Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Time delay in tunneling: Sojourn-time approach versus mean-position approach

Wojciech Jaworski, David M. Wardlaw

Published Nov 1, 1988• 18 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Our previous results [Phys. Rev. A 37, 2843 (1988)], based on the concept of sojourn time, for the transmission and reflection time delays in one-dimensional scattering by a potential barrier are compared to the corresponding results of E. H. Hauge, J. P. Falck, and T. A. Fjedly [Phys. Rev. B 36, 4203 (1987)], based on the idea of following the time evolution of the mean position of wave packets. It is shown that the mean-position approach agrees with the more general sojourn-time approach in the limit of well-defined momentum, and that, in general, the two approaches appear to be related in a classical-like manner.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.38.5404

Related papers

Time delay in tunneling: Transmission and reflection time delays

Wojciech Jaworski, David M. Wardlaw

The problem of time delay in one-dimensional quantum-mechanical scattering by a potential barrier is studied in the framework of time-dependent scattering theory. It is shown how the concept of sojourn time can be used to define three separate time delays: the time delay for transmission through the barrier, the time delay for reflection, and the total time delay (i.e., averaged over transmission and reflection). In addition to the anticipated dependence on the S matrix and its energy derivative, the time delays depend on certain parameters which can be interpreted as describing positions of detectors in a gedanken-experiment measurement. The problem of defining separate time delays for transmission and reflection appears to be rooted in the foundations of quantum theory and its interpretation.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1988•69 citations

Interaction times in quantum scattering: The sojourn-time-operator approach versus the Feynman path-integral approach

Wojciech Jaworski, David M. Wardlaw

A ready comparison of the two methods noted in the title is obscured by the very different formalisms that they employ. Our sojourn-time approach [Jaworski and Wardlaw, Phys. Rev. A 45, 292 (1992)] is based on a Hermitian sojourn-time operator in the framework of time-dependent scattering theory whereas Sokolovski and co-workers [Sokolovski and Baskin, Phys. Rev. A 36, 4604 (1987); Sokolovski and Connor, ibid. 42, 6512 (1990)] have developed an approach based on the Feynman path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics. By translating the path-integral approach into the language of wave functions and linear operators, we reveal the similarities of the two approaches and show that the results for the interaction times are closely related, becoming equivalent in the asymptotic limit.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1993•2 citations

Temporal aspects of one-dimensional completed scattering: An alternative view

Nikolay Leonidovich Chuprikov

A {\it completed} scattering of a particle on a static one-dimensional (1D) potential barrier is a combined quantum process to consist from two elementary sub-processes (transmission and reflection) evolved coherently at all stages of scattering and macroscopically distinct at the final stage. The existing model of the process is clearly inadequate to its nature: all one-particle "observables" and "tunneling times", introduced as quantities to be common for the sub-processes, cannot be experimentally measured and, consequently, have no physical meaning; on the contrary, quantities introduced for either sub-process have no basis, for the time evolution of either sub-process is unknown in this model. We show that the wave function to describe a completed scattering can be uniquely presented as the sum of two solutions to the Schrödinger equation, which describe separately the sub-processes at all stages of scattering. For symmetric potential barriers such solutions are found explicitly. For either sub-process we define the time spent, on the average, by a particle in the barrier region. We define it as the Larmor time. As it turned out, this time is just Buttiker's dwell time averaged over the corresponding localized state. Thus, firstly, we justify the known definition of the local dwell time introduced by Hauge and co-workers as well by Leavens and Aers, for now this time can be measured; secondly, we confirm that namely Buttiker's dwell time gives the energy-distribution for the tunneling time; thirdly, we state that all the definitions are valid only if they are based on the wave functions for transmission and reflection found in our paper. Besides, we define the exact and asymptotic group times to be auxiliary in timing the scattering process.

arXiv:quant-ph/0511024•Nov 3, 2005•1 citation

Time delay in quantum coherence and tunneling

Mohsen Razavy, Ashok V. Pimpale

The problem of time delay in quantum mechanics and its relation to the classical concept of traversal time is studied. For a monochromatic wave, in one dimension, it is shown that the time delay is proportional to a linear combination of the derivatives of the phases of the transmission and reflection coefficients with respect to the frequency. In particular it is shown that the definition of time delay for quantum coherence given in terms of the periods of oscillations of a wave packet between the two wells, in the proper limit, agrees with the corresponding definition in tunneling.

Canadian Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1990•2 citations

Path-integral analysis of the time delay for wave-packet scattering and the status of complex tunneling times

D. Sokolovski, J. N. L. Connor

The wave-packet simulation (WPS) method for calculating the time a tunneling particle spends inside a one-dimensional potential barrier is reexamined using the Feynman path-integral technique. Following earlier work by Sokolovski and Baskin [Phys. Rev. A 36, 4604 (1987)], the tunneling (or traversal) time ${\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}$ is defined as a matrix element of a classical nonlocal functional between two states that represent the initial and transmitted wave packets. These states do not lie on the same orbit in Hilbert space; as a result, ${\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}$ is complex-valued. It is shown that Re${\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}$ reduces to the standard WPS result, ${\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{phase}}^{\mathit{T}}$, for conditions similar to those employed in the conventional WPS analysis. Similarly, Im${\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}$ is shown to contain information about the energy dependence of the transmission probability. Under semiclassical conditions, Im${\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}$ reduces to the well-known Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin expression for the tunneling time. It is shown there are different definitions for the traversal time of a classical moving object, whose size is comparable to the width of the region of interest. In the quantum case, these different definitions correspond to different ways of analyzing the WPS experiment. The path-integral approach demonstrates that the tunneling-time problem is one of understanding the physical significance of complex-valued off-orbit matrix elements of an operator or functional. The physical content of complex-valued tunneling times is discussed. It is emphasized that the use of complex tunneling times includes real-time approaches as a special case. Nevertheless, there is a limitation in the description of tunneling experiments using tunneling times, whether real or complex. The path-integral approach does not supply a universal traversal time, analogous to a classical time, that can be used in quantum situations. It is demonstrated that the often expressed hope of finding a well-defined and universal real tunneling time is erroneous.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1990•74 citations

Sojourn time, sojourn time operators, and perturbation theory for one-dimensional scattering by a potential barrier

Wojciech Jaworski, David M. Wardlaw

We show that a useful concept of the time spent by a quantum-mechanical particle in a given spatial region can be expressed in terms of a Hermitian sojourn time operator. Mean values of this operator give the mean sojourn time (dwell time) of the particle. We show that the sojourn time operators occur in a natural way in first-order perturbation theory for the barrier perturbed by any finite-range potential. The perturbed S operator, and also the effect of the perturbation on the change of observables due to the scattering, are, to a first-order approximation, fully expressible in terms of sojourn time operators. We anticipate that this result can be generalized to the case when the translational motion of the tunneling particle is weakly coupled to additional degrees of freedom. As a specific example of such a system, we explicitly reconsider the Larmor clock, originally proposed as a device measuring interaction times. We show that the change of the spin components, to a first-order approximation, is indeed fully expressible in terms of a sojourn time operator. In particular, when set as a clock, the system measures mean values of the sojourn time operator or real parts of some of its matrix elements.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1989•28 citations
Our previous results [Phys. Rev. A 37, 2843 (1988)], based on the concept of sojourn time, for the transmission and reflection time delays in one-dimensional scattering by a potential barrier are compared to the corresponding results of E. H. Hauge, J. P. Falck, and T. A. Fjedly [Phys. Rev. B 36, 4203 (1987)], based on the idea of following the time evolution of the mean position of wave packets. It is shown that the mean-position approach agrees with the more general sojourn-time approach in the limit of well-defined momentum, and that, in general, the two approaches appear to be related in a classical-like manner.
The problem of time delay in one-dimensional quantum-mechanical scattering by a potential barrier is studied in the framework of time-dependent scattering theory. It is shown how the concept of sojourn time can be used to define three separate time delays: the time delay for transmission through the barrier, the time delay for reflection, and the total time delay (i.e., averaged over transmission and reflection). In addition to the anticipated dependence on the S matrix and its energy derivative, the time delays depend on certain parameters which can be interpreted as describing positions of detectors in a gedanken-experiment measurement. The problem of defining separate time delays for transmission and reflection appears to be rooted in the foundations of quantum theory and its interpretation.
A ready comparison of the two methods noted in the title is obscured by the very different formalisms that they employ. Our sojourn-time approach [Jaworski and Wardlaw, Phys. Rev. A 45, 292 (1992)] is based on a Hermitian sojourn-time operator in the framework of time-dependent scattering theory whereas Sokolovski and co-workers [Sokolovski and Baskin, Phys. Rev. A 36, 4604 (1987); Sokolovski and Connor, ibid. 42, 6512 (1990)] have developed an approach based on the Feynman path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics. By translating the path-integral approach into the language of wave functions and linear operators, we reveal the similarities of the two approaches and show that the results for the interaction times are closely related, becoming equivalent in the asymptotic limit.
A {\it completed} scattering of a particle on a static one-dimensional (1D) potential barrier is a combined quantum process to consist from two elementary sub-processes (transmission and reflection) evolved coherently at all stages of scattering and macroscopically distinct at the final stage. The existing model of the process is clearly inadequate to its nature: all one-particle "observables" and "tunneling times", introduced as quantities to be common for the sub-processes, cannot be experimentally measured and, consequently, have no physical meaning; on the contrary, quantities introduced for either sub-process have no basis, for the time evolution of either sub-process is unknown in this model. We show that the wave function to describe a completed scattering can be uniquely presented as the sum of two solutions to the Schrödinger equation, which describe separately the sub-processes at all stages of scattering. For symmetric potential barriers such solutions are found explicitly. For either sub-process we define the time spent, on the average, by a particle in the barrier region. We define it as the Larmor time. As it turned out, this time is just Buttiker's dwell time averaged over the corresponding localized state. Thus, firstly, we justify the known definition of the local dwell time introduced by Hauge and co-workers as well by Leavens and Aers, for now this time can be measured; secondly, we confirm that namely Buttiker's dwell time gives the energy-distribution for the tunneling time; thirdly, we state that all the definitions are valid only if they are based on the wave functions for transmission and reflection found in our paper. Besides, we define the exact and asymptotic group times to be auxiliary in timing the scattering process.
The problem of time delay in quantum mechanics and its relation to the classical concept of traversal time is studied. For a monochromatic wave, in one dimension, it is shown that the time delay is proportional to a linear combination of the derivatives of the phases of the transmission and reflection coefficients with respect to the frequency. In particular it is shown that the definition of time delay for quantum coherence given in terms of the periods of oscillations of a wave packet between the two wells, in the proper limit, agrees with the corresponding definition in tunneling.
The wave-packet simulation (WPS) method for calculating the time a tunneling particle spends inside a one-dimensional potential barrier is reexamined using the Feynman path-integral technique. Following earlier work by Sokolovski and Baskin [Phys. Rev. A 36, 4604 (1987)], the tunneling (or traversal) time tpackT{\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}tpackT​ is defined as a matrix element of a classical nonlocal functional between two states that represent the initial and transmitted wave packets. These states do not lie on the same orbit in Hilbert space; as a result, tpackT{\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}tpackT​ is complex-valued. It is shown that RetpackT{\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}tpackT​ reduces to the standard WPS result, tphaseT{\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{phase}}^{\mathit{T}}tphaseT​, for conditions similar to those employed in the conventional WPS analysis. Similarly, ImtpackT{\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}tpackT​ is shown to contain information about the energy dependence of the transmission probability. Under semiclassical conditions, ImtpackT{\mathit{t}}_{\mathrm{pack}}^{\mathit{T}}tpackT​ reduces to the well-known Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin expression for the tunneling time. It is shown there are different definitions for the traversal time of a classical moving object, whose size is comparable to the width of the region of interest. In the quantum case, these different definitions correspond to different ways of analyzing the WPS experiment. The path-integral approach demonstrates that the tunneling-time problem is one of understanding the physical significance of complex-valued off-orbit matrix elements of an operator or functional. The physical content of complex-valued tunneling times is discussed. It is emphasized that the use of complex tunneling times includes real-time approaches as a special case. Nevertheless, there is a limitation in the description of tunneling experiments using tunneling times, whether real or complex. The path-integral approach does not supply a universal traversal time, analogous to a classical time, that can be used in quantum situations. It is demonstrated that the often expressed hope of finding a well-defined and universal real tunneling time is erroneous.
We show that a useful concept of the time spent by a quantum-mechanical particle in a given spatial region can be expressed in terms of a Hermitian sojourn time operator. Mean values of this operator give the mean sojourn time (dwell time) of the particle. We show that the sojourn time operators occur in a natural way in first-order perturbation theory for the barrier perturbed by any finite-range potential. The perturbed S operator, and also the effect of the perturbation on the change of observables due to the scattering, are, to a first-order approximation, fully expressible in terms of sojourn time operators. We anticipate that this result can be generalized to the case when the translational motion of the tunneling particle is weakly coupled to additional degrees of freedom. As a specific example of such a system, we explicitly reconsider the Larmor clock, originally proposed as a device measuring interaction times. We show that the change of the spin components, to a first-order approximation, is indeed fully expressible in terms of a sojourn time operator. In particular, when set as a clock, the system measures mean values of the sojourn time operator or real parts of some of its matrix elements.