolved exercises are included in the chapter. The basic purpose of the chapter has been to bring out the quantum mechanical importance of the theory of angular momenta with the use of essential mathematical derivations, which are self-consistent, and to adopt an elegant modern approach. Special mention on why orbital angular momentum cannot have non-integer values is made. The concept of spin angular momentum, which is purely a quantum mechanical quantity, is introduced in a simple and most convincing manner.