Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Decrease of the tunneling time and violation of the Hartman effect for large barriers

V. S. Olkhovsky, V. Petrillo, Aleksandr K. Zaichenko

Published Sep 24, 2004• 26 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The explicit formulation of the initial conditions of the definition of the wave-packet tunneling time is proposed. This formulation takes adequately into account the irreversibility of the wave-packet space-time spreading. Moreover, it explains the violations of the Hartman effect, leading to a strong decrease of the tunneling times up to negative values for wave packets with large momentum spreads due to strong wave-packet time spreading.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.70.034103

Related papers

Selection of the initial conditions in the tunneling time definition

Aleksandr K. Zaichenko

The necessity of changing of the initial conditions in the Olkhovsky-Recami definition of the tunneling time is justified. The new initial conditions are proposed which adequately taking into account the irreversibility of the wave packets spreading. The expression for the tunneling time with the new initial conditions is reduced to the form which is convenient for the performing and controlling the accuracy of calculations.

Nuclear Physics and Atomic Energy•Jun 30, 2004•0 citations

Evolution of a wave packet scattered by a one-dimensional potential

А. Ж. Хачатрян, Al.G. Alexanyan, V. A. Khoetsyan +1 more

We consider the evolution of a wave packet that is made up of a group of the wave functions describing the stationary scattering process and tunnels through a one-dimensional potential of arbitrary form. As the main characteristics of the time difference of the tunnelling process, use is made of the propagation speed of the wave-packet maximum. We show that the known Hartman formula for the tunnelling time corresponds to the wave packet with a wavenumber-uniform spectral composition in the case, when the phase and transmission coefficient modulus dispersions are taken into account only in the linear approximation. The amplitude of the main peak of the transmitted wave intensity is proven to be independent of the tunnelling time and is determined by the transmission coefficient of the spectral component at the carrier frequency and the spectral width of the wave packet. In the limit of an infinitely wide potential barrier the amplitude of the wave-packet maximum is shown to tend to zero slower than the tunnelling time tends to its asymptotic value, i.e., indeed we deal with the paradox of an infinitely large propagation speed of a wave disturbance through the barrier.

Quantum Electronics•Jun 30, 2013•1 citation

Sub-barrier quantum tunneling: eliminating the MacColl-Hartman paradox

Atom Zh. Muradyan

I show that the MacColl-Hartman effect, namely, the saturation of the group delay time of sub-barrier quantum tunneling as a function of the barrier width, comes from the saturating behavior of a more fundamental concept - the phase of the stationary wave function. The explanation of saturation is given based on the decomposition of the stationary wave function into the spectrum of wave numbers and formulation of the initial condition for the direction of propagation of the incident matter wave. It is also shown that the saturation plateau of MacColl and Hartman actually doesn't continue indefinitely, but has a finite length. After the plateau, the sub-barrier tunneling time monotonically increases with increasing width of the potential, and this applies both to the maximum's of the wave packet and to the average tunneling time.

arXiv:2108.03054•Aug 6, 2021•0 citations

Barrier penetration by wave packets and the tunneling times

M. S. Marinov, Bilha Segev

An interesting analytical expression is obtained for the coordinate probability distribution of a wave packet transmitted through a potential barrier. In the large-time asymptotics the distribution is given in terms of the transmission amplitude and the phase-space quasidistribution of the initial (not necessarily pure) state. The distortion of a (broad) wave packet due to the barrier penetration is determined by two timelike parameters, given by the energy derivative of the complex transmission amplitude. The resulting change of the packet shape reveals a dependence on the detector position and incorporates a possible speed-up effect and a negative dispersion.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1997•22 citations

Space and momentum representation analysis of Hartman’s effect in wave packet transmission

María F. González, Josep María Bofill, Xavier Giménez +1 more

The Hartman effect is analyzed in both the position and momentum representations of the problem. The importance of Wigner tunneling and deep tunneling is singled out. It is shown quantitatively how the barrier acts as a filter for low momenta (quantum speed up) as the width increases, and a detailed mechanism is proposed. Superluminal transmission is also discussed.

Physical Review A•Sep 3, 2008•4 citations

From the paradoxes of the standard wave-packet analysis to the definition of tunneling times for particles

Nikolay Leonidovich Chuprikov

We develop a new variant of the wave-packet analysis and solve the tunneling time problem for one particle. Our approach suggests an individual asymptotic description of the quantum subensembles of transmitted and reflected particles both at the final and initial stage of tunneling. We find the initial states of both subensembles, which are non-orthogonal. The latter reflects ultimately the fact that at the initial stage of tunneling it is impossible to predict whether a particle will be transmitted through or reflected off the barrier. At the same time, in this case, one can say about the to-be-transmitted and to-be-reflected subensembles of particles. We show that before the interaction of the incident packet with the barrier both the number of particles and the expectation value of the particle's momentum are constant for each subensemble. Besides, these asymptotic quantities coincide with those of the corresponding scattered subensemble. On the basis of this formalism we define individual delay times for both scattering channels. Taking into account the spreading of wave packets, we define the low bound of the scattering time to describe the whole quantum ensemble of particles. All three characteristic times are derived in terms of the expectation values of the position and momentum operators. The condition which must be fulfilled for completed scattering events is derived. We propose also the scheme of a {\it gedanken} experiment that allows one to verify our approach.

arXiv:quant-ph/0106129•Jun 23, 2001•0 citations
The explicit formulation of the initial conditions of the definition of the wave-packet tunneling time is proposed. This formulation takes adequately into account the irreversibility of the wave-packet space-time spreading. Moreover, it explains the violations of the Hartman effect, leading to a strong decrease of the tunneling times up to negative values for wave packets with large momentum spreads due to strong wave-packet time spreading.
We consider the evolution of a wave packet that is made up of a group of the wave functions describing the stationary scattering process and tunnels through a one-dimensional potential of arbitrary form. As the main characteristics of the time difference of the tunnelling process, use is made of the propagation speed of the wave-packet maximum. We show that the known Hartman formula for the tunnelling time corresponds to the wave packet with a wavenumber-uniform spectral composition in the case, when the phase and transmission coefficient modulus dispersions are taken into account only in the linear approximation. The amplitude of the main peak of the transmitted wave intensity is proven to be independent of the tunnelling time and is determined by the transmission coefficient of the spectral component at the carrier frequency and the spectral width of the wave packet. In the limit of an infinitely wide potential barrier the amplitude of the wave-packet maximum is shown to tend to zero slower than the tunnelling time tends to its asymptotic value, i.e., indeed we deal with the paradox of an infinitely large propagation speed of a wave disturbance through the barrier.
I show that the MacColl-Hartman effect, namely, the saturation of the group delay time of sub-barrier quantum tunneling as a function of the barrier width, comes from the saturating behavior of a more fundamental concept - the phase of the stationary wave function. The explanation of saturation is given based on the decomposition of the stationary wave function into the spectrum of wave numbers and formulation of the initial condition for the direction of propagation of the incident matter wave. It is also shown that the saturation plateau of MacColl and Hartman actually doesn't continue indefinitely, but has a finite length. After the plateau, the sub-barrier tunneling time monotonically increases with increasing width of the potential, and this applies both to the maximum's of the wave packet and to the average tunneling time.
An interesting analytical expression is obtained for the coordinate probability distribution of a wave packet transmitted through a potential barrier. In the large-time asymptotics the distribution is given in terms of the transmission amplitude and the phase-space quasidistribution of the initial (not necessarily pure) state. The distortion of a (broad) wave packet due to the barrier penetration is determined by two timelike parameters, given by the energy derivative of the complex transmission amplitude. The resulting change of the packet shape reveals a dependence on the detector position and incorporates a possible speed-up effect and a negative dispersion.
We develop a new variant of the wave-packet analysis and solve the tunneling time problem for one particle. Our approach suggests an individual asymptotic description of the quantum subensembles of transmitted and reflected particles both at the final and initial stage of tunneling. We find the initial states of both subensembles, which are non-orthogonal. The latter reflects ultimately the fact that at the initial stage of tunneling it is impossible to predict whether a particle will be transmitted through or reflected off the barrier. At the same time, in this case, one can say about the to-be-transmitted and to-be-reflected subensembles of particles. We show that before the interaction of the incident packet with the barrier both the number of particles and the expectation value of the particle's momentum are constant for each subensemble. Besides, these asymptotic quantities coincide with those of the corresponding scattered subensemble. On the basis of this formalism we define individual delay times for both scattering channels. Taking into account the spreading of wave packets, we define the low bound of the scattering time to describe the whole quantum ensemble of particles. All three characteristic times are derived in terms of the expectation values of the position and momentum operators. The condition which must be fulfilled for completed scattering events is derived. We propose also the scheme of a {\it gedanken} experiment that allows one to verify our approach.