Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Materials science forum

Rare Earth Doped Crystals for Quantum Information: Quantum Computing and Quantum Storage

Philippe Goldner, O. Guillot-Noël

Published Jul 1, 2006• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum information uses special properties of quantum systems to manipulate or transmit data. This results in new processes, which are impossible to obtain with classical devices. For example, quantum computing and quantum storage, which are two important fields in quantum information research, aim respectively at performing very fast calculations and at storing quantum states of photons. These two applications could be obtained in solid-state systems using rare earth doped crystals. In this context, the most important property of these materials is the long coherence lifetimes of rare earth ion optical and hyperfine transitions. This allows one to create long-lived superposition states, which is a fundamental requirement for efficient quantum computing and storage. Promising results have already been demonstrated in rare earth doped crystals but it will be difficult to improve them with current materials. In this paper, we discuss the general and specific requirements for rare earth ions and crystals in order to perform quantum computing with a large number of quantum bits as well as all solid-state quantum storage. We also present the properties of a few recently studied crystals: Ho3+:YVO4, Ho3+:LuVO4 (quantum computing) and Tm3+:Y3Al5O12 (quantum storage).

DOI
10.4028/www.scientific.net/msf.518.173

Related papers

Coherent Interactions in Rare-Earth-Ion-Doped Crystals for Applications in Quantum Information Science

Mattias Nilsson

This thesis describes investigations of the use of cryogenically cooled rare-earth-ion-doped crystals for quantum information processing and quantum optics. Several aspects of the coherent interaction between light and rare-earth ions in solids are addressed. Quantum information science has given physicists new views of quantum mechanics. The transmission of quantum states has already found practical use and full scale quantum computers may one day perform computations and simulations that would be impossible on a conventional computer. The work presented in this thesis can be seen as a part of a broad effort to learn how to control and manipulate quantum mechanical systems, which will become necessary as science and technology continue to push ever deeper into the nanoscopic world. Coherent radiation, such as laser light, provides us with an ideal tool for these investigations and, along the way, we may also learn more about the quantum nature of light. Rare-earth ions in inorganic crystals have several unusual properties that are interesting for applications within quantum information science, including long coherence times and long-lived ground state sublevels that can be used for storage of quantum and classical information. As part of the work presented in this thesis, new materials have been investigated with respect to these properties, and ways to enhance the useful properties of the materials were explored. In one investigation, the lifetime of information stored in the ground state population distribution of Tm3 ions in YAG was shown to increase by several orders of magnitude with the application of a magnetic field. It is demonstrated how the optical inhomogeneous absorption profile can be prepared, so that the light only interacts with a selected group of ions, absorbing on a specific transition. Narrow absorbing structures, with widths approaching the optical homogeneous linewidth, have been prepared with no absorption in the surrounding spectral interval. This thesis addresses the use of such structures as hardware for quantum bits. Tailored pulses, capable of inducing controlled changes in the quantum states of the ions (qubits), even in the presence of unknown variations of coupling strengths and frequencies, have been realised experimentally and used for multiple transfer of ions between energy levels. Ion-ion interactions, which can be used for performing quantum logic operations, have been investigated in some detail. Techniques for selecting strongly interacting ions, by transferring weakly interacting ions to auxiliary states, have been demonstrated. A scheme for storing the quantum state of light in a solid, using photon-echo-like techniques, is proposed and analysed. In the proposed scheme, an optical wave packet is absorbed and subsequently re-emitted by an inhomogeneous absorption profile, which is tailored and externally controlled by the application of an electric field Additionally, an accumulated photon echo experiment has been performed using faint optical pulses. The experiment can be viewed as a demonstration of delayed self-interference of a single photon and as a demonstration of how a single photon can act as two of the fields in a photon echo process.

Lund reports on atomic physics•Jan 1, 2005•9 citations

Research progress of quantum coherence performance and applications of micro/nano scale rare-earth doped crystals

Mucheng Guo, Fudong Wang, Zhao-Gao Hu +5 more

Rare-earth ion doped crystals possess stable solid state physicochemical properties and long optical coherence time and spin coherence time, thus showing important development prospect in quantum information science and technology area. Investigations on macroscopic bulk rare-earth single crystals have obtained many promising results, especially in the field of optical quantum memory. With the rapid development of quantum information science, a variety of new functions or multifunctional integrations are found in rare earth crystal systems, such as on chip quantum storage, microwave to optical frequency conversion, scalable quantum single photon sources, and quantum logic gates. As a result, beyond the macroscopic bulk rare-earth single crystals, micro/nano-scale rare-earth crystals have received much attention in recent years and they are regarded as promising candidates in highly integrated hybrid quantum systems and miniaturized quantum devices. Moreover, wet chemical method synthesized micro/nano-scale rare-earth crystals have lower growth difficulty and more flexible manipulation in volume, shape and composition. Therefore, exploring high-performance micro/nano-scale rare-earth crystals and precisely manipulating their quantum states have become one of the important directions in today’s quantum information science and technology research. In this review, we first briefly introduce the basic concepts and high resolution spectroscopic techniques that are commonly used in rare earth ion doped crystals for quantum information science and technologies, such as hole burning technique and photon echo technique. Then we summarize comprehensively recent research status and development trends of rare earth ion doped polycrystalline nanoparticles, thin films, single crystal based micro systems, and some other micro/nano-scale rare earth platforms in terms of material fabrication, quantum coherence property, dephasing mechanisms, and also quantum device explorations. The latest research advances in quantum information applications such as quantum storage, quantum frequency conversion, quantum single photon sources and quantum logic gates are given. Finally, we discuss the possible optimization directions and strategies to improve the component design, material synthesis and quantum performance of micro/nano-scale rare earth crystals and their related quantum devices. This review highlights that the micro/nano-scale rare earth crystals may offer many new possibilities for designing quantum light-matter interfaces, thus are promising quantum systems to develop scalable and integrated quantum devices in the future.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

Coherent Processes in Rare-Earth-Ion-Doped Solids

Andreas Walther

This thesis describes a number of coherent processes, such as quantum information processing, superradiance and electromagnetically induced transparency, which have been experimentally implemented using rare-earth-ion-doped crystals. The rare-earths are a class of elements that have in common, an atomic structure that allows for very long lifetimes as well as coherence times, both on optical transitions and on spin transitions. These ions can be naturally trapped inside host crystals, and with the phonon vibrations removed by cooling down to cryogenic temperatures (< 4 K), they can be used for a number of different quantum information processes. Most experiments were carried out using PrYSO, but also other crystal types were investigated, such as Nd:YVO4, and La2(WO4)3. The characterization of the ions were done with a variety of methods, including among others, photon echo techniques and electromagnetically induced transparency. Quantum computing is a rapidly growing field and there are still many potential candidates for its implementation. In our work we have utilized the spin states of the Pr rare-earth ion as a qubit, and demonstrated arbitrary single qubit gates, which are important pieces towards a quantum computing realization in these systems. Most of the experimental work done for the thesis was carried out using an ensemble approach, that has the advantage of giving a strong readout signal, but for future scaling to multiple qubits, single instances are more promising, which is discussed. Quantum memories are crucial components in applications such as quantum networks and long distance quantum communication. In this thesis, work has been done to investigate how quantum memories can be implemented in rare-earth crystals. In particular, there are two protocols, CRIB and AFC, which were suggested with rare-earth crystals directly in mind, and both of these require high optical depth, for maximum recall efficiency. In this thesis, implications of being in the high optical depth regime, with phenomena such as superradiance, a collective effect that could cause the stored light to be immediately reemitted, and slow light effects that come from performing the storage inside spectrally structured materials, were investigated. In order to carry out the phase-sensitive experiments, a laser system with a very narrow linewidth of ~1 kHz at 606 nm was constructed, by locking the laser to a semi-persistent spectral hole. In addition, many experiments required advanced pulse shapes, such as complex sechyp pulses or pulses obtained from optimal control theory. In order to be able to accurately create such shapes, an elaborate system using an arbitrary waveform generator and two well calibrated AOMs, controlled from a computer, was also built.

•Jan 1, 2009•5 citations

Long-lived quantum memories with rare-earth ions doped in crystals

Yu-Yu Sa, Pei-Xi Liu, Zong‐Quan Zhou +1 more

Abstract Quantum memory is a core enabling device for large-scale quantum networks, serving as the fundamental building block for quantum repeaters and transportable quantum memories. Among various physical platforms, rare-earth-ion-doped crystals stand out as one of the most promising solid-state candidates for long-lived photonic quantum memories, owing to their exceptionally long spin coherence time and their compatibility with integration. In this review, we first introduce the physical mechanisms underlying long-lived spin coherence in rare-earth systems, with particular emphasis on the zero-first-order-Zeeman transition and dynamical decoupling techniques. We then review the experimental progress in this field, highlighting three distinct lifetimes—the spin coherence time, the light storage time, and the quantum storage time—and covering experiments that have achieved hour-scale spin coherence, minute- to hour-scale light storage, and minute-scale single-photon-level quantum storage. Finally, we discuss the remaining challenges that hinder the realization of practical long-lived quantum memories, explore potential strategies to overcome these obstacles, and outline the prospects for their future applications in quantum networks.

Quantum Frontiers•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Computing Hardware based on Rare-Earth-Ion Doped Whispering-Gallery Mode Resonators

D. L. McAuslan

Rare-earth-ion doped crystals are an interesting system for quantum computing investigations due to their long optical and hyperfine coherence times. In particular, the ground-state coherence times can be longer than one second, which makes them perfect for long-term storage of quantum states. They also have the advantage of being a solid-state system. At present, many of the fundamental requirements for quantum computing have been demonstrated using rare-earth-ions; however, quantum state readout has yet to be achieved. The strong-coupling regime is of great importance in cavity quantum electrodynamics, as in this regime interactions between single atoms and single photons can be realized. Strong coupling thereby provides a method of enabling qubit-qubit interactions. It is desirable to achieve this regime with rare-earth-ion doped resonators, as it would enable on-demand readout of quantum states, a necessity for quantum computing, and provide the scalability required for implementation of quantum networks. This thesis describes the work that has gone into investigating the suitability of rare-earth-ion doped whispering-gallery mode resonators for quantum computing applications. A theoretical analysis of the strong-coupling regime is performed, followed by experiments investigating the properties of ions in resonators, and of new rare-earth-ion materials. A final set of experiments studies a new quantum memory protocol for use with rare-earth-ions. A theoretical investigation is undertaken to determine whether the strong-coupling regime will be attainable with rare-earth-ion doped whispering-gallery mode resonators. Emphasis is given to determining which rare-earth-ion materials will have the best properties when used as resonators. Specific applications of the strong-coupling regime are examined for this system; in particular, whether it will be possible to demonstrate the reversible transfer of quantum states, and detection of single dopants. Experiments are performed, measuring the properties of millimetre-sized Pr3+:Y2SiO5 resonators. Direct measurements of cavity quantum electrodynamics parameters are made using photon echoes, giving good agreement with theoretical predictions. Interactions between the atom and cavity are observed and a theoretical model is presented to describe these effects. Thus, a more realistic picture is obtained of the experimental requirements for achieving the strong-coupling regime. The properties of different rare-earth-ion doped materials are measured and analysed to determine their suitability for quantum computing applications. The spin Hamiltonian parameters of Pr3+:YAG are measured using Raman heterodyne spectroscopy, and then used to find the optical transitions with zero first-order Zeeman shift, as this should allow the coherence time to be extended to a point where this system is useful for resonator applications. Hyperfine transitions with zero first-order Zeeman shift are also calculated for Er3+:Y2SiO5, with the aim of enabling long-term storage in a telecommunication-wavelength memory. The thesis concludes with an experimental investigation into a new quantum memory technique that does not require spectral hole burning. The hybrid photon echo rephasing protocol uses strong optical pulses to perform rephasing, thus utilizing the advantageous properties of the two-pulse photon echo. Furthermore, the use of external broadening fields removes the usual problem of noise from amplified spontaneous emission. The properties of this memory are examined using a Pr3+:Y2SiO5 crystal.

•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

A solid-state source for non-classical photon pairs with controllable delay

Kutlu Kutluer, Margherita Mazzera, Hugues de Riedmatten

Quantum memories for light are important resources as quantum interfaces between light and matter in future quantum information networks. In particular, solid state optical memories based on rare earth ion doped (REID) crystals are of great interest due to their unique physical properties. They provide large number of atoms naturally trapped in a solid with narrow optical and spin transitions. They indeed have excellent optical and spin state coherence times at cryogenic temperatures. Among the various rare-earth doped materials, Pr3+ :Y 2 SiO 5 crystals have shown excellent properties for light storage and exhibit a level scheme suitable for long lived storage in spin states.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 1, 2017•0 citations
Quantum information uses special properties of quantum systems to manipulate or transmit data. This results in new processes, which are impossible to obtain with classical devices. For example, quantum computing and quantum storage, which are two important fields in quantum information research, aim respectively at performing very fast calculations and at storing quantum states of photons. These two applications could be obtained in solid-state systems using rare earth doped crystals. In this context, the most important property of these materials is the long coherence lifetimes of rare earth ion optical and hyperfine transitions. This allows one to create long-lived superposition states, which is a fundamental requirement for efficient quantum computing and storage. Promising results have already been demonstrated in rare earth doped crystals but it will be difficult to improve them with current materials. In this paper, we discuss the general and specific requirements for rare earth ions and crystals in order to perform quantum computing with a large number of quantum bits as well as all solid-state quantum storage. We also present the properties of a few recently studied crystals: Ho3+:YVO4, Ho3+:LuVO4 (quantum computing) and Tm3+:Y3Al5O12 (quantum storage).
This thesis describes investigations of the use of cryogenically cooled rare-earth-ion-doped crystals for quantum information processing and quantum optics. Several aspects of the coherent interaction between light and rare-earth ions in solids are addressed. Quantum information science has given physicists new views of quantum mechanics. The transmission of quantum states has already found practical use and full scale quantum computers may one day perform computations and simulations that would be impossible on a conventional computer. The work presented in this thesis can be seen as a part of a broad effort to learn how to control and manipulate quantum mechanical systems, which will become necessary as science and technology continue to push ever deeper into the nanoscopic world. Coherent radiation, such as laser light, provides us with an ideal tool for these investigations and, along the way, we may also learn more about the quantum nature of light. Rare-earth ions in inorganic crystals have several unusual properties that are interesting for applications within quantum information science, including long coherence times and long-lived ground state sublevels that can be used for storage of quantum and classical information. As part of the work presented in this thesis, new materials have been investigated with respect to these properties, and ways to enhance the useful properties of the materials were explored. In one investigation, the lifetime of information stored in the ground state population distribution of Tm3 ions in YAG was shown to increase by several orders of magnitude with the application of a magnetic field. It is demonstrated how the optical inhomogeneous absorption profile can be prepared, so that the light only interacts with a selected group of ions, absorbing on a specific transition. Narrow absorbing structures, with widths approaching the optical homogeneous linewidth, have been prepared with no absorption in the surrounding spectral interval. This thesis addresses the use of such structures as hardware for quantum bits. Tailored pulses, capable of inducing controlled changes in the quantum states of the ions (qubits), even in the presence of unknown variations of coupling strengths and frequencies, have been realised experimentally and used for multiple transfer of ions between energy levels. Ion-ion interactions, which can be used for performing quantum logic operations, have been investigated in some detail. Techniques for selecting strongly interacting ions, by transferring weakly interacting ions to auxiliary states, have been demonstrated. A scheme for storing the quantum state of light in a solid, using photon-echo-like techniques, is proposed and analysed. In the proposed scheme, an optical wave packet is absorbed and subsequently re-emitted by an inhomogeneous absorption profile, which is tailored and externally controlled by the application of an electric field Additionally, an accumulated photon echo experiment has been performed using faint optical pulses. The experiment can be viewed as a demonstration of delayed self-interference of a single photon and as a demonstration of how a single photon can act as two of the fields in a photon echo process.
Rare-earth ion doped crystals possess stable solid state physicochemical properties and long optical coherence time and spin coherence time, thus showing important development prospect in quantum information science and technology area. Investigations on macroscopic bulk rare-earth single crystals have obtained many promising results, especially in the field of optical quantum memory. With the rapid development of quantum information science, a variety of new functions or multifunctional integrations are found in rare earth crystal systems, such as on chip quantum storage, microwave to optical frequency conversion, scalable quantum single photon sources, and quantum logic gates. As a result, beyond the macroscopic bulk rare-earth single crystals, micro/nano-scale rare-earth crystals have received much attention in recent years and they are regarded as promising candidates in highly integrated hybrid quantum systems and miniaturized quantum devices. Moreover, wet chemical method synthesized micro/nano-scale rare-earth crystals have lower growth difficulty and more flexible manipulation in volume, shape and composition. Therefore, exploring high-performance micro/nano-scale rare-earth crystals and precisely manipulating their quantum states have become one of the important directions in today’s quantum information science and technology research. In this review, we first briefly introduce the basic concepts and high resolution spectroscopic techniques that are commonly used in rare earth ion doped crystals for quantum information science and technologies, such as hole burning technique and photon echo technique. Then we summarize comprehensively recent research status and development trends of rare earth ion doped polycrystalline nanoparticles, thin films, single crystal based micro systems, and some other micro/nano-scale rare earth platforms in terms of material fabrication, quantum coherence property, dephasing mechanisms, and also quantum device explorations. The latest research advances in quantum information applications such as quantum storage, quantum frequency conversion, quantum single photon sources and quantum logic gates are given. Finally, we discuss the possible optimization directions and strategies to improve the component design, material synthesis and quantum performance of micro/nano-scale rare earth crystals and their related quantum devices. This review highlights that the micro/nano-scale rare earth crystals may offer many new possibilities for designing quantum light-matter interfaces, thus are promising quantum systems to develop scalable and integrated quantum devices in the future.
This thesis describes a number of coherent processes, such as quantum information processing, superradiance and electromagnetically induced transparency, which have been experimentally implemented using rare-earth-ion-doped crystals. The rare-earths are a class of elements that have in common, an atomic structure that allows for very long lifetimes as well as coherence times, both on optical transitions and on spin transitions. These ions can be naturally trapped inside host crystals, and with the phonon vibrations removed by cooling down to cryogenic temperatures (< 4 K), they can be used for a number of different quantum information processes. Most experiments were carried out using PrYSO, but also other crystal types were investigated, such as Nd:YVO4, and La2(WO4)3. The characterization of the ions were done with a variety of methods, including among others, photon echo techniques and electromagnetically induced transparency. Quantum computing is a rapidly growing field and there are still many potential candidates for its implementation. In our work we have utilized the spin states of the Pr rare-earth ion as a qubit, and demonstrated arbitrary single qubit gates, which are important pieces towards a quantum computing realization in these systems. Most of the experimental work done for the thesis was carried out using an ensemble approach, that has the advantage of giving a strong readout signal, but for future scaling to multiple qubits, single instances are more promising, which is discussed. Quantum memories are crucial components in applications such as quantum networks and long distance quantum communication. In this thesis, work has been done to investigate how quantum memories can be implemented in rare-earth crystals. In particular, there are two protocols, CRIB and AFC, which were suggested with rare-earth crystals directly in mind, and both of these require high optical depth, for maximum recall efficiency. In this thesis, implications of being in the high optical depth regime, with phenomena such as superradiance, a collective effect that could cause the stored light to be immediately reemitted, and slow light effects that come from performing the storage inside spectrally structured materials, were investigated. In order to carry out the phase-sensitive experiments, a laser system with a very narrow linewidth of ~1 kHz at 606 nm was constructed, by locking the laser to a semi-persistent spectral hole. In addition, many experiments required advanced pulse shapes, such as complex sechyp pulses or pulses obtained from optimal control theory. In order to be able to accurately create such shapes, an elaborate system using an arbitrary waveform generator and two well calibrated AOMs, controlled from a computer, was also built.
Abstract Quantum memory is a core enabling device for large-scale quantum networks, serving as the fundamental building block for quantum repeaters and transportable quantum memories. Among various physical platforms, rare-earth-ion-doped crystals stand out as one of the most promising solid-state candidates for long-lived photonic quantum memories, owing to their exceptionally long spin coherence time and their compatibility with integration. In this review, we first introduce the physical mechanisms underlying long-lived spin coherence in rare-earth systems, with particular emphasis on the zero-first-order-Zeeman transition and dynamical decoupling techniques. We then review the experimental progress in this field, highlighting three distinct lifetimes—the spin coherence time, the light storage time, and the quantum storage time—and covering experiments that have achieved hour-scale spin coherence, minute- to hour-scale light storage, and minute-scale single-photon-level quantum storage. Finally, we discuss the remaining challenges that hinder the realization of practical long-lived quantum memories, explore potential strategies to overcome these obstacles, and outline the prospects for their future applications in quantum networks.
Rare-earth-ion doped crystals are an interesting system for quantum computing investigations due to their long optical and hyperfine coherence times. In particular, the ground-state coherence times can be longer than one second, which makes them perfect for long-term storage of quantum states. They also have the advantage of being a solid-state system. At present, many of the fundamental requirements for quantum computing have been demonstrated using rare-earth-ions; however, quantum state readout has yet to be achieved. The strong-coupling regime is of great importance in cavity quantum electrodynamics, as in this regime interactions between single atoms and single photons can be realized. Strong coupling thereby provides a method of enabling qubit-qubit interactions. It is desirable to achieve this regime with rare-earth-ion doped resonators, as it would enable on-demand readout of quantum states, a necessity for quantum computing, and provide the scalability required for implementation of quantum networks. This thesis describes the work that has gone into investigating the suitability of rare-earth-ion doped whispering-gallery mode resonators for quantum computing applications. A theoretical analysis of the strong-coupling regime is performed, followed by experiments investigating the properties of ions in resonators, and of new rare-earth-ion materials. A final set of experiments studies a new quantum memory protocol for use with rare-earth-ions. A theoretical investigation is undertaken to determine whether the strong-coupling regime will be attainable with rare-earth-ion doped whispering-gallery mode resonators. Emphasis is given to determining which rare-earth-ion materials will have the best properties when used as resonators. Specific applications of the strong-coupling regime are examined for this system; in particular, whether it will be possible to demonstrate the reversible transfer of quantum states, and detection of single dopants. Experiments are performed, measuring the properties of millimetre-sized Pr3+:Y2SiO5 resonators. Direct measurements of cavity quantum electrodynamics parameters are made using photon echoes, giving good agreement with theoretical predictions. Interactions between the atom and cavity are observed and a theoretical model is presented to describe these effects. Thus, a more realistic picture is obtained of the experimental requirements for achieving the strong-coupling regime. The properties of different rare-earth-ion doped materials are measured and analysed to determine their suitability for quantum computing applications. The spin Hamiltonian parameters of Pr3+:YAG are measured using Raman heterodyne spectroscopy, and then used to find the optical transitions with zero first-order Zeeman shift, as this should allow the coherence time to be extended to a point where this system is useful for resonator applications. Hyperfine transitions with zero first-order Zeeman shift are also calculated for Er3+:Y2SiO5, with the aim of enabling long-term storage in a telecommunication-wavelength memory. The thesis concludes with an experimental investigation into a new quantum memory technique that does not require spectral hole burning. The hybrid photon echo rephasing protocol uses strong optical pulses to perform rephasing, thus utilizing the advantageous properties of the two-pulse photon echo. Furthermore, the use of external broadening fields removes the usual problem of noise from amplified spontaneous emission. The properties of this memory are examined using a Pr3+:Y2SiO5 crystal.
Quantum memories for light are important resources as quantum interfaces between light and matter in future quantum information networks. In particular, solid state optical memories based on rare earth ion doped (REID) crystals are of great interest due to their unique physical properties. They provide large number of atoms naturally trapped in a solid with narrow optical and spin transitions. They indeed have excellent optical and spin state coherence times at cryogenic temperatures. Among the various rare-earth doped materials, Pr3+ :Y 2 SiO 5 crystals have shown excellent properties for light storage and exhibit a level scheme suitable for long lived storage in spin states.