Critical comments on quantization of the angular momentum: I. Analysis based on the physical requirement on eigenfunctions and on the commutation relations
G. S. Japaridze, Anzor Khelashvili, K. Sh. Turashvili
Eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the operator of the square of the angular momentum are studied. It is shown that neither from the requirement for the eigenfunctions be normalizable nor from the commutation relations it is possible to prove that the eigenvalues spectrum is a set of only integer numbers (in units $\hbar=1$). We present regular, normalizable eigenfunctions with the non-integer eigenvalues thus demonstrating that a non-integer angular momentum is admissible from the theoretical viewpoint.
Eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the operator of the square of the angular momentum are studied. It is shown that neither from the requirement for the eigenfunctions be normalizable nor from the commutation relations it is possible to prove that the eigenvalues spectrum is a set of only integer numbers (in units ℏ=1). We present regular, normalizable eigenfunctions with the non-integer eigenvalues thus demonstrating that a non-integer angular momentum is admissible from the theoretical viewpoint.
We discuss the requirement of single valuedness and periodicity of eigenfunction of the third component of the operator of angular momentum. This condition, imposed on a non observable, is often used to derive that the eigenvalues of angular momentum could be only integer. We reexamine the arguments based on this requirement and alternate condition imposed by Pauli and show that they do not follow from the first principles and therefore these constraints can dropped. Consequently, we arrive to the same conclusion as in [1]: there exist regular, normalizable eigenfunctions with the non-integer eigenvalues thus a non-integer angular momentum is perfectly admissible from the theoretical viewpoint. The issue of the nature of eigenvalues forming the spectrum of the angular momentum remains open. What can be derived from the first principles is that to a fixed value of the angular momentum L corresponds a discrete spectrum of eigenvalues of the third component of the angular momentum, m, defined by the relation |m|=L-k, k=0,1,...,[L], where [L] is an integer part of L. As a mathematical byproduct of our analysis of eigenfunctions, we present an alternate definition of a power of a complex number allowing to retain initial translational invariance of a base.
Based on the novel prescription for the power function, (x+iy)m, the new expression for Ψ(x,y|m), the eigenfunction of the operator of the third component of the angular momentum, M^z, is presented. These functions are normalizable, single valued and, distinct to the traditional presentation, (x+iy)m=ρmeimϕ, are invariant under the rotations at 2π for any, not necessarily integer, m—the eigenvalue of M^z. For any real m the functions Ψ(x,y|m) form an orthonormal set, therefore they may serve as a quantum mechanical eigenfunction of M^z. The eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of the angular momentum operator squared, M^2, derived for the two different prescriptions for the square root, (m2)1/2, (m2)1/2=|m| and (m2)1/2=±m, are reported. The normalizable eigenfunctions of M^2 are presented in terms of hypergeometric functions, admitting integer as well as non-integer eigenvalues. It is shown that the purely integer spectrum is not the most general solution but is just the artifact of a particular choice of the Legendre functions as the pair of linearly independent solutions of the eigenvalue problem for the M^2.
The theory of angular momentum performance a significant position in the classical and quantum mechanical study of physical properties, such as studies into nuclear, atomic, and molecular processes, as well as other quantum problems, including spherical symmetry. In this analysis, angular momentum operators are described in multiple ways, based on the angular momentum operator's commutator, matrix, and geometric representation, The eigenvalue and eigenvector were also known for operatorsJ ̂_±,J ⃑ ̂^2, J ̂_x,J ̂_y and J ̂_zwithin the |j,┤ ├ m⟩ basis. Furthermore, in quantum mechanics, angular momentum is called quantized variable, meaning that it comes in discrete quantities. In contrast to the macroscopic system case where a continuous variable is angular momentum.
The recent two papers have successively proposed the concepts and more precise expressions of strict conservation or statistical conservation of physical quantities, which are different from the expression of a conserved quantity in quantum mechanics. The Hamiltonian operator of the system discussed in this paper are independent of time, so it is commutative with the operators of an angular momentum itself, its component and its square, so that all these quantities are conserved quantities. In an isolated composite system, one of the angular momentum components of the total system are strictly conserved, while the angular momentum components of the subsystems can only be conserved statistically, both of which can be expressed in terms of eigenvalues and eigenfunctions. Generally, angular momentum itself does not have eigenvalues and eigenfunctions, so it cannot be expressed as strict conservation in terms of these concepts. Although there are eigenvalues and eigenfunctions for the square of angular momentum, they cannot express strict conservation either. And they can only be expressed as statistical conservation.
An elementary approach to the quantum theory of angular momentum is sketched. The quantization of angular momentum components, Heisenberg-type inequalities for their spectral dispersions, and the quantization of the angular momentum modulus are introduced without using operators or commutation relations. The purpose is to focus the attention on angular momemtum as a very important practical concept of quantum physics, as well as on its specifically quantum-theoretical aspects, right from the beginning of an introductory course. Since the heuristic arguments employed here closely parallel the rigorous derivations of a formal approach, the intuitive presentation does not contradict, but rather supports, the theoretical concepts to be introduced at a later stage.