Linear optics quantum computing - construction of small networks and asymptotic scaling

Konrad Kieling

Published Jan 1, 2008• 5 citations

Abstract

In the paradigm of linear optics, quantum states of optical field modes are manipulated by means of photon sources, beam splitters, and photodetectors. This restriction of the allowed interactions introduces non-unit success probabilities into every non-trivial computation irrevocably. The resulting probabilistic nature of this architecture opens up questions about scalability of this approach as well as about basic limitations like optimal resource consumption and the construction of optical networks for given tasks. The scalability question is addressed within the framework of cluster state computing which allows to shift the problem towards the problem of scalable state production. Several schemes with different constraints, resulting in different experimental feasibility, are shown to exhibit optimal scaling behaviour. These schemes include restrictions to certain easy-to-implement gate sets, and the banning of re-routing, which is a major obstacle in optical quantum computing. In the small-scale regime various methods for constructing and analysing linear optics networks are presented. Rather than constructing the gates in the general quantum gate model, a direct construction from linear optics’ basic elements – beam splitters and phase shifters – will be considered. This can result in higher success probabilities and smaller resource consumption. Due to the complexity of the problems, these techniques are applicable only to quantum gates which involve a small number of optical modes and photons. A couple of examples ranging from state preparation over quantum gates to state discrimination are used to illustrate these tools. LOQC – construction of small networks and asymptotic scaling 2

Related papers

Quantum Computing: Linear Optics Implementations

Pål Sundsøy, Egil Fjeldberg

One of the main problems that optical quantum computing has to overcome is the efficient construction of two-photon gates. Theoretically these gates can be realized using Kerr-nonlinearities, but the techniques involved are experimentally very difficult. We therefore employ linear optics with projective measurements to generate these non-linearities. The downside is that the measurement-induced nonlinearities achieved with linear optics are less versatile and the success rate can be quite low. This project is mainly the result of a literature study but also a theoretical work on the physics behind quantum optical multiports which is essential for realizing two-photon gates. By applying different postcorrection techniques we increase the probability of success in a modifed non-linear sign shift gate which is foundational for the two photon controlled-NOT gate. We prove that it's not possible to correct the states by only using a single beam splitter. We show that it might be possible to increase the probability of success using a more complex setup with at least two error-correcting beam splitters.

arXiv:1607.03935Jul 13, 20162 citations

Optical implementation of quantum computers

John Rarity, Harald Weinfurter

Optical quantum computation was limited to a few photon applications such as quantum cryptography and partial teleportation until 2001. Then the possibility of performing arbitrary logic conditional on certain detection outcomes was introduced by Knill, Laflamme and Milburn ( Nature 2001 409 46). Simple circuits consisting of single photon sources, entangled pair sources, linear optical elements and high efficiency photon counting detectors can be used to develop probabilistic two-photon logic gates. Initially such gates show a low probability of success but can approach the success rate of deterministic (non-linear) logic at the cost of added complexity. These developments have led to the emergence of a novel field of research aimed at improving the efficiency of linear logic and developing the efficient sources and detectors for its implementation. This topical issue of Journal of Optics B: Quantum and Semiclassical Optics is devoted to recent advances in this field. Key to all linear optics gates is the interference effect between separate photons that have no previous history. In this issue we include the first experiment to show such an effect (Rarity et al ), on which many later experiments are based. These interference effects can then be used to entangle separate pairs of particles into higher order entangled states (Zou et al 2005 J. Opt. B: Quantum Semiclass. Opt. 7 119–121) and also to establish entanglement between matter qubits (Kok et al ). Quantum dot single photon sources suitable for linear optics quantum logic are discussed in the paper by Unitt et al while a waveguide source of pair photons is presented by Ducci et al . The difficulties in scaling linear optics quantum computing arise from the low success probabilities of the gates. Introducing a small amount of non-linearity could allow unit efficiency gates to be designed (Munro et al ) while large non-linearities generated by the collective effects in EIT could be used to implement a wide variety of quantum logic functions (Petrosyan). The development of algorithms suitable for optical implementation is addressed by Ellinas et al . Key contributors to this issue are collaborating in the project IST:38864 RAMBOQ which has a primary goal of developing linear optics computation tools and techniques.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical OpticsJun 30, 20050 citations

Optical simulation of quantum logic

Nicolas J. Cerf, Christoph Adami, Paul G. Kwiat

A constructive method for simulating small-scale quantum circuits by use of linear optical devices is presented. It relies on the representation of several quantum bits by a single photon, and on the implementation of universal quantum gates using simple optical components (beam splitters, phase shifters, etc.). This suggests that the optical realization of small quantum networks with present-day quantum optics technology is a reasonable goal. This technique could be useful for demonstrating basic concepts of simple quantum algorithms or error-correction schemes. The optical analog of a nontrivial three-bit quantum circuit is presented as an illustration.

arXiv:quant-ph/9706022Physical Review AMar 1, 1998323 citations

Towards practical linear optical quantum computing

Mercedes Gimeno-Segovia

Quantum computing promises a new paradigm of computation where information is processed in a way that has no classical analogue. There are a number of physical platforms conducive to quantum computation, each with a number of advantages and challenges. Single photons, manipulated using integrated linear optics, constitute a promising platform for universal quantum computation. Their low decoherence rates make them particularly favourable, however the inability to perform deterministic two-qubit gates and the issue of photon loss are challenges that need to be overcome. In this thesis we explore the construction of a linear optical quantum computer based on the cluster state model. We identify the different necessary stages: state preparation, cluster state construction and implementation of quantum error correcting codes, and address the challenges that arise in each of these stages. For the state preparation, we propose a series of linear optical circuits for the generation of small entangled states, assessing their performance under different scenarios. For the cluster state construction, we introduce a ballistic scheme which not only consumes an order of magnitude fewer resources than previously proposed schemes, but also benefits from a natural loss tolerance. Based on this scheme, we propose a full architectural blueprint with fixed physical depth. We make investigations into the resource efficiency of this architecture and propose a new multiplexing scheme which optimises the use of resources. Finally, we study the integration of quantum error-correcting codes in the linear optical scheme proposed and suggest three ways in which the linear optical scheme can be made fault-tolerant.

Nov 1, 201514 citations

TOPICS IN LINEAR OPTICAL QUANTUM COMPUTATION

Scott Glancy

This thesis covers several topics in optical quantum computation. A quantum computer is a computational device which is able to manipulate information by performing unitary operations on some physical system whose state can be described as a vector (or mixture of vectors) in a Hilbert space. The basic unit of information, called the qubit, is considered to be a system with two orthogonal states, which are assigned logical values of 0 and 1. Photons make excellent candidates to serve as qubits. They have little interactions with the environment. Many operations can be performed using very simple linear optical devices such as beam splitters and phase shifters. Photons can easily be processed through circuit-like networks. Operations can be performed in very short times. Photons are ideally suited for the long-distance communication of quantum information. The great difficulty in constructing an optical quantum computer is that photons naturally interact weakly with one another. This thesis first gives a brief review of two early approaches to optical quantum computation. It will describe how any discrete unitary operation can be performed using a single photon and a network of beam splitters, and how the Kerr effect can be used to construct a two photon logic gate. Second, this work provides a thorough introduction to the linear optical quantum computer developed by Knill, Laflamme, and Milburn. It then presents this author's results on the reliability of this scheme when implemented using imperfect photon detectors. This author finds that quantum computers of this sort cannot be built using current technology. Third, this dissertation describes a method for constructing a linear optical quantum computer using nearly orthogonal coherent states of light as the qubits. It shows how a universal set of logic operations can be performed, including calculations of the fidelity with which these operations may be accomplished. It discusses methods for reducing and correcting errors and recovering from failed operations. Lastly it describes an analysis of the long distance transmission of the coherent state qubits and shows how transmission errors can be corrected.

Sep 15, 20220 citations

Experimental Implementation of Efficient Linear Optics Quantum Computation

Gerard J Milburn, Timothy C. Ralph, Andrew G. White

One of the earliest proposals for implementing quantum computation was based on encoding each qubit in two optical modes, each containing exactly one photon. However, it is extremely difficult to unitarily couple two optical modes containing few photons. In 2001, Knill, Laflamme, and Milburn (KLM) found a way to circumvent this restriction and implement efficient quantum computation using only passive linear optics, photodetectors, and single photon sources. This efficient linear optical quantum computing (LOQC) is distinct from other linear optical schemes that are not efficiently scalable. The technological requirements for even the simplest gates in the KLM proposal initially seemed out of reach. However, Ralph, White, Munro and Milburn soon showed that, in principle, demonstrations of key gates and techniques could be achieved with current technology. The objective of the research undertaken in this project was to produce, in three years, a prototype two-qubit gate for photons using the KLM linear optics quantum computation approach, and to develop a blue-print for a multiple qubit device that might be implemented over a longer time scale. A non-deterministic two-qubit gate was demonstrated that operates with high fidelity. A number of key tasks were demonstrated using this gate, and several theoretical investigations of short, medium, and longer term issues for the LOQC approach were successfully completed.

Nov 25, 20040 citations