Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.04526 · Quantum Frontiers

Long-lived quantum memories with rare-earth ions doped in crystals

Yu-Yu Sa, Pei-Xi Liu, Zong-Quan Zhou, Chuan-Feng Li

quant-phSubmitted Nov 3, 2026• Announced Nov 4, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum memory is a core enabling device for large-scale quantum networks, serving as the fundamental building block for quantum repeaters and transportable quantum memories. Among various physical platforms, rare-earth-ion-doped crystals stand out as one of the most promising solid-state candidates for long-lived photonic quantum memories, owing to their exceptionally long spin coherence time and their compatibility with integration. In this review, we first introduce the physical mechanisms underlying long-lived spin coherence in rare-earth systems, with particular emphasis on the zero-first-order-Zeeman transition and dynamical decoupling techniques. We then review the experimental progress in this field, highlighting three distinct lifetimes--the spin coherence time, the light storage time, and the quantum storage time--and covering experiments that have achieved hour-scale spin coherence, minute- to hour-scale light storage, and minute-scale single-photon-level quantum storage. Finally, we discuss the remaining challenges that hinder the realization of practical long-lived quantum memories, explore potential strategies to overcome these obstacles, and outline the prospects for their future applications in quantum networks.

AI Summary

This review examines how rare-earth-ion-doped crystals support long-lived photonic memories and what prevents long spin coherence from translating into efficient quantum storage. It surveys published experiments rather than presenting new data, focusing on zero-first-order-Zeeman (ZEFOZ) transitions, which suppress linear magnetic-field sensitivity, and dynamical decoupling (DD), which refocuses spin dephasing. The discussion distinguishes ensemble spin coherence, coherent optical storage, and storage with demonstrated quantum fidelity. Reviewed milestones include approximately six-hour spin coherence in Eu$^{3+}$:Y$_2$SiO$_5$ under ZEFOZ conditions and DD; atomic-frequency-comb optical storage with a $52.9\pm1.2$ minute decay time and $92.9\pm4.9\%$ interference visibility after one hour; and noiseless-photon-echo storage of weak coherent inputs with a $27.6\pm0.5$ second decay time. In the latter experiment, time-bin fidelity was $88.0\%$ after 5.6 seconds, exceeding the corresponding $82.1\%$ classical benchmark. Retrieval after 42 seconds had a single-photon-equivalent signal-to-noise ratio of $1.34\pm0.33$, inferred from inputs averaging 4.14 photons; quantum fidelity was not directly demonstrated at that duration. The review identifies competing requirements for absorption and coherence: higher dopant concentration improves optical depth but increases interactions and broadening, while comb preparation further reduces effective absorption. Long DD sequences introduce pulse-error noise and heating, and ZEFOZ operation remains sensitive to higher-order magnetic fluctuations and field alignment. Proposed directions include improved crystals and control sequences, alternative ZEFOZ transitions, cavity-enhanced absorption, and compact cryogenic and magnetic hardware for integrated or transportable memories.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaims

Central claim may not hold: The review claims minute-scale quantum storage, but its explicitly reported above-classical qubit-fidelity demonstration is at 5.6 s, with no equivalent certification reported at tens-of-seconds delays. At 42 s, the reported single-photon-equivalent SNR is normalized from coherent pulses with mean photon number 4.14, and its interpretation as beyond-classical storage is conditional on an ideal single-photon input rather than established for the measured input ensemble. The conclusion identifies the 27.6 s signal-decay constant as a quantum storage time without establishing that the applicable quantum-fidelity benchmark remains exceeded for that duration.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Journal reference
Quantum Frontiers 5, 14 (2026)
DOI
10.1007/s44214-026-00110-1
Comments
The incorrect value 4.14 on page 7 of the published version has been corrected to 1.16

Related papers

Solid-state spin-wave quantum memories for single photons (Conference Presentation)

Hugues de Riedmatten

Photonic quantum memories are important devices in quantum information science, and are crucial for several applications including quantum repeaters and quantum networks. Rare-earth (RE) doped crystals are promising candidates as quantum memories for light as they offer coherence properties comparable to those of atomic systems, but free of the drawbacks deriving from atomic motion. The research on RE based quantum memories has been so far mostly focused on the mapping of photonic quantum bits to optical collective excitations, but this leads to short lived and mostly pre-determined storage. However, some RE ions, as Praseodymium and Europium, exhibit the suitable energy level scheme, with three long-lived hyperfine ground states, to enable the spin-wave storage by transferring the collective optical excitations into collective spin excitations. Proof of principle spin-wave quantum memories have been reported in rare-earth doped crystals, using weak coherent states as input [1,2]. Here, I will present our recent results on the realization of multimode spin-wave quantum memories in a Praseodymium doped crystal, using non-classical input light. [1] M. Gündoğan, P. M. Ledingham, K. Kutluer, M. Mazzera and H. de Riedmatten , A solid state spin-wave quantum memory for time-bin qubits, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 230501 (2015) [2] P. Jobez, C. Laplane, N. Timoney, N. Gisin, A. Ferrier, P. Goldner, and M. Afzelius, Coherent Spin Control at the Quantum Level in an Ensemble-Based Optical Memory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 230502 (2015)

•Apr 28, 2017•0 citations

Multimode solid-state quantum memory

Tian-Shu Yang, Zong‐Quan Zhou, Chuan‐Feng Li +1 more

The faithful storage and coherent manipulation of single photon state in a matter-system are crucial for linear-optical quantum computation, long-distance quantum communication, and quantum networking.To reach useful data rate in a large-scale quantum network, highly multimode quantum memories are required to build a multiplexed quantum repeater.Rare-earth-ion doped crystal (REIC) is very promising material as a candidate for multimode quantum storage due to the wide inhomogeneous broadening and long optical coherence time.In this article, we review the recent advances in multimode quantum memories based on REICs.First, we briefly introduce the properties of REIC and the atomic frequency comb protocol based on REIC.Next, we review the achievements of multimode quantum memories based on REIC in recent years, including frequency, temporal and spatial multimode storage.Afterwards, we review our experimental work on multiplexed storage based on a multiple degree-of-freedom quantum memory.Finally, we introduce the quantum mode converter and real-time arbitrary manipulations based on the multiple degree-of-freedom quantum memory. The combination of storage and real-time manipulation in a device should enable the construction of a versatility quantum repeater.This review highlights that multimode quantum memories based on REIC can be found to possess some practical applications in developing the optical quantum information processing in the near future.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 2019•2 citations

Solid state quantum memory

Zong‐Quan Zhou, ChuanFeng Li

Quantum memory is one of the fundamental building blocks for quantum networks. It can be used as a synchronization tool that matches various processes within a quantum computer, a tool to convert heralded photons to photons-on-demand and a quantum repeater for long-distance quantum communication. The rare-earth-ion doped crystal has been one of the best candidate systems for quantum memory. Here we report on the state-of-the-art developments in the field of solid state quantum memory, detail current perfomance levels and discuss potential applications of the developed techniques in other fields.

Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)•Feb 1, 2013•6 citations

Storage and retrieval of collective excitations on a long-lived spin transition in a rare-earth ion-doped crystal

Elizabeth A. Goldschmidt, Sarah E. Beavan, Sergey V. Polyakov +2 more

Robust, long-lived optical quantum memories are important components of many quantum information and communication protocols. We demonstrate coherent generation, storage, and retrieval of excitations on a long-lived spin transition via spontaneous Raman scattering in a rare-earth ion-doped crystal. We further study the time dynamics of the optical correlations in this system. This is the first demonstration of its kind in a solid and an enabling step toward realizing a solid-state quantum repeater.

Optics Express•Apr 16, 2013•11 citations

Quantum light storage in rare-earth-ion-doped solids

Yi-Lin Hua, Zong‐Quan Zhou, Chuan‐Feng Li +1 more

The reversible transfer of unknown quantum states between light and matter is essential for constructing large-scale quantum networks. Over the last decade, various physical systems have been proposed to realize such quantum memory for light. The solid-state quantum memory based on rare-earth-ion-doped solids has the advantages of a reduced setup complexity and high robustness for scalable application. We describe the methods used to spectrally prepare the quantum memory and release the photonic excitation on-demand. We will review the state of the art experiments and discuss the perspective applications of this particular system in both quantum information science and fundamental tests of quantum physics.

Chinese Physics B•Feb 1, 2018•12 citations

Long-Lived Spin Coherence in a Densely Populated Stoichiometric Rare-Earth Crystal

Anonymous, Zhehao Xu, Weiye Sun +7 more

Dense rare-earth spin ensembles in solids offer strong collective light-matter coupling for scalable quantum technologies but are typically incompatible with long coherence times due to strong dipolar interactions. Here we challenge this paradigm by showing long-lived coherence in such systems. In a stoichiometric EuCl_{3}·6H_{2}O crystal, we achieve hyperfine coherence times T_{2}^{CPMG} of up to 15 s at 4 K, extending the zero-field value T_{2} of 1.28 ms by more than four orders of magnitude using dynamical decoupling at a zero-first-order Zeeman (ZEFOZ) transition. Homogeneous linewidth measurements reveal a substantial suppression of resonant Eu^{3+}-Eu^{3+} spin interactions introduced by the full concentration near the ZEFOZ point. Coherence remains resilient to strong local perturbations, with a 32 ms coherence time for Eu^{3+} ions adjacent to Er^{3+} dopants. These results establish stoichiometric rare-earth crystals as a promising platform for quantum memories and spin-photon interfaces, demonstrating that intrinsically high optical depth and long-lived spin coherence can coexist in a fully concentrated ensemble.

Physical Review Letters•Sep 3, 2026•0 citations
Quantum memory is a core enabling device for large-scale quantum networks, serving as the fundamental building block for quantum repeaters and transportable quantum memories. Among various physical platforms, rare-earth-ion-doped crystals stand out as one of the most promising solid-state candidates for long-lived photonic quantum memories, owing to their exceptionally long spin coherence time and their compatibility with integration. In this review, we first introduce the physical mechanisms underlying long-lived spin coherence in rare-earth systems, with particular emphasis on the zero-first-order-Zeeman transition and dynamical decoupling techniques. We then review the experimental progress in this field, highlighting three distinct lifetimes--the spin coherence time, the light storage time, and the quantum storage time--and covering experiments that have achieved hour-scale spin coherence, minute- to hour-scale light storage, and minute-scale single-photon-level quantum storage. Finally, we discuss the remaining challenges that hinder the realization of practical long-lived quantum memories, explore potential strategies to overcome these obstacles, and outline the prospects for their future applications in quantum networks.
This review examines how rare-earth-ion-doped crystals support long-lived photonic memories and what prevents long spin coherence from translating into efficient quantum storage. It surveys published experiments rather than presenting new data, focusing on zero-first-order-Zeeman (ZEFOZ) transitions, which suppress linear magnetic-field sensitivity, and dynamical decoupling (DD), which refocuses spin dephasing.
The discussion distinguishes ensemble spin coherence, coherent optical storage, and storage with demonstrated quantum fidelity. Reviewed milestones include approximately six-hour spin coherence in Eu3+^{3+}3+:Y2_22​SiO5_55​ under ZEFOZ conditions and DD; atomic-frequency-comb optical storage with a 52.9±1.252.9\pm1.252.9±1.2 minute decay time and 92.9±4.9%92.9\pm4.9\%92.9±4.9% interference visibility after one hour; and noiseless-photon-echo storage of weak coherent inputs with a 27.6±0.527.6\pm0.527.6±0.5 second decay time. In the latter experiment, time-bin fidelity was 88.0%88.0\%88.0% after 5.6 seconds, exceeding the corresponding 82.1%82.1\%82.1% classical benchmark. Retrieval after 42 seconds had a single-photon-equivalent signal-to-noise ratio of 1.34±0.331.34\pm0.331.34±0.33, inferred from inputs averaging 4.14 photons; quantum fidelity was not directly demonstrated at that duration.
The review identifies competing requirements for absorption and coherence: higher dopant concentration improves optical depth but increases interactions and broadening, while comb preparation further reduces effective absorption. Long DD sequences introduce pulse-error noise and heating, and ZEFOZ operation remains sensitive to higher-order magnetic fluctuations and field alignment. Proposed directions include improved crystals and control sequences, alternative ZEFOZ transitions, cavity-enhanced absorption, and compact cryogenic and magnetic hardware for integrated or transportable memories.
Photonic quantum memories are important devices in quantum information science, and are crucial for several applications including quantum repeaters and quantum networks. Rare-earth (RE) doped crystals are promising candidates as quantum memories for light as they offer coherence properties comparable to those of atomic systems, but free of the drawbacks deriving from atomic motion. The research on RE based quantum memories has been so far mostly focused on the mapping of photonic quantum bits to optical collective excitations, but this leads to short lived and mostly pre-determined storage. However, some RE ions, as Praseodymium and Europium, exhibit the suitable energy level scheme, with three long-lived hyperfine ground states, to enable the spin-wave storage by transferring the collective optical excitations into collective spin excitations. Proof of principle spin-wave quantum memories have been reported in rare-earth doped crystals, using weak coherent states as input [1,2]. Here, I will present our recent results on the realization of multimode spin-wave quantum memories in a Praseodymium doped crystal, using non-classical input light. [1] M. Gündoğan, P. M. Ledingham, K. Kutluer, M. Mazzera and H. de Riedmatten , A solid state spin-wave quantum memory for time-bin qubits, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 230501 (2015) [2] P. Jobez, C. Laplane, N. Timoney, N. Gisin, A. Ferrier, P. Goldner, and M. Afzelius, Coherent Spin Control at the Quantum Level in an Ensemble-Based Optical Memory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 230502 (2015)
The faithful storage and coherent manipulation of single photon state in a matter-system are crucial for linear-optical quantum computation, long-distance quantum communication, and quantum networking.To reach useful data rate in a large-scale quantum network, highly multimode quantum memories are required to build a multiplexed quantum repeater.Rare-earth-ion doped crystal (REIC) is very promising material as a candidate for multimode quantum storage due to the wide inhomogeneous broadening and long optical coherence time.In this article, we review the recent advances in multimode quantum memories based on REICs.First, we briefly introduce the properties of REIC and the atomic frequency comb protocol based on REIC.Next, we review the achievements of multimode quantum memories based on REIC in recent years, including frequency, temporal and spatial multimode storage.Afterwards, we review our experimental work on multiplexed storage based on a multiple degree-of-freedom quantum memory.Finally, we introduce the quantum mode converter and real-time arbitrary manipulations based on the multiple degree-of-freedom quantum memory. The combination of storage and real-time manipulation in a device should enable the construction of a versatility quantum repeater.This review highlights that multimode quantum memories based on REIC can be found to possess some practical applications in developing the optical quantum information processing in the near future.
Quantum memory is one of the fundamental building blocks for quantum networks. It can be used as a synchronization tool that matches various processes within a quantum computer, a tool to convert heralded photons to photons-on-demand and a quantum repeater for long-distance quantum communication. The rare-earth-ion doped crystal has been one of the best candidate systems for quantum memory. Here we report on the state-of-the-art developments in the field of solid state quantum memory, detail current perfomance levels and discuss potential applications of the developed techniques in other fields.
Robust, long-lived optical quantum memories are important components of many quantum information and communication protocols. We demonstrate coherent generation, storage, and retrieval of excitations on a long-lived spin transition via spontaneous Raman scattering in a rare-earth ion-doped crystal. We further study the time dynamics of the optical correlations in this system. This is the first demonstration of its kind in a solid and an enabling step toward realizing a solid-state quantum repeater.
The reversible transfer of unknown quantum states between light and matter is essential for constructing large-scale quantum networks. Over the last decade, various physical systems have been proposed to realize such quantum memory for light. The solid-state quantum memory based on rare-earth-ion-doped solids has the advantages of a reduced setup complexity and high robustness for scalable application. We describe the methods used to spectrally prepare the quantum memory and release the photonic excitation on-demand. We will review the state of the art experiments and discuss the perspective applications of this particular system in both quantum information science and fundamental tests of quantum physics.
Dense rare-earth spin ensembles in solids offer strong collective light-matter coupling for scalable quantum technologies but are typically incompatible with long coherence times due to strong dipolar interactions. Here we challenge this paradigm by showing long-lived coherence in such systems. In a stoichiometric EuCl_{3}·6H_{2}O crystal, we achieve hyperfine coherence times T_{2}^{CPMG} of up to 15 s at 4 K, extending the zero-field value T_{2} of 1.28 ms by more than four orders of magnitude using dynamical decoupling at a zero-first-order Zeeman (ZEFOZ) transition. Homogeneous linewidth measurements reveal a substantial suppression of resonant Eu^{3+}-Eu^{3+} spin interactions introduced by the full concentration near the ZEFOZ point. Coherence remains resilient to strong local perturbations, with a 32 ms coherence time for Eu^{3+} ions adjacent to Er^{3+} dopants. These results establish stoichiometric rare-earth crystals as a promising platform for quantum memories and spin-photon interfaces, demonstrating that intrinsically high optical depth and long-lived spin coherence can coexist in a fully concentrated ensemble.