Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Modern Physics A

QUANTUM COMPUTATION IN SILICON — DEVICE MODELING, TRANSPORT AND FAULT-TOLERANCE

Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg

Published Oct 30, 2007• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Kane concept of quantum computation using single phosphorus donors in silicon has revolutionized the way we think about P -doped silicon devices. However, because of the enormous effort required in fabricating such devices using single atom techniques, detailed modeling and assessment of fault-tolerant operation is required to determine and optimize the scalability, and indeed feasibility, of such a vision.

DOI
10.1142/s0217751x07038359

Related papers

Modelling nanoelectronic quantum control of donor qubits in silicon

Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg, Cameron J. Wellard

The Kane concept of quantum computation using single phosphorous donors in silicon has revolutionized the way we think about P-doped silicon devices. However, because of the enormous effort required in single atom fabrication detailed modeling is required to determine and optimise the scalability, and indeed feasibility, of such a vision.

•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

QUANTUM COMPUTATION IN SILICON — DEVICE MODELING, TRANSPORT AND FAULT-TOLERANCE

Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg

•Oct 1, 2007•0 citations

A silicon-based cluster state quantum computer

John J. L. Morton

It has been over ten years since Kane's influential proposal for a silicon-based nuclear spin quantum computer using phosphorous donors. Since then, silicon-based architectures have been refined as the experimental challenges associated with the original proposal have become better understood, while simultaneously a number of powerful and generic models for quantum computation have emerged. Here, I discuss how the cluster state or "one-way" model for quantum computing might be advantageously applied to donors in silicon, with the potential to substantially reduce the practical requirements of a successful implementation. The essence of the scheme is to use the electron spin associated with a donor to weave an entangled network between 31P donor nuclear spins. This resource has been shown to have exceptional coherence times and supports universal quantum computation through local measurements on the nuclear spins. Some of the key ingredients, such as global spin manipulation, have been robustly established, while others, such as single spin measurement, have seen much progress in recent years. A key challenge will be the demonstration of electron transfer between donors that preserves spin coherence.

arXiv:0905.4008•May 25, 2009•10 citations

Towards scalable silicon quantum computing

M. Vinet, Louis Hutin, Benoît Bertrand +14 more

Qubits can be made out of a variety of experimental platforms, fig. 1. Small processors have already been demonstrated in trapped ions and superconductors but in both cases, the constraints for coherent manipulation and the effective large size of the qubits including all quantum functionalities are hardly compatible with very large-scale architecture. When it comes to the crucial issue of large-scale integration, Si spin qubits are well positioned due to their long coherence times and compatibility with semiconductor fabrication techniques. Indeed, dephasing times of the order of 1s have been achieved in Si-based spin qubits and single-qubit gate fidelities are high enough for scalable, fault-tolerant quantum computing.

Conference digest•Jun 1, 2018•12 citations

Quantum Computation With Electron Spins of Phosphorous Donors in Silicon

Angbo Fang

The discovery of efficient quantum algorithms a decade ago has shown that a quantum computer encoding and processing information quantum mechanically, can solve important problems intractable with conventional computers. The invention of quantum error correction principle, makes quantum computation possibly fault-tolerant against the decoherence of information carriers. Thereafter, intensive research activities have been made toward the implementation of quantum computation with various realistic quantum systems. Among them, the most attractive implementation proposals are using silicon-based materials, which have the advantage of borrowing the existing ingenuity and resources accumulated during the development of modern microelectronics. In this dissertation we investigate several theoretical aspects of a silicon- based quantum computer in which qubits are represented by the spins of electrons bound to phosphorous donors in silicon. Encoding each qubit in terms of three neighboring donor electron spins, we can realize universal quantum gate operations with only the Heisenberg exchange coupling J S1 •S2 between neighboring donors. Therefore, studying the exchange coupling for a phosphorous donor pair in silicon is of central importance for providing the experimentalists with qualitative insights and quantitative guidance for building such a silicon quantum computer. After giving some general considerations on the quantum computer architecture, we develop the necessary theoretical tools. A multi-valley effective mass equation is derived and discussed, to handle impurities in a multi-valley semiconductor. Then we apply it to solve a single Si:P donor embedded in our quantum computer architecture. We show that the width of the silicon quantum well can significantly influence the energy splitting and charge distributions of the ground state. Oscillation of level splitting is observed as the quantum well width or donor position is varied at atomic scale. Elementary gate operations for 3-donor-spin qubits involve a neighboring pair of donors at each step. The exchange coupling in Heisenberg model hamiltonian, defined as the energy splitting of the lowest singlet and triplet states, has to be calculated from the realistic two-donor hamiltonian. We discuss several popular methods to solve the two-donor problem and develop an appropriate extended Hartree-Fock method that can give reliable results for a well-separated donor pair subject to tunable coupling. This method is first applied to a Si:P donor pair in the framework of hydrogenic effective mass theory, to study how to tune the exchange coupling with simple gate potentials. A followed study shows that under a parallel electric field the singlet and triplet states exhibit very different polarization behaviors. This difference can be exploited to measure the state of an electron spin. We also show that, a perpendicular electric field cannot tune the exchange coupling efficiently. Then we apply the realistic multi-valley effective mass equation, coupled with a realistic modeling of the potential generated by gate electrodes, to a pair of phosphorous donors in silicon quantum well. By varying the gate electrode voltages, the exchange coupling can be tuned with exponential efficiency in a wide range. We find that, for best performance, we need to set the quantum well width to be around 10 nm, and the donor separation to be around 10 a∗ b---- 24nm in the doping plane. We analyze in detail an adiabatic half-swap operation between neighboring donor spins. The gate operation time is estimated to be 0.2 ns, which satisfies the constraints put by the donor spin decoherence time and by the validity of adiabatic approximation. The interference between different valley components could lead to oscillations of exchange coupling as donor positions are shifted by occasion. We find the exchange oscillation persists even with only two relevant valleys for donors in a strongly-strained silicon quantum well. It is also shown that the oscillation induced by changing donor separation at atomic scale is strongly suppressed as donors approach each other. Finally, we study the entanglement issue in quantum computing context. We analyze the low-energy Hilbert space for a pair of qubits encoded by localized electron spins and suggest a suitable measure to describe the entanglement between qubits involving indistinguishable electrons and in the presence of leakage errors. The dynamics of inter-qubit entanglement during a gate operation is also studied.

•Oct 1, 2005•0 citations

Quantum Information in Silicon Devices Based on Individual Dopants

Andrea Morello

Several solid-state quantum information processor proposals are based on silicon [16-18, 20, 52], including the original architecture conceived by Kane in 1998 [22], in which the quantum information was stored in the spin states of 31P donors. The interest raised by silicon in the field of quantum information is twofold. On the one hand, it represents the main semiconductor used for large- scale fabrication. On the other hand, it owns interesting physical properties suitable for preserving andmanipulating quantum states, such as long coherence times and relatively low disturbance of nuclear spins, which are further enhanced by employing purified 28Si. The employment of individual donors in silicon covers all the aspects of quantum information encoding and processing, like quantumbit (qubit) storage, implementation of quantum logic gates, coherent transfer of quantum states, and readout schemes. This chapter is devoted to the physics of few dopants in nanometric silicon devices and their applications to quantum information processing purposes. In the first part, an overview of the physics of themost common donors and acceptors in silicon is presented. Next, the quantum information key concepts and their implementation in donor-based architectures are discussed. Finally, decoherence effects and the concept of measurement of quantum states are presented for the case of electron states bound to donors in silicon. Between the sixties and the early eighties of the twentieth century, all the theoretical and experimental aspects related to the doping of bulk silicon have been investigated and explained. A silicon crystal consists of a diamond lattice constituted by two interleaved cubic lattices (face-centered cubic, FCC), the second of which has the origin in the center of the tetrahedron given by the origin (0,0,0) and the centers of the faces 100. Each Si atom has four valence electrons, which create a covalent bond with the shared electrons of four other Si atoms. The substitution of silicon atoms with atoms of a group V element (indicated as donors, typically P, As, and Sb in silicon) generates an n-doped silicon crystal (n-Si). Each donor introduces an eccess electron in the crystal, and it provides new energy levels in the band gap, close to the conduction band edge. Similarly, substituting silicon atoms with atoms of a group III element (an acceptor, typically B in silicon) generates a p-doped silicon crystal (p-Si). Each acceptor introduces an electron hole in the crystal, and it provides new energy levels in the band gap, close to the valence band. The diffusion of impurities in semiconductors alters the conduction properties from an insulating to a metallic regime. Depending on the different doping concentration, the wavefunction of the electron (hole) states introduced by each donor (acceptor) may overlap negligibly or substantially with those of neighboring sites. Such a transition from low doping to high doping as a function of the average distance between neighboring sites is described in terms of an Anderson-Mott transition and produces additional impurity bands (Hubbard bands) below the conduction band edge at sufficiently high concentration [1, 34]. The transport is governed by mechanisms based on localized states at low density, while it is based on delocalized states at high density. Four conventional regimes of impurity concentration are defined [50]. The dilute concentration of impurities holds for n < 1 · 1016 cm−3. There, the problem of the donor is that of a hydrogen atom with a scaled Rydberg and radius. Between the densities n of 1 ·1016 cm−3 and 2 · 1017 cm−3 (rNN = 11.9 nm), respectively, the regime is called semidilute, and it is characterized by formation of pairs. Above 2 · 1017 cm−3 and below the metallic behavior, which occurs at 3.7 · 1018 cm−3, the regime is called intermediate, and the formation of random clusters leads to effects generally accounted by the Hubbard band formation. Above n > 3.7 · 1018 cm−3, silicon is treated as a metal. In this section the physics of the first three regimes of donor concentration and the Anderson-Mott transition are described. The Anderson-Mott transition has been observed down to microscopic scale by employing arrays of few deterministically implanted As ions (see chapter 5) in Si transistors [39]. Analogous arguments and treatment can be given to acceptor concentration regimes.

Pan Stanford Publishing eBooks•Apr 17, 2013•3 citations
The Kane concept of quantum computation using single phosphorus donors in silicon has revolutionized the way we think about P -doped silicon devices. However, because of the enormous effort required in fabricating such devices using single atom techniques, detailed modeling and assessment of fault-tolerant operation is required to determine and optimize the scalability, and indeed feasibility, of such a vision.
It has been over ten years since Kane's influential proposal for a silicon-based nuclear spin quantum computer using phosphorous donors. Since then, silicon-based architectures have been refined as the experimental challenges associated with the original proposal have become better understood, while simultaneously a number of powerful and generic models for quantum computation have emerged. Here, I discuss how the cluster state or "one-way" model for quantum computing might be advantageously applied to donors in silicon, with the potential to substantially reduce the practical requirements of a successful implementation. The essence of the scheme is to use the electron spin associated with a donor to weave an entangled network between 31P donor nuclear spins. This resource has been shown to have exceptional coherence times and supports universal quantum computation through local measurements on the nuclear spins. Some of the key ingredients, such as global spin manipulation, have been robustly established, while others, such as single spin measurement, have seen much progress in recent years. A key challenge will be the demonstration of electron transfer between donors that preserves spin coherence.
Qubits can be made out of a variety of experimental platforms, fig. 1. Small processors have already been demonstrated in trapped ions and superconductors but in both cases, the constraints for coherent manipulation and the effective large size of the qubits including all quantum functionalities are hardly compatible with very large-scale architecture. When it comes to the crucial issue of large-scale integration, Si spin qubits are well positioned due to their long coherence times and compatibility with semiconductor fabrication techniques. Indeed, dephasing times of the order of 1s have been achieved in Si-based spin qubits and single-qubit gate fidelities are high enough for scalable, fault-tolerant quantum computing.
The discovery of efficient quantum algorithms a decade ago has shown that a quantum computer encoding and processing information quantum mechanically, can solve important problems intractable with conventional computers. The invention of quantum error correction principle, makes quantum computation possibly fault-tolerant against the decoherence of information carriers. Thereafter, intensive research activities have been made toward the implementation of quantum computation with various realistic quantum systems. Among them, the most attractive implementation proposals are using silicon-based materials, which have the advantage of borrowing the existing ingenuity and resources accumulated during the development of modern microelectronics. In this dissertation we investigate several theoretical aspects of a silicon- based quantum computer in which qubits are represented by the spins of electrons bound to phosphorous donors in silicon. Encoding each qubit in terms of three neighboring donor electron spins, we can realize universal quantum gate operations with only the Heisenberg exchange coupling J S1 •S2 between neighboring donors. Therefore, studying the exchange coupling for a phosphorous donor pair in silicon is of central importance for providing the experimentalists with qualitative insights and quantitative guidance for building such a silicon quantum computer. After giving some general considerations on the quantum computer architecture, we develop the necessary theoretical tools. A multi-valley effective mass equation is derived and discussed, to handle impurities in a multi-valley semiconductor. Then we apply it to solve a single Si:P donor embedded in our quantum computer architecture. We show that the width of the silicon quantum well can significantly influence the energy splitting and charge distributions of the ground state. Oscillation of level splitting is observed as the quantum well width or donor position is varied at atomic scale. Elementary gate operations for 3-donor-spin qubits involve a neighboring pair of donors at each step. The exchange coupling in Heisenberg model hamiltonian, defined as the energy splitting of the lowest singlet and triplet states, has to be calculated from the realistic two-donor hamiltonian. We discuss several popular methods to solve the two-donor problem and develop an appropriate extended Hartree-Fock method that can give reliable results for a well-separated donor pair subject to tunable coupling. This method is first applied to a Si:P donor pair in the framework of hydrogenic effective mass theory, to study how to tune the exchange coupling with simple gate potentials. A followed study shows that under a parallel electric field the singlet and triplet states exhibit very different polarization behaviors. This difference can be exploited to measure the state of an electron spin. We also show that, a perpendicular electric field cannot tune the exchange coupling efficiently. Then we apply the realistic multi-valley effective mass equation, coupled with a realistic modeling of the potential generated by gate electrodes, to a pair of phosphorous donors in silicon quantum well. By varying the gate electrode voltages, the exchange coupling can be tuned with exponential efficiency in a wide range. We find that, for best performance, we need to set the quantum well width to be around 10 nm, and the donor separation to be around 10 a∗ b---- 24nm in the doping plane. We analyze in detail an adiabatic half-swap operation between neighboring donor spins. The gate operation time is estimated to be 0.2 ns, which satisfies the constraints put by the donor spin decoherence time and by the validity of adiabatic approximation. The interference between different valley components could lead to oscillations of exchange coupling as donor positions are shifted by occasion. We find the exchange oscillation persists even with only two relevant valleys for donors in a strongly-strained silicon quantum well. It is also shown that the oscillation induced by changing donor separation at atomic scale is strongly suppressed as donors approach each other. Finally, we study the entanglement issue in quantum computing context. We analyze the low-energy Hilbert space for a pair of qubits encoded by localized electron spins and suggest a suitable measure to describe the entanglement between qubits involving indistinguishable electrons and in the presence of leakage errors. The dynamics of inter-qubit entanglement during a gate operation is also studied.
Several solid-state quantum information processor proposals are based on silicon [16-18, 20, 52], including the original architecture conceived by Kane in 1998 [22], in which the quantum information was stored in the spin states of 31P donors. The interest raised by silicon in the field of quantum information is twofold. On the one hand, it represents the main semiconductor used for large- scale fabrication. On the other hand, it owns interesting physical properties suitable for preserving andmanipulating quantum states, such as long coherence times and relatively low disturbance of nuclear spins, which are further enhanced by employing purified 28Si. The employment of individual donors in silicon covers all the aspects of quantum information encoding and processing, like quantumbit (qubit) storage, implementation of quantum logic gates, coherent transfer of quantum states, and readout schemes. This chapter is devoted to the physics of few dopants in nanometric silicon devices and their applications to quantum information processing purposes. In the first part, an overview of the physics of themost common donors and acceptors in silicon is presented. Next, the quantum information key concepts and their implementation in donor-based architectures are discussed. Finally, decoherence effects and the concept of measurement of quantum states are presented for the case of electron states bound to donors in silicon. Between the sixties and the early eighties of the twentieth century, all the theoretical and experimental aspects related to the doping of bulk silicon have been investigated and explained. A silicon crystal consists of a diamond lattice constituted by two interleaved cubic lattices (face-centered cubic, FCC), the second of which has the origin in the center of the tetrahedron given by the origin (0,0,0) and the centers of the faces 100. Each Si atom has four valence electrons, which create a covalent bond with the shared electrons of four other Si atoms. The substitution of silicon atoms with atoms of a group V element (indicated as donors, typically P, As, and Sb in silicon) generates an n-doped silicon crystal (n-Si). Each donor introduces an eccess electron in the crystal, and it provides new energy levels in the band gap, close to the conduction band edge. Similarly, substituting silicon atoms with atoms of a group III element (an acceptor, typically B in silicon) generates a p-doped silicon crystal (p-Si). Each acceptor introduces an electron hole in the crystal, and it provides new energy levels in the band gap, close to the valence band. The diffusion of impurities in semiconductors alters the conduction properties from an insulating to a metallic regime. Depending on the different doping concentration, the wavefunction of the electron (hole) states introduced by each donor (acceptor) may overlap negligibly or substantially with those of neighboring sites. Such a transition from low doping to high doping as a function of the average distance between neighboring sites is described in terms of an Anderson-Mott transition and produces additional impurity bands (Hubbard bands) below the conduction band edge at sufficiently high concentration [1, 34]. The transport is governed by mechanisms based on localized states at low density, while it is based on delocalized states at high density. Four conventional regimes of impurity concentration are defined [50]. The dilute concentration of impurities holds for n < 1 · 1016 cm−3. There, the problem of the donor is that of a hydrogen atom with a scaled Rydberg and radius. Between the densities n of 1 ·1016 cm−3 and 2 · 1017 cm−3 (rNN = 11.9 nm), respectively, the regime is called semidilute, and it is characterized by formation of pairs. Above 2 · 1017 cm−3 and below the metallic behavior, which occurs at 3.7 · 1018 cm−3, the regime is called intermediate, and the formation of random clusters leads to effects generally accounted by the Hubbard band formation. Above n > 3.7 · 1018 cm−3, silicon is treated as a metal. In this section the physics of the first three regimes of donor concentration and the Anderson-Mott transition are described. The Anderson-Mott transition has been observed down to microscopic scale by employing arrays of few deterministically implanted As ions (see chapter 5) in Si transistors [39]. Analogous arguments and treatment can be given to acceptor concentration regimes.