Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Spontaneous emission without field quantization

Richard J. Cook

Published Apr 1, 1983• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A theory of spontaneous emission is presented which does not quantize the radiation field. By allowing the atomic electron's radiation-reaction field to act in the equation of motion for the atomic density operator, the theory accounts for sponteneous emission without leaving the Hilbert space of the atom. The theory is quite simple and leads to exactly the same relaxation terms in the density-operator equation of motion as those predicted by the quantum theory of radiation.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.27.2265

Related papers

Spontaneous emission and absorber theory

David Thomas Pegg

One of the long term interests of George Series was the construction of a theory of spontaneous emission which does not involve field quantisation. His approach was written in terms of atomic operators only and he drew a parallel with the Wheeler-Feynman absorber theory of radiation. By making a particular extra postulate, he was able to obtain the correct spontaneous emission rate and the Lamb shift reasonably simply and directly. An examination of his approach indicates that this postulate is physically reasonable and the need for it arises because quantisation in his theory occurs after the response of the absorber has been accounted for by means of the radiative reaction field. We review briefly an alternative absorber theory approach to spontaneous emission based on the direct action between the emitting atom and a quantised absorber, and outline some applications to more recent effects of interest in quantum optics.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1997•3 citations

Semiclassical description of coherence effects in spontaneous emission and superradiance

Alan V. Durrant

A semiclassical radiation theory is developed in which the spontaneous emission field of a two-level atom is a quantum entity represented by atomic operators acting in the Hilbert space of the atomic states. The theory is applied to an investigation of the coherence properties of spontaneous emission. It is found that incoherent and coherent components can be identified in the emission field, the former dominating in the early stages of the decay from the excited state and the latter dominating in the later stages or in the emission from a weakly excited atom. The single-atom coherence properties are shown to lead to well-known superradiance phenomena in the spontaneous emission from an assembly of similar atoms. The paper does not use the theory of quantum electrodynamics; it builds on knowledge at the undergraduate level of classical radiation theory and the quantum mechanics of atoms.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1977•2 citations

The quantum theory of the emission and absorption of radiation

P. A. M. Dirac

Abstract The new quantum theory, based on the assumption that the dynamical variables do not obey the commutative law of multiplication, has by now been developed sufficiently to form a fairly complete theory of dynamics. One can treat mathematically the problem of any dynamical system composed of a number of particles with instantaneous forces acting between them, provided it is describable by a Hamiltonian function, and one can interpret the mathematics physically by a quite definite general method. On the other hand, hardly anything has been done up to the present on quantum electrodynamics. The questions of the correct treatment of a system in which the forces are propagated with the velocity of light instead of instantaneously, of the production of an electromagnetic field by a moving electron, and of the reaction of this field on the electron have not yet been touched. In addition, there is a serious difficulty in making the theory satisfy all the requirements of the restricted principle of relativity, since a Hamiltonian function can no longer be used. This relativity question is, of course, connected with the previous ones, and it will be impossible to answer any one question completely without at the same time answering them all. However, it appears to be possible to build up a fairly satisfactory theory of the emission of radiation and of the reaction of the radiation field on the emitting system on the basis of a kinematics and dynamics which are not strictly relativistic. This is the main object of the present paper. The theory is noil-relativistic only on account of the time being counted throughout as a c-number, instead of being treated symmetrically with the space co-ordinates. The relativity variation of mass with velocity is taken into account without difficulty. The underlying ideas of the theory are very simple. Consider an atom interacting with a field of radiation, which we may suppose for definiteness to be confined in an enclosure so as to have only a discrete set of degrees of freedom. Resolving the radiation into its Fourier components, we can consider the energy and phase of each of the components to be dynamical variables describing the radiation field. Thus if Er is the energy of a component labelled r and θr is the corresponding phase (defined as the time since the wave was in a standard phase), we can suppose each Er and θr to form a pair of canonically conjugate variables. In the absence of any interaction between the field and the atom, the whole system of field plus atom will be describable by the Hamiltonian H ═ ΣrEr + Ho equal to the total energy, Ho being the Hamiltonian for the atom alone, since the variables Er, θr obviously satisfy their canonical equations of motion Er ═ — ∂H/∂θr ═ 0, θr ═ ∂H/∂Er ═ 1.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Mar 1, 1927•2,288 citations

Generation of coherence in spontaneous emission

Juha Javanainen

Spontaneous emission may be regarded as a result of the radiation-reaction fields emitted by an atom acting back on the atom itself. It is commonly (and often implicitly) assumed that the frequencies of different transitions in the atom are sufficiently different that the field radiated by one dipole is not in near resonance with any other transition. The “secular assumption” is then made that the field couples back only on the same dipole that originally sent it. In this work we study spontaneous emission without making the secular approximation.

Quantum Electronics and Laser Science Conference•May 12, 1991•0 citations

Interaction Hamiltonian and Spontaneous Emission

Peter W. Milonni

Abstract The atom-field interaction is formulated within the fully quantized-field theory, starting from a detailed analysis of the transformation from the fundamental minimal coupling interaction Hamiltonian to the electric dipole Hamiltonian used extensively in quantum optics. Spontaneous emission, radiative level shifts, and the natural radiative lineshape are treated in both the Schrodinger and Heisenberg pictures, with emphasis on the roles of vacuum field fluctuations, radiation reaction, and the fluctuation-dissipation relation between them. The shortcomings of semiclassical radiation theories are discussed.

•Jan 31, 2019•0 citations

Spontaneous emission: vacuum fluctuations or radiation reaction?

Ravinder Rupchand Puri

The role of vacuum fluctuations and radiation reaction in the process of spontaneous emission is examined with particular reference to the Heisenberg picture of quantum electrodynamics. In this picture the radiation reaction is found to be responsible for spontaneous emission if the equations are ordered normally. However, in the case of nonnormally ordered equations there appears to be an explicit contribution to the observable effects from vacuum fluctuations as well. We point out that this contribution from the vacuum field is an artifact of the approximation methods employed for eliminating the free-field variables from the nonnormally ordered equations These approximations are the same as those used in the master-equation approach, in which spontaneous emission appears to be due solely to the vacuum fluctuations. We show that the vacuum field does not contribute explicitly in any ordering if it is eliminated nonperturbatively and the approximation methods are invoked only after its elimination from the equations of motion.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Mar 1, 1985•3 citations
A theory of spontaneous emission is presented which does not quantize the radiation field. By allowing the atomic electron's radiation-reaction field to act in the equation of motion for the atomic density operator, the theory accounts for sponteneous emission without leaving the Hilbert space of the atom. The theory is quite simple and leads to exactly the same relaxation terms in the density-operator equation of motion as those predicted by the quantum theory of radiation.
One of the long term interests of George Series was the construction of a theory of spontaneous emission which does not involve field quantisation. His approach was written in terms of atomic operators only and he drew a parallel with the Wheeler-Feynman absorber theory of radiation. By making a particular extra postulate, he was able to obtain the correct spontaneous emission rate and the Lamb shift reasonably simply and directly. An examination of his approach indicates that this postulate is physically reasonable and the need for it arises because quantisation in his theory occurs after the response of the absorber has been accounted for by means of the radiative reaction field. We review briefly an alternative absorber theory approach to spontaneous emission based on the direct action between the emitting atom and a quantised absorber, and outline some applications to more recent effects of interest in quantum optics.
A semiclassical radiation theory is developed in which the spontaneous emission field of a two-level atom is a quantum entity represented by atomic operators acting in the Hilbert space of the atomic states. The theory is applied to an investigation of the coherence properties of spontaneous emission. It is found that incoherent and coherent components can be identified in the emission field, the former dominating in the early stages of the decay from the excited state and the latter dominating in the later stages or in the emission from a weakly excited atom. The single-atom coherence properties are shown to lead to well-known superradiance phenomena in the spontaneous emission from an assembly of similar atoms. The paper does not use the theory of quantum electrodynamics; it builds on knowledge at the undergraduate level of classical radiation theory and the quantum mechanics of atoms.
Abstract The new quantum theory, based on the assumption that the dynamical variables do not obey the commutative law of multiplication, has by now been developed sufficiently to form a fairly complete theory of dynamics. One can treat mathematically the problem of any dynamical system composed of a number of particles with instantaneous forces acting between them, provided it is describable by a Hamiltonian function, and one can interpret the mathematics physically by a quite definite general method. On the other hand, hardly anything has been done up to the present on quantum electrodynamics. The questions of the correct treatment of a system in which the forces are propagated with the velocity of light instead of instantaneously, of the production of an electromagnetic field by a moving electron, and of the reaction of this field on the electron have not yet been touched. In addition, there is a serious difficulty in making the theory satisfy all the requirements of the restricted principle of relativity, since a Hamiltonian function can no longer be used. This relativity question is, of course, connected with the previous ones, and it will be impossible to answer any one question completely without at the same time answering them all. However, it appears to be possible to build up a fairly satisfactory theory of the emission of radiation and of the reaction of the radiation field on the emitting system on the basis of a kinematics and dynamics which are not strictly relativistic. This is the main object of the present paper. The theory is noil-relativistic only on account of the time being counted throughout as a c-number, instead of being treated symmetrically with the space co-ordinates. The relativity variation of mass with velocity is taken into account without difficulty. The underlying ideas of the theory are very simple. Consider an atom interacting with a field of radiation, which we may suppose for definiteness to be confined in an enclosure so as to have only a discrete set of degrees of freedom. Resolving the radiation into its Fourier components, we can consider the energy and phase of each of the components to be dynamical variables describing the radiation field. Thus if Er is the energy of a component labelled r and θr is the corresponding phase (defined as the time since the wave was in a standard phase), we can suppose each Er and θr to form a pair of canonically conjugate variables. In the absence of any interaction between the field and the atom, the whole system of field plus atom will be describable by the Hamiltonian H ═ ΣrEr + Ho equal to the total energy, Ho being the Hamiltonian for the atom alone, since the variables Er, θr obviously satisfy their canonical equations of motion Er ═ — ∂H/∂θr ═ 0, θr ═ ∂H/∂Er ═ 1.
Spontaneous emission may be regarded as a result of the radiation-reaction fields emitted by an atom acting back on the atom itself. It is commonly (and often implicitly) assumed that the frequencies of different transitions in the atom are sufficiently different that the field radiated by one dipole is not in near resonance with any other transition. The “secular assumption” is then made that the field couples back only on the same dipole that originally sent it. In this work we study spontaneous emission without making the secular approximation.
Abstract The atom-field interaction is formulated within the fully quantized-field theory, starting from a detailed analysis of the transformation from the fundamental minimal coupling interaction Hamiltonian to the electric dipole Hamiltonian used extensively in quantum optics. Spontaneous emission, radiative level shifts, and the natural radiative lineshape are treated in both the Schrodinger and Heisenberg pictures, with emphasis on the roles of vacuum field fluctuations, radiation reaction, and the fluctuation-dissipation relation between them. The shortcomings of semiclassical radiation theories are discussed.
The role of vacuum fluctuations and radiation reaction in the process of spontaneous emission is examined with particular reference to the Heisenberg picture of quantum electrodynamics. In this picture the radiation reaction is found to be responsible for spontaneous emission if the equations are ordered normally. However, in the case of nonnormally ordered equations there appears to be an explicit contribution to the observable effects from vacuum fluctuations as well. We point out that this contribution from the vacuum field is an artifact of the approximation methods employed for eliminating the free-field variables from the nonnormally ordered equations These approximations are the same as those used in the master-equation approach, in which spontaneous emission appears to be due solely to the vacuum fluctuations. We show that the vacuum field does not contribute explicitly in any ordering if it is eliminated nonperturbatively and the approximation methods are invoked only after its elimination from the equations of motion.