Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Transactions of the American Mathematical Society

On the Existence of Solutions of the Helium Wave Equation

Tosio Kato

Published Jan 1, 1951• 132 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Introduction. The helium wave equation has been studied by several authors(') with a view to obtaining the exact solution for the ground state, or at least to establishing its existence. The subject is of importance as a matter of principle, since it implies the decision whether the present formulation of nonrelativistic many-body problems is correct(2). Also, the validity of the variational method(3) depends upon it, for this method would be meaningless if there existed no stationary state at all. Unfortunately the attempts of these authors have not been successful; their method of series expansion proved to be powerless to control manyparticle problems. In the present paper, the writer wishes to settle this problem by showing rigorously that the wave equation for the two-electron problem, in particular the helium wave equation, has a very large number-even infinity if the nucleus is assumed to be infinitely heavy-of solutions corresponding to stationary states of the system. In particular the existence of the ground state solution is established. Our method is different from those adopted by the authors cited above. We shall not attempt, for the present, to find explicit expressions for the solutions and shall resort to a method based on the abstract theory of operators in Hilbert space. The essential part of our theory may be regarded as already completed in the previous paper(4), where it was shown that the Hamiltonian operator of every atom, molecule, or ion is essentially selfadjoint(5). This means that the closed Hamiltonianfl of such a system, which is uniquely determined by the given Hamiltonian as a formal differential operator, is self-adjoint in the strict sense, that is, that it has a complete set (discrete or continuous) of eigenfunctions. Further, it was shown that eigen-

DOI
10.1090/s0002-9947-1951-0041011-1

Related papers

Axiomatic quantum theory and resonances

C. S. Sharma, E O Ogunsulire

It remains a difficult task to establish contact between the rigorous quantum theory built on sound foundations by Birkhoff and von Neumann and others and the models usually used to describe resonances. A theorem is proved which gives a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of solutions of formal perturbation and kindred equations in atomic physics and establishes certain uniqueness properties of solutions which exist. In another theorem it is proved that whenever a state vector belonging to a point eigenvalue of the Hamiltonian is perturbed, one has the phenomenon of spectral concentration and it is possible that in cases where the resulting spectral concentration does not constitute a point eigenvalue of the perturbed Hamiltonian, one has the phenomenon which probably corresponds to a resonance. It is shown that in the autoionising 2s2p 1.3 P states of helium, a solution of the formal perturbation equations exists in the underlying Hilbert space only in the zero order, though a formal solution which is outside the underlying Hilbert space exists and belongs to the space of distributions on a subset of the Hilbert space. It is also shown that in cases where a complex eigenvalue is obtained by interfering with a self-adjoint operator, the phenomenon is not related to deficiency indices. The mathematical background of the work of Sharma and Bowtell (1975) has been examined and some progress has been made towards finding the rigorous mathematical framework in which the theory should find a proper formulation.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Nov 1, 1978•3 citations

Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics

Fumitomo Maeda

Although• quantum mechanics has achieved great success in the explanation of physical phenomena, the mathematics used in quantum mechanics is not rigorous.Unrigorous treatments occur in the case of continuous spectrum.In a Hilbert • space, let A be a self-adjoint operator.When we define the eigenvalue and the eigenelement by the ' ' relation Af=J.f, (1) ' ' h d -. -f(q)=).f(q)2m dq has solutions 2,ri f(q)=ce"Aq for any ;.., But these are not quadratically integrable.E. Hellinger and H. Weyi< 0 have already investigated the problem of continuous spectrum and introduced the " eigendifferential."But they are concerned with a special problem, i. e. bounded quadratic forms and solutions of differential equation.In respect of generality, they do not satisfy.< 2 > E. Fues< 3 > and some other writers<" have used this conception " eigendifferential " in quantum mechanics.But the treatments are either complicated or not rigorous.J. v. Neumann< 5 > has proved that in Hilbert space, for any selfadjoint operator A, there exists a resolution of identity E(;..) such that Af= J:and he has applied this theory to quantum mechanics.Although his theory gave a rigorous mathematical foundation to quantum mechanics, it did not give any interpretation to the representation theory of Dirac's form.Recently I investigated the "theory of vector-valued set functions."This theory removes the difficulties in the treatement of continuous spectrum, and gives a rigorous interpretation to the representation theory.< 5 > The vector-valued set function q(U) is a function of set U, and its functional value is an element (vector) in the Hilbert ,space, (1) E. Hellinger [l], 231-271.H. Weyl [1], 238-251.(2) T. Carlemann used this conception "eigendifferential" in the treatise of singular integral equations.Cf.T. Carlemann [1].(3) E. Fues [1], 295-303.(4) For example, L. de Broglie [2], 140-159.(5) J. v. Neumann [1], 53-121.(6) F. Maeda [2], [5], [6].A summary of the theory of vector-valued set functions is given in the first part Qf the present paper.(1) G. Temple has formulated a principle of quantum theory in which projective operators are given priority over self-adjoint operators.(C(.G. Temple [1)).But. the .whole discussion differs from that of my present paper.

Hiroshima Mathematical Journal•Jan 1, 1937•50 citations

Exact classical quantum mechanical solution for atomic helium which predicts conjugate parameters from a unique solution for the first time

Randell L Mills

Quantum mechanics (QM) and quantum electrodynamics (QED) are often touted as the most successful theories ever. In this paper, this claim is critically evaluated by a test of internal consistency for the ability to calculate the conjugate observables of the nature of the free electron, ionization energy, elastic electron scattering, and the excited states of the helium atom using the same solution for each of the separate experimental measurements. It is found that in some cases quantum gives good numbers, but the solutions are meaningless numbers since each has no relationship to providing an accurate physical model. Rather, the goal is to mathematically reproduce an experimental or prior theoretical number using adjustable parameters including arbitrary wave functions in computer algorithms with precision that is often much greater (e.g. 8 significant figures greater) than possible based on the propagation of errors in the measured fundamental constants implicit in the physical problem. Given the constraints of adherence to physical laws and internal consistency, an extensive literature search indicates that quantum mechanics has never solved a single physical problem correctly including the hydrogen atom and the next member of the periodic chart, the helium atom. Rather than using postulated unverifiable theories that treat atomic particles as if they were not real, physical laws are now applied to the same problem. In an attempt to provide some physical insight into atomic problems and starting with the same essential physics as Bohr of − e moving in the Coulombic field of the proton and the wave equation as modified after Schrodinger, a classical approach is explored which yields a model which is remarkably accurate and provides insight into physics on the atomic level. The proverbial view deeply seated in the wave-particle duality notion that there is no large-scale physical counterpart to the nature of the electron is shown not to be correct. Physical laws and intuition may be restored when dealing with the wave equation and quantum atomic problems. Specifically, a theory of classical quantum mechanics (CQM) was derived from first principles as reported previously [1-7] that successfully applied physical laws to the solution of atomic problems that has its basis in a breakthrough in the understanding of the stability of the bound electron to radiation. Rather than using the postulated Schrodinger boundary condition: “ 0 Ψ→ as →∞ r ,” which leads to a purely mathematical model of the electron, the constraint is based on experimental observation. Using Maxwell’s equations, the classical wave equation is solved with the constraint that the bound 1 = n -state electron cannot radiate energy. Although it is well known that an accelerated point particle radiates, an extended distribution, modeled as a superposition of accelerating charges, does not have to radiate. A simple invariant physical model arises naturally wherein the predicted results are extremely straightforward and internally consistent requiring minimal math as in the case of the most famous equations of Newton, Maxwell, Einstein, de Broglie, and Planck on which the model is based. No new physics is needed; only the known physical laws based on direct observation are used. The accurate solution of the helium atom is confirmed by the agreement of predicted and observed conjugate parameters using the same unique physical model in all cases.

Physics Essays•Jun 1, 2008•16 citations

A Strong Contradiction in the Conventional Non-relativistic Theory of the Ground State Helium Atom and Helium-like Ions

V. D. Ignatiev

In the conventional theory of the ground state of heliu m ato m, any solution of the two-electron Schrodinger equation is wrong! That is caused by a strong imbalance of proportions of the attraction versus repulsion operators' acting on a wave function, in the initial differential Schrodinger equation and in its integral algebraic form. In the differential equation, the attraction operators act on the radial part of wave function independently fro m one another obeying the true proportion: one attraction versus one repulsion per electron. But the resulting wave function turns out to satisfy the wrong integral proportion: two attraction energies versus one repulsion energy per electron. The underlying contradiction is un-coincidence of the additivity rules of energies and energy operators: whereas energies of the electrons may be summed the corresponding energy operators referred to different electrons may not. Consequences of this principal contradiction are d iscussed.

International Journal of Theoretical and Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Perturbation theory in quantum mechanics—II

Alan Herries Wilson

Abstract In a previous paper the theory of perturbations was discussed for system which possess only discrete spectra. The theory is now extended to systems with both discrete and continuous spectra, and in addition a slightly more general method of perturbation is considered. The Hamiltonian H of the perturbed systems is split up into three parts H0, H1, H2 (t), two of which can be chosen arbitrarily. The solutions of the perturbed problem can then be worked out in terms of the characteristic functions corresponding to the Hamiltonian H0 + H2 (T), where T is any arbitrary fixed time. In general, however, the series of perturbations does not converge, and different modes of splitting up the Hamiltonian will lead to different formal results. The perturbation theory does usually give the correct physical results, and it is therefore necessary to give some explanation of how this happens. In (I) the asymptotic nature of certain solutions was emphasised, but this does not extend to the more general systems treated here. It is suggested that the usual boundary conditions do not give an adequate description of any but the simplest atomic problems, and that more detailed restrictions, determined by the experimental conditions, ought to be substituted. As this is impossible in practice, an alternative method is to regard the motion as a perturbation on that Hamiltonian H0 + H2 (T) which most nearly corresponds to the experimental conditions. (For example, we may regard an electron as free or bound according as the experiment determines the number of free or bound electrons respectively, whereas in the usual theory the initial Hamiltonian is taken as fundamental.) This criterion, together with the initial conditions, suffices to fix the division of H into the three parts H0, H1, H2 (t) which at first were chosen arbitrarily. The formal solution can be worked out on this basis, and it is then assumed that this solution is asymptotic to the one which would be obtained if the full boundary conditions were used. This suggestion is in accordance with the fact that a hydrogen atom in an electric field gives rise not only to the usual Stark effect, but also to an ionisation effect. In § 2 the perturbation equation are derived in a slightly more general form than has previously been given. The theories of Born,* Dirac and Oppenheimer are particular cases of that given here, and are obtained by particular choices of H0, H1, H2 (t). To obtain Born’s theory we take H1 = 0, and for Oppenheimer’s we take H2 (t) = H2 (T) and T = 0. In Dirac’s theory we have H1 = 0, H2 (0) = 0 and T = 0. Each of these theories is appropriate for the solution of special problems, but the more general method of this paper is required for the full discussion of the perturbation theory.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•May 2, 1929•5 citations

Perturbation theory in quantum mechanics

Alan Herries Wilson

Abstract The theory of perturbations of electronic systems has been considered by various writers, and the method is the basis of the solution of most quantum problems. It therefore seems desirable that the theory should be placed on a firm footing, and this necessitates the discussion of the convergence of the series of perturbations, which up to the present has been avoided. This investigation is all the more necessary since the wave equation of the Stark Effect has no solution of the form assumed by Schrödinger in his original discussion of the perturbation theory. Dirac’s theory leads to a system of linear differential equations in an infinite number of variables, and 2 is devoted to the discussion of the existence theorem for such a system by a matrix method. In 3 the application is made to the perturbation theory in the case of perturbations satisfying the conditions assumed in 2. In 4 the theory is extended so as to include more general types of disturbances. It is shown that, though the series of perturbations does not in general converge, yet it usually possesses the same asymptotic character as in the classical theory, and its use can therefore be justified.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Feb 1, 1929•8 citations
Introduction. The helium wave equation has been studied by several authors(') with a view to obtaining the exact solution for the ground state, or at least to establishing its existence. The subject is of importance as a matter of principle, since it implies the decision whether the present formulation of nonrelativistic many-body problems is correct(2). Also, the validity of the variational method(3) depends upon it, for this method would be meaningless if there existed no stationary state at all. Unfortunately the attempts of these authors have not been successful; their method of series expansion proved to be powerless to control manyparticle problems. In the present paper, the writer wishes to settle this problem by showing rigorously that the wave equation for the two-electron problem, in particular the helium wave equation, has a very large number-even infinity if the nucleus is assumed to be infinitely heavy-of solutions corresponding to stationary states of the system. In particular the existence of the ground state solution is established. Our method is different from those adopted by the authors cited above. We shall not attempt, for the present, to find explicit expressions for the solutions and shall resort to a method based on the abstract theory of operators in Hilbert space. The essential part of our theory may be regarded as already completed in the previous paper(4), where it was shown that the Hamiltonian operator of every atom, molecule, or ion is essentially selfadjoint(5). This means that the closed Hamiltonianfl of such a system, which is uniquely determined by the given Hamiltonian as a formal differential operator, is self-adjoint in the strict sense, that is, that it has a complete set (discrete or continuous) of eigenfunctions. Further, it was shown that eigen-
It remains a difficult task to establish contact between the rigorous quantum theory built on sound foundations by Birkhoff and von Neumann and others and the models usually used to describe resonances. A theorem is proved which gives a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of solutions of formal perturbation and kindred equations in atomic physics and establishes certain uniqueness properties of solutions which exist. In another theorem it is proved that whenever a state vector belonging to a point eigenvalue of the Hamiltonian is perturbed, one has the phenomenon of spectral concentration and it is possible that in cases where the resulting spectral concentration does not constitute a point eigenvalue of the perturbed Hamiltonian, one has the phenomenon which probably corresponds to a resonance. It is shown that in the autoionising 2s2p 1.3 P states of helium, a solution of the formal perturbation equations exists in the underlying Hilbert space only in the zero order, though a formal solution which is outside the underlying Hilbert space exists and belongs to the space of distributions on a subset of the Hilbert space. It is also shown that in cases where a complex eigenvalue is obtained by interfering with a self-adjoint operator, the phenomenon is not related to deficiency indices. The mathematical background of the work of Sharma and Bowtell (1975) has been examined and some progress has been made towards finding the rigorous mathematical framework in which the theory should find a proper formulation.
Although• quantum mechanics has achieved great success in the explanation of physical phenomena, the mathematics used in quantum mechanics is not rigorous.Unrigorous treatments occur in the case of continuous spectrum.In a Hilbert • space, let A be a self-adjoint operator.When we define the eigenvalue and the eigenelement by the ' ' relation Af=J.f, (1) ' ' h d -. -f(q)=).f(q)2m dq has solutions 2,ri f(q)=ce"Aq for any ;.., But these are not quadratically integrable.E. Hellinger and H. Weyi< 0 have already investigated the problem of continuous spectrum and introduced the " eigendifferential."But they are concerned with a special problem, i. e. bounded quadratic forms and solutions of differential equation.In respect of generality, they do not satisfy.< 2 > E. Fues< 3 > and some other writers<" have used this conception " eigendifferential " in quantum mechanics.But the treatments are either complicated or not rigorous.J. v. Neumann< 5 > has proved that in Hilbert space, for any selfadjoint operator A, there exists a resolution of identity E(;..) such that Af= J:and he has applied this theory to quantum mechanics.Although his theory gave a rigorous mathematical foundation to quantum mechanics, it did not give any interpretation to the representation theory of Dirac's form.Recently I investigated the "theory of vector-valued set functions."This theory removes the difficulties in the treatement of continuous spectrum, and gives a rigorous interpretation to the representation theory.< 5 > The vector-valued set function q(U) is a function of set U, and its functional value is an element (vector) in the Hilbert ,space, (1) E. Hellinger [l], 231-271.H. Weyl [1], 238-251.(2) T. Carlemann used this conception "eigendifferential" in the treatise of singular integral equations.Cf.T. Carlemann [1].(3) E. Fues [1], 295-303.(4) For example, L. de Broglie [2], 140-159.(5) J. v. Neumann [1], 53-121.(6) F. Maeda [2], [5], [6].A summary of the theory of vector-valued set functions is given in the first part Qf the present paper.(1) G. Temple has formulated a principle of quantum theory in which projective operators are given priority over self-adjoint operators.(C(.G. Temple [1)).But. the .whole discussion differs from that of my present paper.
Quantum mechanics (QM) and quantum electrodynamics (QED) are often touted as the most successful theories ever. In this paper, this claim is critically evaluated by a test of internal consistency for the ability to calculate the conjugate observables of the nature of the free electron, ionization energy, elastic electron scattering, and the excited states of the helium atom using the same solution for each of the separate experimental measurements. It is found that in some cases quantum gives good numbers, but the solutions are meaningless numbers since each has no relationship to providing an accurate physical model. Rather, the goal is to mathematically reproduce an experimental or prior theoretical number using adjustable parameters including arbitrary wave functions in computer algorithms with precision that is often much greater (e.g. 8 significant figures greater) than possible based on the propagation of errors in the measured fundamental constants implicit in the physical problem. Given the constraints of adherence to physical laws and internal consistency, an extensive literature search indicates that quantum mechanics has never solved a single physical problem correctly including the hydrogen atom and the next member of the periodic chart, the helium atom. Rather than using postulated unverifiable theories that treat atomic particles as if they were not real, physical laws are now applied to the same problem. In an attempt to provide some physical insight into atomic problems and starting with the same essential physics as Bohr of − e moving in the Coulombic field of the proton and the wave equation as modified after Schrodinger, a classical approach is explored which yields a model which is remarkably accurate and provides insight into physics on the atomic level. The proverbial view deeply seated in the wave-particle duality notion that there is no large-scale physical counterpart to the nature of the electron is shown not to be correct. Physical laws and intuition may be restored when dealing with the wave equation and quantum atomic problems. Specifically, a theory of classical quantum mechanics (CQM) was derived from first principles as reported previously [1-7] that successfully applied physical laws to the solution of atomic problems that has its basis in a breakthrough in the understanding of the stability of the bound electron to radiation. Rather than using the postulated Schrodinger boundary condition: “ 0 Ψ→ as →∞ r ,” which leads to a purely mathematical model of the electron, the constraint is based on experimental observation. Using Maxwell’s equations, the classical wave equation is solved with the constraint that the bound 1 = n -state electron cannot radiate energy. Although it is well known that an accelerated point particle radiates, an extended distribution, modeled as a superposition of accelerating charges, does not have to radiate. A simple invariant physical model arises naturally wherein the predicted results are extremely straightforward and internally consistent requiring minimal math as in the case of the most famous equations of Newton, Maxwell, Einstein, de Broglie, and Planck on which the model is based. No new physics is needed; only the known physical laws based on direct observation are used. The accurate solution of the helium atom is confirmed by the agreement of predicted and observed conjugate parameters using the same unique physical model in all cases.
In the conventional theory of the ground state of heliu m ato m, any solution of the two-electron Schrodinger equation is wrong! That is caused by a strong imbalance of proportions of the attraction versus repulsion operators' acting on a wave function, in the initial differential Schrodinger equation and in its integral algebraic form. In the differential equation, the attraction operators act on the radial part of wave function independently fro m one another obeying the true proportion: one attraction versus one repulsion per electron. But the resulting wave function turns out to satisfy the wrong integral proportion: two attraction energies versus one repulsion energy per electron. The underlying contradiction is un-coincidence of the additivity rules of energies and energy operators: whereas energies of the electrons may be summed the corresponding energy operators referred to different electrons may not. Consequences of this principal contradiction are d iscussed.
Abstract In a previous paper the theory of perturbations was discussed for system which possess only discrete spectra. The theory is now extended to systems with both discrete and continuous spectra, and in addition a slightly more general method of perturbation is considered. The Hamiltonian H of the perturbed systems is split up into three parts H0, H1, H2 (t), two of which can be chosen arbitrarily. The solutions of the perturbed problem can then be worked out in terms of the characteristic functions corresponding to the Hamiltonian H0 + H2 (T), where T is any arbitrary fixed time. In general, however, the series of perturbations does not converge, and different modes of splitting up the Hamiltonian will lead to different formal results. The perturbation theory does usually give the correct physical results, and it is therefore necessary to give some explanation of how this happens. In (I) the asymptotic nature of certain solutions was emphasised, but this does not extend to the more general systems treated here. It is suggested that the usual boundary conditions do not give an adequate description of any but the simplest atomic problems, and that more detailed restrictions, determined by the experimental conditions, ought to be substituted. As this is impossible in practice, an alternative method is to regard the motion as a perturbation on that Hamiltonian H0 + H2 (T) which most nearly corresponds to the experimental conditions. (For example, we may regard an electron as free or bound according as the experiment determines the number of free or bound electrons respectively, whereas in the usual theory the initial Hamiltonian is taken as fundamental.) This criterion, together with the initial conditions, suffices to fix the division of H into the three parts H0, H1, H2 (t) which at first were chosen arbitrarily. The formal solution can be worked out on this basis, and it is then assumed that this solution is asymptotic to the one which would be obtained if the full boundary conditions were used. This suggestion is in accordance with the fact that a hydrogen atom in an electric field gives rise not only to the usual Stark effect, but also to an ionisation effect. In § 2 the perturbation equation are derived in a slightly more general form than has previously been given. The theories of Born,* Dirac and Oppenheimer are particular cases of that given here, and are obtained by particular choices of H0, H1, H2 (t). To obtain Born’s theory we take H1 = 0, and for Oppenheimer’s we take H2 (t) = H2 (T) and T = 0. In Dirac’s theory we have H1 = 0, H2 (0) = 0 and T = 0. Each of these theories is appropriate for the solution of special problems, but the more general method of this paper is required for the full discussion of the perturbation theory.
Abstract The theory of perturbations of electronic systems has been considered by various writers, and the method is the basis of the solution of most quantum problems. It therefore seems desirable that the theory should be placed on a firm footing, and this necessitates the discussion of the convergence of the series of perturbations, which up to the present has been avoided. This investigation is all the more necessary since the wave equation of the Stark Effect has no solution of the form assumed by Schrödinger in his original discussion of the perturbation theory. Dirac’s theory leads to a system of linear differential equations in an infinite number of variables, and 2 is devoted to the discussion of the existence theorem for such a system by a matrix method. In 3 the application is made to the perturbation theory in the case of perturbations satisfying the conditions assumed in 2. In 4 the theory is extended so as to include more general types of disturbances. It is shown that, though the series of perturbations does not in general converge, yet it usually possesses the same asymptotic character as in the classical theory, and its use can therefore be justified.