Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

Linear stochastic electrodynamics: Looking for the physics behind quantum theory

Luis de la Peña, Ana Marı́a Cetto

Published Jan 1, 1999• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this chapter, which covers part of the course given at ELAF, a straight-forward procedure is presented that leads from the basic postulates of stochastic electrodynamics to the usual formalism of quantum theory. The theory thus developed is called linear stochastic electrodynamics, to underline that one of its basic features is the (asymptotic) linear response of atomic systems to the background field. The chapter starts with a brief discussion of some open questions in quantum theory and of the possibility to find an answer to them by resorting to the zeropoint radiation field as the source of the quantum behavior of matter. The basic properties of this field are discussed, and a brief enumeration is made of some of the positive results and vital shortcomings of standard stochastic electrodynamics. After identifying the source of these shortcomings in the assumption that the background field is not altered by its interaction with matter, linear stochastic electrodynamics is developed and shown to lead, under certain approximations, to a consistent picture of both matter and field quantization. In the concluding part, it is shown that also the electron spin can be considered to be generated by the interaction of the particle with the zeropoint field; in particular, the two-valuedness of the spin projection is associated with the existence of just two independent states of polarization of the field.

DOI
10.1063/1.58238

Related papers

The Quantum Dice: An Introduction to Stochastic Electrodynamics

Luis de la Peña, Ana Marı́a Cetto

Preface. Part I: Prelude. 1. Quantum mechanics and the real world. 2. Quantum mechanics as a stochastic theory. 3. Elements of electrodynamics. Part II: Theme. 4. The zeropoint radiation field. 5. The equilibrium radiation field. 6. Environmental effects through the zero-point field. 7. The harmonic oscillator. 8. Quantum properties of other simple systems. 9. Breakdown of detailed energy balance. Part III: Coda. 10. Linear stochastic electrodynamics. 11. Radiative corrections in linear SED. 12. The wave properties of matter. 13. Stochastic optics. 14. Outlook and some corollaries. Bibliography. Index.

•Mar 14, 2014•230 citations

The Physics Underlying Quantum Phenomena

Ana Marı́a Cetto, Luis de la Peña

Chapter 10, more than any other, makes this textbook unique. It explains the physics underlying quantum phenomena, with the aim of giving the student a clearer picture of quantum behavior and its causes, and thus making it easier for them to understand the further reading. The phenomenological approach of stochastic quantum mechanics, inspired by Nelson’s theory, shows the Markovian nature of the quantum description. The discussion then points to the vacuum or zero-point field mentioned in Chapter 2, as the source of the quantum stochasticity and characteristic wave-like phenomena. The theory thus developed, stochastic electrodynamics, is shown to provide a first-principles explanation for the operator formalism and related quantum postulates. The chapter concludes with a brief introduction of the hydrodynamic quantum analogue of a walking droplet, a striking macroscopic example of a particle-wave system capable of expressing quantum-like features under appropriate conditions.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

Origin of the quantum operator formalism and its connection with linear response theory

Ana Marı́a Cetto, Luis de la Peña

Abstract Linear response theory is concerned with the way in which a physical system reacts to a small change in the applied forces. Here we show that quantum mechanics in the Heisenberg representation can be understood as a linear response theory. To this effect, we first address the question of the physical origin of the quantum operator formalism by considering the interaction of a bound electron with the radiation field, including the zero-point component, following the approach of stochastic electrodynamics. Once the electron has reached a stationary state, it responds linearly and resonantly to a set of modes of the driving radiation field. Such a response can lead the system to a new stationary state. Identifying a one-to-one relationship between the response variables and the corresponding operators results in the ( x,p ) commutator as the Poisson bracket of these variables with respect to the driving field amplitudes. To account for the order of the response variables, which is reflected in the non-commutativity of the operators, we introduce the concept of ordered covariance. The results obtained allow to establish a natural contact with linear response theory at the fundamental quantum level.

arXiv:2504.03144•The European Physical Journal Special Topics•Jul 16, 2025•1 citation

Contribution from stochastic electrodynamics to the understanding of quantum mechanics

Luis de la Peña, Ana Marı́a Cetto

During the last decades there has been a relatively extensive attempt to develop the theory of stochastic electrodynamics (SED) with a view to establishing it as the foundation for quantum mechanics. The theory had several important successes, but failed when applied to the study of particles subject to nonlinear forces. An analysis of the failure showed that its reasons are not to be ascribed to the principles of SED, but to the methods used to construct the theory, particularly the use of a Fokker-Planck approximation and perturbation theory. A new, non perturbative approach has been developed, called linear stochastic electrodynamics (LSED), of which a clean form is presented here. After introducing the fundamentals of SED, we discuss in detail the principles on which LSED is constructed. We pay attention to the fundamental issue of the mechanism that leads to the quantum behaviour of field and matter, and demonstrate that indeed LSED is a natural way to the quantum formalism by demanding its solutions to comply with a limited number of principles, each one with a clear physical meaning. As a further application of the principles of LSED we derive also the Planck distribution. In a final section we revisit some of the most tantalizing quandaries of quantum mechanics from the point of view offered by the present theory, and show that it offers a clear physical answer to them.

arXiv:quant-ph/0501011•Jan 3, 2005•12 citations

Time-Dependent Perturbations. Field Quantization and Second Quantization

Ana Marı́a Cetto, Luis de la Peña

Chapter 17 begins by approaching the general problem of a quantum system subject to a time-dependent perturbation. We then apply perturbation theory to the interaction of atomic matter with the radiation field and derive the most important radiative corrections. Atomic transitions – both induced and spontaneous – are discussed in detail, with some important applications. The formal introduction of field quantization allows us to make contact with quantum electrodynamics and quantum optics and discuss the Jaynes–Cummings model. Stochastic electrodynamics, in which the matter–field interaction is not a perturbation but is present ab initio, is used to explain atomic stability and its breakdown leading to radiative transitions. In the same spirit, the quantization of the field is physically justified by deriving the conventionally postulated field operators and their basic commutators. The chapter ends with a brief introduction to second quantization, an elegant and powerful formalism for describing and analyzing quantum many-body systems.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

Electrodynamics in the presence of sources

G. Compagno, Roberto Passante, Franco Persico

Introduction . In the previous chapter we have obtained the form of the coupling between matter and the electromagnetic field. We are thus in a position to treat electrodynamics in the presence of charges and currents. We start by obtaining the Euler-Lagrange equations of the matter-electromagnetic field system. These turn out to be the Maxwell-Lorentz equations, which is a set of coupled equations of motion in which the matter field acts as a source for the electromagnetic field and vice versa. In Section 4.2 we derive the Hamiltonian of the complete system in the Coulomb gauge, and this leads to the so-called minimal coupling Hamiltonian, containing both the electromagnetic potential and the matter-field amplitude. Specializing the nonrelativistic matter field to the case of a neutral atom, consisting of the field of electrons in a static nuclear potential, in Section 4.3 we obtain the atom-photon Hamiltonian in the minimal coupling scheme. Some of the basic processes induced by the atom-photon interaction part of the Hamiltonian are also discussed in this section. This gives us the possibility of introducing at this stage a fundamental simplification of the interaction Hamiltonian, namely the electric dipole approximation. The minimal coupling scheme, however, is not the only possible atom-field coupling.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 3, 1995•0 citations
In this chapter, which covers part of the course given at ELAF, a straight-forward procedure is presented that leads from the basic postulates of stochastic electrodynamics to the usual formalism of quantum theory. The theory thus developed is called linear stochastic electrodynamics, to underline that one of its basic features is the (asymptotic) linear response of atomic systems to the background field. The chapter starts with a brief discussion of some open questions in quantum theory and of the possibility to find an answer to them by resorting to the zeropoint radiation field as the source of the quantum behavior of matter. The basic properties of this field are discussed, and a brief enumeration is made of some of the positive results and vital shortcomings of standard stochastic electrodynamics. After identifying the source of these shortcomings in the assumption that the background field is not altered by its interaction with matter, linear stochastic electrodynamics is developed and shown to lead, under certain approximations, to a consistent picture of both matter and field quantization. In the concluding part, it is shown that also the electron spin can be considered to be generated by the interaction of the particle with the zeropoint field; in particular, the two-valuedness of the spin projection is associated with the existence of just two independent states of polarization of the field.
Preface. Part I: Prelude. 1. Quantum mechanics and the real world. 2. Quantum mechanics as a stochastic theory. 3. Elements of electrodynamics. Part II: Theme. 4. The zeropoint radiation field. 5. The equilibrium radiation field. 6. Environmental effects through the zero-point field. 7. The harmonic oscillator. 8. Quantum properties of other simple systems. 9. Breakdown of detailed energy balance. Part III: Coda. 10. Linear stochastic electrodynamics. 11. Radiative corrections in linear SED. 12. The wave properties of matter. 13. Stochastic optics. 14. Outlook and some corollaries. Bibliography. Index.
Chapter 10, more than any other, makes this textbook unique. It explains the physics underlying quantum phenomena, with the aim of giving the student a clearer picture of quantum behavior and its causes, and thus making it easier for them to understand the further reading. The phenomenological approach of stochastic quantum mechanics, inspired by Nelson’s theory, shows the Markovian nature of the quantum description. The discussion then points to the vacuum or zero-point field mentioned in Chapter 2, as the source of the quantum stochasticity and characteristic wave-like phenomena. The theory thus developed, stochastic electrodynamics, is shown to provide a first-principles explanation for the operator formalism and related quantum postulates. The chapter concludes with a brief introduction of the hydrodynamic quantum analogue of a walking droplet, a striking macroscopic example of a particle-wave system capable of expressing quantum-like features under appropriate conditions.
Abstract Linear response theory is concerned with the way in which a physical system reacts to a small change in the applied forces. Here we show that quantum mechanics in the Heisenberg representation can be understood as a linear response theory. To this effect, we first address the question of the physical origin of the quantum operator formalism by considering the interaction of a bound electron with the radiation field, including the zero-point component, following the approach of stochastic electrodynamics. Once the electron has reached a stationary state, it responds linearly and resonantly to a set of modes of the driving radiation field. Such a response can lead the system to a new stationary state. Identifying a one-to-one relationship between the response variables and the corresponding operators results in the ( x,p ) commutator as the Poisson bracket of these variables with respect to the driving field amplitudes. To account for the order of the response variables, which is reflected in the non-commutativity of the operators, we introduce the concept of ordered covariance. The results obtained allow to establish a natural contact with linear response theory at the fundamental quantum level.
During the last decades there has been a relatively extensive attempt to develop the theory of stochastic electrodynamics (SED) with a view to establishing it as the foundation for quantum mechanics. The theory had several important successes, but failed when applied to the study of particles subject to nonlinear forces. An analysis of the failure showed that its reasons are not to be ascribed to the principles of SED, but to the methods used to construct the theory, particularly the use of a Fokker-Planck approximation and perturbation theory. A new, non perturbative approach has been developed, called linear stochastic electrodynamics (LSED), of which a clean form is presented here. After introducing the fundamentals of SED, we discuss in detail the principles on which LSED is constructed. We pay attention to the fundamental issue of the mechanism that leads to the quantum behaviour of field and matter, and demonstrate that indeed LSED is a natural way to the quantum formalism by demanding its solutions to comply with a limited number of principles, each one with a clear physical meaning. As a further application of the principles of LSED we derive also the Planck distribution. In a final section we revisit some of the most tantalizing quandaries of quantum mechanics from the point of view offered by the present theory, and show that it offers a clear physical answer to them.
Chapter 17 begins by approaching the general problem of a quantum system subject to a time-dependent perturbation. We then apply perturbation theory to the interaction of atomic matter with the radiation field and derive the most important radiative corrections. Atomic transitions – both induced and spontaneous – are discussed in detail, with some important applications. The formal introduction of field quantization allows us to make contact with quantum electrodynamics and quantum optics and discuss the Jaynes–Cummings model. Stochastic electrodynamics, in which the matter–field interaction is not a perturbation but is present ab initio, is used to explain atomic stability and its breakdown leading to radiative transitions. In the same spirit, the quantization of the field is physically justified by deriving the conventionally postulated field operators and their basic commutators. The chapter ends with a brief introduction to second quantization, an elegant and powerful formalism for describing and analyzing quantum many-body systems.
Introduction . In the previous chapter we have obtained the form of the coupling between matter and the electromagnetic field. We are thus in a position to treat electrodynamics in the presence of charges and currents. We start by obtaining the Euler-Lagrange equations of the matter-electromagnetic field system. These turn out to be the Maxwell-Lorentz equations, which is a set of coupled equations of motion in which the matter field acts as a source for the electromagnetic field and vice versa. In Section 4.2 we derive the Hamiltonian of the complete system in the Coulomb gauge, and this leads to the so-called minimal coupling Hamiltonian, containing both the electromagnetic potential and the matter-field amplitude. Specializing the nonrelativistic matter field to the case of a neutral atom, consisting of the field of electrons in a static nuclear potential, in Section 4.3 we obtain the atom-photon Hamiltonian in the minimal coupling scheme. Some of the basic processes induced by the atom-photon interaction part of the Hamiltonian are also discussed in this section. This gives us the possibility of introducing at this stage a fundamental simplification of the interaction Hamiltonian, namely the electric dipole approximation. The minimal coupling scheme, however, is not the only possible atom-field coupling.