Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Classical Model of the Dirac Electron

A. O. Barut, Nino Zanghı̀

Published Jun 4, 1984• 249 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A covariant, symplectic, classical dynamical system is presented whose quantization, by replacement of the Poisson brackets with commutators, gives precisely the Dirac electron theory. For the classical system the velocity and momentum are independent dynamical variables, as in Dirac electron; it undergoes a real Zitterbewegung so that the spin is the orbital angular momentum of the Zitterbewegung. Thus the longstanding problem of representing the configuration space of quantum spin by a classical model is solved. Three different forms of the dynamical equations are given.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.52.2009

Related papers

Classical Theory of the Dirac Electron

Zvi Grossmann, Asher Peres

This paper contains the Hamiltonian theory of a classical particle displaying all the features of the Dirac electron (spin, Zitterbewegung, etc.) except, of course, for the superposition principle. The particle is described by eight internal canonical variables, of which three are the spin angular momentum vector. The five other variables have no simple physical meaning, but are nevertheless necessary for a consistent theory. The equations of motion are not manifestly covariant, and the Lorentz invariance of the theory is proved by constructing the ten generators of the inhomogeneous Lorentz group.

Physical Review•Dec 1, 1963•21 citations

Relativistic Mechanics Theory for Electrons that Exhibits Spin, Zitterbewegung, Superposition and Produces Dirac's Wave Equation

James L. Beck

A neo-classical relativistic mechanics theory is presented where the spin of an electron is a natural part of its space-time path as a point particle. The fourth-order equation of motion corresponds to the same Lagrangian function in proper time as in special relativity except for an additional spin energy term. The total motion can be decomposed into a sum of a local spin motion about a point and a global motion of this point, called the spin center. The global motion is sub-luminal and obeys Newton's second law in proper time, the time for a clock fixed at the spin center, while the total motion occurs at the speed of light c, consistent with the eigenvalues of Dirac's velocity operators having magnitude c. The local spin motion corresponds to Schrödinger's zitterbewegung and is a perpetual motion, which for a free electron has a circular path in the spin-center frame. In an electro-magnetic field, this spin motion generates magnetic and electric dipole energies through the Lorentz force on the electron's point charge. The corresponding electric dipole energy is consistent with the spin-orbit coupling term in the corrected Pauli non-relativistic Hamiltonian but the magnetic dipole energy is one half of that in Dirac's theory. By defining a spin tensor as the angular momentum of the electron's total motion about its spin center, the fundamental equations of motion can be re-written in an identical form to those of the Barut-Zanghi electron theory. These equations of motion can then be expressed using operators applied to a state function of proper time satisfying a Dirac-Schrödinger spinor equation. The operators produce dynamic variables without any probability implications. For the free electron, the state function satisfies Dirac's relativistic wave equation when the Lorentz transformation is applied to express proper time in terms of an observer's space-time coordinates.

arXiv:2108.07267•Aug 14, 2021•2 citations

Exact Solutions of the Heisenberg Equations and Zitterbewegung of the Electron in a Constant Uniform Magnetic Field

A. O. Barut, Anthony J. Bracken

For a free Dirac electron, the Heisenberg equations define an internal dynamical system in the rest frame, isomorphic to a finite three-dimensional oscillator with a compact SO(5) phase space, such that the spin of the electron is the orbital angular momentum of the internal dynamics (Barut and Bracken 1980, 1981a). In the present work, the change in this internal dynamics due to an external magnetic field is studied. In order that the internal motion can be distinguished from the centre of mass motion, the solutions of the corresponding Hamilton and Heisenberg equations for the relativistic classical motion and the relativistic quantum mechanical spinless motion are also presented. The solutions for the electron exhibit the effect of the spin terms both in the internal motion and external motion, and we are able to identify the properties of the Zitterbewegung in the external field.

Australian Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1982•12 citations

The Frenkel-Kramers Model and the Zitterbewegung in the Extended Heisenberg Picture of the Dirac Electron

Hisaiti Yamasaki

With respect to the principal operators including the sixteen 4-4 matrices of the Dirac electron, two covariant forms of the extended Heisenberg picture can be presented with the “two covariant Hamiltonians HI and HII” of the first and second order, respectively. One form with HII involving the proper electromagnetic moment corresponds perfectly to the Frenkel-Kramers model which was recently treated by the author; the other form with HI containing the Zitterbewegung corresponds partly to the so-called Weyssenhoff-like model. That an amalgamation of the former form and the Zitterbewegung brings immediately the latter is explicitly shown by virtue of a decomposition of the operator of the Dirac electron into two corresponding parts. This decomposition is derived from the author's extension of the Feynman-Bunge-Corben formula for the position operator of the electron and, in case without external fields, it corresponds to the covariant form of the so-called ‘gerade-ungerade’ decomposition. In the case of the free state mixed with positive and negative energy, the Zitterbewegung of operators derived from HI can properly be realized by the expectation values of the operators. In this process, the author's complex hyperbolic metric of velocity which represents a new negative energy state plays an essential role. These results give an important clue to solve the puzzling problem of the construction of a consistent classical model for the Dirac electron, and also may be useful for investigation of ‘internal structure’ of elementary particles as well as their spin.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Feb 1, 1968•4 citations

A New Derivation of Classical Models of the Spinning Electron from the WKB Solutions to the Pauli and Dirac Equations

Hisaiti Yamasaki

The functional form of the wave function with respect to variables appropriate for the WKB approximation is chosen by taking into account the transformation properties of the spinor wave-function.This representation makes it possible, using only the wave equation, to pursue directly the time changes in the variables, i.e. the spin direction, velocity and density, etc., characterizing an electron.These changes correspond straightforwardly to a classical model of the non-relativistic Pauli electron with the proper magnetic moment, and the covariant form of this model, which is just "the Frenkel-Kramers model of the Dirac electron" introduced recently by the author.In this derivation, the existence of freedom of • rotation around the .spinaxis and certain definite angular velocity of this rotation are required.These results and the correspondence obtained may clarify the classical-mechanical significance of the spinor wave-function and also of the spin itself.An explanation is appended of the hyperbolic functions of the velocity metric, which help in the complicated calculations for the Dirac electron. § I. Introduction*) The main part of this paper appeared previously in Rep. Seisanken.No. 22 (1957), 55, in Japanese.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Jul 1, 1966•2 citations

Non-Grassmann "Classicization" of Fermion Dynamics

Steven Kenneth Kauffmann

A carefully motivated symmetric variant of the Poisson bracket in ordinary (not Grassmann) phase space variables is shown to satisfy identities which are in algebraic correspondence with the anticommutation postulates for quantized Fermion systems. "Symplecticity" in terms of this symmetric Poisson bracket implies generalized Hamilton's equations that can only be of Schroedinger type (e.g., the Dirac equation but not the Klein-Gordon or Maxwell equations). This restriction also excludes the old "four-Fermion" theory of beta decay.

arXiv:hep-th/9606164•Jun 25, 1996•0 citations
A covariant, symplectic, classical dynamical system is presented whose quantization, by replacement of the Poisson brackets with commutators, gives precisely the Dirac electron theory. For the classical system the velocity and momentum are independent dynamical variables, as in Dirac electron; it undergoes a real Zitterbewegung so that the spin is the orbital angular momentum of the Zitterbewegung. Thus the longstanding problem of representing the configuration space of quantum spin by a classical model is solved. Three different forms of the dynamical equations are given.
This paper contains the Hamiltonian theory of a classical particle displaying all the features of the Dirac electron (spin, Zitterbewegung, etc.) except, of course, for the superposition principle. The particle is described by eight internal canonical variables, of which three are the spin angular momentum vector. The five other variables have no simple physical meaning, but are nevertheless necessary for a consistent theory. The equations of motion are not manifestly covariant, and the Lorentz invariance of the theory is proved by constructing the ten generators of the inhomogeneous Lorentz group.
A neo-classical relativistic mechanics theory is presented where the spin of an electron is a natural part of its space-time path as a point particle. The fourth-order equation of motion corresponds to the same Lagrangian function in proper time as in special relativity except for an additional spin energy term. The total motion can be decomposed into a sum of a local spin motion about a point and a global motion of this point, called the spin center. The global motion is sub-luminal and obeys Newton's second law in proper time, the time for a clock fixed at the spin center, while the total motion occurs at the speed of light c, consistent with the eigenvalues of Dirac's velocity operators having magnitude c. The local spin motion corresponds to Schrödinger's zitterbewegung and is a perpetual motion, which for a free electron has a circular path in the spin-center frame. In an electro-magnetic field, this spin motion generates magnetic and electric dipole energies through the Lorentz force on the electron's point charge. The corresponding electric dipole energy is consistent with the spin-orbit coupling term in the corrected Pauli non-relativistic Hamiltonian but the magnetic dipole energy is one half of that in Dirac's theory. By defining a spin tensor as the angular momentum of the electron's total motion about its spin center, the fundamental equations of motion can be re-written in an identical form to those of the Barut-Zanghi electron theory. These equations of motion can then be expressed using operators applied to a state function of proper time satisfying a Dirac-Schrödinger spinor equation. The operators produce dynamic variables without any probability implications. For the free electron, the state function satisfies Dirac's relativistic wave equation when the Lorentz transformation is applied to express proper time in terms of an observer's space-time coordinates.
For a free Dirac electron, the Heisenberg equations define an internal dynamical system in the rest frame, isomorphic to a finite three-dimensional oscillator with a compact SO(5) phase space, such that the spin of the electron is the orbital angular momentum of the internal dynamics (Barut and Bracken 1980, 1981a). In the present work, the change in this internal dynamics due to an external magnetic field is studied. In order that the internal motion can be distinguished from the centre of mass motion, the solutions of the corresponding Hamilton and Heisenberg equations for the relativistic classical motion and the relativistic quantum mechanical spinless motion are also presented. The solutions for the electron exhibit the effect of the spin terms both in the internal motion and external motion, and we are able to identify the properties of the Zitterbewegung in the external field.
With respect to the principal operators including the sixteen 4-4 matrices of the Dirac electron, two covariant forms of the extended Heisenberg picture can be presented with the “two covariant Hamiltonians HI and HII” of the first and second order, respectively. One form with HII involving the proper electromagnetic moment corresponds perfectly to the Frenkel-Kramers model which was recently treated by the author; the other form with HI containing the Zitterbewegung corresponds partly to the so-called Weyssenhoff-like model. That an amalgamation of the former form and the Zitterbewegung brings immediately the latter is explicitly shown by virtue of a decomposition of the operator of the Dirac electron into two corresponding parts. This decomposition is derived from the author's extension of the Feynman-Bunge-Corben formula for the position operator of the electron and, in case without external fields, it corresponds to the covariant form of the so-called ‘gerade-ungerade’ decomposition. In the case of the free state mixed with positive and negative energy, the Zitterbewegung of operators derived from HI can properly be realized by the expectation values of the operators. In this process, the author's complex hyperbolic metric of velocity which represents a new negative energy state plays an essential role. These results give an important clue to solve the puzzling problem of the construction of a consistent classical model for the Dirac electron, and also may be useful for investigation of ‘internal structure’ of elementary particles as well as their spin.
The functional form of the wave function with respect to variables appropriate for the WKB approximation is chosen by taking into account the transformation properties of the spinor wave-function.This representation makes it possible, using only the wave equation, to pursue directly the time changes in the variables, i.e. the spin direction, velocity and density, etc., characterizing an electron.These changes correspond straightforwardly to a classical model of the non-relativistic Pauli electron with the proper magnetic moment, and the covariant form of this model, which is just "the Frenkel-Kramers model of the Dirac electron" introduced recently by the author.In this derivation, the existence of freedom of • rotation around the .spinaxis and certain definite angular velocity of this rotation are required.These results and the correspondence obtained may clarify the classical-mechanical significance of the spinor wave-function and also of the spin itself.An explanation is appended of the hyperbolic functions of the velocity metric, which help in the complicated calculations for the Dirac electron. § I. Introduction*) The main part of this paper appeared previously in Rep. Seisanken.No. 22 (1957), 55, in Japanese.
A carefully motivated symmetric variant of the Poisson bracket in ordinary (not Grassmann) phase space variables is shown to satisfy identities which are in algebraic correspondence with the anticommutation postulates for quantized Fermion systems. "Symplecticity" in terms of this symmetric Poisson bracket implies generalized Hamilton's equations that can only be of Schroedinger type (e.g., the Dirac equation but not the Klein-Gordon or Maxwell equations). This restriction also excludes the old "four-Fermion" theory of beta decay.