Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Today

Kramers's Contributions to Statistical Mechanics

Max Dresden

Published Sep 1, 1988• 10 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Hendrik A. Kramers was a major figure in the long and painful struggle that propelled quantum physics from the inspired but artful guessing game of the Bohr rules to a well-defined, coherent and systematic quantum mechanics. Kramers's basic and deep contributions in this struggle are barely known nowadays, and he actually suffers in comparison with Niels Bohr and Louis de Broglie, let alone Paul Dirac, Werner Heisenberg and Wolfgang Pauli. Kramers is still known for a number of isolated and disconnected results, such as the WKB method, the Kramers degeneracy in magnetism and the Kramers-Kronig relations. Although these are unquestionably significant and first-rate contributions, they do not demonstrate Kramers's deep physical insight and his profound concern for fundamental questions. They show Kramers as an extraordinarily skillful craftsman rather than as a scientific innovator. This may be an important reason why Kramers's reputation has faded so markedly in comparison with those of, say, Heisenberg or Pauli, whose contemporary he was and who, as his fellow architects of quantum mechanics, recognized him as a talented physicist and deep thinker. For example, when Bartel L. van der Waerden started to collect what he believed were the seminal papers in quantum mechanics, Pauli, hardly a person known for his generosity in giving undeserved credit, alerted him to the importance of Kramers's investigations.

DOI
10.1063/1.881132

Related papers

The third way to quantum mechanics is the forgotten first

S. Antoci, Dierck Ekkehard Liebscher

Quantum mechanics can be formulated in three ways, as Heisenberg, Schrödinger and Feynman did respectively. For the last way, an unknown (i.e. forgotten) forerunner exists, that we have found in a paper by Gregor Wentzel, published before the famous works by Heisenberg and Schrödinger, and contemporary with the fundamental works of L. de Broglie. In that paper, one can find the basic formulae and their interpretation as they were adopted by Feynman twenty years later. We believe that Wentzel's work was forgotten for several reasons: (I) Schrödinger's equation was much simpler to deal with (Wentzel himself contributed to its development in the same way as L.Brillouin and H.Kramers did). (II) The first application was rejected by Heisenberg and Kramers. (III) The approximation used by Wentzel was too na\"ıve and failed. Nevertheless, the foundation laid by Wentzel was sound, as it has been shown by Feynman's work. Therefore, Wentzel has to be considered as one of the founders of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:physics/9704028•Apr 28, 1997•9 citations

Quantum Mechanics

RICHARD E. FITZPATRICK

Quantum mechanics was developed during the first few decades of the twentieth century via a series of inspired guesses made by various physicists, including Planck, Einstein, Bohr, Schroedinger, Heisenberg, Pauli, and Dirac. All these scientists were trying to construct a self-consistent theory of microscopic dynamics that was compatible with experimental observations. The purpose of this book is to present quantum mechanics in a clear, concise, and systematic fashion, starting from the fundamental postulates, and developing the theory in as logical manner as possible. Topics covered in the book include the fundamental postulates of quantum mechanics, angular momentum, time-dependent and time-dependent perturbation theory, scattering theory, identical particles, and relativistic electron theory.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 18, 2015•20 citations

When Bohr got it wrong

Philip Ball

Philip Ball peers into the quantum past, and uncovers a little-known paper published by Niels Bohr, Hendrik Kramers and John Slater in 1924, that proposed that the first law of thermodynamics may no longer hold firm. Their idea turned out to be wrong, but in interesting and provocative ways, and it demonstrates the intense turmoil in physics on the brink of quantum mechanics.

Physics World•Feb 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics

Teunis C. Dorlas

At the beginning of the twentieth century, it became clear that microscopic particles do not obey Newton's laws of classical mechanics. The idea of light quanta was at odds with the established wisdom that light is a wave phenomenon, of course, but no other explanation of the photoelectric effect seemed possible. The next step in the development of quantum mechanics was taken by Niels Bohr, who introduced postulates about the discreteness of the energy of the bound electrons in an atom similar to the discreteness of the energy of light quanta. Modern quantum mechanics was founded by Werner Heisenberg, Max Born, Erwin Schroedinger, Paul Adrian Maurice Dirac, Wolfgang Pauli, Enrico Fermi, and others. In quantum mechanics, it is in general fundamentally impossible to determine the exact outcome of an experiment; one can only determine the probability of any given outcome.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 2, 2021•0 citations

Reflections on the philosophy of Bohr, Heisenberg, and Schrödinger

Abner Shimony

Many of the pioneers of quantum mechanics – notably Planck, Einstein, Bohr, de Broglie, Heisenberg, Schrodinger, Born, Jordan, Landé, Wigner, and London – were seriously concerned with philosophical problems. In each case one can ask a question of psychological and historical interest: was it a philosophical penchant which drew the investigator towards a kind of physics research which is linked to philosophy, or was it rather that the conceptual difficulties of fundamental physics pulled him willynilly into the labyrinth of philosophy? I shall not undertake to discuss this question, but shall cite an opinion of Peter Bergmann, which I find congenial: he learned from Einstein that “the theoretical physicist is … a philosopher in workingman's clothes” ([1], q. v.).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•3 citations

Niels Bohr. Rule Breaker

Helge Kastrup, Jeffry V. Mallow A

Niels Bohr made numerous contributions to physics. But his most important was to break the rules. Bohr propounded several postulates. First, that electrons revolved in their orbits around the nucleus of an atom without emitting energy. Second, that spectral lines came from electrons emitting energy by jumping from one orbit to a lower one. Third, that only certain orbital radii were allowed. All three of these unsubstantiated claims violated classical physics, according to which accelerating charges emit energy. Thus, electrons should lose their energy and spiral into the nucleus. But this theory could not account for spectra; Bohr's postulates could. Bohr was the leader of a brilliant group of physicists who developed most of the fundamentals of quantum mechanics and showed that its laws proved the validity of his inspired guesses. A non-member of the group was Einstein, who disagreed with his friend Bohr over the actual meaning of quantum mechanics.

•Sep 27, 2022•0 citations
Hendrik A. Kramers was a major figure in the long and painful struggle that propelled quantum physics from the inspired but artful guessing game of the Bohr rules to a well-defined, coherent and systematic quantum mechanics. Kramers's basic and deep contributions in this struggle are barely known nowadays, and he actually suffers in comparison with Niels Bohr and Louis de Broglie, let alone Paul Dirac, Werner Heisenberg and Wolfgang Pauli. Kramers is still known for a number of isolated and disconnected results, such as the WKB method, the Kramers degeneracy in magnetism and the Kramers-Kronig relations. Although these are unquestionably significant and first-rate contributions, they do not demonstrate Kramers's deep physical insight and his profound concern for fundamental questions. They show Kramers as an extraordinarily skillful craftsman rather than as a scientific innovator. This may be an important reason why Kramers's reputation has faded so markedly in comparison with those of, say, Heisenberg or Pauli, whose contemporary he was and who, as his fellow architects of quantum mechanics, recognized him as a talented physicist and deep thinker. For example, when Bartel L. van der Waerden started to collect what he believed were the seminal papers in quantum mechanics, Pauli, hardly a person known for his generosity in giving undeserved credit, alerted him to the importance of Kramers's investigations.
Quantum mechanics can be formulated in three ways, as Heisenberg, Schrödinger and Feynman did respectively. For the last way, an unknown (i.e. forgotten) forerunner exists, that we have found in a paper by Gregor Wentzel, published before the famous works by Heisenberg and Schrödinger, and contemporary with the fundamental works of L. de Broglie. In that paper, one can find the basic formulae and their interpretation as they were adopted by Feynman twenty years later. We believe that Wentzel's work was forgotten for several reasons: (I) Schrödinger's equation was much simpler to deal with (Wentzel himself contributed to its development in the same way as L.Brillouin and H.Kramers did). (II) The first application was rejected by Heisenberg and Kramers. (III) The approximation used by Wentzel was too na\"ıve and failed. Nevertheless, the foundation laid by Wentzel was sound, as it has been shown by Feynman's work. Therefore, Wentzel has to be considered as one of the founders of quantum mechanics.
Quantum mechanics was developed during the first few decades of the twentieth century via a series of inspired guesses made by various physicists, including Planck, Einstein, Bohr, Schroedinger, Heisenberg, Pauli, and Dirac. All these scientists were trying to construct a self-consistent theory of microscopic dynamics that was compatible with experimental observations. The purpose of this book is to present quantum mechanics in a clear, concise, and systematic fashion, starting from the fundamental postulates, and developing the theory in as logical manner as possible. Topics covered in the book include the fundamental postulates of quantum mechanics, angular momentum, time-dependent and time-dependent perturbation theory, scattering theory, identical particles, and relativistic electron theory.
At the beginning of the twentieth century, it became clear that microscopic particles do not obey Newton's laws of classical mechanics. The idea of light quanta was at odds with the established wisdom that light is a wave phenomenon, of course, but no other explanation of the photoelectric effect seemed possible. The next step in the development of quantum mechanics was taken by Niels Bohr, who introduced postulates about the discreteness of the energy of the bound electrons in an atom similar to the discreteness of the energy of light quanta. Modern quantum mechanics was founded by Werner Heisenberg, Max Born, Erwin Schroedinger, Paul Adrian Maurice Dirac, Wolfgang Pauli, Enrico Fermi, and others. In quantum mechanics, it is in general fundamentally impossible to determine the exact outcome of an experiment; one can only determine the probability of any given outcome.
Many of the pioneers of quantum mechanics – notably Planck, Einstein, Bohr, de Broglie, Heisenberg, Schrodinger, Born, Jordan, Landé, Wigner, and London – were seriously concerned with philosophical problems. In each case one can ask a question of psychological and historical interest: was it a philosophical penchant which drew the investigator towards a kind of physics research which is linked to philosophy, or was it rather that the conceptual difficulties of fundamental physics pulled him willynilly into the labyrinth of philosophy? I shall not undertake to discuss this question, but shall cite an opinion of Peter Bergmann, which I find congenial: he learned from Einstein that “the theoretical physicist is … a philosopher in workingman's clothes” ([1], q. v.).
Niels Bohr made numerous contributions to physics. But his most important was to break the rules. Bohr propounded several postulates. First, that electrons revolved in their orbits around the nucleus of an atom without emitting energy. Second, that spectral lines came from electrons emitting energy by jumping from one orbit to a lower one. Third, that only certain orbital radii were allowed. All three of these unsubstantiated claims violated classical physics, according to which accelerating charges emit energy. Thus, electrons should lose their energy and spiral into the nucleus. But this theory could not account for spectra; Bohr's postulates could. Bohr was the leader of a brilliant group of physicists who developed most of the fundamentals of quantum mechanics and showed that its laws proved the validity of his inspired guesses. A non-member of the group was Einstein, who disagreed with his friend Bohr over the actual meaning of quantum mechanics.