Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A

Interaction-Free Which-Path Information and Some of Its Consequences

Luiz Carlos Ryff

Published Feb 1, 2001• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Let us consider a single particle in an interferometer. If one of the two possible paths is blocked and the particle is detected, we know that the particle has followed the path which is not blocked. This would be an interference-free "which-path" information experiment. However, we no longer have an interfe­rometer, since one path is blocked. An alternative is to interact with the particle, but this would change its momentum and as a consequence the interference fringes would disappear, as discussed by Feynman. We can also consider two particles entangled in direction. Knowing the path followed by one of the par­ticles, it is possible to know the path followed by the other. On the other hand, when this information is erased, interference can be observed. However, this is a two particle interference: no single particle inter­ference can be observed. Retrodiction experiments are also possible, but these are not conclusive. Here we propose a much less intuitive experiment in which, without blocking one path or directly interacting with the particle, it is possible to know the path which is being followed by the particle in the interferom­eter. According to quantum mechanics, this is sufficient to lose the single particle interference. The same idea can be used to test the local pilot wave interpretation, to test quantum nonlocality under new conditions, and to devise an interferometer for a two-photon wave packet. This last result strongly suggests that there must be some connection between the deBroglie wavelength of an N-particle wave packet and entanglement. Wavelength of an /V-particle Wave Packet.

DOI
10.1515/zna-2001-0124

Related papers

Single photon quantum erasing: a demonstration experiment

Todorka L. Dimitrova, Antoine Weis

In the conventional interpretation of quantum mechanics the interference of particles in a two-beam interferometer is closely related to the problem of which-way information. One of the mysteries of quantum mechanics relies on the assumption that the wavefunction of each photon propagates simultaneously along both classically allowed paths, and that interference arises as a consequence of the indistinguishability of those paths. Any attempt to obtain which-way information by putting individual labels on the photons in each pathway inevitably destroys interference. However, even in cases in which the photons carry which-way labels, it is possible to erase those labels after the particle has left the interferometer. The erasing process (partly or completely) destroys the which-way information, and thereby restores interference. This phenomenon is known as quantum erasing. Here we present a lecture demonstration experiment of quantum erasing based on a Mach–Zehnder interferometer operated with single photons.

European Journal of Physics•Apr 7, 2010•22 citations

Franson’s experiment using polarized photons

Luiz Carlos Ryff

A modified Franson's two-photon correlation experiment is discussed. It is shown that the interference in the coincidence detection rate is lost when it is possible to determine the path followed by one of the photons. The interference is recovered when this information is ``erased.'' The experiment is devised so that the polarization of one of the photons depends on the path followed in the interferometer. Although the path difference is greater than the coherence length, when the two paths are open the photon can be found in a polarization state represented by the superposition of the polarization states associated to the paths. This can be comprehended by considering the situation in which one of the photons is detected before the other can reach the interferometer. In this case, the second photon has to be described by two wave packets simultaneously.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1993•9 citations

Linear and angular momenta of photons in the context of "which path" experiments of quantum mechanics

Masud Mansuripur

In optical experiments involving a single photon that takes alternative paths through an optical system and ultimately interferes with itself (e.g., Young's double-slit experiment, Mach-Zehnder interferometer, Sagnac interferometer), there exist fundamental connections between the linear and angular momenta of the photon on the one hand, and the ability of an observer to determine the photon's path through the system on the other hand. This paper examines the arguments that relate the photon momenta (through the Heisenberg uncertainty principle) to the "which path" (German: welcher Weg) question at the heart of quantum mechanics. We show that the linear momenta imparted to apertures or mirrors, or the angular momenta picked up by strategically placed wave-plates in a system, could lead to an identification of the photon's path only at the expense of destroying the corresponding interference effects. We also describe a thought experiment involving the scattering of a circularly-polarized photon from a pair of small particles kept at a fixed distance from one another. The exchange of angular momentum between the photon and the scattering particle in this instance appears to provide the "which path" information that must, of necessity, wipe out the corresponding interference fringes, although the fringe-wipe-out mechanism does not seem to involve the uncertainty principle in any obvious way.

arXiv:2210.01890•Optical Trapping and Optical Micromanipulation•Oct 3, 2022•1 citation

Delayed Choice and Quantum Eraser: An Illustrated Guide Based on the Wave-or-Particle Geometric Framework

junfeng gu

The delayed-choice experiment and the quantum eraser experiment are two of the most challenging interpretive problems in quantum mechanics. Standard textbook accounts trace the presence or absence of interference to whether the experimenter "knows" the photon's path — a causal framework implying backward-in-time influence. This article offers an intuitive, diagram-rich account grounded in the wave-or-particle geometric framework, revealing that both experiments share a far simpler backbone: interference depends solely on how many waves reach a given detector. One wave → no interference. Two waves → interference. This conclusion alters no mathematical prediction of quantum mechanics; it merely flips the causal arrow from "knowing the path destroys interference" to "the number of waves creates interference." A forthcoming main paper will present the complete three-column correspondence (experimental step → geometry → QFT standard) with full algebraic verification.

•Aug 2, 2026•0 citations

Quantum erasure with causally disconnected choice

Xiao‐Song Ma, Johannes Kofler, A. Qarry +9 more

The counterintuitive features of quantum physics challenge many common-sense assumptions. In an interferometric quantum eraser experiment, one can actively choose whether or not to erase which-path information (a particle feature) of one quantum system and thus observe its wave feature via interference or not by performing a suitable measurement on a distant quantum system entangled with it. In all experiments performed to date, this choice took place either in the past or, in some delayed-choice arrangements, in the future of the interference. Thus, in principle, physical communications between choice and interference were not excluded. Here, we report a quantum eraser experiment in which, by enforcing Einstein locality, no such communication is possible. This is achieved by independent active choices, which are space-like separated from the interference. Our setup employs hybrid path-polarization entangled photon pairs, which are distributed over an optical fiber link of 55 m in one experiment, or over a free-space link of 144 km in another. No naive realistic picture is compatible with our results because whether a quantum could be seen as showing particle- or wave-like behavior would depend on a causally disconnected choice. It is therefore suggestive to abandon such pictures altogether.

arXiv:1206.6578•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Jan 3, 2013•113 citations

Which-path problem for one and two particles with two degrees of freedom and a relation between transverse spatial structure and group velocity of light

Gergely Ferenczi

Quantum mechanics, optics and indeed any wave theory exhibits the phenomenon of interference. In this thesis we present two problems investigating interference due to indistinguishable alternatives and a mostly unrelated investigation into the free space propagation speed of light pulses in particular spatial modes. In chapter 1 we introduce the basic properties of the electromagnetic field needed for the subsequent chapters. In chapter 2 we review the properties of interference using the beam splitter and the Mach-Zehnder interferometer. In particular we review what happens when one of the paths of the interferometer is marked in some way so that the particle having traversed it contains information as to which path it went down (to be followed up in chapter 3) and we review Hong-Ou-Mandel interference at a beam splitter (to be followed up in chapter 5). In chapter 3 we present the first of the interference problems. This consists of a nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer in which each of the free space propagation segments are weakly marked by mirrors vibrating at different frequencies [1]. The original experiment drew the conclusions that the photons followed disconnected paths. We partition the description of the light in the interferometer according to the number of paths it contains which-way information about and reinterpret the results reported in [1] in terms of the interference of paths spatially connected from source to detector. In chapter 4 we briefly review optical angular momentum, entanglement and spontaneous parametric down conversion. These concepts feed into chapter 5 in which we present the second of the interference problems namely Hong-Ou-Mandel interference with particles possessing two degrees of freedom. We analyse the problem in terms of exchange symmetry for both boson and fermion pairs and show that the particle statistics at a beam splitter can be controlled for suitably chosen states. We propose an experimental test of these ideas using orbital angular momentum entangled photons. In chapter 6 we look at the effect that the transverse spatial structure of the mode that a pulse of light is excited in has on its group velocity. We show that the resulting group velocity is slower than the speed of light in vacuum for plane waves and that this reduction in the group velocity is related to the spread in the wave vectors required to create the transverse spatial structure. We present experimental results of the measurement of this slowing down using Hong-Ou-Mandel interference.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations
Abstract Let us consider a single particle in an interferometer. If one of the two possible paths is blocked and the particle is detected, we know that the particle has followed the path which is not blocked. This would be an interference-free "which-path" information experiment. However, we no longer have an interfe­rometer, since one path is blocked. An alternative is to interact with the particle, but this would change its momentum and as a consequence the interference fringes would disappear, as discussed by Feynman. We can also consider two particles entangled in direction. Knowing the path followed by one of the par­ticles, it is possible to know the path followed by the other. On the other hand, when this information is erased, interference can be observed. However, this is a two particle interference: no single particle inter­ference can be observed. Retrodiction experiments are also possible, but these are not conclusive. Here we propose a much less intuitive experiment in which, without blocking one path or directly interacting with the particle, it is possible to know the path which is being followed by the particle in the interferom­eter. According to quantum mechanics, this is sufficient to lose the single particle interference. The same idea can be used to test the local pilot wave interpretation, to test quantum nonlocality under new conditions, and to devise an interferometer for a two-photon wave packet. This last result strongly suggests that there must be some connection between the deBroglie wavelength of an N-particle wave packet and entanglement. Wavelength of an /V-particle Wave Packet.
In the conventional interpretation of quantum mechanics the interference of particles in a two-beam interferometer is closely related to the problem of which-way information. One of the mysteries of quantum mechanics relies on the assumption that the wavefunction of each photon propagates simultaneously along both classically allowed paths, and that interference arises as a consequence of the indistinguishability of those paths. Any attempt to obtain which-way information by putting individual labels on the photons in each pathway inevitably destroys interference. However, even in cases in which the photons carry which-way labels, it is possible to erase those labels after the particle has left the interferometer. The erasing process (partly or completely) destroys the which-way information, and thereby restores interference. This phenomenon is known as quantum erasing. Here we present a lecture demonstration experiment of quantum erasing based on a Mach–Zehnder interferometer operated with single photons.
A modified Franson's two-photon correlation experiment is discussed. It is shown that the interference in the coincidence detection rate is lost when it is possible to determine the path followed by one of the photons. The interference is recovered when this information is ``erased.'' The experiment is devised so that the polarization of one of the photons depends on the path followed in the interferometer. Although the path difference is greater than the coherence length, when the two paths are open the photon can be found in a polarization state represented by the superposition of the polarization states associated to the paths. This can be comprehended by considering the situation in which one of the photons is detected before the other can reach the interferometer. In this case, the second photon has to be described by two wave packets simultaneously.
In optical experiments involving a single photon that takes alternative paths through an optical system and ultimately interferes with itself (e.g., Young's double-slit experiment, Mach-Zehnder interferometer, Sagnac interferometer), there exist fundamental connections between the linear and angular momenta of the photon on the one hand, and the ability of an observer to determine the photon's path through the system on the other hand. This paper examines the arguments that relate the photon momenta (through the Heisenberg uncertainty principle) to the "which path" (German: welcher Weg) question at the heart of quantum mechanics. We show that the linear momenta imparted to apertures or mirrors, or the angular momenta picked up by strategically placed wave-plates in a system, could lead to an identification of the photon's path only at the expense of destroying the corresponding interference effects. We also describe a thought experiment involving the scattering of a circularly-polarized photon from a pair of small particles kept at a fixed distance from one another. The exchange of angular momentum between the photon and the scattering particle in this instance appears to provide the "which path" information that must, of necessity, wipe out the corresponding interference fringes, although the fringe-wipe-out mechanism does not seem to involve the uncertainty principle in any obvious way.
The delayed-choice experiment and the quantum eraser experiment are two of the most challenging interpretive problems in quantum mechanics. Standard textbook accounts trace the presence or absence of interference to whether the experimenter "knows" the photon's path — a causal framework implying backward-in-time influence. This article offers an intuitive, diagram-rich account grounded in the wave-or-particle geometric framework, revealing that both experiments share a far simpler backbone: interference depends solely on how many waves reach a given detector. One wave → no interference. Two waves → interference. This conclusion alters no mathematical prediction of quantum mechanics; it merely flips the causal arrow from "knowing the path destroys interference" to "the number of waves creates interference." A forthcoming main paper will present the complete three-column correspondence (experimental step → geometry → QFT standard) with full algebraic verification.
The counterintuitive features of quantum physics challenge many common-sense assumptions. In an interferometric quantum eraser experiment, one can actively choose whether or not to erase which-path information (a particle feature) of one quantum system and thus observe its wave feature via interference or not by performing a suitable measurement on a distant quantum system entangled with it. In all experiments performed to date, this choice took place either in the past or, in some delayed-choice arrangements, in the future of the interference. Thus, in principle, physical communications between choice and interference were not excluded. Here, we report a quantum eraser experiment in which, by enforcing Einstein locality, no such communication is possible. This is achieved by independent active choices, which are space-like separated from the interference. Our setup employs hybrid path-polarization entangled photon pairs, which are distributed over an optical fiber link of 55 m in one experiment, or over a free-space link of 144 km in another. No naive realistic picture is compatible with our results because whether a quantum could be seen as showing particle- or wave-like behavior would depend on a causally disconnected choice. It is therefore suggestive to abandon such pictures altogether.
Quantum mechanics, optics and indeed any wave theory exhibits the phenomenon of interference. In this thesis we present two problems investigating interference due to indistinguishable alternatives and a mostly unrelated investigation into the free space propagation speed of light pulses in particular spatial modes. In chapter 1 we introduce the basic properties of the electromagnetic field needed for the subsequent chapters. In chapter 2 we review the properties of interference using the beam splitter and the Mach-Zehnder interferometer. In particular we review what happens when one of the paths of the interferometer is marked in some way so that the particle having traversed it contains information as to which path it went down (to be followed up in chapter 3) and we review Hong-Ou-Mandel interference at a beam splitter (to be followed up in chapter 5). In chapter 3 we present the first of the interference problems. This consists of a nested Mach-Zehnder interferometer in which each of the free space propagation segments are weakly marked by mirrors vibrating at different frequencies [1]. The original experiment drew the conclusions that the photons followed disconnected paths. We partition the description of the light in the interferometer according to the number of paths it contains which-way information about and reinterpret the results reported in [1] in terms of the interference of paths spatially connected from source to detector. In chapter 4 we briefly review optical angular momentum, entanglement and spontaneous parametric down conversion. These concepts feed into chapter 5 in which we present the second of the interference problems namely Hong-Ou-Mandel interference with particles possessing two degrees of freedom. We analyse the problem in terms of exchange symmetry for both boson and fermion pairs and show that the particle statistics at a beam splitter can be controlled for suitably chosen states. We propose an experimental test of these ideas using orbital angular momentum entangled photons. In chapter 6 we look at the effect that the transverse spatial structure of the mode that a pulse of light is excited in has on its group velocity. We show that the resulting group velocity is slower than the speed of light in vacuum for plane waves and that this reduction in the group velocity is related to the spread in the wave vectors required to create the transverse spatial structure. We present experimental results of the measurement of this slowing down using Hong-Ou-Mandel interference.