Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Models for universal reduction of macroscopic quantum fluctuations

Lajos Diósi

Published Aug 1, 1989• 1,028 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper adopts the hypothesis that the absence of macroscopic quantum fluctuations is due to a certain universal mechanism. Such a mechanism has recently been proposed by Ghirardi et al. [Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)], and here we recapitulate a compact version of it. K\'arolyh\'azy [Nuovo Cimento 52, 390 (1966)] showed earlier the possible role of gravity and, along this line, we construct here a new parameter-free unification of micro- and macrodynamics. We apply gravitational measures for reducing macroscopic quantum fluctuations of the mass density. This model leads to classical trajectories in the macroscopic limit of translational motion. For massive objects, unwanted macroscopic superpositions of quantum states become destroyed in very short times. The relation between state-vector and density-operator formalisms has also been discussed. We only anticipate the need for elaborating characteristic predictions of the model in the region separating micro- and macroscopic properties.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.40.1165

Related papers

Quantum collapse dynamics with attractive densities

Franck Laloë

We discuss a model of spontaneous collapse of the quantum state that does not require adding any stochastic processes to the standard dynamics. The additional ingredient with respect to the wave function is a position in the configuration space which drives the collapse in a completely deterministic way. This new variable is equivalent to a set of positions of all the particles, i.e., a set of Bohmian positions, which obey the usual guiding equation of Bohmian theory. Any superposition of quantum states of a macroscopic object occupying different regions of space is projected by a localization process onto the region occupied by the positions. Since the Bohmian positions are well defined in a single realization of the experiment, a space localization into one region is produced. The mechanism is based on the correlations between these positions arising from the cohesive forces inside macroscopic objects. The model introduces two collapse parameters which play a role very similar to those of the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) [Ghirardi et al., Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)] and continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) [Pearle, Phys. Rev. A 39, 2277 (1989); Ghirardi et al., Phys. Rev. A 42, 78 (1990)] theories. With appropriate values of these parameters, we check that the corresponding dynamics rapidly projects superpositions of macroscopic states localized in different regions of space into a single region, while it maintains a negligible effect in all situations where the predictions of standard quantum dynamics are known to be correct. We briefly speculate about the possible relations with gravity. We then study the evolution of the density operator and a mean-field approximation of the dynamical equations of this model, as well as the change of the evolution of the momentum introduced by the localization process. Possible theoretical interpretations are discussed. Generally speaking, this model introduces a sharper border between the quantum and classical worlds than the GRW and CSL theories and leaves a broader range of acceptable values for the parameters.

arXiv:1901.08016•Physical Review A•May 14, 2019•4 citations

Continuous-spontaneous-reduction model involving gravity

G. C. Ghirardi, Renata Grassi, A. Rimini

A continuous-reduction model implying the dynamical suppression of linear superpositions of macroscopically distinguishable states, presented recently by Di\`osi [Phys. Rev. A 40, 1165 (1989)], is investigated. The model exhibits appealing features; in particular, it relates reduction to gravity and contains no constants besides Newton's gravitational constant G. It turns out, however, that the model is not fully consistent. A slight modification of this model is proposed, which overcomes the difficulties and retains partially its appealing features. The resulting model deals with systems containing distinguishable or identical constituents, allows the derivation from microdynamics of wave-packet reduction, and accounts for the emergence of definite macroscopic properties for macro-objects. Reduction is related to gravity in the same way as in Di\`osi's model, but a fundamental length must be introduced to avoid inconsistencies.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1990•302 citations

Continuous spontaneous reduction model involving gravity

G. C. Ghirardi, Renata Grassi, A. Rimini

A continuous-reduction model implying the dynamical suppression of linear superpositions of macroscopically distinguishable states, presented recently by Di\`osi [Phys. Rev. A 40, 1165 (1989)], is investigated. The model exhibits appealing features; in particular, it relates reduction to gravity and contains no constants besides Newton's gravitational constant G. It turns out, however, that the model is not fully consistent. A slight modification of this model is proposed, which overcomes the difficulties and retains partially its appealing features. The resulting model deals with systems containing distinguishable or identical constituents, allows the derivation from microdynamics of wave-packet reduction, and accounts for the emergence of definite macroscopic properties for macro-objects. Reduction is related to gravity in the same way as in Di\`osi's model, but a fundamental length must be introduced to avoid inconsistencies.

Unknow•Jun 1, 1989•0 citations

Superposing spacetimes: lessons from analogue gravity

Carlos Barceló, Luis J. Garay, Gerardo García-Moreno

We analyze Penrose's ideas concerning the role of gravity in the quantum-mechanical state reduction from the perspective of analogue-gravity models. We first review a line of work which argues that it is not enough to find a satisfactory quantization scheme for gravity in the description of a matter-gravity system. Instead of that; the standard rules of quantum mechanics as they are actually applied to matter systems need to be modified when the gravitational interaction is relevant. Among these ideas we focus on Penrose's argument for the absence of macroscopic quantum superpositions. He argues that such phenomenon has its roots in the idiosyncratic aspects of gravity, which become relevant just when the system is macroscopic and hence able to generate a sufficiently strong gravitational field, and not in the environmental decoherence. We then present an analogue model consisting of a Bose-Einstein condensate in a double well potential, where it is possible to build states that would correspond to putative superpositions of spacetimes. Such configurations are unstable and the source of instability from a microscopic point of view can be related to the abscence of a well-defined causal structure in the effective geometric description. We also discuss some additional lessons that can be taken from these instabilities.

•Apr 30, 2021•1 citation

Classical Channel Gravity in the Newtonian Limit

Kiran E. Khosla, Stefan Nimmrichter

We present a minimal model for the quantum evolution of matter under the influence of classical gravity in the Newtonian limit. Based on a continuous measurement-feedback channel that acts simultaneously on all constituent masses of a given quantum system, the model scales and applies consistently to arbitrary mass densities, and it recovers the classical Newton force between macroscopic masses. The concomitant loss of coherence is set by a model parameter, does not depend on mass, and can thus be confined to unobservable time scales for micro- and macroscopic systems alike. The model can be probed in high-precision matter-wave interferometry, and ultimately tested in recently proposed optomechanical quantum gravity experiments.

arXiv:1812.03118•Dec 7, 2018•14 citations

Proposing new experiments to test the quantum-to-classical transition

M Bahrami, Angelo Bassi

An open problem in modern physics is why microscopic quantum objects can be at two places at once (i.e. a superposed quantum state) while macroscpoic classical object never show such a behaviour. Collapse models provides a quantitative answer for this problem and explain how macroscopic classical world emerges out of microscopic quantum world. A universal noise field is postulated in collapse models, inducing appropriate Brownian- motion corrections to standard quantum dynamics. The strength of collapse-driven Brownian fluctuations depend on: (i) the parameters characterizing the system (e.g., mass, size, density), and (ii) two phenomenological parameters defining the statistical properties of the collapse noise. The collapse-driven Brownian motion works such that microscopic systems behave quantum mechanically, while macroscopic objects are classical. At the intermediate mesocopic scale, collapse models predict deviations from standard quantum predictions. This issue has been subject of experimental tests. All experiments to date have been at the scales where collapse effects are negligible for all practical purposes. However, recent experimental progress in revealing quantum features of larger objects, increases the hope for testing at unprecedented scales where collapse models can be falsified. Current experiments are mainly focused on the preparation of macroscopic systems in a spatial quantum superposition state. The collapse effects would then manifest as loss of visibility in the observed inference pattern. However, one needs a quantum interference with single particles of mass ∼ 10 10 amu for a decisive test of collapse models. Creating such massive superpositionsis quite challenging, and beyond currectstate-of-the-art. Quite recently, an alternative approach has been proposed where the collapse manifests in the fluctuating properties of light interacting with the quantum system. The great advantage of this new approach is that here there is no need for the preparation of a quantum superposed state. It has been discussed that promising results can be revealed in the spectrum of light interacting with a radiation pressure-driven mechanical oscillator in a cavity optomechanics setting. Here, we review the theoretical modelling of the above optomechenical proposal. We discuss how collapse-driven Brownian motion modifies the spectrum. We quantify the collapse effect and explain how it depends on the parameters of the mechanical oscillator (e.g., mass, density, geometry).

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 3, 2015•2 citations
This paper adopts the hypothesis that the absence of macroscopic quantum fluctuations is due to a certain universal mechanism. Such a mechanism has recently been proposed by Ghirardi et al. [Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)], and here we recapitulate a compact version of it. K'arolyh'azy [Nuovo Cimento 52, 390 (1966)] showed earlier the possible role of gravity and, along this line, we construct here a new parameter-free unification of micro- and macrodynamics. We apply gravitational measures for reducing macroscopic quantum fluctuations of the mass density. This model leads to classical trajectories in the macroscopic limit of translational motion. For massive objects, unwanted macroscopic superpositions of quantum states become destroyed in very short times. The relation between state-vector and density-operator formalisms has also been discussed. We only anticipate the need for elaborating characteristic predictions of the model in the region separating micro- and macroscopic properties.
We discuss a model of spontaneous collapse of the quantum state that does not require adding any stochastic processes to the standard dynamics. The additional ingredient with respect to the wave function is a position in the configuration space which drives the collapse in a completely deterministic way. This new variable is equivalent to a set of positions of all the particles, i.e., a set of Bohmian positions, which obey the usual guiding equation of Bohmian theory. Any superposition of quantum states of a macroscopic object occupying different regions of space is projected by a localization process onto the region occupied by the positions. Since the Bohmian positions are well defined in a single realization of the experiment, a space localization into one region is produced. The mechanism is based on the correlations between these positions arising from the cohesive forces inside macroscopic objects. The model introduces two collapse parameters which play a role very similar to those of the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber (GRW) [Ghirardi et al., Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)] and continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) [Pearle, Phys. Rev. A 39, 2277 (1989); Ghirardi et al., Phys. Rev. A 42, 78 (1990)] theories. With appropriate values of these parameters, we check that the corresponding dynamics rapidly projects superpositions of macroscopic states localized in different regions of space into a single region, while it maintains a negligible effect in all situations where the predictions of standard quantum dynamics are known to be correct. We briefly speculate about the possible relations with gravity. We then study the evolution of the density operator and a mean-field approximation of the dynamical equations of this model, as well as the change of the evolution of the momentum introduced by the localization process. Possible theoretical interpretations are discussed. Generally speaking, this model introduces a sharper border between the quantum and classical worlds than the GRW and CSL theories and leaves a broader range of acceptable values for the parameters.
A continuous-reduction model implying the dynamical suppression of linear superpositions of macroscopically distinguishable states, presented recently by Di\`osi [Phys. Rev. A 40, 1165 (1989)], is investigated. The model exhibits appealing features; in particular, it relates reduction to gravity and contains no constants besides Newton's gravitational constant G. It turns out, however, that the model is not fully consistent. A slight modification of this model is proposed, which overcomes the difficulties and retains partially its appealing features. The resulting model deals with systems containing distinguishable or identical constituents, allows the derivation from microdynamics of wave-packet reduction, and accounts for the emergence of definite macroscopic properties for macro-objects. Reduction is related to gravity in the same way as in Di\`osi's model, but a fundamental length must be introduced to avoid inconsistencies.
A continuous-reduction model implying the dynamical suppression of linear superpositions of macroscopically distinguishable states, presented recently by Di\`osi [Phys. Rev. A 40, 1165 (1989)], is investigated. The model exhibits appealing features; in particular, it relates reduction to gravity and contains no constants besides Newton's gravitational constant G. It turns out, however, that the model is not fully consistent. A slight modification of this model is proposed, which overcomes the difficulties and retains partially its appealing features. The resulting model deals with systems containing distinguishable or identical constituents, allows the derivation from microdynamics of wave-packet reduction, and accounts for the emergence of definite macroscopic properties for macro-objects. Reduction is related to gravity in the same way as in Di\`osi's model, but a fundamental length must be introduced to avoid inconsistencies.
We analyze Penrose's ideas concerning the role of gravity in the quantum-mechanical state reduction from the perspective of analogue-gravity models. We first review a line of work which argues that it is not enough to find a satisfactory quantization scheme for gravity in the description of a matter-gravity system. Instead of that; the standard rules of quantum mechanics as they are actually applied to matter systems need to be modified when the gravitational interaction is relevant. Among these ideas we focus on Penrose's argument for the absence of macroscopic quantum superpositions. He argues that such phenomenon has its roots in the idiosyncratic aspects of gravity, which become relevant just when the system is macroscopic and hence able to generate a sufficiently strong gravitational field, and not in the environmental decoherence. We then present an analogue model consisting of a Bose-Einstein condensate in a double well potential, where it is possible to build states that would correspond to putative superpositions of spacetimes. Such configurations are unstable and the source of instability from a microscopic point of view can be related to the abscence of a well-defined causal structure in the effective geometric description. We also discuss some additional lessons that can be taken from these instabilities.
We present a minimal model for the quantum evolution of matter under the influence of classical gravity in the Newtonian limit. Based on a continuous measurement-feedback channel that acts simultaneously on all constituent masses of a given quantum system, the model scales and applies consistently to arbitrary mass densities, and it recovers the classical Newton force between macroscopic masses. The concomitant loss of coherence is set by a model parameter, does not depend on mass, and can thus be confined to unobservable time scales for micro- and macroscopic systems alike. The model can be probed in high-precision matter-wave interferometry, and ultimately tested in recently proposed optomechanical quantum gravity experiments.
An open problem in modern physics is why microscopic quantum objects can be at two places at once (i.e. a superposed quantum state) while macroscpoic classical object never show such a behaviour. Collapse models provides a quantitative answer for this problem and explain how macroscopic classical world emerges out of microscopic quantum world. A universal noise field is postulated in collapse models, inducing appropriate Brownian- motion corrections to standard quantum dynamics. The strength of collapse-driven Brownian fluctuations depend on: (i) the parameters characterizing the system (e.g., mass, size, density), and (ii) two phenomenological parameters defining the statistical properties of the collapse noise. The collapse-driven Brownian motion works such that microscopic systems behave quantum mechanically, while macroscopic objects are classical. At the intermediate mesocopic scale, collapse models predict deviations from standard quantum predictions. This issue has been subject of experimental tests. All experiments to date have been at the scales where collapse effects are negligible for all practical purposes. However, recent experimental progress in revealing quantum features of larger objects, increases the hope for testing at unprecedented scales where collapse models can be falsified. Current experiments are mainly focused on the preparation of macroscopic systems in a spatial quantum superposition state. The collapse effects would then manifest as loss of visibility in the observed inference pattern. However, one needs a quantum interference with single particles of mass ∼ 10 10 amu for a decisive test of collapse models. Creating such massive superpositionsis quite challenging, and beyond currectstate-of-the-art. Quite recently, an alternative approach has been proposed where the collapse manifests in the fluctuating properties of light interacting with the quantum system. The great advantage of this new approach is that here there is no need for the preparation of a quantum superposed state. It has been discussed that promising results can be revealed in the spectrum of light interacting with a radiation pressure-driven mechanical oscillator in a cavity optomechanics setting. Here, we review the theoretical modelling of the above optomechenical proposal. We discuss how collapse-driven Brownian motion modifies the spectrum. We quantify the collapse effect and explain how it depends on the parameters of the mechanical oscillator (e.g., mass, density, geometry).