Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Constrained-pairing mean-field theory. V. Triplet pairing formalism

Jason K. Ellis, Carlos A. Jiménez-Hoyos, Thomas M. Henderson, Takashi Tsuchimochi, Gustavo E. Scuseria

Published Jul 20, 2011• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Describing strong (also known as static) correlation caused by degenerate or nearly degenerate orbitals near the Fermi level remains a theoretical challenge, particularly in molecular systems. Constrained-pairing mean-field theory has been quite successful, capturing the effects of static correlation in bond formation and breaking in closed-shell molecular systems by using singlet electron entanglement to model static correlation at mean-field computational cost. This work extends the previous formalism to include triplet pairing. Additionally, a spin orbital extension of the "odd-electron" formalism is presented as a method for understanding electron entanglement in molecules.

DOI
10.1063/1.3610650

Related papers

Strong correlations via constrained-pairing mean-field theory

Takashi Tsuchimochi, Gustavo E. Scuseria

We present a mean-field approach for accurately describing strong correlations via electron number fluctuations and pairings constrained to an active space. Electron number conservation is broken and correct only on average, but both spin and spatial symmetries are preserved. Optimized natural orbitals and occupations are determined by diagonalization of a mean-field Hamiltonian. This constrained-pairing mean-field theory (CPMFT) yields a two-particle density matrix ansatz that exclusively describes strong correlations. We demonstrate CPMFT accuracy with applications to the metal-insulator transition of large hydrogen clusters and molecular dissociation curves.

arXiv:0904.2010•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Sep 25, 2009•93 citations

Orbital Entanglement in Bond-Formation Processes

Katharina Bogusławski, Paweł Tecmer, Gergely Barcza +2 more

The accurate calculation of the (differential) correlation energy is central to the quantum chemical description of bond-formation and bond-dissociation processes. In order to estimate the quality of single- and multireference approaches for this purpose, various diagnostic tools have been developed. In this work, we elaborate on our previous observation [J. Phys. Chem. Lett.2012, 3, 3129] that one- and two-orbital-based entanglement measures provide quantitative means for the assessment and classification of electron correlation effects among molecular orbitals. The dissociation behavior of some prototypical diatomic molecules features all types of correlation effects relevant for chemical bonding. We demonstrate that our entanglement analysis is convenient to dissect these electron correlation effects and to provide a conceptual understanding of bond-forming and bond-breaking processes from the point of view of quantum information theory.

arXiv:1303.7207•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•May 14, 2013•145 citations

Realistic theory of electronic correlations in nanoscopic systems

Malte Schüler, Stefan Barthel, Tim Oliver Wehling +3 more

Nanostructures with open shell transition metal or molecular constituents host often strong electronic correlations and are highly sensitive to atomistic material details. This tutorial review discusses method developments and applications of theoretical approaches for the realistic description of the electronic and magnetic properties of nanostructures with correlated electrons. First, the implementation of a flexible interface between density functional theory and a variant of dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) highly suitable for the simulation of complex correlated structures is explained and illustrated. On the DMFT side, this interface is largely based on recent developments of quantum Monte Carlo and exact diagonalization techniques allowing for efficient descriptions of general four fermion Coulomb interactions, reduced symmetries and spin-orbit coupling, which are explained here. With the examples of the Cr (001) surfaces, magnetic adatoms, and molecular systems it is shown how the interplay of Hubbard U and Hund’s J determines charge and spin fluctuations and how these interactions drive different sorts of correlation effects in nanosystems. Non-local interactions and correlations present a particular challenge for the theory of low dimensional systems. We present our method developments addressing these two challenges, i.e., advancements of the dynamical vertex approximation and a combination of the constrained random phase approximation with continuum medium theories. We demonstrate how non-local interaction and correlation phenomena are controlled not only by dimensionality but also by coupling to the environment which is typically important for determining the physics of nanosystems.

arXiv:1707.08333•The European Physical Journal Special Topics•Jul 1, 2017•26 citations

Entanglement coupled cluster theory: Exact spin-adaptation

Sarai Dery Folkestad, Bendik Støa Sannes, Henrik Koch

We present a novel framework for spin-adapted coupled cluster theory. The approach exploits the entanglement of an open-shell molecule with electrons in a non-interacting bath. Together, the molecule and the bath form a closed-shell system, and electron correlation can be included using the standard spin-adapted closed-shell coupled cluster formalism. A projection operator, which enforces conditions on the electrons in the bath, is used to obtain the desired state of the molecule. This entanglement coupled cluster theory is outlined, and proof-of-concept calculations for doublet states are reported. The approach is further extendable to open-shell systems with other values of the total spin.

arXiv:2301.12228•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jun 12, 2023•6 citations

Capturing electron correlation at mean-field cost: Assessment of i-DMFT and the underlying correlation conjecture

Paul G. Graf, Florian Matz, Lexin Ding +3 more

Accurately treating strong electron correlation in quantum chemistry typically requires multireference wave-function methods with steep computational scaling. The recently proposed i-DMFT method promises near configuration-interaction accuracy at mean-field cost by invoking an empirical linear relation between correlation energy and entropy (Collins' conjecture), whose validity remains unclear. We systematically assess this relation across a range of di- and polyatomic molecules, including diverse bond types, third-row elements, different types of geometric distortions, and excited states. We find that the conjectured linearity holds for bond-breaking processes dominated by electron redistribution within orbital pairs, but breaks down for heterolytic dissociation and excited states. In simple molecules, i-DMFT provides a reasonable description of total energies, but does not reliably reproduce reduced density matrices or individual energy components. It further degrades in more complex cases such as ethylene. Based on these results, we formulate criteria for the validity of the conjecture and outline implications for entropy-based reduced density matrix functionals.

physics.chem-phCross-listedarXiv:2604.19804•Apr 14, 2026

强关联分子体系电子结构方法研究进展

Wei Liang Huang, Yifan Cheng, Haibo Ma

In recent years, numerous novel materials have emerged in fields such as high-temperature superconductivity and quantum communication, including unconventional superconductors, topological insulators, and spin liquids. These materials exhibit significant quantum phenomena such as quantum interference, tunneling, fluctuations, and entanglement, often arising from strong correlation effects among electrons within molecules. In the community of quantum chemistry, strong correlation effects are typically classified into dynamic electron correlation and static electron correlation. Dynamic electron correlation, caused by the instantaneous movement of electrons leading to charge density fluctuations, presents computational challenges due to the necessity of introducing a multi-particle form of the wave function. This departure from the mean-field single-particle perspective results in a substantial increase in the computational cost for calculating electron correlation levels. On the other hand, static electron correlation arises from the near-degeneracy of numerous frontier molecular orbitals, resulting in a quantum superposition of electron configurations. It requires the use of multi-configuration methods and faces the well-known “exponential wall” challenge, where computational complexity exponentially grows with the system size. Therefore, due to the involvement of both dynamic and static electron correlations in strongly correlated systems, achieving precise electronic structure calculations is exceptionally difficult, representing a significant challenge in theoretical chemistry and computational physics. Traditionally, to describe the static correlation, quantum chemists often define crucial correlated orbitals and their electrons within the complete active space (CAS). Full configuration interaction (FCI) calculations are performed within the CAS, while the region outside the CAS is described by mean-field methods. While these multi-configuration methods allow for arbitrary electron arrangement within the CAS, effectively capturing the static correlation of the system, they struggle to handle the dynamic correlations beyond the CAS. Therefore, combining them with multi-reference configuration interaction (MRCI), multi-reference perturbation theory (MRPT), multi-reference coupled cluster theory (MRCC), and other multi-reference methods becomes essential to accurately handle strong correlation systems. Constructing multi-configuration wave functions to obtain static correlation by multi-configuration methods, and then generating excitation configurations based on these multi-configuration wave functions to obtain dynamic correlation has become the mainstream of the development of current wave function methods. Challenges in this direction include the exponential growth in computational complexity with an increase in CAS size and the precision of multi-reference methods affecting the accuracy of capturing dynamic correlations beyond the active space. Over the last decade, various multi-configuration methods, such as selected configuration interaction (sCI), Density matrix renormalization group (DMRG), full configuration interaction quantum Monte Carlo (FCIQMC), and neural-network quantum states (NQS), have successfully expanded the computable active space by explicitly or implicitly extracting and compressing complete configuration space information. Furthermore, combining these multi-configuration methods with traditional multi-reference approaches, such as MRCI, MRPT and MRCC, enables capturing dynamic correlations caused by electronic instantaneous interactions beyond the active space. This achieves higher precision and quantitative descriptions for mid-sized strongly correlated molecular systems (around 50 active orbitals). Additionally, novel methods like Block-Correlated Coupled Cluster Theory (BCCC) have made progress in attempting to discuss static and dynamic correlations within a unified framework. This article primarily introduces the advancements in wave function theory electronic structure methods for strongly correlated molecular systems in recent years. The first section details multi-configuration methods that have expanded the CAS size, including sCI, DMRG, FCIQMC, NQS, and outlines their developmental trajectories. The second section delves into the combination of these multi-configuration methods with traditional multi-reference approaches, leveraging larger active spaces to address dynamic correlations and achieve higher precision results. Finally, the article discusses the prospects of these methods in three directions: Handling static and dynamic correlations within a unified framework, integrating with relativistic effects, and combining with machine learning.

Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)•Apr 1, 2024•0 citations
Describing strong (also known as static) correlation caused by degenerate or nearly degenerate orbitals near the Fermi level remains a theoretical challenge, particularly in molecular systems. Constrained-pairing mean-field theory has been quite successful, capturing the effects of static correlation in bond formation and breaking in closed-shell molecular systems by using singlet electron entanglement to model static correlation at mean-field computational cost. This work extends the previous formalism to include triplet pairing. Additionally, a spin orbital extension of the "odd-electron" formalism is presented as a method for understanding electron entanglement in molecules.
We present a mean-field approach for accurately describing strong correlations via electron number fluctuations and pairings constrained to an active space. Electron number conservation is broken and correct only on average, but both spin and spatial symmetries are preserved. Optimized natural orbitals and occupations are determined by diagonalization of a mean-field Hamiltonian. This constrained-pairing mean-field theory (CPMFT) yields a two-particle density matrix ansatz that exclusively describes strong correlations. We demonstrate CPMFT accuracy with applications to the metal-insulator transition of large hydrogen clusters and molecular dissociation curves.
The accurate calculation of the (differential) correlation energy is central to the quantum chemical description of bond-formation and bond-dissociation processes. In order to estimate the quality of single- and multireference approaches for this purpose, various diagnostic tools have been developed. In this work, we elaborate on our previous observation [J. Phys. Chem. Lett.2012, 3, 3129] that one- and two-orbital-based entanglement measures provide quantitative means for the assessment and classification of electron correlation effects among molecular orbitals. The dissociation behavior of some prototypical diatomic molecules features all types of correlation effects relevant for chemical bonding. We demonstrate that our entanglement analysis is convenient to dissect these electron correlation effects and to provide a conceptual understanding of bond-forming and bond-breaking processes from the point of view of quantum information theory.
Nanostructures with open shell transition metal or molecular constituents host often strong electronic correlations and are highly sensitive to atomistic material details. This tutorial review discusses method developments and applications of theoretical approaches for the realistic description of the electronic and magnetic properties of nanostructures with correlated electrons. First, the implementation of a flexible interface between density functional theory and a variant of dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) highly suitable for the simulation of complex correlated structures is explained and illustrated. On the DMFT side, this interface is largely based on recent developments of quantum Monte Carlo and exact diagonalization techniques allowing for efficient descriptions of general four fermion Coulomb interactions, reduced symmetries and spin-orbit coupling, which are explained here. With the examples of the Cr (001) surfaces, magnetic adatoms, and molecular systems it is shown how the interplay of Hubbard U and Hund’s J determines charge and spin fluctuations and how these interactions drive different sorts of correlation effects in nanosystems. Non-local interactions and correlations present a particular challenge for the theory of low dimensional systems. We present our method developments addressing these two challenges, i.e., advancements of the dynamical vertex approximation and a combination of the constrained random phase approximation with continuum medium theories. We demonstrate how non-local interaction and correlation phenomena are controlled not only by dimensionality but also by coupling to the environment which is typically important for determining the physics of nanosystems.
We present a novel framework for spin-adapted coupled cluster theory. The approach exploits the entanglement of an open-shell molecule with electrons in a non-interacting bath. Together, the molecule and the bath form a closed-shell system, and electron correlation can be included using the standard spin-adapted closed-shell coupled cluster formalism. A projection operator, which enforces conditions on the electrons in the bath, is used to obtain the desired state of the molecule. This entanglement coupled cluster theory is outlined, and proof-of-concept calculations for doublet states are reported. The approach is further extendable to open-shell systems with other values of the total spin.
Accurately treating strong electron correlation in quantum chemistry typically requires multireference wave-function methods with steep computational scaling. The recently proposed i-DMFT method promises near configuration-interaction accuracy at mean-field cost by invoking an empirical linear relation between correlation energy and entropy (Collins' conjecture), whose validity remains unclear. We systematically assess this relation across a range of di- and polyatomic molecules, including diverse bond types, third-row elements, different types of geometric distortions, and excited states. We find that the conjectured linearity holds for bond-breaking processes dominated by electron redistribution within orbital pairs, but breaks down for heterolytic dissociation and excited states. In simple molecules, i-DMFT provides a reasonable description of total energies, but does not reliably reproduce reduced density matrices or individual energy components. It further degrades in more complex cases such as ethylene. Based on these results, we formulate criteria for the validity of the conjecture and outline implications for entropy-based reduced density matrix functionals.
In recent years, numerous novel materials have emerged in fields such as high-temperature superconductivity and quantum communication, including unconventional superconductors, topological insulators, and spin liquids. These materials exhibit significant quantum phenomena such as quantum interference, tunneling, fluctuations, and entanglement, often arising from strong correlation effects among electrons within molecules. In the community of quantum chemistry, strong correlation effects are typically classified into dynamic electron correlation and static electron correlation. Dynamic electron correlation, caused by the instantaneous movement of electrons leading to charge density fluctuations, presents computational challenges due to the necessity of introducing a multi-particle form of the wave function. This departure from the mean-field single-particle perspective results in a substantial increase in the computational cost for calculating electron correlation levels. On the other hand, static electron correlation arises from the near-degeneracy of numerous frontier molecular orbitals, resulting in a quantum superposition of electron configurations. It requires the use of multi-configuration methods and faces the well-known “exponential wall” challenge, where computational complexity exponentially grows with the system size. Therefore, due to the involvement of both dynamic and static electron correlations in strongly correlated systems, achieving precise electronic structure calculations is exceptionally difficult, representing a significant challenge in theoretical chemistry and computational physics. Traditionally, to describe the static correlation, quantum chemists often define crucial correlated orbitals and their electrons within the complete active space (CAS). Full configuration interaction (FCI) calculations are performed within the CAS, while the region outside the CAS is described by mean-field methods. While these multi-configuration methods allow for arbitrary electron arrangement within the CAS, effectively capturing the static correlation of the system, they struggle to handle the dynamic correlations beyond the CAS. Therefore, combining them with multi-reference configuration interaction (MRCI), multi-reference perturbation theory (MRPT), multi-reference coupled cluster theory (MRCC), and other multi-reference methods becomes essential to accurately handle strong correlation systems. Constructing multi-configuration wave functions to obtain static correlation by multi-configuration methods, and then generating excitation configurations based on these multi-configuration wave functions to obtain dynamic correlation has become the mainstream of the development of current wave function methods. Challenges in this direction include the exponential growth in computational complexity with an increase in CAS size and the precision of multi-reference methods affecting the accuracy of capturing dynamic correlations beyond the active space. Over the last decade, various multi-configuration methods, such as selected configuration interaction (sCI), Density matrix renormalization group (DMRG), full configuration interaction quantum Monte Carlo (FCIQMC), and neural-network quantum states (NQS), have successfully expanded the computable active space by explicitly or implicitly extracting and compressing complete configuration space information. Furthermore, combining these multi-configuration methods with traditional multi-reference approaches, such as MRCI, MRPT and MRCC, enables capturing dynamic correlations caused by electronic instantaneous interactions beyond the active space. This achieves higher precision and quantitative descriptions for mid-sized strongly correlated molecular systems (around 50 active orbitals). Additionally, novel methods like Block-Correlated Coupled Cluster Theory (BCCC) have made progress in attempting to discuss static and dynamic correlations within a unified framework. This article primarily introduces the advancements in wave function theory electronic structure methods for strongly correlated molecular systems in recent years. The first section details multi-configuration methods that have expanded the CAS size, including sCI, DMRG, FCIQMC, NQS, and outlines their developmental trajectories. The second section delves into the combination of these multi-configuration methods with traditional multi-reference approaches, leveraging larger active spaces to address dynamic correlations and achieve higher precision results. Finally, the article discusses the prospects of these methods in three directions: Handling static and dynamic correlations within a unified framework, integrating with relativistic effects, and combining with machine learning.