Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The New Scientist

Is there a language problem with quantum physics?

David Peat

Published Jan 1, 2008• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1016/s0262-4079(08)60049-4

Related papers

Some problems concerning language and physics

Adonai S. Sant’Anna, Gabriel Guerrer

Synthese•Nov 20, 2006•0 citations

A Non-Intuitionist’s Approach To The Interpretation Problem Of Quantum Mechanics

Hans Herlof Grelland

A philosophy of physics called “linguistic empiricism” is presented and applied to the interpretation problem of quantum mechanics. This philosophical position is based on the works of Jacques Derrida. The main propositions are (i) that meaning, included the meaning attached to observations, are language‐dependent and (ii) that mathematics in physics should be considered as a proper language, not necessary translatable to a more basic language of intuition and immediate experience. This has fundamental implications for quantum mechanics, which is a mathematically coherent and consistent theory; its interpretation problem is associated with its lack of physical images expressible in ordinary language.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2005•2 citations

Is there a Problem of Interpreting Quantum Mechanics?

Howard Stein

Noûs•Feb 1, 1970•23 citations

Measurement Problem from the Perspective of Wittgenstein’s Philosophy

Tadashi Nakajima

We analyze the measurement problem in quantum mechanics from two aspects of Wittgenstein’s philosophy. First, Wittgenstein emphasizes how the first false step can be voided so that a philosophical problem is dissolved, rather than solved. In the unsuccessful theories of the measurement problem, the postulate of classicality of apparatus (PCA) turned out to be the first false step implicitly adopted. By discarding the PCA and by adopting the microscopic quantum jump interpretation simultaneously, the measurement problem itself disappeared completely. Second, from Wittgenstein’s view of languages, the microscopic world is described by quantum mechanics, whose language is the Schrödinger equation, while the macroscopic world is described by classical physics, whose language is either calculus for Newtonian mechanics or vector analysis for electromagnetism. Both worlds are described by mathematical languages, but they are distinct. The measurement problem deals with the transition from microscopic to macroscopic. There is no single physical theory to explain this transition, and there is no corresponding mathematical language to describe it. This shows why the measurement problem must be described by an ordinary language in use. As concrete examples of the unsuccessful theories, we discuss the works of Niels Bohr and John von Neumann. This is a unique situation in which philosophy is used to assess the validity of physical theories. Finally, we show the classicality of a one-particle state with an extreme number of bosons. Therefore, there is no change in language in a macroscopic quantum jump.

Qeios•Aug 6, 2025•3 citations

Quantum physics and language

Jean-Marc Lévy-Leblond

Physica B+C•Jul 1, 1988•25 citations

Measurement Problem from the Perspective of Wittgenstein’s Philosophy

Tadashi Nakajima

We analyze the measurement problem in quantum mechanics from two aspects of Wittgenstein’s philosophy. First, Wittgenstein emphasizes how the first false step can be voided so that a philosophical problem is dissolved, rather than solved. In the unsuccessful theories of the measurement problem, the postulate of classicality of apparatus(PCA) turned out to be the first false step implicitly adopted. By discarding the PCA and by adopting the microscopic quantum jump interpretation simultaneously, the measurement problem itself disappeared completely. Second, from Wittgenstein’s view of languages, the microscopic world is described by quantum mechanics whose language is Schrödinger equation, while the macroscopic world is described by classical physics whose language is either calculus for Newtonian mechanics or vector analysis for electromagnetism. Both worlds are described by mathematical languages, but they are distinct. The measurement problem deals with the transition from microscopic to macroscopic. There is no single physical theory to explain this transition and there is no corresponding mathematical language to describe it. This shows why the measurement problem must be described by an ordinary language in use. As concrete examples of the unsuccessful theories, we discuss the works of Niels Bohr and John von Neumann. This is a unique situation in which philosophy is used to assess the validity of physical theories.

Qeios•Mar 17, 2026•0 citations
A philosophy of physics called “linguistic empiricism” is presented and applied to the interpretation problem of quantum mechanics. This philosophical position is based on the works of Jacques Derrida. The main propositions are (i) that meaning, included the meaning attached to observations, are language‐dependent and (ii) that mathematics in physics should be considered as a proper language, not necessary translatable to a more basic language of intuition and immediate experience. This has fundamental implications for quantum mechanics, which is a mathematically coherent and consistent theory; its interpretation problem is associated with its lack of physical images expressible in ordinary language.
We analyze the measurement problem in quantum mechanics from two aspects of Wittgenstein’s philosophy. First, Wittgenstein emphasizes how the first false step can be voided so that a philosophical problem is dissolved, rather than solved. In the unsuccessful theories of the measurement problem, the postulate of classicality of apparatus (PCA) turned out to be the first false step implicitly adopted. By discarding the PCA and by adopting the microscopic quantum jump interpretation simultaneously, the measurement problem itself disappeared completely. Second, from Wittgenstein’s view of languages, the microscopic world is described by quantum mechanics, whose language is the Schrödinger equation, while the macroscopic world is described by classical physics, whose language is either calculus for Newtonian mechanics or vector analysis for electromagnetism. Both worlds are described by mathematical languages, but they are distinct. The measurement problem deals with the transition from microscopic to macroscopic. There is no single physical theory to explain this transition, and there is no corresponding mathematical language to describe it. This shows why the measurement problem must be described by an ordinary language in use. As concrete examples of the unsuccessful theories, we discuss the works of Niels Bohr and John von Neumann. This is a unique situation in which philosophy is used to assess the validity of physical theories. Finally, we show the classicality of a one-particle state with an extreme number of bosons. Therefore, there is no change in language in a macroscopic quantum jump.
We analyze the measurement problem in quantum mechanics from two aspects of Wittgenstein’s philosophy. First, Wittgenstein emphasizes how the first false step can be voided so that a philosophical problem is dissolved, rather than solved. In the unsuccessful theories of the measurement problem, the postulate of classicality of apparatus(PCA) turned out to be the first false step implicitly adopted. By discarding the PCA and by adopting the microscopic quantum jump interpretation simultaneously, the measurement problem itself disappeared completely. Second, from Wittgenstein’s view of languages, the microscopic world is described by quantum mechanics whose language is Schrödinger equation, while the macroscopic world is described by classical physics whose language is either calculus for Newtonian mechanics or vector analysis for electromagnetism. Both worlds are described by mathematical languages, but they are distinct. The measurement problem deals with the transition from microscopic to macroscopic. There is no single physical theory to explain this transition and there is no corresponding mathematical language to describe it. This shows why the measurement problem must be described by an ordinary language in use. As concrete examples of the unsuccessful theories, we discuss the works of Niels Bohr and John von Neumann. This is a unique situation in which philosophy is used to assess the validity of physical theories.