Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Optics and Spectroscopy

Observing superpositions of different number states

Jacob Dunningham, L M Rico-Gutierrez, Veiko Palge

Published Oct 1, 2011• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The formal structure of quantum mechanics allows systems to exist in a superposition of different states. A curious feature is that while some superpositions, such as position or momentum, are routinely observed, others such as mass or charge are not. This anomaly is at least partly due to the fact that it is much easier to carry out interference experiments for certain observables than others. Here we focus particularly on the superposition of two different number states for photons or bosonic atoms. This can equally well be thought of as a superposition of different masses in the case of atoms. We present different interferometry schemes that should, at least in principle, allow us to observe interference between these states. This would provide evidence of a superposition that we would normally consider to be prevented by superselection rules.

DOI
10.1134/s0030400x11110075

Related papers

Observing the superposition of a single particle with the vacuum

L M Rico-Gutierrez, Veiko Palge, Jacob Dunningham

A defining feature of quantum mechanics is that it allows systems to exist in a superposition of different eigenstates of certain observables such as position or spin. However, superpositions of other quantities such as mass or charge are not seen in nature. It is thought that this disparity is partly due to the fact that it is much easier to carry out interference experiments for certain observables than others. Here we present an interferometry scheme that should allow us to observe interference between the vacuum and a single photon or atom. We begin by presenting a scheme for a Hadamard gate that operates in the Fock state basis and then show how, by creating an interferometer from two such gates, interference between a single particle and the vacuum could indeed be observed. This would provide evidence of a superposition of different particle numbers.

Mathematical Structures in Computer Science•Nov 8, 2010•4 citations

Charge Superselection Rule

Yakir Aharonov, Leonard Susskind

Questions concerning superselection rules are considered. Two experiments are discussed. In the first, coherent superpositions of different angular-momentum states are constructed. In the second, coherent superpositions of states with different charge are constructed in complete analogy with the angular-momentum case. We suggest that, contrary to a widespread belief, interference may be possible between states with different charges.

Physical Review•Mar 25, 1967•242 citations

Searching for microscopic classical cats

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

With the exception of superselection rules, there are no known explicit violations of the Principle of quantum Superposition. However, quantum measurement and the emergence of classicality seem to imply that the Principle of Superposition is not universal, so perhaps new superselection rules or something similar wait to be found. This invites us to search for explicit violations of superposition, even in places where we expect it to hold. Given that many quantum measurement devices rely on atoms absorbing photons, these processes are natural places for a first search for such violations. We propose experiments designed to test whether the emission and absorption of photons by atoms may suppress the interference in certain conditions. If the atom is found, in certain situations, to absorb completely the photon, this would mean that in those situations the atom cannot exist or at least it cannot be stable as a superposition of states in which it absorbed the photon and it did not absorb it. Then we will have a new possibility to resolve the problem of measurement, and that of the emergence of classicality. A negative result would mean an additional confirmation of the Principle of Superposition in these particular cases.

arXiv:1604.05063•Apr 18, 2016•1 citation

Limitations on the superposition principle: superselection rules in non-relativistic quantum mechanics

C. Cisneros, R. P. Martı́nez-y-Romero, H. N. Núñez‐Yépez +1 more

The superposition principle is a very basic ingredient of quantum theory. What may come as a surprise to many students, and even to many practitioners of the quantum craft, is tha superposition has limitations imposed by certain requirements of the theory. The discussion of such limitations arising from the so-called superselection rules is the main purpose of this paper. Some of their principal consequences are also discussed. The univalence, mass and particle number superselection rules of non-relativistic quantum mechanics are also derived using rather simple methods.

arXiv:quant-ph/9809059•European Journal of Physics•May 1, 1998•25 citations

Single- and two-photon wave-particle superpositions: Theory and experiment

Qing-Feng Xue, Xu-Cai Zhuang, Nguyen Ba An +6 more

Simultaneous observation of the wave and particle natures of a quantum object under one experimental arrangement represents the latest development regarding wave-particle duality. In this work, we propose a simple scheme using linear-optics devices to observe either the particle nature or wave nature or the wave-particle superposition (WPS) of photons by controlling a relevant classical parameter. Our setup consists of two stages, the preparation and measurement stages, with the latter stage containing an additional classical variable whose value will be given only after the first stage in order to avoid any possible communication between the two stages and thus rule out the classical hidden-variable model. We not only develop the theory but also perform the corresponding experiments. The experimental observations perfectly agree with the theoretical predictions. Our findings are the following. The frequency (wavelength) of both single- and two-photon systems is independent of whether the photon(s) is wavelike or in a WPS state, with the common fact being that the frequency (wavelength) of two photons as a whole entity is twice (half) that of a single photon. As for the interference-pattern visibility, it is always lower in the case of WPS than in the case of a wavelike state for a single photon as well as for two photons. Remarkably, with a given value of the control parameter, the interference visibility in the case of WPS is always higher in the single-photon scenario than in the two-photon one. Although here we are dealing with photons, the obtained results apply equally well to matter particles.

Physical Review A•Aug 29, 2023•2 citations

Quantum nature of time -- proposition of experimental verification

Slobodan Prvanović, D. Arsenović

In quantum mechanics time usually appears as classical parameter which means that it is treated as being essentially different from spatial coordinates that are represented by operators. On the other hand, relativity theory demands to treat space and time on an equal footing and there are many approaches to the problem how to introduce time operator. In order to support these approaches we propose the experiment that will clearly expose the equivalence of space and time regarding the relation towards quantum interference. The proposed experiment can show that it is possible to have superposition of being created in two different moments in time, and by measuring standard interference pattern, it will be shown that there is interference in time. It is similar to the case of verification of the possibility of single quantum system to be in the state that is superposition of two different positions in space. If so, this would mean that there should be exactly the same formal approach to the space coordinates and time in quantum mechanics since they are all quantum in their nature.

arXiv:2106.15088•Jun 29, 2021•0 citations
The formal structure of quantum mechanics allows systems to exist in a superposition of different states. A curious feature is that while some superpositions, such as position or momentum, are routinely observed, others such as mass or charge are not. This anomaly is at least partly due to the fact that it is much easier to carry out interference experiments for certain observables than others. Here we focus particularly on the superposition of two different number states for photons or bosonic atoms. This can equally well be thought of as a superposition of different masses in the case of atoms. We present different interferometry schemes that should, at least in principle, allow us to observe interference between these states. This would provide evidence of a superposition that we would normally consider to be prevented by superselection rules.
A defining feature of quantum mechanics is that it allows systems to exist in a superposition of different eigenstates of certain observables such as position or spin. However, superpositions of other quantities such as mass or charge are not seen in nature. It is thought that this disparity is partly due to the fact that it is much easier to carry out interference experiments for certain observables than others. Here we present an interferometry scheme that should allow us to observe interference between the vacuum and a single photon or atom. We begin by presenting a scheme for a Hadamard gate that operates in the Fock state basis and then show how, by creating an interferometer from two such gates, interference between a single particle and the vacuum could indeed be observed. This would provide evidence of a superposition of different particle numbers.
With the exception of superselection rules, there are no known explicit violations of the Principle of quantum Superposition. However, quantum measurement and the emergence of classicality seem to imply that the Principle of Superposition is not universal, so perhaps new superselection rules or something similar wait to be found. This invites us to search for explicit violations of superposition, even in places where we expect it to hold. Given that many quantum measurement devices rely on atoms absorbing photons, these processes are natural places for a first search for such violations. We propose experiments designed to test whether the emission and absorption of photons by atoms may suppress the interference in certain conditions. If the atom is found, in certain situations, to absorb completely the photon, this would mean that in those situations the atom cannot exist or at least it cannot be stable as a superposition of states in which it absorbed the photon and it did not absorb it. Then we will have a new possibility to resolve the problem of measurement, and that of the emergence of classicality. A negative result would mean an additional confirmation of the Principle of Superposition in these particular cases.
The superposition principle is a very basic ingredient of quantum theory. What may come as a surprise to many students, and even to many practitioners of the quantum craft, is tha superposition has limitations imposed by certain requirements of the theory. The discussion of such limitations arising from the so-called superselection rules is the main purpose of this paper. Some of their principal consequences are also discussed. The univalence, mass and particle number superselection rules of non-relativistic quantum mechanics are also derived using rather simple methods.
Simultaneous observation of the wave and particle natures of a quantum object under one experimental arrangement represents the latest development regarding wave-particle duality. In this work, we propose a simple scheme using linear-optics devices to observe either the particle nature or wave nature or the wave-particle superposition (WPS) of photons by controlling a relevant classical parameter. Our setup consists of two stages, the preparation and measurement stages, with the latter stage containing an additional classical variable whose value will be given only after the first stage in order to avoid any possible communication between the two stages and thus rule out the classical hidden-variable model. We not only develop the theory but also perform the corresponding experiments. The experimental observations perfectly agree with the theoretical predictions. Our findings are the following. The frequency (wavelength) of both single- and two-photon systems is independent of whether the photon(s) is wavelike or in a WPS state, with the common fact being that the frequency (wavelength) of two photons as a whole entity is twice (half) that of a single photon. As for the interference-pattern visibility, it is always lower in the case of WPS than in the case of a wavelike state for a single photon as well as for two photons. Remarkably, with a given value of the control parameter, the interference visibility in the case of WPS is always higher in the single-photon scenario than in the two-photon one. Although here we are dealing with photons, the obtained results apply equally well to matter particles.
In quantum mechanics time usually appears as classical parameter which means that it is treated as being essentially different from spatial coordinates that are represented by operators. On the other hand, relativity theory demands to treat space and time on an equal footing and there are many approaches to the problem how to introduce time operator. In order to support these approaches we propose the experiment that will clearly expose the equivalence of space and time regarding the relation towards quantum interference. The proposed experiment can show that it is possible to have superposition of being created in two different moments in time, and by measuring standard interference pattern, it will be shown that there is interference in time. It is similar to the case of verification of the possibility of single quantum system to be in the state that is superposition of two different positions in space. If so, this would mean that there should be exactly the same formal approach to the space coordinates and time in quantum mechanics since they are all quantum in their nature.