Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Space and momentum representation analysis of Hartman’s effect in wave packet transmission

María F. González, Josep María Bofill, Xavier Giménez, F. Borondo

Published Sep 3, 2008• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Hartman effect is analyzed in both the position and momentum representations of the problem. The importance of Wigner tunneling and deep tunneling is singled out. It is shown quantitatively how the barrier acts as a filter for low momenta (quantum speed up) as the width increases, and a detailed mechanism is proposed. Superluminal transmission is also discussed.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.78.032102

Related papers

Transmission times of wave packets tunneling through barriers

Yu. E. Lozovik, Alexey V. Filinov

The transmission of wave packets through barriers by tunneling is studied in detail by the method of quantum molecular dynamics. The distribution of the arrival times of a tunneling packet in front of and behind a barrier and the momentum distribution function of the packet are calculated. The average position and average momentum of the packet and their spread are investigated. It is found that below the barrier a part of the packet is reflected, and a Gaussian barrier increases the average momentum of the transmitted packet and its spread in momentum space.

arXiv:quant-ph/9905047•Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•May 1, 1999•21 citations

Spectral Pinning of the Tunneling-Time Variance Width-Independent Temporal Spread and Barrier-Induced Reshaping Beyond the Hartman Effect

Henrique Coelho Barbosa

A quantum particle's traversal time through a forbidden barrier has long been debated, with definitions varying across Wigner, Büttiker–Landauer, and path-integral frameworks. Prior work focused on the mean delay and the Hartman effect—where the average time becomes constant for opaque barriers, implying superluminal speed. This study shifts focus from the mean to the variance of arrival time. For a finite-bandwidth wave packet, we prove that in the narrow-band limit, the transmitted arrival-time variance becomes independent of barrier width and equals that of the incident packet—a spectral-pinning effect. This universal plateau, confirmed numerically within 0.5% accuracy, overturns the expectation that opaque barriers broaden pulses. Instead, the width is set by the incident spectrum via time-energy uncertainty. Beyond this limit, the barrier acts as a spectral filter, slightly narrowing the variance with opacity while shifting the mean above the Hartman plateau. These predictions are experimentally testable via attoclock measurements, reframing tunneling time as a robust statistical property rather than a problematic mean value.

•Jul 10, 2026•0 citations

Spectral Pinning of the Tunneling-Time Variance: Width-Independent Temporal Spread and Barrier-Induced Reshaping Beyond the Hartman Effect

Henrique Coelho Barbosa

The time a quantum particle spends traversing a classically forbidden region is among the most persistently contested observables in quantum theory, its definition splintering across the Wigner phase time, the Büttiker–Landauer clock, and complex-time path-integral constructions. The debate has centered almost exclusively on a single number—the mean delay—and on the Hartman effect, whereby that mean saturates to a width-independent constant for an opaque barrier, suggesting an unbounded and apparently superluminal traversal speed. Yet an attoclock measures not a number but a distribution: the observable imprinted on the photoelectron spectrum is a temporal spread, not a delay. The narrow-band limit of this variance is fixed by the time-energy uncertainty relation alone, $\text{Var}(\tau) \to \hbar^2/4\Delta E^2$, a general property of any finite-bandwidth wave packet. What has not been shown is that this floor survives intact through a barrier deep in the Hartman-opaque regime, where the mean delay has already saturated and where naive intuition expects the pulse to broaden. We prove, for the rectangular barrier, that the transmitted variance remains locked onto this incident-packet value independently of the barrier width $d$—a spectral-pinning theorem. Equivalently, the dimensionless product $\text{Var}(\tau)\Delta E^2$ collapses onto a single universal plateau shared by all bandwidths, a data collapse confirmed numerically to better than 0.5% across two decades of opacity and verified against the predicted inverse-square bandwidth scaling $\text{Var}{\text{narrow}}/\text{Var}{\text{broad}} = (\Delta E_{\text{broad}}/\Delta E_{\text{narrow}})^2$ to within a few percent, the small residual excess (28.56 versus 25) being itself a quantitative signature of barrier-induced reshaping. The genuine new result is the finite-bandwidth correction responsible for this excess: the opaque barrier acts as a coherent spectral filter—a tunneling analogue of the gain-narrowing mechanism familiar from ultrafast optics—that reweights the transmitted band and causes the variance to decrease weakly with opacity [log-log exponent $\alpha \approx +0.070$ in the convention $\text{Var} \propto (\kappa d)^{-\alpha}$], while the mean arrival time is pushed above the Hartman plateau. We derive the leading filter coefficient $\lambda_2$ in closed form, verify it against an independent, exactly solvable smooth barrier (Eckart), and connect both the pinned floor and its filtering correction to experiment through the attoclock map $\sigma_\theta \simeq \omega \sigma_\tau$. The result recasts the tunneling-time question from the fragile arithmetic of a saturating mean to the robust, universal statistics of a spectrally pinned—and quantifiably filtered—width.

•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations

Hartman effect and weak measurements that are not really weak

D. Sokolovski, Elena V. Akhmatskaya

We show that in wave packet tunneling, localization of the transmitted particle amounts to a quantum measurement of the delay it experiences in the barrier. With no external degree of freedom involved, the envelope of the wave packet plays the role of the initial pointer state. Under tunneling conditions such ``self-measurement'' is necessarily weak, and the Hartman effect just reflects the general tendency of weak values to diverge, as postselection in the final state becomes improbable. We also demonstrate that it is a good precision, or a `not really weak' quantum measurement: no matter how wide the barrier $d$, it is possible to transmit a wave packet with a width $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ small compared to the observed advancement. As is the case with all weak measurements, the probability of transmission rapidly decreases with the ratio $\ensuremath{\sigma}/d$.

arXiv:1103.5620•Physical Review A•Aug 2, 2011•7 citations

Decrease of the tunneling time and violation of the Hartman effect for large barriers

V. S. Olkhovsky, V. Petrillo, Aleksandr K. Zaichenko

The explicit formulation of the initial conditions of the definition of the wave-packet tunneling time is proposed. This formulation takes adequately into account the irreversibility of the wave-packet space-time spreading. Moreover, it explains the violations of the Hartman effect, leading to a strong decrease of the tunneling times up to negative values for wave packets with large momentum spreads due to strong wave-packet time spreading.

Physical Review A•Sep 24, 2004•26 citations

Reevaluating the Hartman effect for field emission

Kevin L. Jensen, Andrew Shabaev, Jeanne M. Riga +3 more

An electron wave packet tunneling through a barrier has a transmission (or ``group delay'') time ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{g}$ that, for a rectangular barrier, is commonly held to become independent of the barrier width $L$ as the width increases (the McColl-Hartman effect). In the present study, it is shown that first, the McColl-Hartman effect for a rectangular barrier is dependent upon $L$ as the Gamow tunneling factor $\ensuremath{\theta}(k)$ vanishes, and ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{g}$ is only independent of $L$ when $\ensuremath{\theta}(k)$ is large; and second, for a triangular barrier to model field emission, although ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{g}$ can be large for small field, it vanishes when the energy matches the barrier height.

Physical Review A•Dec 9, 2021•9 citations
The Hartman effect is analyzed in both the position and momentum representations of the problem. The importance of Wigner tunneling and deep tunneling is singled out. It is shown quantitatively how the barrier acts as a filter for low momenta (quantum speed up) as the width increases, and a detailed mechanism is proposed. Superluminal transmission is also discussed.
The transmission of wave packets through barriers by tunneling is studied in detail by the method of quantum molecular dynamics. The distribution of the arrival times of a tunneling packet in front of and behind a barrier and the momentum distribution function of the packet are calculated. The average position and average momentum of the packet and their spread are investigated. It is found that below the barrier a part of the packet is reflected, and a Gaussian barrier increases the average momentum of the transmitted packet and its spread in momentum space.
A quantum particle's traversal time through a forbidden barrier has long been debated, with definitions varying across Wigner, Büttiker–Landauer, and path-integral frameworks. Prior work focused on the mean delay and the Hartman effect—where the average time becomes constant for opaque barriers, implying superluminal speed. This study shifts focus from the mean to the variance of arrival time. For a finite-bandwidth wave packet, we prove that in the narrow-band limit, the transmitted arrival-time variance becomes independent of barrier width and equals that of the incident packet—a spectral-pinning effect. This universal plateau, confirmed numerically within 0.5% accuracy, overturns the expectation that opaque barriers broaden pulses. Instead, the width is set by the incident spectrum via time-energy uncertainty. Beyond this limit, the barrier acts as a spectral filter, slightly narrowing the variance with opacity while shifting the mean above the Hartman plateau. These predictions are experimentally testable via attoclock measurements, reframing tunneling time as a robust statistical property rather than a problematic mean value.
The time a quantum particle spends traversing a classically forbidden region is among the most persistently contested observables in quantum theory, its definition splintering across the Wigner phase time, the Büttiker–Landauer clock, and complex-time path-integral constructions. The debate has centered almost exclusively on a single number—the mean delay—and on the Hartman effect, whereby that mean saturates to a width-independent constant for an opaque barrier, suggesting an unbounded and apparently superluminal traversal speed. Yet an attoclock measures not a number but a distribution: the observable imprinted on the photoelectron spectrum is a temporal spread, not a delay. The narrow-band limit of this variance is fixed by the time-energy uncertainty relation alone, Var(τ)→ℏ2/4ΔE2\text{Var}(\tau) \to \hbar^2/4\Delta E^2Var(τ)→ℏ2/4ΔE2, a general property of any finite-bandwidth wave packet. What has not been shown is that this floor survives intact through a barrier deep in the Hartman-opaque regime, where the mean delay has already saturated and where naive intuition expects the pulse to broaden. We prove, for the rectangular barrier, that the transmitted variance remains locked onto this incident-packet value independently of the barrier width ddd—a spectral-pinning theorem. Equivalently, the dimensionless product Var(τ)ΔE2\text{Var}(\tau)\Delta E^2Var(τ)ΔE2 collapses onto a single universal plateau shared by all bandwidths, a data collapse confirmed numerically to better than 0.5% across two decades of opacity and verified against the predicted inverse-square bandwidth scaling Varnarrow/Varbroad=(ΔEbroad/ΔEnarrow)2\text{Var}{\text{narrow}}/\text{Var}{\text{broad}} = (\Delta E_{\text{broad}}/\Delta E_{\text{narrow}})^2Varnarrow/Varbroad=(ΔEbroad​/ΔEnarrow​)2 to within a few percent, the small residual excess (28.56 versus 25) being itself a quantitative signature of barrier-induced reshaping. The genuine new result is the finite-bandwidth correction responsible for this excess: the opaque barrier acts as a coherent spectral filter—a tunneling analogue of the gain-narrowing mechanism familiar from ultrafast optics—that reweights the transmitted band and causes the variance to decrease weakly with opacity [log-log exponent α≈+0.070\alpha \approx +0.070α≈+0.070 in the convention Var∝(κd)−α\text{Var} \propto (\kappa d)^{-\alpha}Var∝(κd)−α], while the mean arrival time is pushed above the Hartman plateau. We derive the leading filter coefficient λ2\lambda_2λ2​ in closed form, verify it against an independent, exactly solvable smooth barrier (Eckart), and connect both the pinned floor and its filtering correction to experiment through the attoclock map σθ≃ωστ\sigma_\theta \simeq \omega \sigma_\tauσθ​≃ωστ​. The result recasts the tunneling-time question from the fragile arithmetic of a saturating mean to the robust, universal statistics of a spectrally pinned—and quantifiably filtered—width.
We show that in wave packet tunneling, localization of the transmitted particle amounts to a quantum measurement of the delay it experiences in the barrier. With no external degree of freedom involved, the envelope of the wave packet plays the role of the initial pointer state. Under tunneling conditions such ``self-measurement'' is necessarily weak, and the Hartman effect just reflects the general tendency of weak values to diverge, as postselection in the final state becomes improbable. We also demonstrate that it is a good precision, or a `not really weak' quantum measurement: no matter how wide the barrier ddd, it is possible to transmit a wave packet with a width $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ small compared to the observed advancement. As is the case with all weak measurements, the probability of transmission rapidly decreases with the ratio $\ensuremath{\sigma}/d$.
An electron wave packet tunneling through a barrier has a transmission (or ``group delay'') time ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{g}$ that, for a rectangular barrier, is commonly held to become independent of the barrier width LLL as the width increases (the McColl-Hartman effect). In the present study, it is shown that first, the McColl-Hartman effect for a rectangular barrier is dependent upon LLL as the Gamow tunneling factor $\ensuremath{\theta}(k)$ vanishes, and ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{g}$ is only independent of LLL when $\ensuremath{\theta}(k)$ is large; and second, for a triangular barrier to model field emission, although ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{g}$ can be large for small field, it vanishes when the energy matches the barrier height.