Quantum Optics. II. Description of a Mode
I. R. Senitzky
Conceptual problems in quantum optics are investigated by a study of the physical significance of various types of description of the field of a single mode. The descriptions are examined through the effect of the field on matter. Both undamped and damped modes are considered, the descriptions being those of various degrees of precision in classical and quantum-mechanical formalisms. The matter consists of a large number of "molecules," and the interaction is studied by means of low-order perturbation theory. Formal expressions are obtained for the energy interchange between field and molecules in terms of the zeroth-order (uncoupled) operators, with the effect of the commutation properties of the field variables explicitly separated from that of the excitation of the field, in second order. The significance of taking expectation values of the operator results is discussed, and it is concluded that this procedure is justified only when the experiment under consideration involves an averaging process; thus, the molecular variables should be averaged, but not necessarily those of the field. Conditions under which the averaging process is justified are considered, and it is reasoned that, when such a process is not justified, a statistical description of the field can result only in a statistical description of the interaction process. Results of various field descriptions are compared, and it is shown that for induced emission and for spontaneous emission from coherently oscillating molecules, classical and quantum-mechanical fields are equivalent. However, for a self-consistent theory of spontaneous emission from molecules that are not oscillating coherently, the quantum-mechanical commutation properties of the field are essential if the molecules are treated quantum-mecahnically, and the field must be treated classically if the molecules are treated classically; the type of description used for the excitation of the field is inconsequential. Photoelectric emission is examined, and, within the approximation framework used, shown to be accurately described by a classical treatment of the field. It is pointed out that there does not necessarily exist a connection between "photon statistics," that is, the statistics associated with an ensemble of fields, and photocurrent fluctuations in one or more detectors coupled to the same field.
Physical Review•Oct 25, 1968•4 citations