Two approaches to extend Hardy's proof of nonlocality without inequalities to maximally entangled states of bipartite two-level systems are shown to fail. On one hand, it is shown that the proof of Wu and co-workers [Phys. Rev. A 53, R1927 (1996)] uses an effective state which is not maximally entangled. On the other hand, it is demonstrated that Hardy's proof cannot be generalized by the replacement of one of the four von Neumann measurements involved in the original proof by a generalized measurement to unambiguously discriminate between nonorthogonal states.Two approaches to extend Hardy's proof of nonlocality without inequalities to maximally entangled states of bipartite two-level systems are shown to fail. On one hand, it is shown that the proof of Wu and co-workers [Phys. Rev. A 53, R1927 (1996)] uses an effective state which is not maximally entangled. On the other hand, it is demonstrated that Hardy's proof cannot be generalized by the replacement of one of the four von Neumann measurements involved in the original proof by a generalized measurement to unambiguously discriminate between nonorthogonal states.

arXiv:quant-ph/9911023Physical Review AJan 18, 20007 citations

Nonlocality in Multipartite Quantum States

Jordi Tura i Brugués

Springer thesesDec 3, 20160 citations

On a Recent Proof of Nonlocality Without Inequalities

G. C. Ghirardi

arXiv:1101.5252Foundations of PhysicsMar 17, 20114 citations

Wigner-approach-enabled detection of multipartite nonlocality using all different bipartitions

Sumit Nandi, Debashis Saha, Dipankar Home +1 more

Distinct from Bell's approach, Wigner derived a form of local realist (LR) inequality which is quantum-mechanically violated for a bipartite maximally entangled state. Subsequently, this approach was generalized to obtain a multipartite LR inequality. However, the violation of such a generalized Wigner inequality does not guarantee nonlocality between all possible different bipartitions of the multipartite system. In the present paper, this limitation has been overcome by formulating a further generalization of Wigner's approach through the derivation of a set of LR inequalities with respect to all different bipartitions of a $N$ -partite system. Quantum-mechanical violations of all individual LR inequalities belonging to such a set would rigorously certify multipartite nonlocality by also providing a finer characterization of the nature of multipartite nonlocality in the following sense. The quantum-mechanical violation of any given inequality of our complete set of LR inequalities would enable identification of the corresponding bipartition which exhibits nonlocality. This is in contrast to other multipartite LR inequalities such as the Svetlichny inequality or its generalization that cannot be used to detect whether there is any particular bipartition which is nonlocally correlated. The efficacy of the scheme developed in this paper is illustrated for the tripartite and quadripartite states.Distinct from Bell's approach, Wigner derived a form of local realist (LR) inequality which is quantum-mechanically violated for a bipartite maximally entangled state. Subsequently, this approach was generalized to obtain a multipartite LR inequality. However, the violation of such a generalized Wigner inequality does not guarantee nonlocality between all possible different bipartitions of the multipartite system. In the present paper, this limitation has been overcome by formulating a further generalization of Wigner's approach through the derivation of a set of LR inequalities with respect to all different bipartitions of a $N$-partite system. Quantum-mechanical violations of all individual LR inequalities belonging to such a set would rigorously certify multipartite nonlocality by also providing a finer characterization of the nature of multipartite nonlocality in the following sense. The quantum-mechanical violation of any given inequality of our complete set of LR inequalities would enable identification of the corresponding bipartition which exhibits nonlocality. This is in contrast to other multipartite LR inequalities such as the Svetlichny inequality or its generalization that cannot be used to detect whether there is any particular bipartition which is nonlocally correlated. The efficacy of the scheme developed in this paper is illustrated for the tripartite and quadripartite states.

arXiv:2202.11475Physical Review ADec 2, 20225 citations

All Bipartite Entangled States Display Some Hidden Nonlocality

Lluís Masanes, Yeong-Cherng Liang, Andrew C. Doherty

One of the most significant and well-known properties of entangled states is that they may lead to violations of Bell inequalities and are thus inconsistent with any local-realistic theory. However, there are entangled states that cannot violate any Bell inequality, and in general the precise relationship between entanglement and observable nonlocality is not well understood. We demonstrate that a violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality can be demonstrated in a certain kind of Bell experiment for all entangled states. Our proof of the result consists of two main steps. We first provide a simple characterization of the set of states that do not violate the CHSH inequality even after general local operations and classical communication. Second, we prove that for each entangled state sigma, there exists another state rho not violating the CHSH inequality, such that rhomultiply sign in circlesigma violates the CHSH inequality.One of the most significant and well-known properties of entangled states is that they may lead to violations of Bell inequalities and are thus inconsistent with any local-realistic theory. However, there are entangled states that cannot violate any Bell inequality, and in general the precise relationship between entanglement and observable nonlocality is not well understood. We demonstrate that a violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality can be demonstrated in a certain kind of Bell experiment for all entangled states. Our proof of the result consists of two main steps. We first provide a simple characterization of the set of states that do not violate the CHSH inequality even after general local operations and classical communication. Second, we prove that for each entangled state sigma, there exists another state rho not violating the CHSH inequality, such that rhomultiply sign in circlesigma violates the CHSH inequality.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703268Physical Review LettersMar 4, 2008136 citations

N

-partite system. Quantum-mechanical violations of all individual LR inequalities belonging to such a set would rigorously certify multipartite nonlocality by also providing a finer characterization of the nature of multipartite nonlocality in the following sense. The quantum-mechanical violation of any given inequality of our complete set of LR inequalities would enable identification of the corresponding bipartition which exhibits nonlocality. This is in contrast to other multipartite LR inequalities such as the Svetlichny inequality or its generalization that cannot be used to detect whether there is any particular bipartition which is nonlocally correlated. The efficacy of the scheme developed in this paper is illustrated for the tripartite and quadripartite states.