Physical Review A
Comment on Relative Magnetic Substate Amplitudes in Foil Excitation of Fast Hydrogen Atoms
Ivan A. Sellin
Abstract
If the particle-foil interaction potential governing production of H atoms coherently excited by passage through thin foils obeys the $\mathrm{LS}$ coupling scheme applied by Macek (conservation of $z$ components of total orbital and spin angular momenta of the entire particle-foil system, and incoherence of final states of foil constituents), the ad hoc assumption that random phases prevail among the hydrogenic magnetic substate amplitudes invoked in the interpretation of certain recent experiments is avoided. Arguments concerning relative phases of states of different orbital angular momentum are unaffected.