Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0904.2010 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

Strong correlations via constrained-pairing mean-field theory

Takashi Tsuchimochi, Gustavo E. Scuseria

Published Sep 25, 2009• 93 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a mean-field approach for accurately describing strong correlations via electron number fluctuations and pairings constrained to an active space. Electron number conservation is broken and correct only on average, but both spin and spatial symmetries are preserved. Optimized natural orbitals and occupations are determined by diagonalization of a mean-field Hamiltonian. This constrained-pairing mean-field theory (CPMFT) yields a two-particle density matrix ansatz that exclusively describes strong correlations. We demonstrate CPMFT accuracy with applications to the metal-insulator transition of large hydrogen clusters and molecular dissociation curves.

DOI
10.1063/1.3237029

Related papers

Constrained-pairing mean-field theory. III. Inclusion of density functional exchange and correlation effects via alternative densities

Takashi Tsuchimochi, Gustavo E. Scuseria, Andreas Savin B

The recently proposed constrained-pairing mean-field theory (CPMFT) is here extended to include exchange and correlation effects from density functional theory (DFT) via alternative densities. We transform from alpha and beta spin densities to alternatives based on the total and on-top pair densities. This transformation is needed because CPMFT produces correct spin-symmetry and space-symmetry adapted densities that traditional DFT functionals are not designed to work with. The inclusion of DFT exchange and correlation effects in CPMFT is well founded both on practical and methodological reasons. We present multiple benchmarks showing that in many cases our model accurately reproduces unrestricted hybrid functional energies (both regular and range separated) and does so on the correct space-symmetry and spin-symmetry surface. Our approach affords efficient inclusion of dynamical correlation effects absent in CPMFT.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jan 14, 2010•35 citations

New methods for the ab-initio simulation of correlated systems

Schade, Robert

Strong electronic correlations are at the heart of many interesting phenomena. For the theoretical description of these materials, a proper treatment of the local atomic physics is required. We propose a novel approach combining functionals of the electron density and functionals of the one-particle reduced density matrix to improve this description. The proposed method has a solid foundation in reduced density-matrix functional theory and no double-counting problem arises. It employs a decomposition of the electron-electron interaction in real space. The interaction close to the correlated orbitals, for example, the partially filled 3d-orbitals of transition-metal ions, is described with a density-matrix functional and otherwise with a local or semi-local density functional. We propose to evaluate the density-matrix functional from Levy’s constrained search problem, i.e., via a constrained minimization over an ensemble of many-particle wave functions. In contrast to approximate parametrized density-matrix functionals, this evaluation allows us to systematically improve the functional towards the exact result. In situations where the one-particle basis is too large to evaluate the density-matrix functional from Levy’s constrained minimization problem, we apply a series of approximations that each can be converged to the exact result: the first approximation step is the local approximation of the density-matrix functional proposed by Blöchl, Walther and Pruschke. For the density-matrix functionals within the local interactions, we propose the adaptive cluster approximation (ACA) that systematically truncates non-interacting one-particle states and drastically reduces the computational effort. The resulting density-matrix functional for a local interaction and a small number of non-interacting one-particle states is then evaluated with the constrained minimization problem. We explore different parametrizations of many-particle wave functions in this constrained minimization problem. A parametrization based on a configuration-interaction-like ansatz is shown to converge rapidly if suitable selection criterion for the Slater determinants is chosen. An impurity-bath-separation ansatz is shown to be suitable for single-impurity Anderson models. It is shown that the constrained minimization can be solved for matrix product states with a DMRG-like iterative minimization. Furthermore, we show that Gutzwiller-Jastrow-correlated wave functions can be used with a quantum Monte Carlo procedure as many-particle wave functions. Finally, we formulate an algorithm for the evaluation of the density-matrix functional on near-term quantum computers. Results from the execution of the algorithm on an existing quantum computer with transmon qubits are presented. The proposed approach combining density functionals and density-matrix functionals is implemented in the CP-PAW code based on the projector augmented-wave formalism. We present results for the dissociation curve of the hydrogen molecule as the prototypical case of strong static correlation and show that static correlation is well described with the new approach. We show results for the nonmagnetic state of the transition-metaoxide NiO that is described qualitatively wrong with the DFT+U method. The proposed method properly describes the nonmagnetic state of NiO as an insulator and predicts a qualitatively correct spectral function.

•Jan 1, 2019•1 citation

Natural orbital functional theory and pairing correlation effects in electron momentum density

B. Barbiellini

Occupation numbers of natural orbitals capture the physics of strong electron correlations in momentum space. A natural orbital density functional theory based on the antisymmetrized geminal product provides these occupation numbers and the corresponding electron momentum density. A practical implementation of this theory approximates the natural orbitals by the Kohn–Sham orbitals and uses a mean-field approach to estimate pairing amplitudes leading to corrections for the independent particle model. The method is applied to weakly doped La2CuO4.

arXiv:1403.0004•Low Temperature Physics•Apr 1, 2014•5 citations

Constrained-pairing mean-field theory. V. Triplet pairing formalism

Jason K. Ellis, Carlos A. Jiménez-Hoyos, Thomas M. Henderson +2 more

Describing strong (also known as static) correlation caused by degenerate or nearly degenerate orbitals near the Fermi level remains a theoretical challenge, particularly in molecular systems. Constrained-pairing mean-field theory has been quite successful, capturing the effects of static correlation in bond formation and breaking in closed-shell molecular systems by using singlet electron entanglement to model static correlation at mean-field computational cost. This work extends the previous formalism to include triplet pairing. Additionally, a spin orbital extension of the "odd-electron" formalism is presented as a method for understanding electron entanglement in molecules.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 20, 2011•9 citations

Strong Electron Correlation in Materials from Pair-Interacting Model Hamiltonians

Nicholas C. Rubin, David A. Mazziotti

Strong electron correlation in materials is explored within a class of model Hamiltonians that treat only pair interactions between electrons. The model is unique among typical spin Hamiltonians in that it does not have an effective mean-field reference wave function. The ground-state wave functions from all Hamiltonians in the model have the same one-electron reduced density matrix (1-RDM); consequently, one-electron theories such as the Hartree–Fock and density functional theories are inapplicable. In contrast, the ground-state two-electron reduced density matrix (2-RDM) has a one-to-one mapping to the ground-state wave function. For a range of lattices including linear, ladder, and square topologies, we variationally compute the 2-RDM subject to constraints, known as N -representability conditions, that are necessary for the 2-RDM to represent an N -electron ensemble density matrix. We find that for all model Hamiltonians the 2-RDM is accurately computed as long as the D, Q, and G N -representability conditions are supplemented with the T 2 condition. Energies, orbital and geminal occupation numbers, and correlation functions are computed. The model has applications to superconductivity as well as more general pairing phenomena in electronic systems. Effective methods are needed to treat strong electron correlation arising in the study of materials including the study of high-temperature superconductivity and phase transitions.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry C•Mar 26, 2015•10 citations

Two-electron reduced density matrix method for the electronic structure of correlated materials

Anna O. Schouten, Simon Ewing, David A. Mazziotti

The last several decades have seen significant advances in the theoretical modeling of materials within the fields of solid-state physics and materials science, but many methods commonly applied to this problem struggle to capture strong electron correlation accurately. Recent widespread interest in quantum materials---where strong correlation plays a crucial role in the quantum effects governing their behavior---further highlights the need for theoretical methods capable of rigorously treating such correlation. Here, we present a periodic generalization of variational two-electron reduced density matrix (2-RDM) theory, a bootstrapping-type method that minimizes the ground-state energy as a functional of the 2-RDM without relying on the wave function. The 2-RDM is computed directly by semidefinite programming with $N$-representability conditions, ensuring accurate treatment of strongly correlated electronic systems. By exploiting translational symmetry, we significantly reduce computational scaling, enabling applications to realistic materials-scale systems. Additionally, we introduce an alternative to conventional energy band structures: natural-orbital occupation-number bands, which, being independent of mean-field assumptions, offer deeper insights into electron correlation effects. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach by applying the theory to hydrogen chains, molybdenum disulfide, and nickel oxide, showing that natural-orbital occupation bands correctly capture electronic character in regimes where density functional theory fails. This work represents a major step toward accurately describing the electronic structure of quantum materials using reduced density matrices rather than wave functions.

arXiv:2504.02861•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 12, 2025•12 citations
We present a mean-field approach for accurately describing strong correlations via electron number fluctuations and pairings constrained to an active space. Electron number conservation is broken and correct only on average, but both spin and spatial symmetries are preserved. Optimized natural orbitals and occupations are determined by diagonalization of a mean-field Hamiltonian. This constrained-pairing mean-field theory (CPMFT) yields a two-particle density matrix ansatz that exclusively describes strong correlations. We demonstrate CPMFT accuracy with applications to the metal-insulator transition of large hydrogen clusters and molecular dissociation curves.
The recently proposed constrained-pairing mean-field theory (CPMFT) is here extended to include exchange and correlation effects from density functional theory (DFT) via alternative densities. We transform from alpha and beta spin densities to alternatives based on the total and on-top pair densities. This transformation is needed because CPMFT produces correct spin-symmetry and space-symmetry adapted densities that traditional DFT functionals are not designed to work with. The inclusion of DFT exchange and correlation effects in CPMFT is well founded both on practical and methodological reasons. We present multiple benchmarks showing that in many cases our model accurately reproduces unrestricted hybrid functional energies (both regular and range separated) and does so on the correct space-symmetry and spin-symmetry surface. Our approach affords efficient inclusion of dynamical correlation effects absent in CPMFT.
Strong electronic correlations are at the heart of many interesting phenomena. For the theoretical description of these materials, a proper treatment of the local atomic physics is required. We propose a novel approach combining functionals of the electron density and functionals of the one-particle reduced density matrix to improve this description. The proposed method has a solid foundation in reduced density-matrix functional theory and no double-counting problem arises. It employs a decomposition of the electron-electron interaction in real space. The interaction close to the correlated orbitals, for example, the partially filled 3d-orbitals of transition-metal ions, is described with a density-matrix functional and otherwise with a local or semi-local density functional. We propose to evaluate the density-matrix functional from Levy’s constrained search problem, i.e., via a constrained minimization over an ensemble of many-particle wave functions. In contrast to approximate parametrized density-matrix functionals, this evaluation allows us to systematically improve the functional towards the exact result. In situations where the one-particle basis is too large to evaluate the density-matrix functional from Levy’s constrained minimization problem, we apply a series of approximations that each can be converged to the exact result: the first approximation step is the local approximation of the density-matrix functional proposed by Blöchl, Walther and Pruschke. For the density-matrix functionals within the local interactions, we propose the adaptive cluster approximation (ACA) that systematically truncates non-interacting one-particle states and drastically reduces the computational effort. The resulting density-matrix functional for a local interaction and a small number of non-interacting one-particle states is then evaluated with the constrained minimization problem. We explore different parametrizations of many-particle wave functions in this constrained minimization problem. A parametrization based on a configuration-interaction-like ansatz is shown to converge rapidly if suitable selection criterion for the Slater determinants is chosen. An impurity-bath-separation ansatz is shown to be suitable for single-impurity Anderson models. It is shown that the constrained minimization can be solved for matrix product states with a DMRG-like iterative minimization. Furthermore, we show that Gutzwiller-Jastrow-correlated wave functions can be used with a quantum Monte Carlo procedure as many-particle wave functions. Finally, we formulate an algorithm for the evaluation of the density-matrix functional on near-term quantum computers. Results from the execution of the algorithm on an existing quantum computer with transmon qubits are presented. The proposed approach combining density functionals and density-matrix functionals is implemented in the CP-PAW code based on the projector augmented-wave formalism. We present results for the dissociation curve of the hydrogen molecule as the prototypical case of strong static correlation and show that static correlation is well described with the new approach. We show results for the nonmagnetic state of the transition-metaoxide NiO that is described qualitatively wrong with the DFT+U method. The proposed method properly describes the nonmagnetic state of NiO as an insulator and predicts a qualitatively correct spectral function.
Occupation numbers of natural orbitals capture the physics of strong electron correlations in momentum space. A natural orbital density functional theory based on the antisymmetrized geminal product provides these occupation numbers and the corresponding electron momentum density. A practical implementation of this theory approximates the natural orbitals by the Kohn–Sham orbitals and uses a mean-field approach to estimate pairing amplitudes leading to corrections for the independent particle model. The method is applied to weakly doped La2CuO4.
Describing strong (also known as static) correlation caused by degenerate or nearly degenerate orbitals near the Fermi level remains a theoretical challenge, particularly in molecular systems. Constrained-pairing mean-field theory has been quite successful, capturing the effects of static correlation in bond formation and breaking in closed-shell molecular systems by using singlet electron entanglement to model static correlation at mean-field computational cost. This work extends the previous formalism to include triplet pairing. Additionally, a spin orbital extension of the "odd-electron" formalism is presented as a method for understanding electron entanglement in molecules.
Strong electron correlation in materials is explored within a class of model Hamiltonians that treat only pair interactions between electrons. The model is unique among typical spin Hamiltonians in that it does not have an effective mean-field reference wave function. The ground-state wave functions from all Hamiltonians in the model have the same one-electron reduced density matrix (1-RDM); consequently, one-electron theories such as the Hartree–Fock and density functional theories are inapplicable. In contrast, the ground-state two-electron reduced density matrix (2-RDM) has a one-to-one mapping to the ground-state wave function. For a range of lattices including linear, ladder, and square topologies, we variationally compute the 2-RDM subject to constraints, known as N -representability conditions, that are necessary for the 2-RDM to represent an N -electron ensemble density matrix. We find that for all model Hamiltonians the 2-RDM is accurately computed as long as the D, Q, and G N -representability conditions are supplemented with the T 2 condition. Energies, orbital and geminal occupation numbers, and correlation functions are computed. The model has applications to superconductivity as well as more general pairing phenomena in electronic systems. Effective methods are needed to treat strong electron correlation arising in the study of materials including the study of high-temperature superconductivity and phase transitions.
The last several decades have seen significant advances in the theoretical modeling of materials within the fields of solid-state physics and materials science, but many methods commonly applied to this problem struggle to capture strong electron correlation accurately. Recent widespread interest in quantum materials---where strong correlation plays a crucial role in the quantum effects governing their behavior---further highlights the need for theoretical methods capable of rigorously treating such correlation. Here, we present a periodic generalization of variational two-electron reduced density matrix (2-RDM) theory, a bootstrapping-type method that minimizes the ground-state energy as a functional of the 2-RDM without relying on the wave function. The 2-RDM is computed directly by semidefinite programming with NNN-representability conditions, ensuring accurate treatment of strongly correlated electronic systems. By exploiting translational symmetry, we significantly reduce computational scaling, enabling applications to realistic materials-scale systems. Additionally, we introduce an alternative to conventional energy band structures: natural-orbital occupation-number bands, which, being independent of mean-field assumptions, offer deeper insights into electron correlation effects. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach by applying the theory to hydrogen chains, molybdenum disulfide, and nickel oxide, showing that natural-orbital occupation bands correctly capture electronic character in regimes where density functional theory fails. This work represents a major step toward accurately describing the electronic structure of quantum materials using reduced density matrices rather than wave functions.