Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comparison of gapless mean-field theories for trapped Bose-Einstein condensates

Nick P. Proukakis, S. A. Morgan, Seok Jin Choi, Keith R. Burnett

Published Sep 1, 1998• 61 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We present two gapless mean-field theories for trapped Bose-Einstein condensates, and compare them to the better known Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB)-Popov approach. The proposed theories are based on suitable inclusion of the simplest anomalous average of the Bose field operator. This leads to an effective interaction between two atoms which is both temperature and density dependent, as opposed to the HFB-Popov approach, for which it is constant. These theories are compared to the HFB-Popov approach for a trapped one-dimensional condensate of 2000 atoms. The density profiles and excitation frequencies of the proposed theories differ from the corresponding HFB-Popov ones by at most a few percent.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.58.2435

Related papers

Comparison of mean-field theories for vortices in trapped Bose-Einstein condensates

S M M Virtanen, Tapio Simula, M M Salomaa

We compute structures of vortex configurations in a harmonically trapped Bose-Einstein condensed atom gas within three different gapless self-consistent mean-field theories. Outside the vortex core region, the density profiles for the condensate and the thermal gas derived from the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov-Popov theory are found to differ by only a few per cent from those derived from two of its recently proposed gapless extensions. In the core region, however, the differences between the density profiles are substantial. The structural differences are reflected in the energies of the quasiparticle states localized near the vortex core. In particular, the predictions for the energy of the lowest quasiparticle excitation derived from the theoretical models investigated differ considerably.

arXiv:cond-mat/0108462•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Aug 24, 2001•13 citations

Gapless mean-field theory of Bose-Einstein condensates

David A. W. Hutchinson, Keith R. Burnett, R. J. Dodd +6 more

We present a topical review of the development of finite-temperature field theories of Bose-Einstein condensation in weakly interacting atomic gases. We highlight the difficulties in obtaining a consistent finite-temperature theory that has a gapless excitation spectrum in accordance with Goldstone's theorem and which is free from both ultraviolet and infrared divergences. We present results from the two consistent theories developed so far. These are the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov theory within the Popov approximation and a many-body T -matrix approach which we have termed gapless-Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (GHFB). Comparison with the available experimental results is made and the remaining difficulties are highlighted.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Sep 14, 2000•87 citations

Bose condensates in a harmonic trap near the critical temperature

T. H. Bergeman, David L. Feder, Nandor L. Balazs +1 more

The mean-field properties of finite-temperature Bose-Einstein gases confined in spherically symmetric harmonic traps are surveyed numerically. The solutions of the Gross-Pitaevskii (GP) and Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) equations for the condensate and low-lying quasiparticle excitations are calculated self-consistently using the discrete variable representation, while the most high-lying states are obtained with a local-density approximation. Consistency of the theory for temperatures through the Bose condensation point ${T}_{c}$ requires that the thermodynamic chemical potential differ from the eigenvalue of the GP equation; the appropriate modifications lead to results that are continuous as a function of the particle interactions. The HFB equations are made gapless either by invoking the Popov approximation or by renormalizing the particle interactions. The latter approach effectively reduces the strength of the effective scattering length ${a}_{\mathrm{sc}},$ increases the number of condensate atoms at each temperature, and raises the value of ${T}_{c}$ relative to the Popov approximation. The renormalization effect increases approximately with the log of the atom number, and is most pronounced at temperatures near ${T}_{c}.$ Comparisons with the results of quantum Monte Carlo calculations and various local-density approximations are presented, and experimental consequences are discussed.

arXiv:cond-mat/0001079•Physical Review A•May 11, 2000•31 citations

Self-consistent Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov approach for bosons: self-eliminating divergence and pure pair condensate

M. S. Bulakhov, A. S. Peletminskii

We investigate the thermodynamic properties of an interacting Bose gas with a condensate within the energy-functional formulation of the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) approach. For a contact interaction, we derive a self-consistent solution to the HFB equations that intrinsically eliminates divergence. This solution characterizes the equilibrium state featuring a condensate of correlated pairs of particles. We analyze the temperature dependence of key thermodynamic quantities such as condensate density, chemical potential, entropy, pressure, specific heat capacity at constant volume, and isothermal compressibility and compare them with predictions from the Popov approximation (PA). We predict that the transition temperature shifts to higher values due interactions, with the HFB approach yielding a larger shift than the PA. Analysis of the compressibility indicates that a pure pair condensate is unstable, and the stable equilibrium corresponds to only a mixture of single-particle and pair condensates.

arXiv:2506.13413•Jun 16, 2025•0 citations

Finite-temperature theory of the trapped two-dimensional Bose gas

Christopher Gies, Brandon P. van Zyl, S. A. Morgan +1 more

We present a Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) theoretical treatment of the two-dimensional trapped Bose gas and indicate how semiclassical approximations to this and other formalisms have lead to confusion. We numerically obtain results for the quantum-mechanical HFB theory within the Popov approximation and show that the presence of the trap stabilizes the condensate against long wavelength fluctuations. These results are used to show where phase fluctuations lead to the formation of a quasicondensate.

arXiv:cond-mat/0308177•Physical Review A•Feb 25, 2004•47 citations

Effect of the thermal gas component on the stability of vortices in trapped Bose Einstein condensates

Suvi Mirjami Virtanen, M.M. Salomaa

We study the stability of vortices in trapped single-component Bose–Einstein condensates within self-consistent mean-field theories; in particular, we consider the Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov–Popov theory and its recently proposed gapless extensions. It is shown that for sufficiently repulsively interacting systems the anomalous negative-energy modes related to vortex instabilities are lifted to positive energies due to partial filling of the vortex core with noncondensed gas. Such behaviour implies that within these theories the vortex states are eventually stable against the transfer of condensate matter to the anomalous core modes. This self-stabilization of vortices, shown to occur under very general circumstances, is contrasted to the predictions of the non-self-consistent Bogoliubov approximation, which is known to exhibit anomalous modes for all vortex configurations and thus implying instability of these states. In addition, the shortcomings of these approximations in describing the properties of vortices are analysed, and the need for a self-consistent theory taking properly into account the coupled dynamics of the condensate and the noncondensate atoms is emphasized.

arXiv:cond-mat/0203257•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Sep 17, 2002•5 citations
We present two gapless mean-field theories for trapped Bose-Einstein condensates, and compare them to the better known Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB)-Popov approach. The proposed theories are based on suitable inclusion of the simplest anomalous average of the Bose field operator. This leads to an effective interaction between two atoms which is both temperature and density dependent, as opposed to the HFB-Popov approach, for which it is constant. These theories are compared to the HFB-Popov approach for a trapped one-dimensional condensate of 2000 atoms. The density profiles and excitation frequencies of the proposed theories differ from the corresponding HFB-Popov ones by at most a few percent.
We compute structures of vortex configurations in a harmonically trapped Bose-Einstein condensed atom gas within three different gapless self-consistent mean-field theories. Outside the vortex core region, the density profiles for the condensate and the thermal gas derived from the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov-Popov theory are found to differ by only a few per cent from those derived from two of its recently proposed gapless extensions. In the core region, however, the differences between the density profiles are substantial. The structural differences are reflected in the energies of the quasiparticle states localized near the vortex core. In particular, the predictions for the energy of the lowest quasiparticle excitation derived from the theoretical models investigated differ considerably.
We present a topical review of the development of finite-temperature field theories of Bose-Einstein condensation in weakly interacting atomic gases. We highlight the difficulties in obtaining a consistent finite-temperature theory that has a gapless excitation spectrum in accordance with Goldstone's theorem and which is free from both ultraviolet and infrared divergences. We present results from the two consistent theories developed so far. These are the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov theory within the Popov approximation and a many-body T -matrix approach which we have termed gapless-Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (GHFB). Comparison with the available experimental results is made and the remaining difficulties are highlighted.
The mean-field properties of finite-temperature Bose-Einstein gases confined in spherically symmetric harmonic traps are surveyed numerically. The solutions of the Gross-Pitaevskii (GP) and Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) equations for the condensate and low-lying quasiparticle excitations are calculated self-consistently using the discrete variable representation, while the most high-lying states are obtained with a local-density approximation. Consistency of the theory for temperatures through the Bose condensation point Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ requires that the thermodynamic chemical potential differ from the eigenvalue of the GP equation; the appropriate modifications lead to results that are continuous as a function of the particle interactions. The HFB equations are made gapless either by invoking the Popov approximation or by renormalizing the particle interactions. The latter approach effectively reduces the strength of the effective scattering length asc,{a}_{\mathrm{sc}},asc​, increases the number of condensate atoms at each temperature, and raises the value of Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ relative to the Popov approximation. The renormalization effect increases approximately with the log of the atom number, and is most pronounced at temperatures near Tc.{T}_{c}.Tc​. Comparisons with the results of quantum Monte Carlo calculations and various local-density approximations are presented, and experimental consequences are discussed.
We investigate the thermodynamic properties of an interacting Bose gas with a condensate within the energy-functional formulation of the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) approach. For a contact interaction, we derive a self-consistent solution to the HFB equations that intrinsically eliminates divergence. This solution characterizes the equilibrium state featuring a condensate of correlated pairs of particles. We analyze the temperature dependence of key thermodynamic quantities such as condensate density, chemical potential, entropy, pressure, specific heat capacity at constant volume, and isothermal compressibility and compare them with predictions from the Popov approximation (PA). We predict that the transition temperature shifts to higher values due interactions, with the HFB approach yielding a larger shift than the PA. Analysis of the compressibility indicates that a pure pair condensate is unstable, and the stable equilibrium corresponds to only a mixture of single-particle and pair condensates.
We present a Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) theoretical treatment of the two-dimensional trapped Bose gas and indicate how semiclassical approximations to this and other formalisms have lead to confusion. We numerically obtain results for the quantum-mechanical HFB theory within the Popov approximation and show that the presence of the trap stabilizes the condensate against long wavelength fluctuations. These results are used to show where phase fluctuations lead to the formation of a quasicondensate.
We study the stability of vortices in trapped single-component Bose–Einstein condensates within self-consistent mean-field theories; in particular, we consider the Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov–Popov theory and its recently proposed gapless extensions. It is shown that for sufficiently repulsively interacting systems the anomalous negative-energy modes related to vortex instabilities are lifted to positive energies due to partial filling of the vortex core with noncondensed gas. Such behaviour implies that within these theories the vortex states are eventually stable against the transfer of condensate matter to the anomalous core modes. This self-stabilization of vortices, shown to occur under very general circumstances, is contrasted to the predictions of the non-self-consistent Bogoliubov approximation, which is known to exhibit anomalous modes for all vortex configurations and thus implying instability of these states. In addition, the shortcomings of these approximations in describing the properties of vortices are analysed, and the need for a self-consistent theory taking properly into account the coupled dynamics of the condensate and the noncondensate atoms is emphasized.