Von Neumann’s contributions to quantum theory

Miklós Rédei, Michael Stöltzner

Rathindra Nath Sen

Von Neumann's theory of measurement in Quantum Mechanics was spelled out in the last chapter of his book, which was published in 1932. This book was highly mathematical for its time, and in 1939 London and Bauer provided a simplified account of the measurement theory part of it (London and Bauer, 1939). Von Neumann died in 1957. Thirty years after the publication of von Neumann's book, Wigner published a review containing his views on the shortcomings of von Neumann's theory, but omitting any discussion of its mathematical core, namely von Neumann's analysis of composite systems (Wigner, 1963). He also published a set of lecture notes entitled Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (Wigner, 1983) in which some of his concerns were spelled out in greater detail, and an article addressed ‘to an audience of non-physicists’ (Wigner, 1964). Wigner's own contributions to measurement theory were discussed by Shimony in a talk at the Wigner centennial conference (Shimony, 2002). The English translation of von Neumann's book was published in 1955.1 The account that follows is based on these sources. We shall assume that the reader is acquainted with notions such as wave function collapse and the Heisenberg cut, but we shall not assume familiarity with the technicalities of von Neumann's theory. This chapter is organized accordingly. Section 8.1 explains what we mean by the term von Neumann's measurement theory and gives an overview of the subject. It is followed by Sections 8.2 and 8.3, in which the theory is spelled out in detail. Section 8.4 recounts Wigner's reservations.

Tracy Lupher

Luca Lambertini

A methodological discussion is proposed, aiming at illustrating an analogy between game theory in particular (and mathematical economics in general) and quantum mechanics. This analogy relies on the equivalence of the two fundamental operators employed in the two fields, namely, the expected value in economics and the density matrix in quantum physics. I conjecture that this coincidence can be traced back to the contributions of von Neumann in both disciplines.

Giovanni Valente

Daniel Kuby, Patrick Thomas Fraser

In 1957, Feyerabend delivered a paper titled ‘On the Quantum-Theory of Measurement’ at the Colston Research Symposium in Bristol to sketch a completion of von Neumann's measurement scheme without collapse, using only unitary quantum dynamics and well-motivated statistical assumptions about macroscopic quantum systems. Feyerabend's paper has been recognised as an early contribution to quantum measurement, anticipating certain aspects of decoherence. Our paper reassesses the physical and philosophical content of Feyerabend's contribution, detailing the technical steps as well as its overall philosophical motivations and consequences. Summarising our results, Feyerabend interpreted collapse as a positivist assumption in quantum mechanics leading to a strict distinction between the uninterpreted formalism of unitary evolution in quantum mechanics and the classically interpreted observational language describing post-measurement outcomes. Thus Feyerabend took the no-collapse completion of the von Neumann measurement scheme to show the dispensability of the positivist assumption, leading the way to a realistic interpretation of quantum theory. We note, however, that there are substantial problems with his account of measurement that bring into question its viability as a legitimate foil to the orthodox view. We further argue that his dissatisfaction with the von Neumann measurement scheme is indicative of early views on theoretical pluralism.