Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Thermodynamically Equivalent Hamiltonian for Some Many-Body Problems

Gregor Wentzel

Published Dec 1, 1960• 73 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A method which allows a rigorous treatment of the statistical mechanics of a superconductor (Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer model) is generalized so as to be applicable to a wider class of many-fermion or many-boson systems.As an illustration, we study a degenerate boson gas, adopting the "pair Hamiltonian" of Girardeau and Arnowitt. We confirm their finding, for this model, that there is a "gap" in the energy spectrum of the lowest excitations.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.120.1572

Related papers

Excitation Spectrum in Many-Boson Systems

Fumihiko Takano

When only two-body correlations are fully taken into account, there appears an energy gap in the excitation spectrum for many-boson systems as shown by Girardeau and Arnowitt and confirmed by Wentzel. This energy gap is shown to disappear and the spectrum to become phononlike again and proportional to the momentum for small momentum, if we construct the eigenmodes of excitations (collective excitations), taking into consideration appropriate higher-order terms.

Physical Review•Jul 15, 1961•31 citations

Statistical Mechanics of a Nonideal Boson Gas: Pair Hamiltonian Model

Marshall Luban

This work is concerned with a microscopic model of a nonideal boson gas. The Hamiltonian is treated in a rigorous manner free of all approximations and, in particular, the Bogoliubov approximation of replacing the zero-momentum single-particle creation and destruction operators by a $c$ number is entirely avoided. Utilizing a method due to Wentzel, the Hamiltonian is replaced by one involving products of two second quantized operators which, in general, can be diagonalized. This replacement is shown to be rigorously valid in the infinite volume limit for all temperatures despite the avoidance of the Bogoliubov approximation. It is found that the assumption of a positive-definite quasiparticle excitation spectrum $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ becomes untenable for temperatures $T$ less than a critical value ${T}_{c}$, if the interparticle potential is described by a certain kernel which possesses positive eigenvalues only, corresponding to a sufficiently repulsive interparticle force. Assuming that $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})=0$ only for k=0, it is found that for $T<{T}_{c}$ the system undergoes an Einstein condensation into the k=0 single-particle state, and the integral equations characterizing the system are precisely the same as would be obtained if the Bogoliubov approximation were made, proving within the framework of this model the strict validity of this approximation procedure. The well-known criterion for an Einstein condensation $v(0)>0$, where $v(\mathrm{k})$ is the Fourier transform of the interparticle potential, is shown to be a weaker statement of our eigenvalue criterion. Further, in agreement with Girardeau and Arnowitt, it is found that an energy gap separates $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(0)$ and $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ for $k>0$. An approximation method is developed for solving the integral equations which describe those systems which undergo an Einstein condensation, and it is shown that this method can be justified if $|T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}|\ensuremath{\lesssim}\frac{{T}_{c}}{10}$, and in cases of short-range repulsive interparticle forces and systems for which $\ensuremath{\rho}v(0)$ possesses a certain prescribed upper bound, $\ensuremath{\rho}$ being the number of particles per unit volume. The transition temperature is found to be lower than the corresponding quantity for the ideal boson gas of the same density. A detailed discussion of the thermal properties of the system in the vicinity of ${T}_{c}$ is also given. In an Appendix a general type of smeared Einstein condensation is assumed, and it is found that for systems in which this property occurs $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ is linear for small $k$. This ansatz is shown to be tenable only if $v(0)<0$. Finally, by assuming an appropriate pseudopotential representation of a hard repulsive core and by including a weak, longranged attractive force between particles, $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ shows a nonmonotonic behavior of the same qualitative type as observed in liquid ${\mathrm{He}}^{4}$.

Physical Review•Oct 15, 1962•93 citations

Thermodynamically Equivalent Hamiltonian Method in Nonequilibrium Statistical Mechanics

Marvin D. Girardeau

The equilibrium statistical mechanics of the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer model of superconductivity, as well as that of a wide class of similar models, can be evaluated exactly by the ``thermodynamically equivalent Hamiltonian'' method of Bogoliubov, Zubarev, Tserkovnikov, and Wentzel. It has been pointed out by Wentzel that this method can be extended to certain weakly nonequilibrium situations. It is shown here that the method allows an exact evaluation of the nonequilibrium statistical mechanics of the following situations: (a) temporal evolution of the statistical expectation value of an observable O(r) whose initial deviation from equilibrium is spatially localized, but not necessarily small; (b) temporal evolution of the statistical expectation value of an observable O due to a perturbation V which is spatially localized, but not necessarily small.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1967•5 citations

On the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer(BCS) Hamiltonian

MI Umo

We present a detailed diagonalization calculation of the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) Hamiltonian via the unitary transformation method which allows for the Bogolyubov-Valatin transformation to be arrived at naturally. The energy gap equation is derived and solved, and averages of some representative thermodynamic quantities are obtained.KEYWORDS: Hamiltonian, unitary matrix, superconductivity, interaction, ground state.

Global Journal of Pure and Applied Sciences•Jul 15, 2013•0 citations

A mathematical derivation of zero-temperature 2D superconductivity from microscopic Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer model

Magnen, J., Jérémie M. Unterberger

Starting from H. Fröhlich's second-quantized Hamiltonian for a $d$-dimensional electron gas in interaction with lattice phonons describing the quantum vibrations of a metal, we present a rigorous mathematical derivation of the superconducting state, following the principles laid out originally in 1957 by J. Bardeen, L. Cooper and J. Schrieffer. As in the series of papers written on the subject in the 90es, of which the present paper is a continuation, the representation of ions as a uniform charge background allows for a $(1+d)$-dimensional fermionic quantum-field theoretic reformulation of the model at equilibrium. For simplicity, we restrict in this article to $d=2$ dimensions and zero temperature, and disregard effects due to electromagnetic interactions. Under these assumptions, we prove transition from a Fermi liquid state to a superconducting state made up of Cooper pairs of electrons at an energy level $Γ_ϕ\sim \hbarω_D e^{-π/mλ}$ equal to the mass gap, expressed in terms of the Debye frequency $ω_D$, electron mass $m$ and coupling constant $λ$. The dynamical $U(1)$-symmetry breaking produces at energies lower than the energy gap $Γ_ϕ$ a Goldstone boson, a non-massive particle described by an effective $(2+1)$-dimensional non-linear sigma-model, whose parameters and correlations are computed. The proof relies on a mixture of general concepts and tools (multi-scale cluster expansions, Ward identities), adapted to this quantum many-body problem with its extended infra-red singularity located on the Fermi circle, and a specific $1/N$-expansion giving the leading diagrams at intermediate energies. Ladder diagrams are proved to provide the leading behavior in the infra-red limit, in agreement with mean-field theory predictions.

arXiv:1902.02337•Feb 6, 2019•0 citations

Collective excitations in superconductors: From Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer theory to Bose condensation

Jorge O. Sofo, C. A. Balseiro, Horacio E. Castillo

We study the collective excitations of a system with local attractive interactions as a function of the coupling strength. The two-particle excitations are obtained in the random-phase approximation. For the strong-coupling limit we reproduce the excitation spectrum of a hard-core Bose gas, while in the weak-coupling limit we obtained a spectrum consistent with the BCS picture. The evolution of the excitation spectrum from the weak- to the strong-coupling limits is continuous. We briefly discuss the effect of these excitations in the thermodynamic properties of the system.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•May 1, 1992•27 citations
A method which allows a rigorous treatment of the statistical mechanics of a superconductor (Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer model) is generalized so as to be applicable to a wider class of many-fermion or many-boson systems.As an illustration, we study a degenerate boson gas, adopting the "pair Hamiltonian" of Girardeau and Arnowitt. We confirm their finding, for this model, that there is a "gap" in the energy spectrum of the lowest excitations.
This work is concerned with a microscopic model of a nonideal boson gas. The Hamiltonian is treated in a rigorous manner free of all approximations and, in particular, the Bogoliubov approximation of replacing the zero-momentum single-particle creation and destruction operators by a ccc number is entirely avoided. Utilizing a method due to Wentzel, the Hamiltonian is replaced by one involving products of two second quantized operators which, in general, can be diagonalized. This replacement is shown to be rigorously valid in the infinite volume limit for all temperatures despite the avoidance of the Bogoliubov approximation. It is found that the assumption of a positive-definite quasiparticle excitation spectrum $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ becomes untenable for temperatures TTT less than a critical value Tc{T}_{c}Tc​, if the interparticle potential is described by a certain kernel which possesses positive eigenvalues only, corresponding to a sufficiently repulsive interparticle force. Assuming that $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})=0$ only for k=0, it is found that for T<TcT<{T}_{c}T<Tc​ the system undergoes an Einstein condensation into the k=0 single-particle state, and the integral equations characterizing the system are precisely the same as would be obtained if the Bogoliubov approximation were made, proving within the framework of this model the strict validity of this approximation procedure. The well-known criterion for an Einstein condensation v(0)>0v(0)>0v(0)>0, where v(k)v(\mathrm{k})v(k) is the Fourier transform of the interparticle potential, is shown to be a weaker statement of our eigenvalue criterion. Further, in agreement with Girardeau and Arnowitt, it is found that an energy gap separates $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(0)$ and $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ for k>0k>0k>0. An approximation method is developed for solving the integral equations which describe those systems which undergo an Einstein condensation, and it is shown that this method can be justified if $|T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}|\ensuremath{\lesssim}\frac{{T}_{c}}{10}$, and in cases of short-range repulsive interparticle forces and systems for which $\ensuremath{\rho}v(0)$ possesses a certain prescribed upper bound, $\ensuremath{\rho}$ being the number of particles per unit volume. The transition temperature is found to be lower than the corresponding quantity for the ideal boson gas of the same density. A detailed discussion of the thermal properties of the system in the vicinity of Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is also given. In an Appendix a general type of smeared Einstein condensation is assumed, and it is found that for systems in which this property occurs $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ is linear for small kkk. This ansatz is shown to be tenable only if v(0)<0v(0)<0v(0)<0. Finally, by assuming an appropriate pseudopotential representation of a hard repulsive core and by including a weak, longranged attractive force between particles, $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ shows a nonmonotonic behavior of the same qualitative type as observed in liquid He4{\mathrm{He}}^{4}He4.
The equilibrium statistical mechanics of the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer model of superconductivity, as well as that of a wide class of similar models, can be evaluated exactly by the ``thermodynamically equivalent Hamiltonian'' method of Bogoliubov, Zubarev, Tserkovnikov, and Wentzel. It has been pointed out by Wentzel that this method can be extended to certain weakly nonequilibrium situations. It is shown here that the method allows an exact evaluation of the nonequilibrium statistical mechanics of the following situations: (a) temporal evolution of the statistical expectation value of an observable O(r) whose initial deviation from equilibrium is spatially localized, but not necessarily small; (b) temporal evolution of the statistical expectation value of an observable O due to a perturbation V which is spatially localized, but not necessarily small.
Starting from H. Fröhlich's second-quantized Hamiltonian for a ddd-dimensional electron gas in interaction with lattice phonons describing the quantum vibrations of a metal, we present a rigorous mathematical derivation of the superconducting state, following the principles laid out originally in 1957 by J. Bardeen, L. Cooper and J. Schrieffer. As in the series of papers written on the subject in the 90es, of which the present paper is a continuation, the representation of ions as a uniform charge background allows for a (1+d)(1+d)(1+d)-dimensional fermionic quantum-field theoretic reformulation of the model at equilibrium. For simplicity, we restrict in this article to d=2d=2d=2 dimensions and zero temperature, and disregard effects due to electromagnetic interactions. Under these assumptions, we prove transition from a Fermi liquid state to a superconducting state made up of Cooper pairs of electrons at an energy level Γϕ∼ℏωDe−π/mλΓ_ϕ\sim \hbarω_D e^{-π/mλ}Γϕ​∼ℏωD​e−π/mλ equal to the mass gap, expressed in terms of the Debye frequency ωDω_DωD​, electron mass mmm and coupling constant λλλ. The dynamical U(1)U(1)U(1)-symmetry breaking produces at energies lower than the energy gap ΓϕΓ_ϕΓϕ​ a Goldstone boson, a non-massive particle described by an effective (2+1)(2+1)(2+1)-dimensional non-linear sigma-model, whose parameters and correlations are computed. The proof relies on a mixture of general concepts and tools (multi-scale cluster expansions, Ward identities), adapted to this quantum many-body problem with its extended infra-red singularity located on the Fermi circle, and a specific 1/N1/N1/N-expansion giving the leading diagrams at intermediate energies. Ladder diagrams are proved to provide the leading behavior in the infra-red limit, in agreement with mean-field theory predictions.
We study the collective excitations of a system with local attractive interactions as a function of the coupling strength. The two-particle excitations are obtained in the random-phase approximation. For the strong-coupling limit we reproduce the excitation spectrum of a hard-core Bose gas, while in the weak-coupling limit we obtained a spectrum consistent with the BCS picture. The evolution of the excitation spectrum from the weak- to the strong-coupling limits is continuous. We briefly discuss the effect of these excitations in the thermodynamic properties of the system.