Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Relation between Quantum and Semiclassical Description of Optical Coherence

C. L. Mehta, E. C. G. Sudarshan

Published Apr 12, 1965• 225 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The problem of relating the semiclassical and quantum treatments of statistical states of an optical field is re-examined. The case where the rule of association between functions and operators is that of antinormal ordering is studied in detail. It is shown that the distribution function for each mode corresponding to this case is a continuous bounded function, and is also a boundary value of an entire analytic function of two variables. The nature of the distribution for the normal ordering rule of association and its relation to this entire function are discussed. It is shown that this distribution can be regarded as the limit of a sequence of tempered distributions in the following sense: One can find a sequence of density operators ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{(\ensuremath{\nu})}$ which converges in the norm to the density operator $\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}}$ of any given field (consisting of a single mode), such that each member of the sequence can be expressed in the form ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{(\ensuremath{\nu})}=\ensuremath{\int}{\ensuremath{\varphi}}_{(\ensuremath{\nu})}(z)|z〉〈z|{d}^{2}z$, where ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}_{(\ensuremath{\nu})}$ is a tempered distribution.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.138.b274

Related papers

Coherent-State Representations for the Photon Density Operator

Kevin E. Cahill

The "diagonal" $P$ representation of the photon density operator in terms of the coherent states of the radiation field is studied. It is shown that the class of weight functions $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ required to represent all density operators by means of the $P$ representation is much larger than the class of all probability distributions and that therefore the analogy linking the use of the $P$ representation with certain classical stochastic techniques is useful only for a limited class of density operators. The class of density operators for which the $P$ representation is appropriate is shown to be limited in the sense that there are density operators that require weight functions so singular as to lie outside the class of all tempered distributions. Conditions on the weight function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ under which the expectation values of the normal ordered operators ${({a}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}})}^{n}{a}^{m}$ assume a particularly simple integral form are presented. It is shown that if $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ is a tempered distribution, then these expectation values are given by a simple limiting process. A limited correspondence with classical optics is suggested by a formula for these expectation values. Conditions that a density operator must satisfy if its weight function is to be non-negative are presented and are shown to exclude all pure states except the coherent states themselves. The problem of representing an arbitrary operator in terms of the coherent states is studied. New measures of the completeness of the coherent states are established.

Physical Review•Jun 21, 1965•86 citations

Quantum distribution theory and partially coherent radiation

Marlan O. Scully, Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

As we have seen in the previous chapters, there are quantum fluctuations associated with the states corresponding to classically welldefined electromagnetic fields. The general description of fluctuation phenomena requires the density operator. However, it is possible to give an alternative but equivalent description in terms of distribution functions. In the present chapter, we extend our treatment of quantum statistical phenomena by developing the theory of quasi-classical distributions. This is of interest for several reasons. First of all, the extension of the quantum theory of radiation to involve nonquantum stochastic effects such as thermal fluctuations is needed. This is an important ingredient in the theory of partial coherence. Furthermore, the interface between classical and quantum physics is elucidated by the use of such distributions. The arch type example being the Wigner distribution. In this chapter, we introduce various distribution functions. These include the coherent state representation or the Glauber–Sudarshan Prepresentation. The P -representation is used to evaluate the normally ordered correlation functions of the field operators. As we shall see in the next chapter, the P -representation forms a correspondence between the quantum and the classical coherence theory. This distribution function does not have all of the properties of the classical distribution functions for certain states of the field, e.g., it can be negative. We also discuss the so-called Q -representation associated with the antinormally ordered correlation functions. Other distribution functions and their properties are also presented.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 4, 1997•2 citations

Degree of Higher-Order Optical Coherence

C. L. Mehta

In this paper we define the normalized coherence function of arbitrary order (m, n), in a manner which seems to be a natural generalization of that defined for the second-order coherence function. Both classical and quantized optical fields are considered and the results are compared. It is shown that for classical fields and also for quantized optical fields having nonnegative definite diagonal coherent state representations of the density operator, the modulus of these normalized coherence functions is bounded by the values 0 and 1. This definition differs from the one recently given by Glauber for quantized optical fields, where the normalized coherence functions may take arbitrarily large values even for fields having nonnegative definite diagonal representations of the density operator. Conditions for ``complete coherence,'' i.e., those under which the modulus of the normalized coherence function attains the limiting value 1, are discussed. Some consequences of stationarity and quasi-monochromaticity are also discussed.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Sep 1, 1967•6 citations

Relation between the Statistical Representations of Real and Associated Complex Fields in Optical Coherence Theory

G. S. Agarwal, E. Wolf

In the general theory of optical coherence, the following problem discussed in the present paper, arises: to determine the statistical properties of a field represented by an analytic signal from the knowledge of the statistical properties of the corresponding real field. It is shown by the use of the characteristic functionals that in order to determine the joint probability distributions of the complex field at N space-time points, the knowledge of the complete statistical description of the real field is required; on the other hand, the moments of the complex field up to that order can be determined from the knowledge of the moments of the real field up to the same order. The results are illustrated by explicit calculations relating to the Gaussian random process, which, as is well known, characterizes the fluctuations of thermal light. A converse of a well-known theorem of Kac and Siegert relating to a Gaussian random process is derived as an immediate consequence of our analysis.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 1972•4 citations

Entropy of Optical Fields

Vlasta Peřinová, J. Křepelka, Jan Peřina +2 more

A systematic approach to the use of entropy as a measure of noise and order in quantum optical fields is developed. The general definition of entropy, adopting the density matrix, is expressed in terms of both the eigenvalues of this operator and the quasidistribution function related to antinormal ordering of the field operators. Special states of optical fields, such as the Fock state, the coherent state, the chaotic state, single-mode and multimode two-photon coherent states, squeezed states and the shifted gaussian state, including the time development under a particular interaction, are considered. The general conclusions reached are illustrated by numerical results.

Optica Acta International Journal of Optics•Jan 1, 1986•33 citations

Density Operators and Quasiprobability Distributions

Kevin E. Cahill, Roy J. Glauber

The problem of expanding a density operator $\ensuremath{\rho}$ in forms that simplify the evaluation of important classes of quantum-mechanical expectation values is studied. The weight function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ of the $P$ representation, the Wigner distribution $W(\ensuremath{\alpha})$, and the function $〈\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\rho}|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$, where $|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$ is a coherent state, are discussed from a unified point of view. Each of these quasiprobability distributions is examined as the expectation value of a Hermitian operator, as the weight function of an integral representation for the density operator and as the function associated with the density operator by one of the operator-function correspondences defined in the preceding paper. The weight function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ of the $P$ representation is shown to be the expectation value of a Hermitian operator all of whose eigenvalues are infinite. The existence of the function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ as an infinitely differentiable function is found to be equivalent to the existence of a well-defined antinormally ordered series expansion for the density operator in powers of the annihilation and creation operators $a$ and ${a}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$. The Wigner distribution $W(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ is shown to be a continuous, uniformly bounded, square-integrable weight function for an integral expansion of the density operator and to be the function associated with the symmetrically ordered power-series expansion of the density operator. The function $〈\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\rho}|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$, which is infinitely differentiable, corresponds to the normally ordered form of the density operator. Its use as a weight function in an integral expansion of the density operator is shown to involve singularities that are closely related to those which occur in the $P$ representation. A parametrized integral expansion of the density operator is introduced in which the weight function $W(\ensuremath{\alpha},s)$ may be identified with the weight function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ of the $P$ representation, with the Wigner distribution $W(\ensuremath{\alpha})$, and with the function $〈\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\rho}|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$ when the order parameter $s$ assumes the values $s=+1, 0, \ensuremath{-}1$, respectively. The function $W(\ensuremath{\alpha},s)$ is shown to be the expectation value of the ordered operator analog of the $\ensuremath{\delta}$ function defined in the preceding paper. This operator is in the trace class for $\mathrm{Res}<0$, has bounded eigenvalues for $\mathrm{Res}=0$, and has infinite eigenvalues for $s=1$. Marked changes in the properties of the quasiprobability distribution $W(\ensuremath{\alpha},s)$ are exhibited as the order parameter $s$ is varied continuously from $s=\ensuremath{-}1$, corresponding to the function $〈\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\rho}|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$, to $s=+1$, corresponding to the function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$. Methods for constructing these functions and for using them to compute expectation values are presented and illustrated with several examples. One of these examples leads to a physical characterization of the density operators for which the $P$ representation is appropriate.

Physical Review•Jan 25, 1969•1,256 citations
The problem of relating the semiclassical and quantum treatments of statistical states of an optical field is re-examined. The case where the rule of association between functions and operators is that of antinormal ordering is studied in detail. It is shown that the distribution function for each mode corresponding to this case is a continuous bounded function, and is also a boundary value of an entire analytic function of two variables. The nature of the distribution for the normal ordering rule of association and its relation to this entire function are discussed. It is shown that this distribution can be regarded as the limit of a sequence of tempered distributions in the following sense: One can find a sequence of density operators {\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{(\ensuremath{\nu})} which converges in the norm to the density operator \stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}} of any given field (consisting of a single mode), such that each member of the sequence can be expressed in the form {\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{(\ensuremath{\nu})}=\ensuremath{\int}{\ensuremath{\varphi}}_{(\ensuremath{\nu})}(z)|z〉〈z|{d}^{2}z, where \ensuremathφ(\ensuremathν){\ensuremath{\varphi}}_{(\ensuremath{\nu})}\ensuremathφ(\ensuremathν)​ is a tempered distribution.
The "diagonal" PPP representation of the photon density operator in terms of the coherent states of the radiation field is studied. It is shown that the class of weight functions $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ required to represent all density operators by means of the PPP representation is much larger than the class of all probability distributions and that therefore the analogy linking the use of the PPP representation with certain classical stochastic techniques is useful only for a limited class of density operators. The class of density operators for which the PPP representation is appropriate is shown to be limited in the sense that there are density operators that require weight functions so singular as to lie outside the class of all tempered distributions. Conditions on the weight function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ under which the expectation values of the normal ordered operators ${({a}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}})}^{n}{a}^{m}$ assume a particularly simple integral form are presented. It is shown that if $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ is a tempered distribution, then these expectation values are given by a simple limiting process. A limited correspondence with classical optics is suggested by a formula for these expectation values. Conditions that a density operator must satisfy if its weight function is to be non-negative are presented and are shown to exclude all pure states except the coherent states themselves. The problem of representing an arbitrary operator in terms of the coherent states is studied. New measures of the completeness of the coherent states are established.
As we have seen in the previous chapters, there are quantum fluctuations associated with the states corresponding to classically welldefined electromagnetic fields. The general description of fluctuation phenomena requires the density operator. However, it is possible to give an alternative but equivalent description in terms of distribution functions. In the present chapter, we extend our treatment of quantum statistical phenomena by developing the theory of quasi-classical distributions. This is of interest for several reasons. First of all, the extension of the quantum theory of radiation to involve nonquantum stochastic effects such as thermal fluctuations is needed. This is an important ingredient in the theory of partial coherence. Furthermore, the interface between classical and quantum physics is elucidated by the use of such distributions. The arch type example being the Wigner distribution. In this chapter, we introduce various distribution functions. These include the coherent state representation or the Glauber–Sudarshan Prepresentation. The P -representation is used to evaluate the normally ordered correlation functions of the field operators. As we shall see in the next chapter, the P -representation forms a correspondence between the quantum and the classical coherence theory. This distribution function does not have all of the properties of the classical distribution functions for certain states of the field, e.g., it can be negative. We also discuss the so-called Q -representation associated with the antinormally ordered correlation functions. Other distribution functions and their properties are also presented.
In this paper we define the normalized coherence function of arbitrary order (m, n), in a manner which seems to be a natural generalization of that defined for the second-order coherence function. Both classical and quantized optical fields are considered and the results are compared. It is shown that for classical fields and also for quantized optical fields having nonnegative definite diagonal coherent state representations of the density operator, the modulus of these normalized coherence functions is bounded by the values 0 and 1. This definition differs from the one recently given by Glauber for quantized optical fields, where the normalized coherence functions may take arbitrarily large values even for fields having nonnegative definite diagonal representations of the density operator. Conditions for ``complete coherence,'' i.e., those under which the modulus of the normalized coherence function attains the limiting value 1, are discussed. Some consequences of stationarity and quasi-monochromaticity are also discussed.
In the general theory of optical coherence, the following problem discussed in the present paper, arises: to determine the statistical properties of a field represented by an analytic signal from the knowledge of the statistical properties of the corresponding real field. It is shown by the use of the characteristic functionals that in order to determine the joint probability distributions of the complex field at N space-time points, the knowledge of the complete statistical description of the real field is required; on the other hand, the moments of the complex field up to that order can be determined from the knowledge of the moments of the real field up to the same order. The results are illustrated by explicit calculations relating to the Gaussian random process, which, as is well known, characterizes the fluctuations of thermal light. A converse of a well-known theorem of Kac and Siegert relating to a Gaussian random process is derived as an immediate consequence of our analysis.
A systematic approach to the use of entropy as a measure of noise and order in quantum optical fields is developed. The general definition of entropy, adopting the density matrix, is expressed in terms of both the eigenvalues of this operator and the quasidistribution function related to antinormal ordering of the field operators. Special states of optical fields, such as the Fock state, the coherent state, the chaotic state, single-mode and multimode two-photon coherent states, squeezed states and the shifted gaussian state, including the time development under a particular interaction, are considered. The general conclusions reached are illustrated by numerical results.
The problem of expanding a density operator $\ensuremath{\rho}$ in forms that simplify the evaluation of important classes of quantum-mechanical expectation values is studied. The weight function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ of the PPP representation, the Wigner distribution $W(\ensuremath{\alpha})$, and the function $〈\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\rho}|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$, where $|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$ is a coherent state, are discussed from a unified point of view. Each of these quasiprobability distributions is examined as the expectation value of a Hermitian operator, as the weight function of an integral representation for the density operator and as the function associated with the density operator by one of the operator-function correspondences defined in the preceding paper. The weight function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ of the PPP representation is shown to be the expectation value of a Hermitian operator all of whose eigenvalues are infinite. The existence of the function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ as an infinitely differentiable function is found to be equivalent to the existence of a well-defined antinormally ordered series expansion for the density operator in powers of the annihilation and creation operators aaa and ${a}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$. The Wigner distribution $W(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ is shown to be a continuous, uniformly bounded, square-integrable weight function for an integral expansion of the density operator and to be the function associated with the symmetrically ordered power-series expansion of the density operator. The function $〈\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\rho}|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$, which is infinitely differentiable, corresponds to the normally ordered form of the density operator. Its use as a weight function in an integral expansion of the density operator is shown to involve singularities that are closely related to those which occur in the PPP representation. A parametrized integral expansion of the density operator is introduced in which the weight function $W(\ensuremath{\alpha},s)$ may be identified with the weight function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ of the PPP representation, with the Wigner distribution $W(\ensuremath{\alpha})$, and with the function $〈\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\rho}|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$ when the order parameter sss assumes the values $s=+1, 0, \ensuremath{-}1$, respectively. The function $W(\ensuremath{\alpha},s)$ is shown to be the expectation value of the ordered operator analog of the $\ensuremath{\delta}$ function defined in the preceding paper. This operator is in the trace class for Res<0\mathrm{Res}<0Res<0, has bounded eigenvalues for Res=0\mathrm{Res}=0Res=0, and has infinite eigenvalues for s=1s=1s=1. Marked changes in the properties of the quasiprobability distribution $W(\ensuremath{\alpha},s)$ are exhibited as the order parameter sss is varied continuously from $s=\ensuremath{-}1$, corresponding to the function $〈\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\rho}|\ensuremath{\alpha}〉$, to s=+1s=+1s=+1, corresponding to the function $P(\ensuremath{\alpha})$. Methods for constructing these functions and for using them to compute expectation values are presented and illustrated with several examples. One of these examples leads to a physical characterization of the density operators for which the PPP representation is appropriate.