IEEE Communications Magazine

The challenges facing physical layer security

Wade K. Trappe

Published Jun 1, 2015• 278 citations

Abstract

There has recently been significant interest in applying the principles of information-theoretical security and signal processing to secure physical layer systems. Although the community has made progress in understanding how the physical layer can support confidentiality and authentication, it is important to realize that there are many important issues that must be addressed if physical layer security is ever to be adopted by real and practical security systems. In this article, I briefly review several different flavors of physical layer security (at least for wireless systems), and then identify aspects (a.k.a. weaknesses) where the foundation for physical layer security needs to be strengthened. I then highlight that the opportunities for applying physical layer security to real systems will be quite rich if the community can overcome these challenges. In the course of the article, I note new directions for the community to investigate, with the objective of keeping physical layer security research targeted at having a practical impact on real systems.

DOI: 10.1109/mcom.2015.7120011

Related papers

Wireless physical layer security

H. Vincent Poor, Rafael F. Schaefer

Security in wireless networks has traditionally been considered to be an issue to be addressed separately from the physical radio transmission aspects of wireless systems. However, with the emergence of new networking architectures that are not amenable to traditional methods of secure communication such as data encryption, there has been an increase in interest in the potential of the physical properties of the radio channel itself to provide communications security. Information theory provides a natural framework for the study of this issue, and there has been considerable recent research devoted to using this framework to develop a greater understanding of the fundamental ability of the so-called physical layer to provide security in wireless networks. Moreover, this approach is also suggestive in many cases of coding techniques that can approach fundamental limits in practice and of techniques for other security tasks such as authentication. This paper provides an overview of these developments.

Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesDec 27, 2016337 citations

Physical Layer Security for Next Generation Wireless Networks: Theories, Technologies, and Challenges

Yiliang Liu, Hsiao‐Hwa Chen, Liangmin Wang

Physical layer security (PHY-security) takes the advantages of channel randomness nature of transmission media to achieve communication confidentiality and authentication. Wiretap coding and signal processing technologies are expected to play vital roles in this new security mechanism. PHY-security has attracted a lot of attention due to its unique features and the fact that our daily life relies heavily on wireless communications for sensitive and private information transmissions. Compared to conventional cryptography that works to ensure all involved entities to load proper and authenticated cryptographic information, PHY-security technologies perform security functions without considering about how those security protocols are executed. In other words, it does not require to implement any extra security schemes or algorithms on other layers above the physical layer. This survey introduces the fundamental theories of PHY-security, covering confidentiality and authentication, and provides an overview on the state-of-the-art works on PHY-security technologies that can provide secure communications in wireless systems, along with the discussions on challenges and their proposed solutions. Furthermore, at the end of this paper, the open issues are identified as our future research directions.

IEEE Communications Surveys & TutorialsAug 10, 2016706 citations

PHY-layer security is no alternative to cryptography

Pieter Robyns, Peter Quax, Wim Lamotte

In recent works, numerous physical-layer security systems have been proposed as alternatives to classic cryptography. Such systems aim to use the intrinsic properties of radio signals and the wireless medium to provide confidentiality and authentication to wireless devices. However, fundamental vulnerabilities are often discovered in these systems shortly after their inception. We therefore challenge the assumptions made by existing physical-layer security systems, and postulate that weaker assumptions are needed in order to adapt for practical scenarios. We also argue that if no computational advantage over an adversary can be ensured, secure communication cannot be realistically achieved.

ACM Conference on Security and Privacy in Wireless and Mobile Networks (WiSec)Jul 13, 20177 citations

Physical Layer Security in Wireless Communication

Bin Yang

Security is one of the key issues in wireless communication. It is critical to send confidential data to legitimate user rather than intruders in an open space. In recent years, physical layer security attracts much research interest. This article offers a tutorial on several new methods to ensure security at physical layer in wireless communication. The introduction includes several aspects, from the theoretical base of the physical layer security, secure code design, cooperative jamming, to secret key generation, and comparing of the different techniques. Finally we make a view on the future works in this area.

Xinxi wangluo anquanJan 1, 20120 citations

Wireless physical layer security [Guest Editorial]

Walid Saad, Xiangyun Zhou, Merouane Abdelkader Debbah +1 more

The ongoing paradigm shift from classical centralized wireless technologies toward distributed large-scale networks such as the Internet of Things has introduced new security challenges that cannot be fully handled via traditional cryptographic means. In emerging wireless environments, devices have limited capabilities and are not controlled by a central control center; thus, the implementation of computationally expensive cryptographic techniques can be challenging. Motivated by this paradigm shift, substantial recent research has been investigating the use of the physical layer as a means to develop low-complexity and effective wireless security mechanisms. Such techniques are grouped under the umbrella of physical layer security. These techniques range from information-theoretic security, which exploits channel advantages to thwart eavesdropping, to physical layer fi ngerprinting techniques that exploit physical layer features for device identifi cation. In this context, providing state-of-the-art tutorials on the various approaches to physical layer security is of considerable interest. This Feature Topic gathers together tutorial-style and survey articles that provide an in-depth overview of the broad spectrum of security opportunities brought forward by physical layer security.

IEEE Communications MagazineDec 1, 20151 citation

Wireless physical layer security: Part 1 [Guest Editorial]

Walid Saad, Xiangyun Zhou, Merouane Abdelkader Debbah +1 more

The ongoing paradigm shift from classical centralized wireless technologies toward distributed large-scale networks such as the Internet of Things has introduced new security challenges that cannot be fully handled via traditional cryptgraphic means. In such emerging wireless environments, devices have limited capabilities and are not controlled by a central control center; thus, the implementation of computationally expensive cryptographic techniques can be challenging. Motivated by these considerations, substantial recent research has been investigating the use of the physical layer as a means to develop low-complexity and effective wireless security mechanisms. Such techniques are grouped under the umbrella ofphysical layer security. These techniques range from information-theoretic security, which exploits channel advantages to thwart eavesdropping, to physical layer fingerprinting techniques that exploit physical layer features for device identification. In this context, providing state-of-the-art tutorials on the various approaches to physical layer security is of considerable interest. This Feature Topic gathers together such tutorial-style and overview articles that provide an in-depth overview of the broad spectrum of security opportunities brought forward by physical layer security.

IEEE Communications MagazineJun 1, 20152 citations