A Moderatorless Protocol for WEREWOLF
Naoki Kitamura, Hironori Kiya, Hirotaka Ono
Social deduction games, or hidden-role games, are multiplayer games in which players are assigned private roles and act under asymmetric information about other players' roles and actions. In the canonical example Werewolf, werewolves conceal their roles and mislead the other players, while the seer can obtain role information about a chosen player. Thus, a central functionality of such games is controlling which players can access which information. In typical play, this control is implemented by a trusted human moderator, who assigns roles, mediates secret actions, and reveals outcomes. This reliance raises the barrier to participation and introduces a trusted third party as a single point of failure. In this work, we show that Werewolf can be played without a moderator or any digital device, using only ordinary playing cards. Our construction maintains a shared pool of cards that is observable to all players and manipulated according to a common public procedure, while its interpretation depends on each player's private role. This induces role-dependent views from a single public sequence of card operations. Consequently, even without private messages, werewolves can identify one another and coordinate, and the seer can test whether a chosen player is a werewolf in each round. The proposed implementation is built from card-based physical cryptographic primitives, such as face-down commitments and verifiable shuffles, and higher-level subprotocols for intra-role information sharing, secret action designation, and attribute testing. These subprotocols implement the moderator's core functions while keeping all card operations public and auditable under standard assumptions on physical card operations. We show that the resulting complete moderatorless implementation of Werewolf scales to an arbitrary number n of players using O(n^3) cards.
arXiv:2606.00190•May 29, 2026•0 citations